Australian Human Rights Commission Legislation Amendment (Selection and Appointment) Act 2022
type: Document
category: AU
identifier: No. 48 of 2022
description: An Act to amend the law relating to the appointment of members of the Australian Human Rights Commission, and for related purposes
proposed by: legis2cml
curation status: Proposed

1 Short title
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1
note: Short title of the Act
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.6
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-1-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-1-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sec-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: is
logic summary: Identifies the Act as a short title
conclusion text: The Act is the Australian Human Rights Commission Legislation Amendment (Selection and Appointment) Act 2022.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2 Commencement
type: Concept
realized by: sec-2
note: Commencement rules for provisions in the Act.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.6
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-2-norm

1 Section 1
type: Concept
realized by: sec-1-2
note: Commencement of the Act
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.6
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-1-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-1-2-logic-alleninterval-1

c2022a00048-sec-1-2-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
logic summary: Temporal relation
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

10 November
type: Concept
realized by: sec-10
note: Note on table limitations and amendments
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.6
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-10-norm

3 Schedules
type: Concept
realized by: sec-3
note: Legislation in schedules is amended or repealed according to its terms.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.6
asserts: c2022a00048-sec-3-norm

1 Subsection 53A(1) (note)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-1
note: Repeal a note and substitute with new text.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.7
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-1-norm

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-1-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 1 Subsection 53A(1) (note)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

2 Subsection 53A(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-2
has part: 2(2) Subsection 53A(2)
has part: 2(3) Subsection 53A(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.7

2(2) Subsection 53A(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-2-ss-2
part of: 2 Subsection 53A(2)
note: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.7
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 2(2) Subsection 53A(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

2(3) Subsection 53A(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-2-ss-3
part of: 2 Subsection 53A(2)
note: Reappointment exception for previous Age Discrimination Commissioner
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.7
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-cogai-5

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 2(3) Subsection 53A(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Defines the temporal interval for reappointment eligibility
premise text: the start of the period of reappointment
conclusion text: immediately before the start of the period of reappointment
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
logic summary: Justifies the exception for previous Age Discrimination Commissioner
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply in relation to the reappointment of a person who, immediately before the start of the period of reappointment, holds office as the Age Discrimination Commissioner under a previous appointment
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Propagation
logic summary: Applies to all persons eligible for reappointment
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply in relation to the reappointment of a person who, immediately before the start of the period of reappointment, holds office as the Age Discrimination Commissioner under a previous appointment
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-2-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Inference
logic summary: Analyzes the exception for previous Age Discrimination Commissioner
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply in relation to the reappointment of a person who, immediately before the start of the period of reappointment, holds office as the Age Discrimination Commissioner under a previous appointment
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

3 Subsection 53B(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-3
note: Omit the second sentence.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.7
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-3-norm

4 After subsection 53B(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-4
note: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.7
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-4-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-4-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-4-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 4 After subsection 53B(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of excessive appointment duration
premise text: Appointment period exceeds 7 years
conclusion text: No appointment is allowed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

5 After subsection 8A(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-5
has part: 5(1A) After subsection 8A(1)
has part: 5(1B) After subsection 8A(1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.8

5(1A) After subsection 8A(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a
part of: 5 After subsection 8A(1)
note: Must have appropriate qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.8
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a-logic-deontic-2

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 5(1A) After subsection 8A(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Obligation
premise text: (1A) A person must not be appointed...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1a-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Merit-based selection process
premise text: (b) the selection of the person for the appointment is...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

5(1B) After subsection 8A(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b
part of: 5 After subsection 8A(1)
note: No reappointment of President under previous appointment
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.8
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b-logic-alleninterval-2

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 5(1B) After subsection 8A(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits reappointment
premise text: (1B) Paragraph (1A)(b)
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-5-ss-1b-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for exemption
premise text: (1B) Paragraph (1A)(b)
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

6 Subsection 8B(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-6
has part: 6(2) Subsection 8B(2)
has part: 6(3) Subsection 8B(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.8

6(2) Subsection 8B(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-6-ss-2
part of: 6 Subsection 8B(2)
note: Must have appropriate qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.8
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-5

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 6(2) Subsection 8B(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must have qualifications and a merit-based process.
premise text: (a) the person has appropriate qualifications, knowledge or experience;
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must be selected through a merit-based process.
premise text: (b) the selection of the person for the appointment is the result of a process that: (i) was merit-based; and (ii) included public advertising of the position.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
logic summary: The selection process must occur within a specific time frame.
premise text: (b) the selection of the person for the appointment is the result of a process that: (i) was merit-based; and (ii) included public advertising of the position.
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
logic summary: The selection process must occur within a specific time frame.
premise text: (b) the selection of the person for the appointment is the result of a process that: (i) was merit-based; and (ii) included public advertising of the position.
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: The Minister must be satisfied with the qualifications and selection process.
premise text: (2) A person must not be appointed under subsection (1) as the Human Rights Commissioner unless the Minister is satisfied that:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

6(3) Subsection 8B(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-6-ss-3
part of: 6 Subsection 8B(2)
note: No reapplication of paragraph (2)(b) to reappointment of Human Rights Commissioner under previous appointment.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.8
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 6(3) Subsection 8B(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-6-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prevents reapplication of paragraph (2)(b)
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b) does not apply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

7 Subsection 37(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-7
note: Insertion of clause (3) after subsection (2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-7-norm

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-7-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 7 Subsection 37(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

8 Subsection 37(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-8
note: Omit ‘, not exceeding 7 years’.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-8-norm

9 After subsection 37(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-9
has part: 9(2) After subsection 37(1)
has part: 9(3) After subsection 37(1)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9

9(2) After subsection 37(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-9-ss-2
part of: 9 After subsection 37(1)
note: No appointment as President for a period exceeding 7 years.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 9(2) After subsection 37(1)
borne by: Agent
scope note: borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of appointment for excessive period
premise text: (2) A person must not be appointed...
conclusion text: ...for a period if the sum... exceeds 7 years:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

9(3) After subsection 37(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-9-ss-3
part of: 9 After subsection 37(1)
note: Prohibition on exceeding 7 years of appointment as Human Rights Commissioner
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 9(3) After subsection 37(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-9-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
logic summary: Prohibition
premise text: (3) A person must not be appointed...
conclusion text: ...the sum of the following exceeds 7 years:
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

10 Subsection 46B(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-10
has part: 10(2) Subsection 46B(2)
has part: 10(3) Subsection 46B(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9

10(2) Subsection 46B(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-10-ss-2
part of: 10 Subsection 46B(2)
note: No appointment under subsection (1) unless Minister is satisfied of experience and merit-based process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-cogai-5

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 10(2) Subsection 46B(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibits appointment unless conditions are met.
premise text: (2) A person must not be appointed...
conclusion text: ...unless the Minister is satisfied...
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for appointment process.
premise text: (2) A person must not be appointed under subsection (1)...
conclusion text: ...unless the Minister is satisfied that...
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Justification
logic summary: Requires justification of experience and appointment process.
premise text: (a) the person has significant experience in community life of Aboriginal persons or Torres Strait Islanders;
conclusion text: ...and (b) the selection of the person for the appointment is the result of...
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
logic summary: Diffuses responsibility to Minister for satisfaction.
premise text: (2) A person must not be appointed under subsection (1)...
conclusion text: ...unless the Minister is satisfied that...
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognize
logic summary: Recognizes AI application in appointment process.
premise text: (2) A person must not be appointed under subsection (1)...
conclusion text: ...unless the Minister is satisfied that...
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed

10(3) Subsection 46B(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-10-ss-3
part of: 10 Subsection 46B(2)
note: Reappointment of Islander Social Justice Commissioner under previous appointment
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.9
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 10(3) Subsection 46B(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-10-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Reappointment obligation
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

11 Subsection 46D(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-11
note: Omit ‘, not exceeding 7 years’.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.10
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-11-norm

12 After subsection 46D(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-12
note: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.10
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-12-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-12-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-12-logic-alleninterval-2

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-12-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 12 After subsection 46D(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-12-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of excessive appointment term
premise text: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-12-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Exceeds
logic summary: Temporal interval exceeding 7 years
premise text: (a) that period;
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

13 Subsection 46MC(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-13
has part: 13(2) Subsection 46MC(2)
has part: 13(3) Subsection 46MC(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.10

13(2) Subsection 46MC(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-13-ss-2
part of: 13 Subsection 46MC(2)
note: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.10
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 13(2) Subsection 46MC(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

13(3) Subsection 46MC(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-13-ss-3
part of: 13 Subsection 46MC(2)
note: Reappointment exception for National Children’s Commissioner
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.10
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 13(3) Subsection 46MC(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Exclusion
logic summary: Excludes reappointment from paragraph (2)(b)
premise text: (2)(b) does not apply
conclusion text: does not apply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-13-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Reappointment period overlaps with previous appointment
premise text: reappointment period starts after previous appointment
conclusion text: previous appointment and reappointment overlap
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

14 Section 46MD
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-14
note: Insertion of '(1)' before 'The National'
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.10
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-14-norm

15 Section 46MD
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-15
note: Omit the second sentence.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-15-norm

16 At the end of section 46MD
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-16
note: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-16-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-16-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-16-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 16 At the end of section 46MD
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-16-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

17 Subsection 113(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-17
has part: 17(2) Subsection 113(2)
has part: 17(3) Subsection 113(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11

17(2) Subsection 113(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-17-ss-2
part of: 17 Subsection 113(2)
note: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 17(2) Subsection 113(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

17(3) Subsection 113(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-17-ss-3
part of: 17 Subsection 113(2)
note: Reappointment exception for Disability Discrimination Commissioner
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 17(3) Subsection 113(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-17-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Exclusion
logic summary: Excludes reappointment from paragraph (2)(b)
premise text: (2)(b) does not apply
conclusion text: Paragraph (2)(b) does not apply to this reappointment
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

18 Subsection 114(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-18
note: Omit ‘, not exceeding 7 years’.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-18-norm

19 After subsection 114(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-19
note: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.11
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-19-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-19-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-19-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 19 After subsection 114(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-19-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of excessive appointment term
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

20 Subsection 29(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-20
has part: 20(2) Subsection 29(2)
has part: 20(3) Subsection 29(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.12

20(2) Subsection 29(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-20-ss-2
part of: 20 Subsection 29(2)
note: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.12
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 20(2) Subsection 29(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

20(3) Subsection 29(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-20-ss-3
part of: 20 Subsection 29(2)
note: Reappointment exception for Race Discrimination Commissioner
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.12
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-cogai-5

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 20(3) Subsection 29(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the state
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
logic summary: Temporal overlap between appointments
premise text: holds office as the Race Discrimination Commissioner under a previous appointment
conclusion text: immediately before the start of the period of reappointment
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
logic summary: Reappointment exception implies no duty to comply with paragraph (2)(b)
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b) does not apply
conclusion text: in relation to the reappointment of a person who...
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
modality: Diffusion
operator: Propagation
logic summary: Reappointment exception propagates through the definition of Race Discrimination Commissioner
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply in relation to the reappointment of a person who...
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-20-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
modality: CogAI
operator: Inference
logic summary: Reappointment exception inferred from the definition of Race Discrimination Commissioner
premise text: (3) Paragraph (2)(b)
conclusion text: does not apply in relation to the reappointment of a person who...
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

21 Subsection 30(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-21
note: Omit ‘, not exceeding 7 years’.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.12
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-21-norm

22 After subsection 30(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-22
note: No appointment for more than 7 years without exceeding the sum of previous appointments.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.12
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-22-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-22-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-22-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 22 After subsection 30(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-22-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
logic summary: Prohibits appointment for more than 7 years.
premise text: No previous appointments exceeding 7 years.
conclusion text: Cannot be appointed for more than 7 years.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

23 Subsection 96(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-23
has part: 23(2) Subsection 96(2)
has part: 23(3) Subsection 96(2)
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.13

23(2) Subsection 96(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-23-ss-2
part of: 23 Subsection 96(2)
note: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.13
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-2-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-2-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 23(2) Subsection 96(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
logic summary: Must have qualifications, knowledge or experience and a merit-based selection process.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

23(3) Subsection 96(2)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-23-ss-3
part of: 23 Subsection 96(2)
note: Reappointment exception for Sex Discrimination Commissioner
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.13
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-3-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-3-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 23(3) Subsection 96(2)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-23-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the state
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

24 Subsection 97(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-24
note: Omit ‘, not exceeding 7 years’.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.13
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-24-norm

25 After subsection 97(1)
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-25
note: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.13
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-25-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-25-logic-deontic-1
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-25-logic-alleninterval-2

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-25-norm
type: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
part of: 25 After subsection 97(1)
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-25-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
logic summary: Prohibition of excessive appointment term
premise text: No appointment exceeding 7 years is allowed.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-25-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
logic summary: Temporal overlap between appointment term and previous appointments
premise text: (a) that period;
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed

26 Existing appointments
type: Concept
realized by: sch-1-sec-26
note: Appointment validity not affected by amendments.
curation status: Proposed
schema version: 2
proposed by: legis2cml
source: c2022a00048.pdf, p.13
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-26-norm
asserts: c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-26-logic-deontic-1

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-26-norm
type: Obligation
modality: Deontic
part of: 26 Existing appointments
borne by: State
scope note: borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
curation status: Proposed

c2022a00048-sch-1-sec-26-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
logic summary: Obligation to maintain appointment validity.
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed