1 Short title
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.5
note: Citation of the Act
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-1
schema version: 2

1 Section 1
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.5
note: Table of sections
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-1-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-1-2
schema version: 2

10 December 1984 ([1989] ATS 21);
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.6
note: List of international agreements accessible through the Australian Treaties Library.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10
schema version: 2

10 Regulations
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.12
note: Governor-General may make regulations for carrying out or giving effect to the Act.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-2
schema version: 2

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General may make regulations.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Regulations must be prescribed for carrying out or giving effect to the Act.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Prescribing

10 Sept
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Conditional commencement of Statute Law Amendment (Prescribed Forms and Other Updates) Act 74, 2023
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-10-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-3
schema version: 2

11 June
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-11-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-11
schema version: 2

12 June 2024
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.1
note: Amendments included
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-12-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-12
schema version: 2

12 June 2024 (s 2(1)
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Amendment history for Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-12-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-12-2
schema version: 2

18 December 1979 ([1983] ATS 9);
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.6
note: Prohibition on torture and other cruel treatment
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-18-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-18-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18
schema version: 2

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-18-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits torture and other cruel treatment
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (e) the Convention Against Torture...

2 Commencement
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.5
note: Commencement rules
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2
schema version: 2

2 Section 2
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.5
note: Conditional commencement of Parts 2, 3 and 4
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-2-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-2-2-logic-alleninterval-1
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-2-2-logic-ltl-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2-2
schema version: 2

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-2-2-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Undertaking
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Requires a relation between identifiable temporal intervals for commencement
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Applicable
premise text: Later of January 2011 and the 28th day after Royal Assent

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-2-2-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Undertaking
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Requires an ordered or recurring trace for commencement
modality: LTL
operator: Applicable
premise text: Conditional commencement

20 Sept
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Conditional commencement of the Attorney-General’s Portfolio Miscellaneous Measures Act 2024
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-20-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-20
schema version: 2

21 June 2024
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.1
note: Compilation information and notes on amendments.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-21-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-21
schema version: 2

22 Sept
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Statute Law Revision Act 2012
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-22-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-22
schema version: 2

22 Sept
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Conditional commencement of Act 2015 on September 22, 2012
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-22-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-22-2-logic-alleninterval-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-22-2
schema version: 2

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-22-2-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Undertaking
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Requires a relation between identifiable temporal intervals for conditional commencement
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Applicable
premise text: Conditional commencement on September 22, 2012

3 Definitions
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.6
note: Definitions of human rights
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-3
schema version: 2

4 January 2012
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.5
note: Note on original enactment of this Act
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4
schema version: 2

4 Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: Establishment of Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-4-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4-2
schema version: 2

5 Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
curation status: Proposed
has part: 5(1) Membership of the Committee
has part: 5(2) Membership of the Committee
has part: 5(3) Membership of the Committee
has part: 5(4) Membership of the Committee
has part: 5(5) Membership of the Committee
has part: 5(6) Membership of the Committee
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5
schema version: 2

5 Mar 2015
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Amended by Acts and Instruments (Framework Reform) (Consequential Provisions) Act 2015
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-2
schema version: 2

5(1) Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: The Committee must consist of 12 members.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-1-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Membership of the Committee

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Committee's existence spans a specific temporal interval.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
premise text: (1) The Committee is to consist of 12 members:

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Committee must consist of 12 members.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Membership requirement
modality: Deontic
operator: =
premise text: (1) The Committee is to consist of 12 members:

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(1) Membership of the Committee

5(2) Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: Eligibility for Committee Membership
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Membership of the Committee

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exclusion of certain individuals from membership
modality: Deontic
operator: not

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(2) Membership of the Committee

5(3) Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: Cease holding office under specified conditions.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-3-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Membership of the Committee

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to cease holding office.
modality: Deontic
operator: cease
premise text: (3) A member ceases to hold office:

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(3) Membership of the Committee

5(4) Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: Member may resign office by writing signed and delivered to the President of the Senate.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-4-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Membership of the Committee

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member has an obligation to resign office by writing signed and delivered.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(4) Membership of the Committee

5(5) Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: Member may resign office by writing signed and delivered to Speaker.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-5-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Membership of the Committee

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member has obligation to resign office.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(5) Membership of the Committee

5(6) Membership of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.8
note: Either House of Parliament may appoint a member to fill a vacancy in the Committee.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-6-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Membership of the Committee

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by Parliament.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-5-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(6) Membership of the Committee

6 Powers and proceedings of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.9
note: Determination of Committee powers and proceedings
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-6-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6
schema version: 2

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Mandatory determination
modality: Deontic
operator: shall

7 December
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.5
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-7-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7
schema version: 2

7 Functions of the Committee
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.9
note: The Committee has functions related to human rights examination and reporting.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-7-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-7-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7-2
schema version: 2

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-7-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Committee has a function.
modality: Deontic
operator: has

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-7-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 7 Functions of the Committee

7 Dec 2011
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.16
note: Amendment (Sunsetting Measures) Act 2012
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-7-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7-3
schema version: 2

8 Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
curation status: Proposed
has part: 8(1) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
has part: 8(2) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
has part: 8(3) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
has part: 8(4) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
has part: 8(5) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8
schema version: 2

8(1) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Member of Parliament must prepare a statement of compatibility for proposed Bills.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-1-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 8 Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to prepare a statement of compatibility.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 8(1) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

8(2) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Must present statement of compatibility to the House.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 8 Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

8(3) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
type: Concept
description: Assessment of compatibility with human rights
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Assessment of compatibility with human rights required in statements of compatibility.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-3-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 8 Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Assessment of compatibility with human rights is required.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide assessment
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 8(3) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

8(4) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Statement of compatibility is not binding on courts or tribunals.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-4-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 8 Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (4) A statement of compatibility prepared under subsection (1) is not binding on any court or tribunal.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If statement of compatibility is prepared, then it is not binding.
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: (4) A statement of compatibility prepared under subsection (1)

8(5) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Failure to comply does not affect Act validity, operation or enforcement.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-5-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 8 Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The exemption applies.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exemptions from compliance do not affect Act validity.
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
premise text: (5) A failure to comply...

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-8-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 8(5) Statements of compatibility in relation to Bills

9 Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
curation status: Proposed
has part: 9(1) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
has part: 9(2) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
has part: 9(3) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
has part: 9(4) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9
schema version: 2

9(1) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Rule-maker must prepare statement of compatibility for legislative instruments.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-1-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to prepare statement of compatibility.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 9(1) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

9(2) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
type: Concept
description: Human rights assessment
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Assessment of compatibility with human rights must be included in statements of compatibility.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-2-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to include human rights assessment
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 9(2) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

9(3) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Statement of compatibility is not binding on courts or tribunals.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-3-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (3) A statement of compatibility prepared under subsection (1) is not binding on any court or tribunal.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If a statement is prepared, it may not be binding.
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: (3) A statement of compatibility prepared under subsection (1)

9(4) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative
type: Concept
source: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011.pdf, p.10
note: Failure to comply does not affect instrument validity or enforcement.
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-norm
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: This section applies during the effective period of the legislative instrument.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (4) A failure to comply with this section in relation to a legislative instrument does not affect the validity, operation or enforcement of the instrument or any other provision of a law of the Commonwealth.

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: This section applies during the effective period of the legislative instrument.
modality: CogAI
operator: during
premise text: (4) A failure to comply with this section in relation to a legislative instrument does not affect the validity, operation or enforcement of the instrument or any other provision of a law of the Commonwealth.

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exemptions from compliance do not affect instrument validity.
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
premise text: (4) A failure to comply with this section in relation to a legislative instrument does not affect the validity, operation or enforcement of the instrument or any other provision of a law of the Commonwealth.

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: This section applies during the effective period of the legislative instrument.
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (4) A failure to comply with this section in relation to a legislative instrument does not affect the validity, operation or enforcement of the instrument or any other provision of a law of the Commonwealth.

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: This section applies during the effective period of the legislative instrument.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (4) A failure to comply with this section in relation to a legislative instrument does not affect the validity, operation or enforcement of the instrument or any other provision of a law of the Commonwealth.

human-rights-parliamentary-scrutiny-act-2011-sec-9-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 9(4) Statements of compatibility in relation to certain legislative

Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011
type: Document
date: 12 June 2024
description: An Act to establish a Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights, and for related purposes
identifier: No. 186 of 2011
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
category: AU