Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010. ComLaw Authoritative Act C2010A00044
type: Document
category: AU
identifier: No. 44 of 2010
description: An Act to amend the Trade Practices Act 1974 and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001, and for other purposes
proposed by: legis2cml
curation status: Proposed

1 Short title
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1
note: Cites this Act as the Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable
logic summary: Establishes the citation format for this Act.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sec-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-2-norm

2 Commencement
type: Concept
realized by: sec-2-2
note: Commencement rules for provisions in the Act.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-2-2-norm

1 Section 1
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-2
note: Table of sections and commencement provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-2-norm

14 April 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-14
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-14-norm

2 Section 2
type: Concept
realized by: sec-2-3
note: Conditional commencement of the Act
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-2-3-norm

1 January 2010—1 July 2010.
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-3
note: Prohibition on specifying a day before July 1, 2010.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
logic summary: Prohibition on specifying a day before July 1, 2010.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-4
note: References F2010L01315
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-4-norm

3 Section 3
type: Concept
realized by: sec-3
note: Conditional commencement of Schedule 2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-3-norm

15 April 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-15
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-15-norm

4 Section 4
type: Concept
realized by: sec-4
note: Conditional commencement of provision(s) covered by table item 2.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-4-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-5
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-5-norm

5 Section 5
type: Concept
realized by: sec-5
note: Conditional commencement of provision(s) covered by table item 2.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-5-logic-alleninterval-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-5-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >
logic summary: Temporal interval relation
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

6 Section 6
type: Concept
realized by: sec-6
note: Conditional commencement of provisions based on event occurrence
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-6-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-6
note: Applicable provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-6-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-6-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 1 July 2010
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: applies
logic summary: Provision applies
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

7 Section 7
type: Concept
realized by: sec-7
note: Schedule 2 items 42 to 74 at the same time as the provision(s) covered by table item 2.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-7-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-7
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-7-norm

8 Section 8
type: Concept
realized by: sec-8
note: Schedule 3
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-8-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-8
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-8-norm

9 Section 9
type: Concept
realized by: sec-9
note: Conditional commencement of Schedule 3
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-9-norm

15 April 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-15-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-15-2-norm

10 Section 10
type: Concept
realized by: sec-10
note: Schedule 3
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-10-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-9
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-9-norm

11 Section 11
type: Concept
realized by: sec-11
note: Schedule 3
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-11-norm

15 April 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-15-3
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-15-3-norm

12 Section 12
type: Concept
realized by: sec-12
note: Conditional commencement of provision(s) covered by table item 2.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-12-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-10
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-10-norm

13 Section 13
type: Concept
realized by: sec-13
note: The day after this Act receives the Royal Assent.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-13-norm

15 April 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-15-4
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-15-4-norm

14 Section 14
type: Concept
realized by: sec-14-2
note: Conditional commencement of provision(s) covered by table item 2.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-14-2-norm

1 July 2010
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-11
note: Note on table expansion
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-1-11-norm

3 Schedule(s)
type: Concept
realized by: sec-3-2
note: Amendment of Acts specified in a Schedule
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-3-2-norm

4 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sec-4-2
note: Schedule terms have effect according to their terms.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.8
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-4-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-4-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-4-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 4 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sec-4-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes
logic summary: Obligation on the State
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

1 At the end of the Act
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-1
note: Add at the end of the Act
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.9
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-1-sec-1-norm

1 Definitions
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-1
note: Defines terms used in the Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.9
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 1 Definitions
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Class hierarchy for definitions
premise text: Definitions are used to clarify terms
conclusion text: Terms are defined in this Schedule
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Obligation to provide clear definitions
premise text: Definitions must be clear and unambiguous
conclusion text: This Schedule defines terms clearly
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

6 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-6
note: Must provide transparent information about consumer contracts.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 6 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to provide transparency
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2 Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-2
has part: 2(1) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
has part: 2(2) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
has part: 2(3) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10

2(1) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-2-ss-1
part of: 2 Unfair terms of consumer contracts
note: Unfair terms in consumer contracts are void.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: voids
logic summary: Voiding unfair terms
premise text: (a) the term is unfair; and (b) the contract is a standard form contract.
conclusion text: The term is void if it is unfair and the contract is a standard form contract.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Unfair terms are void during the contract period
premise text: (a) the term is unfair; and (b) the contract is a standard form contract.
conclusion text: The term is void if it is unfair and the contract is a standard form contract during the contract period.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: during
logic summary: Unfair terms are void during the contract period
premise text: (a) the term is unfair; and (b) the contract is a standard form contract.
conclusion text: The term is void if it is unfair and the contract is a standard form contract during the contract period.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: if-and-only-if
logic summary: Unfair terms are void if and only if they are unfair and the contract is a standard form contract
premise text: (a) the term is unfair; and (b) the contract is a standard form contract.
conclusion text: The term is void if it is unfair and the contract is a standard form contract.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: if-and-only-if
logic summary: Unfair terms are void if and only if they are unfair and the contract is a standard form contract
premise text: (a) the term is unfair; and (b) the contract is a standard form contract.
conclusion text: The term is void if it is unfair and the contract is a standard form contract.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2(2) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-2-ss-2
part of: 2 Unfair terms of consumer contracts
note: Contract continues to bind parties if it can operate without the unfair term.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 2(2) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Continuation
logic summary: Contract continues to bind parties.
premise text: (2) The contract continues to bind the parties if it is capable of operating without the unfair term.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal interval relation
logic summary: Requires a relation between identifiable temporal intervals.
premise text: Conditional commencement is Undertaking, not Prohibition.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2(3) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-2-ss-3
part of: 2 Unfair terms of consumer contracts
note: Definition of consumer contract
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 2(3) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: =
logic summary: Defines a consumer contract
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

3 Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3
has part: 3(1) Meaning of unfair
has part: 3(2) Meaning of unfair
has part: 3(3) Meaning of unfair
has part: 3(4) Meaning of unfair
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10

3(1) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3-ss-1
part of: 3 Meaning of unfair
note: A term of a consumer contract is unfair if it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations arising under the contract.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 3(1) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State to ensure fairness in consumer contracts.
premise text: (1) A term of a consumer contract is unfair if: (a) it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations arising under the contract; and (b) it is not reasonably necessary in order to protect the legitimate interests of the party who would be advantaged by the term; and (c) it would cause detriment (whether financial or otherwise) to a party if it were to be applied or relied on.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

3(2) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3-ss-2
part of: 3 Meaning of unfair
note: Court must consider certain factors when determining if a term is unfair.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 3(2) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider certain factors.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
logic summary: Court considers factors within a certain timeframe.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Court considers factors within a certain timeframe.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: SPREADS
logic summary: Court considers factors that affect multiple parties.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: REQUIRES
logic summary: Court must consider certain factors when determining if a term is unfair.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

3(3) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3-ss-3
part of: 3 Meaning of unfair
note: Term must be transparent
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 3(3) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must be transparent
premise text: (3) A term is transparent if the term is: (a) expressed in reasonably plain language; and (b) legible; and (c) presented clearly; and (d) readily available to any party affected by the term.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Temporal intervals are relevant for transparency
premise text: (3) A term is transparent if the term is: (a) expressed in reasonably plain language; and (b) legible; and (c) presented clearly; and (d) readily available to any party affected by the term.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Temporal intervals are relevant for transparency
premise text: (3) A term is transparent if the term is: (a) expressed in reasonably plain language; and (b) legible; and (c) presented clearly; and (d) readily available to any party affected by the term.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Transparency is relevant for diffusion
premise text: (3) A term is transparent if the term is: (a) expressed in reasonably plain language; and (b) legible; and (c) presented clearly; and (d) readily available to any party affected by the term.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Transparency is relevant for AI applications
premise text: (3) A term is transparent if the term is: (a) expressed in reasonably plain language; and (b) legible; and (c) presented clearly; and (d) readily available to any party affected by the term.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

3(4) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3-ss-4
part of: 3 Meaning of unfair
note: Term is presumed not reasonably necessary to protect legitimate interests unless proven otherwise.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.10
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-ss-4-norm

4 Examples of unfair terms
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-4
note: Examples of unfair terms in consumer contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.11
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits specific types of unfair terms in consumer contracts
premise text: (1) Without limiting section 3, the following are examples...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

8 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-8
note: Terms that permit unilateral determination of contract breach or interpretation, limit vicarious liability, assign contracts without consent, limit right to sue, limit evidence, impose evidential burden, or prescribe effects on consumers and business.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.12
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-6

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that permit unilateral determination of contract breach or interpretation, limit vicarious liability, assign contracts without consent, limit right to sue, limit evidence, or impose evidential burden.
premise text: (h) a term that permits, or has the effect of permitting, one party unilaterally to determine whether the contract has been breached or to interpret its meaning;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that limit vicarious liability for agents.
premise text: (i) a term that limits, or has the effect of limiting, one party’s vicarious liability for its agents;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that permit assignment of contracts without consent.
premise text: (j) a term that permits, or has the effect of permitting, one party to assign the contract to the detriment of another party without that other party’s consent;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that limit right to sue.
premise text: (k) a term that limits, or has the effect of limiting, one party’s right to sue another party;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that limit evidence in proceedings.
premise text: (l) a term that limits, or has the effect of limiting, the evidence one party can adduce in proceedings relating to the contract;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-logic-deontic-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that impose evidential burden.
premise text: (m) a term that imposes, or has the effect of imposing, the evidential burden on one party in proceedings relating to the contract;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

5 Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-5
has part: 5(1) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
has part: 5(2) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.12

5(1) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-5-ss-1
part of: 5 Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
note: Exemptions from Section 2 for certain terms in consumer contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.12
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 5(1) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Exemptions from obligations
premise text: Section 2 does not apply to a term of a consumer contract
conclusion text: to the extent that, but only to the extent that, the term defines the main subject matter of the contract; or sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or is a term required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal interval for exemptions
premise text: (1) Section 2 does not apply to a term of a consumer contract to the extent that, but only to the extent that, the term defines the main subject matter of the contract; or sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or is a term required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: until
logic summary: Temporal interval for exemptions
premise text: (1) Section 2 does not apply to a term of a consumer contract to the extent that, but only to the extent that, the term defines the main subject matter of the contract; or sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or is a term required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: through
logic summary: Diffusing exemptions to related terms
premise text: (1) Section 2 does not apply to a term of a consumer contract to the extent that, but only to the extent that, the term defines the main subject matter of the contract; or sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or is a term required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: by
logic summary: CogAI analysis for exemptions
premise text: (1) Section 2 does not apply to a term of a consumer contract to the extent that, but only to the extent that, the term defines the main subject matter of the contract; or sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or is a term required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

5(2) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-5-ss-2
part of: 5 Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
note: The upfront price is the consideration that must be provided for the supply, sale or grant under the contract.
description: yes
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.12
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 5(2) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide upfront price
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

7 Standard form contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-7
has part: 7(1) Standard form contracts
has part: 7(2) Standard form contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.13

7(1) Standard form contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-7-ss-1
part of: 7 Standard form contracts
note: Presumption of standard form contract
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.13
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 7(1) Standard form contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: presumption
logic summary: Presumption of standard form contract
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

7(2) Standard form contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-7-ss-2
part of: 7 Standard form contracts
note: Court must consider specific factors when determining if a contract is standard form.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.13
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 7(2) Standard form contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider specific factors.
premise text: Court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant.
conclusion text: Court MUST consider the specified factors.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Factors relate to specific characteristics of a party or transaction.
premise text: (e) whether the terms of the contract (other than the terms referred to in section 5(1)) take into account the specific characteristics of another party or the particular transaction;
conclusion text: The factors contain information about the specific characteristics of a party or transaction.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider all relevant matters.
premise text: A court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but MUST take into account the following:
conclusion text: A court MUST consider all relevant matters when determining if a contract is standard form.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider all factors.
premise text: (f) any other matter prescribed by the regulations.
conclusion text: A court MUST consider all additional matters when determining if a contract is standard form.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

8 Contracts to which this Part does not apply
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-8-2
has part: 8(1) Contracts to which this Part does not apply
has part: 8(2) Contracts to which this Part does not apply
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.13

8(1) Contracts to which this Part does not apply
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-8-2-ss-1
part of: 8 Contracts to which this Part does not apply
note: Exemptions from the Part's application
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.13
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-2-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Exemptions from the Part's application
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

8(2) Contracts to which this Part does not apply
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-8-2-ss-2
part of: 8 Contracts to which this Part does not apply
note: Exemptions from the Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.13
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-2-ss-2-norm

10 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-10
note: Does not apply to contracts of certain types.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.14
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 10 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Class hierarchy
premise text: Contract type
conclusion text: Does not apply
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: !
logic summary: Negative obligation
premise text: State
conclusion text: Does not apply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2 Application and transitional provisions
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-2-2
note: Part 2 of Schedule 2 to the Trade Practices Act 1974 applies to contracts entered into on or after the commencement of this Schedule.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.14
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-2-logic-alleninterval-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 2 Application and transitional provisions
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: applies
logic summary: The provision applies to contracts entered into on or after the commencement of this Schedule.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
logic summary: The provision applies to contracts entered into between the commencement of this Schedule and a future date.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

3 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3-2
note: Defines Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.15
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 3 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defines
logic summary: Defines a term
premise text: Term definition
conclusion text: Australian Consumer Law
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: is defined by
logic summary: Describes the relationship between terms
premise text: Schedule 2
conclusion text: Australian Consumer Law
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

4 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-4-2
note: Defines provision of Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.15
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4-2-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 4 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

5 After section 4KA
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-5-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.15
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-2-norm

4KB References to the Australian Consumer Law etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-4kb
note: Reference to Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.15
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4kb-norm

12 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-12
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-12-norm

4KC Contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-4kc
note: No conduct is taken to contravene the Australian Consumer Law.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4kc-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4kc-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4kc-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 4KC Contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4kc-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: ¬
logic summary: Negation of obligation
premise text: Conduct is not taken
conclusion text: Does not contravene the Australian Consumer Law
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

6 After paragraph 5(1)(e)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-6-2
note: Inserts the Australian Consumer Law into this Act.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 6 After paragraph 5(1)(e)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: INSERTS
logic summary: Insertion of a new provision
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

7 Paragraph 5(1)(f)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-7-2
note: Omit “or (e)”, substitute “, (e) or (ea)”.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-2-norm

8 At the end of subparagraphs 6(2)(a)(i) and (ii), (2)(b)(i) and
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-8-3
note: Add 'or' to the end of certain headings.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 8 At the end of subparagraphs 6(2)(a)(i) and (ii), (2)(b)(i) and
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate
logic summary: Add 'or' to the end of certain headings.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

9 After paragraph 6(2)(c)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-9
note: Prohibits references in Part 2 of the Australian Consumer Law to certain contracts.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-9-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-9-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
logic summary: Prohibits references in Part 2 of the Australian Consumer Law to certain contracts.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

10 After subsection 6(3)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-10-2
note: Inserts provisions of Part 2 ComLaw Authoritative Act into the Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.16
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 10 After subsection 6(3)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insertion
logic summary: Inserts provisions of Part 2 ComLaw Authoritative Act into the Australian Consumer Law
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

11 After Part X
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-11
note: Insert after Part X
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.17
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-11-norm

130 Application of the Australian Consumer Law in relation to
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-130
note: The Australian Consumer Law applies to corporations.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.17
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-130-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-130-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-130-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 130 Application of the Australian Consumer Law in relation to
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-130-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: applies
logic summary: Obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

131 Division does not apply to financial services etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-131
has part: 131(1) Division does not apply to financial services etc.
has part: 131(2) Division does not apply to financial services etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.17

131(1) Division does not apply to financial services etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-131-ss-1
part of: 131 Division does not apply to financial services etc.
note: Division does not apply to financial services.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.17
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 131(1) Division does not apply to financial services etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: does not apply
logic summary: Division does not apply.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

131(2) Division does not apply to financial services etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-131-ss-2
part of: 131 Division does not apply to financial services etc.
note: Part 2 of the Australian Consumer Law does not apply to financial products or contracts for the supply, or possible supply, of services that are financial services.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.17
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-131-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: does not apply
logic summary: Prohibition on application of Part 2 to financial products and services contracts
premise text: (2) Despite section 130
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

132 Saving of other laws and remedies
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-132
note: No exclusion of concurrent State laws
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.17
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-132-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-132-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 132 Saving of other laws and remedies
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

14 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-14
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.18
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-norm

133 Definitions
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-133
note: Defines terms related to the Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.18
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-7

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate
logic summary: Defines terms related to the Australian Consumer Law
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Classifies terms into categories
premise text: application law means...
conclusion text: ...the applied Australian Consumer Law, applying as a law of the participating jurisdiction...
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Defines relationships between terms
premise text: apply, in relation to the applied Australian Consumer Law, means apply the applied Australian Consumer Law by reference:
conclusion text: ...as in force from time to time;
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Classifies entities into categories
premise text: Commonwealth entity means...
conclusion text: ...an authority of the Commonwealth;
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Defines relationships between entities
premise text: officer, in relation to the Commonwealth, includes...
conclusion text: ...a person who is a member or officer of an authority of the Commonwealth;
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Classifies jurisdictions into categories
premise text: participating jurisdiction means a participating State or participating Territory.
conclusion text: ...a State that is a party to the Intergovernmental Agreement for the Australian Consumer Law;
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-133-logic-descriptionlogic-7
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Classifies territories into categories
premise text: participating Territory means a Territory that is a party to the Intergovernmental Agreement for the Australian Consumer Law.
conclusion text: ...the Australian Capital Territory or the Northern Territory;
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

134 Object of this Division
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-134
note: Facilitate application of Australian Consumer Law by participating States and Territories.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.19
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-134-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-134-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-134-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 134 Object of this Division
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-134-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to facilitate application of Australian Consumer Law.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

135 The applied Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-135
has part: 135(1) The applied Australian Consumer Law
has part: 135(2) The applied Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.19

135(1) The applied Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-135-ss-1
part of: 135 The applied Australian Consumer Law
note: Defines the scope of the Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.19
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Applicable
logic summary: Requires temporal intervals for certain provisions
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

135(2) The applied Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-135-ss-2
part of: 135 The applied Australian Consumer Law
note: The Australian Consumer Law must be applied.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.19
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 135(2) The applied Australian Consumer Law
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-135-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must apply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

16 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-16
note: References to corporations are to include references to persons who are not corporations.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-16-norm

136 Federal Court may exercise jurisdiction under application laws
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-136
note: Federal Court may exercise jurisdiction under application laws
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-136-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-136-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-136-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 136 Federal Court may exercise jurisdiction under application laws
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-136-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: hasJurisdiction
logic summary: Exercise jurisdiction
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

137 Exercise of jurisdiction under cross-vesting provisions
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-137
note: No effect on other laws regarding cross-vesting of jurisdiction
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-137-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-137-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-137-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: doesNotImpose
logic summary: Does not impose a duty or obligation on the Commonwealth or States
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

138 Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-138
has part: 138(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
has part: 138(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
has part: 138(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20

138(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-138-ss-1
part of: 138 Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
note: Imposes duties on a Commonwealth entity for the purposes of the applied Australian Consumer Law.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 138(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
borne by: LegalPerson
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes
logic summary: Imposes duties on a Commonwealth entity.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

138(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-138-ss-2
part of: 138 Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
note: No conferral of function or power without Commonwealth consent.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 138(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits conferral of function or power without Commonwealth consent.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

138(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-138-ss-3
part of: 138 Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
note: Agreement between Commonwealth and State/Territory required for conferral of functions etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.20
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-138-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
logic summary: Requires agreement between Commonwealth and State/Territory
premise text: Conferral of function or power without agreement
conclusion text: Invalid
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

139 How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139
has part: 139(1) How duty is imposed
has part: 139(2) How duty is imposed
has part: 139(3) How duty is imposed
has part: 139(4) How duty is imposed
has part: 139(5) How duty is imposed
has part: 139(6) How duty is imposed
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21

139(1) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139-ss-1
part of: 139 How duty is imposed
note: Duty imposed on Commonwealth entities by application law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Imposes duty
logic summary: Section imposes duty on Commonwealth entity
premise text: Application law purports to impose duty
conclusion text: Duty imposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

139(2) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139-ss-2
part of: 139 How duty is imposed
note: Duty is not imposed by this Act to the extent it exceeds State legislative powers.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 139(2) How duty is imposed
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: excludes
logic summary: Exclusion of duty
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

139(3) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139-ss-3
part of: 139 How duty is imposed
note: Duty imposed by law of Commonwealth if necessary for validity
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 139(3) How duty is imposed
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: if-then
logic summary: Conditional obligation
premise text: Law of Commonwealth required for duty validity
conclusion text: Duty imposed by law if necessary
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

139(4) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139-ss-4
part of: 139 How duty is imposed
note: Parliament's intention to rely on available powers under the Constitution to support duty imposition.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 139(4) How duty is imposed
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Relies
logic summary: Parliament relies on available powers under the Constitution.
premise text: This Act imposes a duty.
conclusion text: The Parliament intends to rely on these powers.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Imposes
logic summary: Parliament imposes the duty through this Act.
premise text: This Act is taken to impose a duty.
conclusion text: The Parliament intends to rely on these powers.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Supports
logic summary: Parliament supports the imposition of the duty through available powers under the Constitution.
premise text: This Act is taken to impose a duty.
conclusion text: The Parliament intends to rely on these powers.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Enacts
logic summary: Parliament enacts this provision to impose the duty.
premise text: This Act is taken to impose a duty.
conclusion text: The Parliament intends to rely on these powers.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-4-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Authorizes
logic summary: Parliament authorizes the imposition of the duty through this Act.
premise text: This Act is taken to impose a duty.
conclusion text: The Parliament intends to rely on these powers.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

139(5) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139-ss-5
part of: 139 How duty is imposed
note: Duty is taken to be imposed by this Act in accordance with subsection (3) only.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-logic-deontic-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 139(5) How duty is imposed
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: takes
logic summary: Duty is taken to be imposed
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Act in accordance with subsection (3)
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: within the legislative powers of the Commonwealth
logic summary: Imposing the duty must be within the legislative powers of the Commonwealth
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Act in accordance with subsection (3) only to the extent to which imposing the duty:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-5-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: consistent with constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the entity
logic summary: Imposing the duty must be consistent with constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the entity
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Act in accordance with subsection (3) only to the extent to which imposing the duty:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

139(6) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-139-ss-6
part of: 139 How duty is imposed
note: Duty is not limited by subsections (1) to (5)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.21
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-6-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-139-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 139(6) How duty is imposed
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

18 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-norm

140 When an application law imposes a duty
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-140
note: Application law imposes a duty on Commonwealth entities if it confers a function or power and gives rise to an obligation.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 140 When an application law imposes a duty
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: If the law confers a function or power, then it imposes an obligation.
premise text: The law confers a function or power.
conclusion text: Therefore, it imposes an obligation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: The circumstances in which the function or power is conferred give rise to an obligation during that time.
premise text: The law confers a function or power.
conclusion text: Therefore, it imposes an obligation during that time.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: during
logic summary: The circumstances in which the function or power is conferred give rise to an obligation during that time.
premise text: The law confers a function or power.
conclusion text: Therefore, it imposes an obligation during that time.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
logic summary: The circumstances in which the function or power is conferred give rise to an obligation during that time.
premise text: The law confers a function or power.
conclusion text: Therefore, it imposes an obligation during that time.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-140-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: during
logic summary: The circumstances in which the function or power is conferred give rise to an obligation during that time.
premise text: The law confers a function or power.
conclusion text: Therefore, it imposes an obligation during that time.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

141 Application laws may operate concurrently with this Act
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-141
note: Application laws may operate concurrently with this Act.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-141-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-141-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 141 Application laws may operate concurrently with this Act
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

142 No doubling-up of liabilities
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-142
has part: 142(1) No doubling-up of liabilities
has part: 142(2) No doubling-up of liabilities
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22

142(1) No doubling-up of liabilities
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-142-ss-1
part of: 142 No doubling-up of liabilities
note: No punishment for offence against Act if already punished under application law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 142(1) No doubling-up of liabilities
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
logic summary: If A, then B
premise text: (A)
conclusion text: (B)
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

142(2) No doubling-up of liabilities
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-142-ss-2
part of: 142 No doubling-up of liabilities
note: No liability for same conduct under both laws
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 142(2) No doubling-up of liabilities
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
logic summary: If A, then B
premise text: (2) If a person has been ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty under an application law
conclusion text: The person is not liable to a pecuniary penalty under this Act in respect of the same conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: X overlaps Y
premise text: (2) If a person has been ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty under an application law
conclusion text: The same conduct is covered by this Act and the other law
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
logic summary: X repeats Y
premise text: (2) If a person has been ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty under an application law
conclusion text: The same conduct is covered by this Act and the other law
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuses
logic summary: X diffuses Y
premise text: (2) If a person has been ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty under an application law
conclusion text: The same conduct is covered by this Act and the other law
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-142-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognizes
logic summary: X recognizes Y
premise text: (2) If a person has been ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty under an application law
conclusion text: The same conduct is covered by this Act and the other law
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

143 References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-143
has part: 143(1) References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
has part: 143(2) References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22

143(1) References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-143-ss-1
part of: 143 References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
note: References to Australian Consumer Law must include application under Division 1 and participating jurisdictions.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 143(1) References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: refersTo
logic summary: Reference to law includes application under Division 1 and participating jurisdictions.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

143(2) References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-143-ss-2
part of: 143 References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
note: Contrary intention in instrument or context requires exception to subsection (1) effect.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.22
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 143(2) References in instruments to the Australian Consumer Law
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-143-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: contrary
logic summary: Contrary intention requires exception.
premise text: Instrument or context requires exception.
conclusion text: Subsection (1) effect is overridden.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

20 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-20
note: Reference to Trade Practices Act 1974
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.24
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-20-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-20-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-20-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 20 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-20-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: refersTo
logic summary: Refers to the Trade Practices Act 1974
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

1 Before section 77
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-1-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.24
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-1-2-norm

76E Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76e
has part: 76E(1) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
has part: 76E(2) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
has part: 76E(3) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.24

76E(1) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76e-ss-1
part of: 76E Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
note: Contravention of specific provisions is prohibited.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.24
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76E(2) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76e-ss-2
part of: 76E Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
note: Determine pecuniary penalty considering relevant matters
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.24
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 76E(2) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State to determine pecuniary penalty
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76E(3) Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76e-ss-3
part of: 76E Pecuniary penalties—consumer protection etc.
note: Maximum pecuniary penalty amounts for certain acts and omissions
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.24
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76e-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: >=
logic summary: Upper limit on pecuniary penalty units
premise text: The number of penalty units is not to exceed...
conclusion text: ...10,000 or 2,000
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

22 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-22
note: Maximum penalty units for certain acts or omissions
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.26
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-deontic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 22 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: >=
logic summary: Upper limit on penalty units
premise text: The number of penalty units is not to exceed...
conclusion text: ...300 or 60
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: >=
logic summary: Upper limit on penalty units for certain entities
premise text: (a) if the person is a body corporate—150; or (b) if the person is not a body corporate—30.
conclusion text: ...250 or 50
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: &
logic summary: Multiple provisions apply to contravention
premise text: If conduct constitutes a contravention of 2 or more provisions referred to in paragraph (1)(a):
conclusion text: ...but a person is not liable to more than one pecuniary penalty under this section...
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: <=
logic summary: Maximum number of pecuniary penalties for same conduct
premise text: (b) a person is not liable to more than one pecuniary penalty under this section in respect of the same conduct.
conclusion text: ...one pecuniary penalty
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76F Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76f
has part: 76F(1) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
has part: 76F(2) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
has part: 76F(3) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
has part: 76F(4) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.26

76F(1) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76f-ss-1
part of: 76F Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
note: Court cannot make an order under section 76E against a person in relation to certain consumer protection breaches.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.26
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 76F(1) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
logic summary: Court cannot make an order under section 76E.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76F(2) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2
part of: 76F Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
note: Proceedings for an order under section 76E are stayed if criminal proceedings are started or have already been started against the person for an offence.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.26
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 76F(2) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits proceedings under section 76E if criminal proceedings are started or have already been started.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 76E against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...the proceedings may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between criminal proceedings and section 76E proceedings.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 76E against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...the proceedings may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
logic summary: Describes the recurring nature of criminal proceedings and section 76E proceedings.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 76E against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...the proceedings may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
logic summary: Permits resumption of section 76E proceedings if the person is not convicted of the offence.
premise text: ...the proceedings may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
conclusion text: ...Otherwise, the proceedings are dismissed.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
logic summary: Describes the relationship between criminal conviction and section 76E proceedings.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 76E against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...Otherwise, the proceedings are dismissed.
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76F(3) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76f-ss-3
part of: 76F Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
note: Criminal proceedings can be started against a person for conduct substantially the same as a consumer protection breach.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.26
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76F(4) Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-76f-ss-4
part of: 76F Pecuniary penalties under section 76E and offences
note: Prevents previous evidence from being used in criminal proceedings if the conduct is substantially the same as a previously claimed consumer protection breach.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.26
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-76f-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prevents previous evidence from being used in criminal proceedings.
premise text: None
conclusion text: None
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2 At the end of subsection 77(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-2-3
note: Add “or 76E”.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.27
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-3-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-2-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 2 At the end of subsection 77(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

24 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-24
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.28
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-24-norm

3 Subsection 77A(3) (at the end of the definition of civil
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-3-3
note: Add a pecuniary penalty under section 76E to the definition of civil liability
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.28
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 3 Subsection 77A(3) (at the end of the definition of civil
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-3-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: addition
logic summary: Adding a pecuniary penalty to the definition of civil liability
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

4 Subparagraph 79B(a)(i)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-4-3
note: Substitute section numbers in a provision.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.28
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-4-3-norm

5 At the end of section 85
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-5-3
note: Court may relieve person from liability to pecuniary penalty if they acted honestly and reasonably.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.28
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 5 At the end of section 85
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-5-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: mayRelieve
logic summary: May relieve from liability
premise text: Acted honestly and reasonably
conclusion text: No liability
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

6 Paragraph 86D(1)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-6-3
note: Omit section 76, substitute with section 76 or 76E.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.28
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-6-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits omitting section 76 and substituting with section 76 or 76E.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

7 Before subsection 86E(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-7-3
note: Disqualification from managing corporations for a period considered appropriate by the Court.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.29
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-3-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 7 Before subsection 86E(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-7-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of managing corporations.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

8 Subsection 86E(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-8-4
note: Omit ‘or (1A)’, substitute ‘, (1A) or (1B)”.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.29
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-8-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Omit
logic summary: Remove the specified phrase
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

9 Subsection 86E(3)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-9-2
note: Insertion of subsection (1B) after subsection (1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.29
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-9-2-norm

26 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-26
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-26-norm

10 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-10-3
note: Definition of substantiation notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: definition
logic summary: Defines a key term
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-10-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: class hierarchy
logic summary: Applies to explicit class hierarchies
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

11 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-11-2
note: Defines 'substantiation notice compliance period'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-11-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-11-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-11-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 11 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-11-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: has meaning
logic summary: Defines a term with a specific meaning
premise text: subsection 87ZN(2)
conclusion text: substantiation notice compliance period
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12 Before Part VII
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-12-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-12-2-norm

87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl
has part: 87ZL(1) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 87ZL(2) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 87ZL(3) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 87ZL(4) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 87ZL(5) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 87ZL(6) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30

87ZL(1) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-1
part of: 87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: Commission may require claims to be substantiated.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZL(1) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
logic summary: Requires substantiation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZL(2) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2
part of: 87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: The Commission may require a person to provide information and/or documents within 21 days.
description: true
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZL(2) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: The person must provide information and/or documents.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
logic summary: The person must provide information and/or documents within a specified time period.
premise text: 21 days after the notice is given to the person.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZL(3) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3
part of: 87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: Commission may require substantiation of claims or representations.
description: (a) substantiating or supporting the claim or representation; (b) if the claim or representation relates to a supply, or possible supply, of goods or services by a corporation—substantiating the quantities in which, or the period for which, the corporation is or will be able to make such a supply.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZL(3) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
logic summary: Requires substantiation of claims or representations.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: relevant to
logic summary: Relevant information must be provided for substantiation.
premise text: (2)(c)
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZL(4) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-4
part of: 87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: Notice must be given to a person, specifying the claim or representation and its effect.
description: yes
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZL(4) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide notice
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZL(5) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-5
part of: 87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: The Commission may require substantiation of claims.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-5-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZL(5) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to provide substantiation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZL(6) Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-6
part of: 87ZL Commission may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: Exemption for prescribed information providers
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.30
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zl-ss-6-norm

28 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-28
note: Does not have a commercial relationship with another person for purposes other than publishing or supplying goods/services.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-deontic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 28 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: does not have
logic summary: Lack of commercial relationship
premise text: (c) does not have a commercial relationship with the other person
conclusion text: other person's business or activities
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: within a specific time frame
logic summary: Within the meaning of section 53A
premise text: (c) does not have a commercial relationship with the other person other than for the purpose of: (ii) the other person supplying goods or services, or selling or granting interests in land (within the meaning of section 53A), to the person.
conclusion text: section 53A
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: recurring trace
logic summary: Recurring supply of goods/services
premise text: (c) does not have a commercial relationship with the other person other than for the purpose of: (ii) the other person supplying goods or services, or selling or granting interests in land (within the meaning of section 53A), to the person.
conclusion text: recurring supply of goods/services
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-28-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: does not have a specific purpose
logic summary: Lack of commercial relationship for other purposes
premise text: (c) does not have a commercial relationship with the other person other than for the purpose of: (i) publishing claims or representations promoting, or apparently intended to promote, the other person’s discovery or activities;
conclusion text: other purposes
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZM Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zm
has part: 87ZM(1) Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
has part: 87ZM(2) Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32

87ZM(1) Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-1
part of: 87ZM Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
note: A person may apply for an extension of the period to comply with a substantiation notice.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZM(1) Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: May
logic summary: Expresses permission or obligation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZM(2) Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-2
part of: 87ZM Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
note: Commission may extend period for complying with notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZM(2) Extending periods for complying with substantiation notices
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zm-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Commission obligation to extend period
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZN Compliance with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zn
has part: 87ZN(1) Compliance with substantiation notices
has part: 87ZN(2) Compliance with substantiation notices
has part: 87ZN(3) Compliance with substantiation notices
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32

87ZN(1) Compliance with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-1
part of: 87ZN Compliance with substantiation notices
note: Comply with substantiation notice within specified period.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZN(1) Compliance with substantiation notices
borne by: Agent
scope note: borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Duty to comply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZN(2) Compliance with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-2
part of: 87ZN Compliance with substantiation notices
note: Compliance period for substantiation notices
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZN(2) Compliance with substantiation notices
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must comply with notice
premise text: (2) The substantiation notice compliance period for a substantiation notice is:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZN(3) Compliance with substantiation notices
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3
part of: 87ZN Compliance with substantiation notices
note: Refusal to provide information or document in response to substantiation notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Refusal
logic summary: Refusing to comply with a substantiation notice
premise text: Substantiation notice issued
conclusion text: Individual refuses to provide information or document
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: Uncertainty
logic summary: Doubt about the individual's obligation to comply
premise text: Notice may incriminate or expose to penalty
conclusion text: Individual uncertain about providing information or document
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring
logic summary: Recurring refusal to provide information or document
premise text: Substantiation notice issued repeatedly
conclusion text: Refusal becomes a recurring pattern
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Justification
logic summary: Rationale for refusing to provide information or document
premise text: Notice may incriminate or expose to penalty
conclusion text: Individual justifies refusal based on notice's potential consequences
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zn-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
logic summary: Temporal relationship between substantiation notice and individual's refusal
premise text: Notice issued at time t
conclusion text: Individual refuses at time t+1
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZO False or misleading information etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zo
has part: 87ZO(1) False or misleading information etc.
has part: 87ZO(2) False or misleading information etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32

87ZO(1) False or misleading information etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1
part of: 87ZO False or misleading information etc.
note: Prohibition on giving false or misleading information in compliance with a substantiation notice.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZO(1) False or misleading information etc.
borne by: Agent
scope note: borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: prohibition
logic summary: Prohibition on giving false or misleading information.
premise text: A person must not...
conclusion text: ...in compliance with a substantiation notice.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: The provision applies to documents produced in compliance with a substantiation notice.
premise text: ...documents that contain false or misleading information.
conclusion text: ...during the production of documents.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZO(2) False or misleading information etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2
part of: 87ZO False or misleading information etc.
note: Exemptions from section 87ZO(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.32
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-ltl-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZO(2) False or misleading information etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Section does not apply to certain information
premise text: The section applies to false or misleading information
conclusion text: However, the section does not apply to...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: permission
logic summary: Permission to produce documents with false or misleading information
premise text: The section allows for the production of documents containing false or misleading information under certain circumstances
conclusion text: However, the document must be accompanied by a statement that the information is false or misleading
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
logic summary: Temporal interval for exemption
premise text: The section applies to false or misleading information before a certain point in time
conclusion text: However, the section does not apply to information that could not have been known to be false or misleading at that point in time
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zo-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: until
logic summary: Temporal interval for exemption
premise text: The section applies to false or misleading information until a certain point in time
conclusion text: However, the section does not apply to information that could not have been known to be false or misleading at that point in time
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

30 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-30
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-30-norm

13 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-13
note: Defines enforcement proceeding
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-13-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-13-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-13-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-13-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 13 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-13-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: is
logic summary: States the nature of an enforcement proceeding
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-13-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: has definition
logic summary: Defines a term with a clear meaning
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

14 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-14-2
note: Defines non-party consumer for conduct enforcement proceedings.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 14 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: is defined as
logic summary: Defines a term with a specific meaning.
conclusion text: non-party consumer
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-14-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: has a definition
logic summary: Provides a formal definition for the term.
conclusion text: Insert: non-party consumer, in relation to conduct, means...
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

15 Section 4L
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-15
note: Insertion of new section number
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-15-norm

16 Section 83
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-16-2
note: Inserts section 87AAA(1) after subsection 87(1A)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-16-2-norm

17 Subsection 87(1A)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-17
note: Insertion of section reference
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-17-norm

18 After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2
has part: 18(1) After section 87
has part: 18(2) After section 87
has part: 18(3) After section 87
has part: 18(4) After section 87
has part: 18(5) After section 87
has part: 18(6) After section 87
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34

18(1) After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1
part of: 18 After section 87
note: Court may make orders against a person referred to in subsection (2) of this section.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 18(1) After section 87
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Implies obligation
conclusion text: The Court may make orders.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: hasPart
logic summary: Classifies the provision as part of a larger section
premise text: Section 87AAB
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

18(2) After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2
part of: 18 After section 87
note: Order against person involved in contravening conduct
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 18(2) After section 87
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits making order against person involved in contravening conduct
premise text: (2) An order under subsection (1)
conclusion text: may be made against the person who engaged in the contravening conduct or a person involved in that conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
logic summary: Establishes temporal relation between persons subject to order and contravening conduct
premise text: (2) An order under subsection (1)
conclusion text: the person who engaged in the contravening conduct or a person involved in that conduct.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring trace
logic summary: Establishes recurring trace between persons subject to order and contravening conduct
premise text: (2) An order under subsection (1)
conclusion text: the person who engaged in the contravening conduct or a person involved in that conduct.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
logic summary: Diffuses responsibility for contravening conduct to persons subject to order
premise text: (2) An order under subsection (1)
conclusion text: the person who engaged in the contravening conduct or a person involved in that conduct.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Classify
logic summary: Classifies persons subject to order using artificial intelligence
premise text: (2) An order under subsection (1)
conclusion text: the person who engaged in the contravening conduct or a person involved in that conduct.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

18(3) After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-3
part of: 18 After section 87
note: The Court must consider redressing or preventing loss/damage to non-party consumers before making an order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 18(3) After section 87
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: The Court must consider...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

18(4) After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-4
part of: 18 After section 87
note: Allow application under subsection (1) despite non-institution of enforcement proceeding.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit
logic summary: Granting permission
premise text: (4) An application may be made under subsection (1)
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

18(5) After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5
part of: 18 After section 87
note: Application can be made within 6 years after cause of action accrues.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5-logic-epistemic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 18(5) After section 87
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: can
logic summary: Application can be made
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-5-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: within
logic summary: Within 6 years after cause of action accrues
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

18(6) After section 87
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-6
part of: 18 After section 87
note: Court may consider conduct when making an order against a person.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.34
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-6-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-6-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 18(6) After section 87
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-18-2-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: consider
logic summary: Consideration of conduct in obligation
premise text: Obligation to consider conduct
conclusion text: Court may consider conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

32 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-32
has part: 32(8) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 32(9) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 32(10) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 32(11) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.36

32(8) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-32-ss-8
part of: 32 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Court does not need to determine non-party consumers or nature of loss/damage in making an order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.36
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 32(8) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Exemptions from non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the Court need not make a finding about either of the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: temporal interval
logic summary: Temporal interval for non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: ordered trace
logic summary: Ordered trace for non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion for non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-8-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: cognitive agent
logic summary: Cognitive agent for non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

32(9) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-32-ss-9
part of: 32 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Non-party consumer bound by order if loss or damage is redressed, prevented, or reduced.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.36
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-ltl-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 32(9) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Non-party consumer bound by order.
premise text: Order made under subsection (1) against a person.
conclusion text: Non-party consumer is bound by the order.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: No claim, action or demand may be made or taken against the person.
premise text: Despite any other provision of this Act or any other law of the Commonwealth, or a State or Territory.
conclusion text: No claim, action or demand may be made or taken against the person.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
logic summary: Loss or damage suffered by non-party consumer in relation to contravening conduct.
premise text: Loss or damage suffered, or likely to be suffered, by a non-party consumer.
conclusion text: Loss or damage suffered by non-party consumer is related to contravening conduct.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring trace
logic summary: Redress, prevention, or reduction of loss or damage repeated.
premise text: Redress, prevention, or reduction of loss or damage is redressed, prevented or reduced in accordance with the order.
conclusion text: Redress, prevention, or reduction of loss or damage is repeated.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-9-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Non-party consumer bound by order if conditions are met.
premise text: (a) an order is made under subsection (1) against a person; and (b) the loss or damage suffered, or likely to be suffered, by a non-party consumer in relation to the contravening conduct...
conclusion text: Non-party consumer is bound by the order if conditions are met.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

32(10) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-32-ss-10
part of: 32 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Section 87AB may limit liability for contravention of section 52.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.36
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-10-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-10-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-10-logic-epistemic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-10-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 32(10) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-10-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Limitation
logic summary: Limits liability
premise text: Section 87AB
conclusion text: Section 52
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-10-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: Uncertainty
logic summary: May limit knowledge of liability
premise text: Section 87AB
conclusion text: Contravention of section 52
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

32(11) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-32-ss-11
part of: 32 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Exempts conduct before commencement from application of section.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.36
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-11-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-11-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-11-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 32(11) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-ss-11-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: !
logic summary: Indicates exemption from obligation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

34 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-34
note: Terminates or otherwise affects the operation of an instrument.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.38
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terminating or affecting the operation of an instrument.
premise text: (ii) terminates or otherwise affects, or has the effect of terminating or otherwise affecting the operation or effect of the first-mentioned instrument.
conclusion text: (ii) does not terminate or affect the operation of the first-mentioned instrument.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Termination or affecting overlaps with the operation of an instrument.
premise text: (ii) terminates or otherwise affects, or has the effect of terminating or otherwise affecting the operation or effect of the first-mentioned instrument.
conclusion text: The termination or affecting occurs during the operation of the first-mentioned instrument.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Contains
logic summary: Termination or affecting is contained within the operation of an instrument.
premise text: (ii) terminates or otherwise affects, or has the effect of terminating or otherwise affecting the operation or effect of the first-mentioned instrument.
conclusion text: The termination or affecting occurs during the operation of the first-mentioned instrument.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuses
logic summary: Termination or affecting diffuses to the operation of an instrument.
premise text: (ii) terminates or otherwise affects, or has the effect of terminating or otherwise affecting the operation or effect of the first-mentioned instrument.
conclusion text: The termination or affecting spreads to the operation of the first-mentioned instrument.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-34-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognizes
logic summary: Termination or affecting is recognized as a prohibition.
premise text: (ii) terminates or otherwise affects, or has the effect of terminating or otherwise affecting the operation or effect of the first-mentioned instrument.
conclusion text: The termination or affecting is identified as a prohibition.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

19 Paragraph 87A(1)(d)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-19
note: Insertion of new section reference
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.38
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-19-norm

20 Paragraph 157(1)(d)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-20-2
note: Insertion of new section number
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.38
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-20-2-norm

21 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-21
note: Definition of infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.39
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-21-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-21-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 21 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

22 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-22-2
note: Definition of infringement notice compliance period
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.39
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-22-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defined
logic summary: Defines key term
conclusion text: infringement notice compliance period has the meaning given by section 87ZJ.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

23 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-23
note: Definition of infringement notice provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.39
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-23-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-23-logic-descriptionlogic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-23-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 23 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-23-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: definition
logic summary: Defines the concept of an infringement notice provision
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

24 After Part VIB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-24-2
note: Insert clause after Part VIB
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.39
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-24-2-norm

87ZD Purpose and effect of this Part
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zd
note: Issue of infringement notice for alleged contravention
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.39
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zd-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zd-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zd-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZD Purpose and effect of this Part
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zd-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State to issue an infringement notice
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

36 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-36
note: Does not require an infringement notice to be issued for a contravention.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.40
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-36-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-36-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-36-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 36 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-36-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: ~
logic summary: Exemption from liability
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZE Issue of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ze
has part: 87ZE(1) Issue of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZE(2) Issue of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZE(3) Issue of an infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.40

87ZE(1) Issue of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-1
part of: 87ZE Issue of an infringement notice
note: Commission may issue infringement notice to a person with reasonable grounds.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.40
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZE(1) Issue of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Implies obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZE(2) Issue of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-2
part of: 87ZE Issue of an infringement notice
note: Commission must not issue more than one infringement notice to the same person for the same alleged contravention.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.40
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZE(2) Issue of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibition of issuing multiple infringement notices.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZE(3) Issue of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-3
part of: 87ZE Issue of an infringement notice
note: Infringement notice has no effect if issued more than 12 months after alleged contravention.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.40
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ze-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: impossibility
logic summary: No effect if issued too late
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZF Matters to be included in an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zf
note: Infringement notice requirements
description: a unique number, day of issue, name and address, Commission contact details, alleged contravention details, penalty information, payment instructions
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.40
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zf-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zf-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zf-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZF Matters to be included in an infringement notice
borne by: LegalPerson
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zf-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide required information
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZG Amount of penalty
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zg
note: Specify a pecuniary penalty equal to the number of penalty units
description: penalty amount
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.41
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zg-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zg-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zg-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZG Amount of penalty
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zg-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: must
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the State
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

38 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-38
note: Penalty units for infringement notices
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.42
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-argumentation-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 38 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: =
logic summary: Fixed penalty units
premise text: The number of penalty units is...
conclusion text: ...60; or 12.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: =
logic summary: Temporal intervals for penalty units
premise text: the number of penalty units is ... subsection 65C(1) or (3) or 65D(1) or section 65G
conclusion text: ...60; or 12.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: =
logic summary: Recurring trace for penalty units
premise text: Item If the infringement notice is for an alleged contravention of ...
conclusion text: ...subsection 65C(1) or (3) or 65D(1) or section 65G
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: =
logic summary: Propagation of penalty units
premise text: the number of penalty units is ... subsection 65C(1) or (3) or 65D(1) or section 65G
conclusion text: ...60; or 12.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-38-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: =
logic summary: Rational basis for penalty units
premise text: the number of penalty units is ... subsection 65C(1) or (3) or 65D(1) or section 65G
conclusion text: ...60; or 12.
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZH Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zh
has part: 87ZH(1) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
has part: 87ZH(2) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
has part: 87ZH(3) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.42

87ZH(1) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1
part of: 87ZH Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
note: Compliance with infringement notice results in obligation to pay penalty.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.42
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-deontic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZH(1) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Obligation to pay penalty
premise text: (1) This section applies if...
conclusion text: ...and the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
logic summary: Temporal relation between payment and infringement notice
premise text: (b) the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
conclusion text: ...and the infringement notice is not withdrawn under section 87ZK.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring trace
logic summary: Recurring trace of payment and infringement notice
premise text: (c) the infringement notice is not withdrawn under section 87ZK.
conclusion text: ...and the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Obligation to pay penalty
premise text: (b) the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
conclusion text: ...and the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZH(2) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-2
part of: 87ZH Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
note: No obligation to be regarded as having contravened the infringement notice provision after payment.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.42
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: ¬
logic summary: Negation of obligation
conclusion text: No obligation to be regarded as having contravened the infringement notice provision after payment.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZH(3) Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-3
part of: 87ZH Effect of compliance with an infringement notice
note: No proceedings can be started or continued against the person by, or on behalf of, the Commonwealth or the Commission in relation to the alleged contravention or the same conduct.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.42
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zh-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: No proceedings can be started or continued.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZI Effect of failure to comply with an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zi
note: Liability for failure to comply with infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zi-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zi-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zi-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZI Effect of failure to comply with an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zi-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation
logic summary: Obligation to pay penalty
premise text: Failure to comply with infringement notice
conclusion text: Liability for contravention
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj
has part: 87ZJ(1) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
has part: 87ZJ(2) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
has part: 87ZJ(3) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
has part: 87ZJ(4) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
has part: 87ZJ(5) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
has part: 87ZJ(6) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43

87ZJ(1) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-1
part of: 87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
note: Defines infringement notice compliance period
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-1-norm

87ZJ(2) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-2
part of: 87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
note: Commission may extend infringement notice compliance period by notice in writing.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-2-norm

87ZJ(3) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-3
part of: 87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
note: Maximum extension period for infringement notice compliance
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZJ(3) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: max
logic summary: Limits the maximum extension period
premise text: (3)
conclusion text: Only one extension may be given and the extension must not be for longer than 28 days.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZJ(4) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-4
part of: 87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
note: Must provide notice of extension to the person issued the infringement notice.
description: Notice of extension
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZJ(4) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide notice
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZJ(5) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-5
part of: 87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
note: Failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-5-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZJ(5) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
logic summary: Obligation does not affect validity
premise text: Subsection (4) is an obligation
conclusion text: Extension validity is unaffected
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZJ(6) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-6
part of: 87ZJ Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
note: Reference to extended infringement notice compliance period is taken to be a reference to the extended period.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.43
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-6-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-6-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZJ(6) Infringement notice compliance period for infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zj-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Conditional obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

40 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-40
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-40-norm

87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk
has part: 87ZK(1) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZK(2) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZK(3) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZK(4) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZK(5) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZK(6) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
has part: 87ZK(7) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44

87ZK(1) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-1
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Right to withdraw infringement notice
description: Written representations
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(1) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: can
logic summary: Right to withdraw
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZK(2) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-2
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Protection from self-incrimination in proceedings
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(2) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Protects the person from self-incrimination
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZK(3) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-3
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Commission may withdraw infringement notice upon request.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(3) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Permission to withdraw infringement notice
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

87ZK(4) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-4
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Content of withdrawal notices must be provided.
description: Yes
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(4) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to provide content of withdrawal notices.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZK(5) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-5
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Withdrawal notice must state certain information.
description: name and address of the person, day on which infringement notice was issued, that proceedings may be started or continued against the person
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-5-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(5) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to provide information
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZK(6) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-6
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Withdrawal notice must be given within infringement notice compliance period.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-6-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-6-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(6) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Withdrawal notice must be given
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87ZK(7) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-7
part of: 87ZK Withdrawal of an infringement notice
note: Commission must refund amount paid if infringement notice is withdrawn after payment.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.44
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-7-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-7-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-7-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87ZK(7) Withdrawal of an infringement notice
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87zk-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Commission has an obligation to refund amount paid.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

25 Section 87ZD
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-25
note: Renumber as section 87ZP
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.45
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-25-norm

42 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-42
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.46
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-42-norm

26 After section 86D
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-26-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.46
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-26-2-norm

86DA Commission may issue a public warning notice
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-86da
note: The Commission may issue a public warning notice about suspected contraventions.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.46
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-86da-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-86da-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-86da-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Implies obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

44 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-44
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.48
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-44-norm

27 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-27
note: Defines consumer contract term
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.48
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-27-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-27-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-27-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 27 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-27-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defines
logic summary: Defines a term with obligation
premise text: Consumer contract has meaning given by Australian Consumer Law.
conclusion text: Obligation to define consumer contract term
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

29 Subsection 4(1) (definition of non-party consumer)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-29
note: Definition of non-party consumer
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.48
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-29-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-29-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-29-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-29-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 29 Subsection 4(1) (definition of non-party consumer)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-29-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Class hierarchy
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-29-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Definition of non-party consumer implies a specific condition
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

31 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-31
note: Defines 'rely on' in relation to a consumer contract term.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.48
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-31-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-31-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-31-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-31-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 31 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-31-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defines
logic summary: Defines a key concept.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-31-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: applies to
logic summary: Applies to consumer contract terms.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

32 Subsection 4(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-32-2
note: Defines 'unfair' in relation to a term of a consumer contract.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.48
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 32 Subsection 4(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-32-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defines
logic summary: Defines a term with a specific meaning.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

40 At the end of paragraph 80(1)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-40-2
note: Enforcement and remedies under the Trade Practices Act 1974
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.48
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-40-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-40-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-40-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 40 At the end of paragraph 80(1)(a)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-40-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Enforcement and remedies under the Trade Practices Act 1974
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

41 Paragraph 80(1)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-41
note: Repeal of paragraph and substitution with contravention of certain provisions.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-41-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-41-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-41-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 41 Paragraph 80(1)(a)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-41-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of paragraph
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

42 At the end of paragraphs 80(1)(b) to (d)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-42-2
note: Add “or”.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-42-2-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-42-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 42 At the end of paragraphs 80(1)(b) to (d)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

43 After subsection 80(1B)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-43
note: Reference to contravention of consumer contract term declared unfair by Court.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-43-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-43-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-43-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-43-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 43 After subsection 80(1B)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-43-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
logic summary: Inclusion in contravention list.
premise text: Paragraph (1)(a)
conclusion text: Contravention of consumer contract term declared unfair by Court.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-43-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: refers to
logic summary: Reference to specific consumer contract term.
premise text: Term of consumer contract declared under section 87AC
conclusion text: Unfair term.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

46 Paragraphs 84(1)(b) and (3)(b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-46
note: Insertion of Australian Consumer Law provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-46-norm

47 At the end of subsection 86(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-47
note: Add “or has been instituted in relation to subsection 2(1) of the Australian Consumer Law (as applied under Division 1 of Part XI)”.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-47-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-47-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 47 At the end of subsection 86(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

48 Subsection 86(1A)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-48
note: Insertion of Australian Consumer Law provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-48-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-48-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-48-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 48 Subsection 86(1A)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-48-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insert
logic summary: Insertion obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

49 Subsection 86(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-49
note: Enforcement and remedies under the Trade Practices Act 1974
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.49
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-49-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-49-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-49-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 49 Subsection 86(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-49-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State to enforce and provide remedies under the Trade Practices Act 1974
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

46 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-46-2
note: Insertion of provision into Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-46-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-46-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-46-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insert
logic summary: Insertion of provision
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

50 Paragraphs 86A(1)(b), (4)(b) and (5)(b) and 86B(1)(b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-50
note: Insertion of Australian Consumer Law provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-50-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-50-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-50-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 50 Paragraphs 86A(1)(b), (4)(b) and (5)(b) and 86B(1)(b)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-50-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insert
logic summary: Insertion of provision
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

56 Subsection 87(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-56
note: Insertion of 'or of the Australian Consumer Law' after certain phrases.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-56-norm

57 Paragraphs 87(1A)(a) and (b) and (1B)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-57
note: Insertion of 'or a provision of the Australian Consumer Law' after certain phrases.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-57-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-57-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 57 Paragraphs 87(1A)(a) and (b) and (1B)(a)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

58 Subsection 87(1C)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-58
note: Insertion of additional provision in Australian Consumer Law
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-58-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-58-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 58 Subsection 87(1C)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

59 After subsection 87(5)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-59
note: Reference to contravention of consumer contract term is included.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-59-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-59-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-59-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-59-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 59 After subsection 87(5)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-59-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
logic summary: Inclusion of reference to contravention.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-59-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subClassOf
logic summary: Subclass relationship between terms.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

60 Paragraph 87AAA(1)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-60
note: Repeal of paragraph and substitution with specific conditions.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-60-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-60-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-60-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 60 Paragraph 87AAA(1)(a)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-60-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of conduct in contravention of provisions.
premise text: Part IVA, Division 1 or 1AAA of Part V, or Part VC
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

61 Paragraphs 87AAA(1)(b) and (c)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-61
note: Insertion of term into legal definition
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.50
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-61-norm

62 Subsection 87AAA(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-62
note: Prohibits making an order under subsection (1) against certain parties.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-62-norm

63 Paragraphs 87AAA(3)(a) and (b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-63
note: Insert 'or declared term' after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-63-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-63-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-63-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insertion
logic summary: Insertion of new term
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

64 Subsection 87AAA(4)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-64
note: Insert 'or declared term' after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-64-norm

65 Subsection 87AAA(5)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-65
note: Application can be made within 6 years after declaration or cause of action accrues.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-65-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-65-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-65-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 65 Subsection 87AAA(5)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-65-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: can
logic summary: Application can be made
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66 Subsection 87AAA(6)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-66
note: Replace 'subsection (2)' with 'paragraph (2)(a)'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-66-norm

67 After subsection 87AAA(6)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-67
note: Court may consider conduct of person and non-party consumers in relation to declared term when determining whether to make an order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-67-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-67-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-67-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 67 After subsection 87AAA(6)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-67-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: consider
logic summary: Consideration of conduct
premise text: Court may have regard to the conduct...
conclusion text: Obligation to consider conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

68 Paragraph 87AAA(8)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-68
note: Insertion of term after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.51
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-68-norm

48 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-48-2
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-48-2-norm

69 Paragraph 87AAA(9)(b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-69
note: Insert “, or declared term,” after ‘contravening conduct’.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-69-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-69-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-69-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 69 Paragraph 87AAA(9)(b)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-69-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insertion
logic summary: Insertion of term
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

70 Paragraph 87A(1)(b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-70
note: Insertion of Australian Consumer Law into a list
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-70-norm

72 Paragraph 87A(1)(d)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-72
note: Insertion of Australian Consumer Law in paragraph 87A(1)(d)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-72-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-72-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-72-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: insert
logic summary: Insertion of Australian Consumer Law
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

73 At the end of section 87A
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-73
note: Reference to contravention of a provision of the Australian Consumer Law includes reference to applying or relying on, or purporting to apply or rely on, an unfair term declared by the Court.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-73-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-73-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-73-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-73-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits applying or relying on, or purporting to apply or rely on, an unfair term.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-73-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify
logic summary: Classifies a reference to contravention of a provision as including a reference to applying or relying on, or purporting to apply or rely on, an unfair term.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74 After section 87AB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-74
note: Insert clause
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-74-norm

87AC Declarations
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ac
has part: 87AC(1) Declarations
has part: 87AC(1A) Declarations
has part: 87AC(2) Declarations
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52

87AC(1) Declarations
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1
part of: 87AC Declarations
note: Court may declare a term of a consumer contract as unfair.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87AC(1) Declarations
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Implies obligation
premise text: (1) The Court may...
conclusion text: The Court is obligated to declare...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

87AC(1A) Declarations
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1a
part of: 87AC Declarations
note: Consumer contract must be a standard form contract to apply subsection (1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1a-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87AC(1A) Declarations
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Must
logic summary: Mandatory condition
premise text: (1A) Subsection (1) does not apply unless...
conclusion text: ...the consumer contract is a standard form contract.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

87AC(2) Declarations
type: Concept
realized by: sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-2
part of: 87AC Declarations
note: Court's power to make declarations is not limited by subsection (1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.52
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-2-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-2-sec-87ac-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 87AC(2) Declarations
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

1A Subsections 12AE(1) and (3)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-1a
note: Insertion of new subdivision before Subdivision C
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.53
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-1a-norm

1 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-1
note: Defines consumer contract term
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.53
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-1-norm

3 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-3
note: Defines 'rely on' in relation to a consumer contract term
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.53
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 3 Subsection 12BA(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
logic summary: Includes attempts to enforce or exercise a right
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subClassOf
logic summary: Subclass of 'attempt' and 'exercise'
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

4 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-4
note: Defines 'transparent' in relation to a consumer contract term.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.53
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defines
logic summary: Defines a term with a specific meaning.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

5 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-5
note: Defines 'unfair' in relation to a consumer contract term.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.53
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-5-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 5 Subsection 12BA(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: defines
logic summary: Defines the meaning of 'unfair'
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

50 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-50
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-norm

6 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-6
note: Defines upfront price meaning
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-6-norm

7 After Subdivision B of Division 2 of Part 2
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-7
note: Insertion of subdivision BA—Unfair contract terms
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-7-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-7-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 7 After Subdivision B of Division 2 of Part 2
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

12BF Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bf
has part: 12BF(1) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
has part: 12BF(2) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
has part: 12BF(3) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54

12BF(1) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-1
part of: 12BF Unfair terms of consumer contracts
note: Unfair terms in consumer contracts are void.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BF(1) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: voids
logic summary: Prohibits unfair terms
premise text: (1) A term of a consumer contract is void...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BF(2) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2
part of: 12BF Unfair terms of consumer contracts
note: Contract continues to bind parties if it can operate without the unfair term.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Continuation
logic summary: Contract continuation obligation
premise text: Contract continues to bind parties if it is capable of operating without the unfair term.
conclusion text: The contract continues to bind the parties.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: TemporalContinuation
logic summary: Temporal continuation of contract
premise text: The contract continues to bind the parties if it is capable of operating without the unfair term.
conclusion text: The contract continues to bind the parties until a later time.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: TemporalContinuation
logic summary: Temporal continuation of contract
premise text: The contract continues to bind the parties if it is capable of operating without the unfair term.
conclusion text: The contract continues to bind the parties until a later time.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: TemporalContinuation
logic summary: Temporal continuation of contract
premise text: The contract continues to bind the parties if it is capable of operating without the unfair term.
conclusion text: The contract continues to bind the parties until a later time.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: TemporalContinuation
logic summary: Temporal continuation of contract
premise text: The contract continues to bind the parties if it is capable of operating without the unfair term.
conclusion text: The contract continues to bind the parties until a later time.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BF(3) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-3
part of: 12BF Unfair terms of consumer contracts
note: Consumer contract definition
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BF(3) Unfair terms of consumer contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: =
logic summary: Definition of consumer contract
premise text: Contract at least one party is an individual...
conclusion text: Consumer contract
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BG Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bg
has part: 12BG(1) Meaning of unfair
has part: 12BG(2) Meaning of unfair
has part: 12BG(3) Meaning of unfair
has part: 12BG(4) Meaning of unfair
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54

12BG(1) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1
part of: 12BG Meaning of unfair
note: A term of a consumer contract is unfair if it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations, is not reasonably necessary to protect legitimate interests, and would cause detriment to a party.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-ltl-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BG(1) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Unfair term implies imbalance in rights and obligations.
premise text: (a) it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations arising under the contract;
conclusion text: it is unfair
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Unfair term implies detriment to a party.
premise text: (c) it would cause detriment (whether financial or otherwise) to a party if it were to be applied or relied on;
conclusion text: it is unfair
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: within
logic summary: Unfair term causes detriment within a party.
premise text: (c) it would cause detriment (whether financial or otherwise) to a party if it were to be applied or relied on;
conclusion text: within detriment
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: everywhere
logic summary: Unfair term is everywhere in the contract.
premise text: (a) it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations arising under the contract;
conclusion text: everywhere imbalance
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Unfair term implies imbalance in rights and obligations.
premise text: (b) it is not reasonably necessary in order to protect the legitimate interests of the party who would be advantaged by the term;
conclusion text: it is unfair
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BG(2) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2
part of: 12BG Meaning of unfair
note: Court must consider certain factors when determining if a term is unfair.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BG(2) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider certain factors.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Court considers factors within a certain timeframe.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Court considers factors within a certain timeframe.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Court considers factors within a certain timeframe.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider certain factors.
premise text: (2) In determining whether a term of a consumer contract is unfair under subsection (1), a court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant, but must take into account the following:
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

12BG(3) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-3
part of: 12BG Meaning of unfair
note: Term must be transparent
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BG(3) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must be transparent
premise text: (3) A term is transparent if...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BG(4) Meaning of unfair
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-4
part of: 12BG Meaning of unfair
note: Term is presumed not reasonably necessary to protect legitimate interests unless proven otherwise.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.54
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BG(4) Meaning of unfair
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Presumption
logic summary: Presumes term not reasonably necessary unless proven otherwise.
premise text: (4) For the purposes of paragraph (1)(b)
conclusion text: (4) A term is presumed not to be reasonably necessary...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BH Examples of unfair terms
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bh
note: Examples of unfair terms in consumer contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.55
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bh-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bh-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bh-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits certain types of unfair terms in consumer contracts
premise text: (1) Without limiting section 12BG, the following are examples...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

52 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-52
note: Terms that permit unilateral determination of contract breach or interpretation, limit vicarious liability, assign contracts without consent, limit right to sue, limit evidence, impose evidential burden, or prescribe terms with specific effects are prohibited.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.56
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-6

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits the use of terms with specific effects.
premise text: (h) a term that permits, or has the effect of permitting, one party unilaterally to determine whether the contract has been breached or to interpret its meaning;
conclusion text: No such term is permitted.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that limit vicarious liability for agents.
premise text: (i) a term that limits, or has the effect of limiting, one party’s vicarious liability for its agents;
conclusion text: No such term is permitted.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that allow assignment of contracts without consent.
premise text: (j) a term that permits, or has the effect of permitting, one party to assign the contract to the detriment of another party without that other party’s consent;
conclusion text: No such term is permitted.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that limit a party's right to sue.
premise text: (k) a term that limits, or has the effect of limiting, one party’s right to sue another party;
conclusion text: No such term is permitted.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that limit evidence in proceedings.
premise text: (l) a term that limits, or has the effect of limiting, the evidence one party can adduce in proceedings relating to the contract;
conclusion text: No such term is permitted.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-logic-deontic-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits terms that impose evidential burden on a party.
premise text: (m) a term that imposes, or has the effect of imposing, the evidential burden on one party in proceedings relating to the contract;
conclusion text: No such term is permitted.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BI Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bi
has part: 12BI(1) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
has part: 12BI(2) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
has part: 12BI(3) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.56

12BI(1) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-1
part of: 12BI Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
note: Section 12BF does not apply to a term of a consumer contract under certain conditions.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.56
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: excludes
logic summary: Exclusion from Section 12BF
premise text: (1) Section 12BF does not apply to a term of a consumer contract
conclusion text: (a) defines the main subject matter of the contract; or (b) sets the upfront price payable under the contract; or (c) is a term required, or expressly permitted, by a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

12BI(2) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-2
part of: 12BI Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
note: Upfront price must be provided and disclosed at contract entry.
description: yes
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.56
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BI(2) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide upfront price
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BI(3) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3
part of: 12BI Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
note: Consumer contract consideration includes owed principal amount.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.56
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BI(3) Terms that define main subject matter of consumer contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: =
logic summary: Definition of obligation
conclusion text: Obligation exists
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bi-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
logic summary: Class hierarchy
conclusion text: Consumer contract is a class/subclass of contracts
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BK Standard form contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bk
has part: 12BK(1) Standard form contracts
has part: 12BK(2) Standard form contracts
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.57

12BK(1) Standard form contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-1
part of: 12BK Standard form contracts
note: Presumption of standard form contract
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.57
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BK(1) Standard form contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: presumption
logic summary: Presumes a standard form contract
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BK(2) Standard form contracts
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2
part of: 12BK Standard form contracts
note: Court must consider specific factors when determining if a contract is standard form.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.57
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-deontic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BK(2) Standard form contracts
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider specific factors.
premise text: Court may take into account such matters as it thinks relevant.
conclusion text: Court MUST consider the specified factors.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
logic summary: Factors relate to specific characteristics of parties or transactions.
premise text: (a) whether one of the parties has all or most of the bargaining power relating to the transaction;
conclusion text: The factors are BETWEEN the party's bargaining power and the transaction.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider specified terms in contracts.
premise text: (b) whether the contract was prepared by one party before any discussion relating to the transaction occurred between the parties;
conclusion text: The court MUST consider the specified terms.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bk-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Court must consider specified opportunities for negotiation.
premise text: (d) whether another party was given an effective opportunity to negotiate the terms of the contract that were not the terms referred to in subsection 12BI(1);
conclusion text: The court MUST provide the specified opportunities.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

54 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-54
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.58
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-54-norm

12BL Contracts to which this Part does not apply
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bl
note: Exemptions from application of this Part
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.58
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bl-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bl-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bl-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bl-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Exempts consumer contracts from the scope of this Part
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bl-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subclass
logic summary: Subclass of contracts not covered by this Part
premise text: company, managed investment scheme or other kind of body
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12BM Contraventions of this Subdivision etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12bm
note: Conduct is not taken to contravene this Subdivision merely because of subsection 12BF(1).
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.58
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-ltl-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12BM Contraventions of this Subdivision etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Exclusion
logic summary: Excluding subsection 12BF(1) from contravention
premise text: This Subdivision
conclusion text: Conduct is not taken to contravene this Subdivision
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposing obligation on conduct
premise text: This Act
conclusion text: Conduct is not taken to contravene this Subdivision
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Temporal overlap between subsection 12BF(1) and this Subdivision
premise text: This Act
conclusion text: Conduct is not taken to contravene this Subdivision
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
logic summary: Repeating the scope of subsection 12BF(1) in this Subdivision
premise text: This Act
conclusion text: Conduct is not taken to contravene this Subdivision
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12bm-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Exclusion
logic summary: Excluding subsection 12BF(1) from the scope of this Subdivision
premise text: This Act
conclusion text: Conduct is not taken to contravene this Subdivision
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

8 Application and transitional provisions
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-8
note: Application and transitional provisions
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.58
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-8-norm

9 After section 12GB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-9
has part: 9(1) After section 12GB
has part: 9(2) After section 12GB
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.59

9(1) After section 12GB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-9-ss-1
part of: 9 After section 12GB
note: Ordering pecuniary penalty for contravention of provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.59
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 9(1) After section 12GB
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Imposes prohibition on conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

9(2) After section 12GB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-9-ss-2
part of: 9 After section 12GB
note: Court must consider relevant matters when determining pecuniary penalty.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.59
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 9(2) After section 12GB
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Duty to consider relevant matters
premise text: (2) In determining the appropriate pecuniary penalty, the Court must...
conclusion text: The Court MUST have regard to all relevant matters...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
logic summary: Temporal interval for consideration
premise text: (2) In determining the appropriate pecuniary penalty, the Court must have regard to all relevant matters including:
conclusion text: The temporal interval is between the act or omission and the loss or damage.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: CONTAINS
logic summary: Temporal interval for consideration
premise text: (2) In determining the appropriate pecuniary penalty, the Court must have regard to all relevant matters including:
conclusion text: The temporal interval contains the act or omission and the loss or damage.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Duty to consider circumstances of act or omission
premise text: (b) the circumstances in which the act or omission took place;
conclusion text: The Court MUST have regard to the circumstances in which the act or omission took place.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Duty to consider previous conduct
premise text: (c) whether the person has previously been found by the Court in proceedings under this Subdivision to have engaged in any similar conduct.
conclusion text: The Court MUST have regard to whether the person has previously been found to have engaged in similar conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

56 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-56
has part: 56(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 56(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 56(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 56(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.60

56(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-56-ss-3
part of: 56 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Criminal proceedings may be started against a person for conduct substantially the same as a consumer protection breach. Maximum pecuniary penalty for certain acts or omissions
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.60
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Forbid
logic summary: Maximum pecuniary penalty for certain acts or omissions
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
logic summary: Defines temporal intervals for certain provisions
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

56(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-56-ss-4
part of: 56 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: No more than one pecuniary penalty for the same conduct. Prevents reusing evidence in criminal proceedings for substantially the same conduct as a previous consumer protection breach order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.60
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 56(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits multiple pecuniary penalties for the same conduct.
premise text: (4) If conduct constitutes a contravention of 2 or more provisions referred to in paragraph (1)(a):
conclusion text: but (b) a person is not liable to more than one pecuniary penalty under this section in respect of the same conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
logic summary: Permits multiple pecuniary penalties for different provisions.
premise text: (4) If conduct constitutes a contravention of 2 or more provisions referred to in paragraph (1)(a):
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: RecurringTrace
logic summary: Defines a recurring trace for 'contravention' and 'provision'
premise text: (4) If conduct constitutes a contravention of 2 or more provisions referred to in paragraph (1)(a):
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the person to not exceed one pecuniary penalty.
premise text: (4) If conduct constitutes a contravention of 2 or more provisions referred to in paragraph (1)(a):
conclusion text: but (b) a person is not liable to more than one pecuniary penalty under this section in respect of the same conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-4-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prevents reuse of evidence in criminal proceedings for substantially the same conduct.
premise text: Previous consumer protection breach order
conclusion text: No reusing evidence
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

56(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-56-ss-1
part of: 56 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Court cannot make an order under section 12GBA against a person in relation to certain consumer protection breaches. Commonwealth may recover pecuniary penalty from ASIC.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.60
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-1-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 56(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
logic summary: Prohibition of court action
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Obligation to recover penalty
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

56(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-56-ss-2
part of: 56 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Time limit for commencing a proceeding under subsection (1) Proceedings for an order under section 12GBA are stayed if criminal proceedings are started or have already been started against the person for an offence.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.60
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-ltl-7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-8

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 56(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: must
logic summary: Mandatory obligation
premise text: A proceeding under subsection (1) may be commenced within 6 years after the contravention.
conclusion text: The State must provide a proceeding under subsection (1) within 6 years after the contravention.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal relationship
premise text: (2) A proceeding under subsection (1) may be commenced within 6 years after the contravention.
conclusion text: The proceeding must occur during the 6-year period after the contravention.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal relationship
premise text: (2) A proceeding under subsection (1) may be commenced within 6 years after the contravention.
conclusion text: The proceeding must occur during the 6-year period after the contravention.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: must
logic summary: Mandatory obligation
premise text: (2) A proceeding under subsection (1) may be commenced within 6 years after the contravention.
conclusion text: The State must provide a proceeding under subsection (1) within 6 years after the contravention.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits proceedings under section 12GBA if criminal proceedings are started or have already been started.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 12GBA against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...the proceedings for the order may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between criminal proceedings and section 12GBA proceedings.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 12GBA against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...the proceedings for the order may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-ltl-7
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
logic summary: Describes the recurring nature of criminal proceedings and section 12GBA proceedings.
premise text: (2) Proceedings for an order under section 12GBA against a person in relation to a consumer protection breach are stayed...
conclusion text: ...the proceedings for the order may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-56-ss-2-logic-deontic-8
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
logic summary: Permits resumption of section 12GBA proceedings if the person is not convicted of the offence.
premise text: ...the proceedings for the order may be resumed if the person is not convicted of the offence.
conclusion text: ...Otherwise, the proceedings are dismissed.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

58 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-58
has part: 58(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 58(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 58(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 58(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 58(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62

58(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-58-ss-1
part of: 58 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Body corporate cannot indemnify a person against certain liabilities incurred as an officer.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 58(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: Agent
scope note: borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits indemnification against certain liabilities.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

58(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-58-ss-2
part of: 58 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Outcome of proceedings is the outcome of proceedings and any appeal in relation to the proceedings.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 58(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Outcome of proceedings is obligation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

58(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-58-ss-3
part of: 58 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Indemnities are void due to subsection (1) not authorizing anything unlawful.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-3-norm

58(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-58-ss-4
part of: 58 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Anything that purports to indemnify a person against a liability is void to the extent that it contravenes subsection (1).
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits indemnification against liability
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

58(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-58-ss-5
part of: 58 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Prohibition on conviction of certain offences
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits conviction of certain offences
premise text: (5) If, as a result of the operation of Part 2.4 of the Criminal Code...
conclusion text: the relevant offence is taken to be punishable on conviction by a fine not exceeding 5 penalty units.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for punishment
premise text: (5) If, as a result of the operation of Part 2.4 of the Criminal Code...
conclusion text: the relevant offence is taken to be punishable on conviction by a fine not exceeding 5 penalty units.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
logic summary: Defines recurring trace for punishment
premise text: (5) If, as a result of the operation of Part 2.4 of the Criminal Code...
conclusion text: the relevant offence is taken to be punishable on conviction by a fine not exceeding 5 penalty units.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
logic summary: Diffuses punishment to related offences
premise text: (5) If, as a result of the operation of Part 2.4 of the Criminal Code...
conclusion text: the relevant offence is taken to be punishable on conviction by a fine not exceeding 5 penalty units.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-58-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Classify
logic summary: Classifies offences as punishable by fine using AI
premise text: (5) If, as a result of the operation of Part 2.4 of the Criminal Code...
conclusion text: the relevant offence is taken to be punishable on conviction by a fine not exceeding 5 penalty units.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

10 Paragraph 12GCA(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-10
note: Imposes fines or pecuniary penalties for contraventions of this Division.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.62
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-10-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-10-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-10-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 10 Paragraph 12GCA(a)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-10-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Imposes prohibition.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

11 Section 12GG
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-11
note: Substitute section numbers
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.63
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-11-norm

12 At the end of section 12GI (after the note)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12
note: Court may relieve person from liability to pay a pecuniary penalty if they acted honestly and reasonably.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.63
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-epistemic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-ltl-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Relief
logic summary: Court may relieve person from liability.
premise text: Person has engaged in conduct that relates to a contravention of a provision.
conclusion text: Court relieves person from liability.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Excuse
logic summary: Court may excuse person's conduct if they acted honestly and reasonably.
premise text: Person has engaged in conduct that relates to a contravention of a provision.
conclusion text: Court excuses person's conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-epistemic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: Justification
logic summary: Court considers all circumstances of the case when deciding whether to relieve or excuse the person.
premise text: Person has engaged in conduct that relates to a contravention of a provision.
conclusion text: Court justifies its decision based on the circumstances.
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
logic summary: The court's decision is based on a recurring trace of the person's conduct.
premise text: Person has engaged in conduct that relates to a contravention of a provision.
conclusion text: Court traces the person's conduct.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
logic summary: The court may relieve or excuse the person from liability.
premise text: Person has engaged in conduct that relates to a contravention of a provision.
conclusion text: Court permits relief or excuse.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

13 Subsection 12GLB(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-13
note: Prohibit adverse publicity order against a person who has been ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty or is guilty of an offence under section 12GB.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.63
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-13-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-13-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-13-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

60 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-60
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.64
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-60-norm

14 Before section 12GM
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-14
has part: 14(1) Before section 12GM
has part: 14(2) Before section 12GM
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.64

14(1) Before section 12GM
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-14-ss-1
part of: 14 Before section 12GM
note: Disqualification from managing corporations
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.64
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation
logic summary: Obligation to disqualify
premise text: ASIC applies for disqualification
conclusion text: Court may make an order
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

14(2) Before section 12GM
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-14-ss-2
part of: 14 Before section 12GM
note: Court may consider a person's conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.64
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 14(2) Before section 12GM
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: consider
logic summary: Consideration of conduct
premise text: (a) the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation;
conclusion text: The Court may consider this conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal interval for consideration
premise text: (2) In determining under subsection (1) whether the disqualification is justified, the Court may have regard to: (a) the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation;
conclusion text: This conduct is considered during the determination.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal interval for consideration
premise text: (2) In determining under subsection (1) whether the disqualification is justified, the Court may have regard to: (a) the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation;
conclusion text: This conduct is considered during the determination.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may consider
logic summary: May consider conduct
premise text: (2) In determining under subsection (1) whether the disqualification is justified, the Court may have regard to: (a) the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation;
conclusion text: The Court may consider this conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: must consider
logic summary: Must consider conduct
premise text: (2) In determining under subsection (1) whether the disqualification is justified, the Court must have regard to: (a) the person’s conduct in relation to the management, business or property of any corporation;
conclusion text: The Court must consider this conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

15 After section 206EA
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-15
note: Amendment of corporations legislation
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.64
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-15-norm

206EB Disqualification under the ASIC Act
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-206eb
note: Disqualification from managing corporations based on court order
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.65
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-206eb-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-206eb-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-206eb-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 206EB Disqualification under the ASIC Act
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-206eb-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Court order imposes obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

16 Paragraph 1274AA(1)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-16
note: Substitute provisions
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.65
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-16-norm

17 After paragraph 1274AA(2)(ab)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-17
note: Insert court order referred to in section 206EB
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.65
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-17-norm

62 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-62
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-62-norm

18 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-18
note: Definition of substantiation notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-18-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-18-logic-descriptionlogic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-18-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: definition
logic summary: Defines a term
conclusion text: substantiation notice means a notice under section 12GY.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

19 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-19
note: Defines substantiation notice compliance period
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-19-norm

20 Before Subdivision H of Division 2 of Part 2
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-20
note: Insert Subdivision GC—Substantiation notices
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-20-norm

12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy
has part: 12GY(1) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 12GY(2) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 12GY(3) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 12GY(4) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 12GY(5) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
has part: 12GY(6) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66

12GY(1) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-1
part of: 12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: A person must substantiate claims within 21 days of receiving a substantiation notice. ASIC may require claims to be substantiated.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12GY(1) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide substantiation within 21 days.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GY(2) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-2
part of: 12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: ASIC may give a written notice requiring the person to provide information and/or documents
description: [a, b, c]
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to provide information and/or documents
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GY(3) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-3
part of: 12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: ASIC may require substantiation of claims and representations.
description: (a) substantiating or supporting the claim or representation; (b) substantiating the quantities in which, or the period for which, the person is or will be able to make such a supply
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
logic summary: Requires substantiation of claims and representations.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: relevant
logic summary: Relevant information must be provided for substantiation.
premise text: (2)(c)
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GY(4) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-4
part of: 12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: Notice must be given to a person and specify the claim or representation it relates to.
description: notice, explanation of sections 12GYA, 12GYB, and 12GYC
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Notice must be given
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GY(5) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-5
part of: 12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: ASIC may require substantiation of claims
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-5-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation to provide substantiation
premise text: ASIC may require substantiation of claims
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GY(6) ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-6
part of: 12GY ASIC may require claims to be substantiated etc.
note: Exemption for prescribed information providers
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.66
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gy-ss-6-norm

64 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-64
has part: 64(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 64(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 64(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.68

64(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-64-ss-2
part of: 64 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Substantiation notice compliance period Exemptions from the section's application Extend period for compliance with notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.68
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-logic-deontic-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Section does not apply to certain types of information
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
logic summary: Temporal interval between when information was provided and when it was known to be false or misleading
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: May
logic summary: Grant permission to extend period
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

64(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-64-ss-1
part of: 64 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Comply with substantiation notice within specified period. Prohibits giving false or misleading information to ASIC in compliance with a substantiation notice.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.68
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-logic-deontic-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 64(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: Agent
scope note: borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must comply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
logic summary: Prohibits action
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes duty
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the person
premise text: (1) A person must not...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

64(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-64-ss-3
part of: 64 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Refusal to provide information or produce a document under substantiation notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.68
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 64(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: refuse
logic summary: Refusal to comply with a substantiation notice
premise text: The individual may refuse or fail to give particular information...
conclusion text: The individual is not required to provide the requested information.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: doubt
logic summary: Doubting the request for information due to potential incrimination or penalty
premise text: The individual may refuse or fail to give particular information...
conclusion text: There is doubt about the necessity of providing the requested information.
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: trace
logic summary: Tracing the request for information through a chain of events
premise text: The individual may refuse or fail to give particular information...
conclusion text: The request for information is part of a larger sequence of actions.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: counterclaim
logic summary: Presenting a counterargument to the request for information
premise text: The individual may refuse or fail to give particular information...
conclusion text: There is a valid reason for not providing the requested information.
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-64-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps
logic summary: Identifying overlapping temporal intervals between requests and refusals
premise text: The individual may refuse or fail to give particular information...
conclusion text: There is an overlap in the timing of the request and refusal.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

21 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-21
note: Definition of enforcement proceeding
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.69
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-21-norm

22 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-22
note: Defines non-party consumer for conduct enforcement proceedings.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.69
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-22-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-22-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-22-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-22-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: is defined as
logic summary: Defines a term with a specific meaning.
conclusion text: non-party consumer
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-22-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: has a definition
logic summary: Provides a formal definition for the term.
conclusion text: Insert: non-party consumer, in relation to conduct, means a person who is...
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

23 Section 12GG
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-23
note: Inserts 'or 12GNB(1)' after subsection 12GM(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.69
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-23-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-23-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 23 Section 12GG
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

24 Subsection 12GM(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-24
note: Inserts 'or 12GNB' after section 12GD
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.69
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-24-norm

25 Paragraph 12GN(1)(d)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-25
note: Inserts 'or 12GNB(1)' after certain subsections.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.69
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-25-norm

26 After section 12GNA
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-26
note: Prohibition on conduct contravening a provision of Subdivision C or D
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.69
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-26-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-26-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-26-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition on conduct
premise text: Contravening a provision of Subdivision C or D
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66
has part: 66(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(6) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(8) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(9) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(10) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 66(11) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70

66(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-2
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Order may be made against person who engaged in contravening conduct or a person involved in that conduct.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-2-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Imposes prohibition on conduct.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Hold
logic summary: Holds state responsible for enforcement of prohibition.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-3
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Court must consider redress or prevention of loss/damage before making an order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation
premise text: Court must consider...
conclusion text: Order can only be made if...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-4
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Allow application under subsection (1) despite non-instituted enforcement proceeding.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-4-norm

66(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-5
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Application can be made within 6 years after the cause of action accrues.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-logic-ltl-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: can
logic summary: Ability to make an application within a time limit.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: within
logic summary: Time frame for making an application.
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: trace
logic summary: Application can be made at any time within a specified interval.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66(6) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-6
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Consider conduct of person and non-party consumers in determining whether to make an order under subsection (1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-6-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(6) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

66(8) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-8
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Court does not need to determine non-party consumers or nature of loss/damage in making an order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(8) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
logic summary: Exemptions from non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: temporal interval
logic summary: Temporal intervals for non-party consumers and loss/damage determination are not specified
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: trace
logic summary: No trace of non-party consumers and loss/damage determination is provided
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffusion
logic summary: No diffusion of non-party consumers and loss/damage determination is provided
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-8-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: cognitive agent
logic summary: No cognitive agent is specified for non-party consumers and loss/damage determination
premise text: (8) In determining whether to make an order under subsection (1), the Court need not...
conclusion text: ...the following matters:
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

66(9) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-9
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Non-party consumer bound by order if loss or damage is redressed, prevented, or reduced.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-linearlogic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(9) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Non-party consumer bound by order.
premise text: (a) an order is made under subsection (1) against a person; and (b) the loss or damage suffered, or likely to be suffered, by a non-party consumer...
conclusion text: (d) the non-party consumer is bound by the order;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Implication
logic summary: Non-party consumer bound by order if loss or damage is redressed, prevented, or reduced.
premise text: (a) an order is made under subsection (1) against a person; and (b) the loss or damage suffered, or likely to be suffered, by a non-party consumer...
conclusion text: (d) the non-party consumer is bound by the order;
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: No claim, action, or demand may be made against person.
premise text: (f) despite any other provision of this Act or any other law of the Commonwealth, or a State or Territory, no claim, action or demand may be made or taken against the person by the non-party consumer in relation to that loss or damage.
conclusion text: None;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-9-logic-linearlogic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Implication
logic summary: No claim, action, or demand may be made against person if loss or damage is redressed, prevented, or reduced.
premise text: (f) despite any other provision of this Act or any other law of the Commonwealth, or a State or Territory, no claim, action or demand may be made or taken against the person by the non-party consumer in relation to that loss or damage.
conclusion text: None;
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66(10) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-10
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Section 12GNA may limit liability for contravention of section 12DA.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-epistemic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-linearlogic-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 66(10) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Limitation
logic summary: Limits liability for contravention of section 12DA.
premise text: Section 12GNA may limit the liability, under an order made under subsection (1) of this section...
conclusion text: of a person for his or her contravention of section 12DA
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Restriction
logic summary: Restricts liability for contravention of section 12DA.
premise text: Section 12GNA may limit the liability, under an order made under subsection (1) of this section...
conclusion text: of a person for his or her contravention of section 12DA
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-epistemic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: Uncertainty
logic summary: Introduces uncertainty in liability for contravention of section 12DA.
premise text: Section 12GNA may limit the liability, under an order made under subsection (1) of this section...
conclusion text: of a person for his or her contravention of section 12DA
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-10-logic-linearlogic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Implication
logic summary: Implicates limitation on liability for contravention of section 12DA.
premise text: Section 12GNA may limit the liability, under an order made under subsection (1) of this section...
conclusion text: of a person for his or her contravention of section 12DA
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

66(11) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-66-ss-11
part of: 66 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Exemption from application of section 66(11) for conduct occurring before commencement.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.70
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits application of section for conduct occurring before commencement.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for exemption.
premise text: (11) This section does not apply in relation to contravening conduct that occurred before the commencement of this section.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
logic summary: Establishes implication between exemption and conduct.
premise text: (11) This section does not apply in relation to contravening conduct that occurred before the commencement of this section.
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuses
logic summary: Diffuses exemption to related conduct.
premise text: (11) This section does not apply in relation to contravening conduct that occurred before the commencement of this section.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-66-ss-11-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognizes
logic summary: Recognizes exemption as a rule.
premise text: (11) This section does not apply in relation to contravening conduct that occurred before the commencement of this section.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

68 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-68
note: Orders that may be made to redress loss or damage suffered by non-party consumers
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.72
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-68-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-68-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-68-logic-alleninterval-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-68-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 68 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-68-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
logic summary: Includes all or any of the following orders
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-68-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
logic summary: Orders may specify a date before which the order has effect
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

27 Paragraph 12HB(1)(b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-27
note: Insert 12GNB(1) into the list of alternatives for 12HB(1)(b)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.73
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-27-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-27-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-27-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 27 Paragraph 12HB(1)(b)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-27-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Insert
logic summary: Insertion of a new alternative into an existing list
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

70 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-70
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-70-norm

28 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-28
note: Definition of infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-28-norm

29 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-29
note: Defines infringement notice compliance period
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-29-norm

30 Subsection 12BA(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-30
note: Definition of infringement notice provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-30-norm

31 After Subdivision GA of Division 2 of Part 2
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-31
note: Insertion of infringement notices subdivision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-31-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-31-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 31 After Subdivision GA of Division 2 of Part 2
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

12GX Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gx
has part: 12GX(1) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
has part: 12GX(2) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
has part: 12GX(3) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74

12GX(1) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1
part of: 12GX Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
note: Issue of infringement notice as an alternative to proceedings for order under section 12GBA. ASIC may issue an infringement notice to a person if reasonable grounds exist.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-argumentation-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-deontic-6
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-epistemic-7
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-ltl-8

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12GX(1) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Issue of infringement notice as an alternative to proceedings for order under section 12GBA.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
logic summary: Conditional commencement
premise text: (1) The purpose of this Subdivision is to provide for the issue of an infringement notice to a person for an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision as an alternative to proceedings for an order under section 12GBA.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
logic summary: Issue of infringement notice as an alternative to proceedings for order under section 12GBA.
premise text: (1) The purpose of this Subdivision is to provide for the issue of an infringement notice to a person for an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision as an alternative to proceedings for an order under section 12GBA.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffusion
logic summary: Issue of infringement notice as an alternative to proceedings for order under section 12GBA.
premise text: (1) The purpose of this Subdivision is to provide for the issue of an infringement notice to a person for an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision as an alternative to proceedings for an order under section 12GBA.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Claim
logic summary: Issue of infringement notice as an alternative to proceedings for order under section 12GBA.
premise text: (1) The purpose of this Subdivision is to provide for the issue of an infringement notice to a person for an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision as an alternative to proceedings for an order under section 12GBA.
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-deontic-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Implies an obligation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-epistemic-7
type: LogicApplication
modality: Epistemic
operator: reasonable grounds
logic summary: Requires evidence for the obligation.
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-1-logic-ltl-8
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: if
logic summary: Applies to a conditional situation.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GX(2) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2
part of: 12GX Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
note: ASIC must not issue more than one infringement notice for the same alleged contravention. No infringement notice required for alleged contravention of infringement notice provision
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-6

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 12GX(2) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of issuing multiple infringement notices.
premise text: (2) ASIC must not issue more than one infringement notice to the person for the same alleged contravention of the infringement notice provision.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Restrict
logic summary: Restriction on ASIC's actions regarding issuing infringement notices.
premise text: (2) ASIC must not issue more than one infringement notice to the person for the same alleged contravention of the infringement notice provision.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Imply
logic summary: Implication of ASIC's prohibition on issuing multiple infringement notices.
premise text: (2) ASIC must not issue more than one infringement notice to the person for the same alleged contravention of the infringement notice provision.
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: ¬
logic summary: Negative obligation
premise text: (2) This Subdivision does not: (a) require an infringement notice to be issued to a person for an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision;
conclusion text: No infringement notice required.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: ¬
logic summary: Negative prohibition
premise text: (2) This Subdivision does not: (b) affect the liability of a person to proceedings under Subdivision G (sections 12GA to 12GO) in relation to an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision if:
conclusion text: No effect on liability.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-2-logic-deontic-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: ¬
logic summary: Negative obligation
premise text: (2) This Subdivision does not: (c) prevent a Court from imposing a higher penalty than the penalty specified in the infringement notice if the person does not comply with the notice.
conclusion text: No prevention of higher penalty.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

12GX(3) Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3
part of: 12GX Purpose and effect of this Subdivision
note: Infringement notice has no effect if issued more than 12 months after alleged contravention.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.74
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-logic-ltl-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits issuance of infringement notice after 12 months.
premise text: (3) The infringement notice does not have any effect if the notice: (a) is issued more than 12 months after the day on which the contravention of the infringement notice provision is alleged to have occurred;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: TemporalInterval
logic summary: Defines temporal scope of infringement notice.
premise text: (3) The infringement notice does not have any effect if the notice: (a) is issued more than 12 months after the day on which the contravention of the infringement notice provision is alleged to have occurred;
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-12gx-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: RecurringTrace
logic summary: Defines recurring trace of infringement notices.
premise text: (3) The infringement notice does not have any effect if the notice: (a) is issued more than 12 months after the day on which the contravention of the infringement notice provision is alleged to have occurred;
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

72 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-72
has part: 72(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 72(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 72(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.76

72(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-72-ss-1
part of: 72 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Pay penalty within infringement notice compliance period.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.76
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-logic-deontic-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 72(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Duty to pay penalty
premise text: (a) an infringement notice for an alleged contravention of an infringement notice provision is issued to a person;
conclusion text: the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Duty to pay penalty
premise text: (b) the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
conclusion text: the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Duty to pay penalty
premise text: (c) the infringement notice is not withdrawn under section 12GXG.
conclusion text: the person pays the penalty specified in the infringement notice within the infringement notice compliance period and in accordance with the notice;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

72(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-72-ss-2
part of: 72 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Payment does not imply contravention of infringement notice provision.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.76
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
logic summary: Payment implies obligation to comply.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

72(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-72-ss-3
part of: 72 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: No proceedings can be started or continued against the Commonwealth or ASIC in relation to certain alleged contraventions.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.76
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-72-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: No proceedings can be started or continued.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74
has part: 74(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 74(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 74(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 74(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 74(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 74(6) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
has part: 74(7) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78

74(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-1
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Right to withdraw infringement notice Infringement notice compliance period is 28 days after notice issuance.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-1-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 74(1) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: can
logic summary: Right to withdraw
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the state.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74(2) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-2
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Extend infringement notice compliance period by notice in writing. Protection from adverse inferences against the person or representative making representations to ASIC.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit
logic summary: Grant permission to extend infringement notice compliance period.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Protection from adverse inferences
premise text: The person or representative making representations to ASIC is protected from adverse inferences.
conclusion text: ASIC cannot infer adverse inferences against the person or representative.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
logic summary: Exemptions from adverse inferences
premise text: The person or representative making representations to ASIC is exempt from adverse inferences in proceedings other than those for an offence based on false or misleading evidence.
conclusion text: ASIC cannot infer adverse inferences against the person or representative in proceedings other than those for an offence based on false or misleading evidence.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Protection from adverse inferences against representatives
premise text: The representative making representations to ASIC is protected from adverse inferences.
conclusion text: ASIC cannot infer adverse inferences against the representative making representations to ASIC.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Protection from adverse inferences against ASIC
premise text: ASIC is protected from adverse inferences when making representations under subsection (1).
conclusion text: ASIC cannot infer adverse inferences against itself when making representations under subsection (1).
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74(3) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-3
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Extension of deadline is prohibited after one extension. Withdrawal of infringement notice upon ASIC's satisfaction
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-3-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-3-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition
premise text: (3) Only one extension may be given and the extension must not be for longer than 28 days.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit
logic summary: Granting permission to withdraw infringement notice
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-4
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Notice of extension must be given to the person issued the infringement notice. Must provide content of withdrawal notices regardless of representations made.
description: Content of withdrawal notices
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-4-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-4-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 74(4) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-5
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Withdrawal notice must state certain information. Failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
description: name and address of the person, day on which infringement notice was issued, that proceedings may be started or continued against the person
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-diffusion-5
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-cogai-6

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 74(5) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must state certain information.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
logic summary: Obligation to comply with subsection (4)
premise text: (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
conclusion text: A failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Conjunction
logic summary: Obligation and description logic both apply
premise text: (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
conclusion text: A failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Extension and valid extension overlap in time
premise text: (5) A failure to comply with subsection (4)
conclusion text: A failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: DoesNotPrevent
logic summary: Failure to comply with subsection (4) does not prevent valid extension
premise text: (5) A failure to comply with subsection (4)
conclusion text: A failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-5-logic-cogai-6
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: DoesNotPrevent
logic summary: Failure to comply with subsection (4) does not prevent valid extension
premise text: (5) A failure to comply with subsection (4)
conclusion text: A failure to comply with subsection (4) does not affect the validity of the extension.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74(6) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-6
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Reference to infringement notice compliance period is taken to be the extended period. Withdrawal notice must be given within infringement notice compliance period.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-6-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-6-logic-deontic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 74(6) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
logic summary: Extension of infringement notice compliance period
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-6-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must provide withdrawal notice
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

74(7) Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-74-ss-7
part of: 74 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
note: Refund of penalty paid after withdrawal of infringement notice
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.78
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-7-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-7-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-74-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Duty to refund penalty
premise text: ASIC must refund
conclusion text: to the person an amount equal to the amount paid
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

76 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-76
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.80
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-76-norm

32 After section 12GLB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-32
has part: 32(1) After section 12GLB
has part: 32(2) After section 12GLB
has part: 32(3) After section 12GLB
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.80

32(1) After section 12GLB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-32-ss-1
part of: 32 After section 12GLB
note: ASIC may issue a written notice containing a warning about conduct that constitutes a contravention of a provision.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.80
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Expresses permission or obligation.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

32(2) After section 12GLB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-32-ss-2
part of: 32 After section 12GLB
note: Refusal to respond to substantiation notice within specified period
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.80
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits refusal to respond to substantiation notice
premise text: ASIC is satisfied it is in the public interest
conclusion text: Warning notice may be issued
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

32(3) After section 12GLB
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-32-ss-3
part of: 32 After section 12GLB
note: Notice issued under subsection (1) or (2) is not a legislative instrument.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.80
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-32-ss-3-norm

34 Subsection 12BA(1) (definition of non-party consumer)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-34
note: Definition of non-party consumer
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.81
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-34-norm

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-34-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 34 Subsection 12BA(1) (definition of non-party consumer)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

37 At the end of section 12GD
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-37
note: Reference to unfair term in consumer contract is a contravention of this Division.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.81
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-37-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-37-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-37-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-37-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 37 At the end of section 12GD
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-37-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
logic summary: Inclusion in reference to a contravention.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-37-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subclassOf
logic summary: Unfair term is a subclass of consumer contract term.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

42 At the end of section 12GM
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-42
note: Reference to unfair term in consumer contract is a contravention of this Division.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.81
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-42-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-42-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-42-logic-descriptionlogic-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-42-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 42 At the end of section 12GM
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-42-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
logic summary: Inclusion in reference to a contravention.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-42-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subclassOf
logic summary: Unfair term is a subclass of consumer contract term.
execution surface: modalities::dl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

44 At the end of section 12GN
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-44
note: Reference to contravention of provision includes applying or ComLaw Authoritative Act
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.81
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-44-norm

78 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-78
note: Prohibits relying on or applying unfair terms in consumer contracts declared by the Court.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-cogai-5

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 78 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
logic summary: Prohibits relying on or applying unfair terms.
premise text: Term declared by the Court to be an unfair term.
conclusion text: Relying on or applying such term is prohibited.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Describes the temporal interval during which the prohibition applies.
premise text: Term declared by the Court to be an unfair term.
conclusion text: Relying on or applying such term is prohibited during the period of declaration.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: until
logic summary: Describes the temporal interval until which the prohibition applies.
premise text: Term declared by the Court to be an unfair term.
conclusion text: Relying on or applying such term is prohibited until the declaration is revoked.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: through
logic summary: Describes how the prohibition spreads.
premise text: Term declared by the Court to be an unfair term.
conclusion text: Relying on or applying such term is prohibited through all relevant channels.
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-78-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: by
logic summary: Describes how AI systems apply the prohibition.
premise text: Term declared by the Court to be an unfair term.
conclusion text: Relying on or applying such term is prohibited through AI system applications.
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

45 Paragraph 12GNB(1)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-45
note: Repeal a provision and substitute with a new prohibition
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-45-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-45-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-45-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 45 Paragraph 12GNB(1)(a)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-45-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits conduct in contravention of a provision
premise text: Subdivision C or D
conclusion text: Contravening conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

46 Paragraphs 12GNB(1)(b) and (c)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-46
note: Insert 'or declared term' after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-46-norm

47 Subsection 12GNB(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-47
note: Prohibit making an order under subsection (1) against a specific party.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-logic-alleninterval-3

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
logic summary: Prohibition
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: LinearLogic
operator: and
logic summary: Combination of prohibitions
execution surface: modalities::linear
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-47-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal relation
premise text: (2) An order under subsection (1)
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

48 Paragraphs 12GNB(3)(a) and (b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-48
note: Insertion of term after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-48-norm

49 Subsection 12GNB(4)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-49
note: Insertion of term after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-49-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-49-logic-alleninterval-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-49-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: after
logic summary: Temporal relation application
premise text: contravening conduct
conclusion text: or declared term
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

50 Subsection 12GNB(5)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-50-2
note: Application can be made within 6 years after the declaration is made or the cause of action accrues.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.82
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-2-logic-alleninterval-2

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 50 Subsection 12GNB(5)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate
logic summary: Application can be made within 6 years after the declaration is made or the cause of action accrues.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-50-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal interval
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

51 Subsection 12GNB(6)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-51
note: Replace 'subsection (2)' with 'paragraph (2)(a)'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-51-norm

52 After subsection 12GNB(6)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-52-2
note: Court may consider conduct of person and non-party consumers in relation to declared term when determining whether to make an order.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-2-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-2-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 52 After subsection 12GNB(6)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-52-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: consider
logic summary: Consideration of conduct
premise text: Court may have regard to the conduct...
conclusion text: Obligation to consider conduct
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

53 Paragraph 12GNB(8)(a)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-53
note: Insertion of term after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-53-norm

54 Paragraph 12GNB(9)(b)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-54-2
note: Insertion of term after 'contravening conduct'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-54-2-norm

55 Before section 12GO
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-55
has part: 55(1) Before section 12GO
has part: 55(1A) Before section 12GO
has part: 55(2) Before section 12GO
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83

55(1) Before section 12GO
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-55-ss-1
part of: 55 Before section 12GO
note: Court may declare an unfair term in a consumer contract.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 55(1) Before section 12GO
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: may
logic summary: Declaration of unfair term
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

55(1A) Before section 12GO
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-55-ss-1a
part of: 55 Before section 12GO
note: Consumer contract must be a standard form contract for financial product or services.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1a-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 55(1A) Before section 12GO
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Must
logic summary: Mandatory condition
premise text: (1A) Subsection (1) does not apply unless...
conclusion text: ...a standard form contract that is: ...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

55(2) Before section 12GO
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-55-ss-2
part of: 55 Before section 12GO
note: Court's power to make declarations not limited by subsection (1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.83
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-55-ss-2-norm

80 Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 1) 2010 No. 44,
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-80
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.84
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-80-norm

57 After subsection 102(2B)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-3-sec-57
note: ASIC must not delegate a function or power under section 12GLC, nor under Subdivision GB or GC of Division 2 of Part 2 to a person other than a member of ASIC or a member of staff who is an SES employee or an acting SES employee.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.84
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-norm
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-deontic-1
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-ltl-3
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-argumentation-4

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of delegation
premise text: ASIC must not delegate a function or power under section 12GLC, nor under Subdivision GB or GC of Division 2 of Part 2 to a person other than a member of ASIC or a member of staff who is an SES employee or an acting SES employee.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
logic summary: Temporal interval for delegation
premise text: ASIC must not delegate a function or power under section 12GLC, nor under Subdivision GB or GC of Division 2 of Part 2 to a person other than a member of ASIC or a member of staff who is an SES employee or an acting SES employee.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
logic summary: Recurring trace for delegation
premise text: ASIC must not delegate a function or power under section 12GLC, nor under Subdivision GB or GC of Division 2 of Part 2 to a person other than a member of ASIC or a member of staff who is an SES employee or an acting SES employee.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-3-sec-57-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
logic summary: Implication of delegation on ASIC's functions and powers
premise text: ASIC must not delegate a function or power under section 12GLC, nor under Subdivision GB or GC of Division 2 of Part 2 to a person other than a member of ASIC or a member of staff who is an SES employee or an acting SES employee.
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

1 Paragraphs 2(e) and (f) of Schedule 3
type: Concept
realized by: sch-4-sec-1
note: Substitute 'Schedule 1' for 'the Schedule'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.85
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-4-sec-1-norm

2 Paragraph 5D(5B)(c)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-4-sec-2
note: Replace 'the Schedule' with 'Schedule 1'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.85
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-4-sec-2-norm

3 Subsection 6(3)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-4-sec-3
note: Substitute specific section numbers.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.85
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-4-sec-3-norm

4 Section 150A (definition of Schedule version of Part IV)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-4-sec-4
note: Substitute 'Schedule 1' for 'the Schedule'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.85
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-4-sec-4-norm

5 Schedule (heading)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-4-sec-5
note: Substitute 'Schedule 1' for 'Schedule'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act.pdf, p.85
asserts: trade-practices-amendment-australian-consumer-law-act-sch-4-sec-5-norm