1 Short title
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.29
note: Citation of Act
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-1
schema version: 2

10 Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
curation status: Proposed
has part: 10(1) Deputy Chairpersons
has part: 10(1A) Deputy Chairpersons
has part: 10(1B) Deputy Chairpersons
has part: 10(2) Deputy Chairpersons
has part: 10(3) Deputy Chairpersons
has part: 10(4) Deputy Chairpersons
has part: 10(5) Deputy Chairpersons
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10
schema version: 2

10(1) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Governor-General may appoint a Deputy Chairperson.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 10(1) Deputy Chairpersons

10(1A) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Governor-General must not appoint a Deputy Chairperson unless majority of jurisdictions support the appointment.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Must Not

10(1B) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: The Minister must ensure that there is at least one Deputy Chairperson with knowledge of small business matters after appointment.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-logic-ltl-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-1b
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to ensure
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Knowledge requirement
modality: Epistemic
operator: KNOWLEDGE OF

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-1b-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace of knowledge
modality: LTL
operator: RECURRING TRACE

10(2) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Duty to cease being a member of the Commission upon ceasing to be a member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Cease being a member of the Commission
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Appointment as Deputy Chairperson

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 10(2) Deputy Chairpersons

10(3) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Reappointment eligibility for Deputy Chairpersons
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Reappointment eligibility obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: hasObligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 10(3) Deputy Chairpersons

10(4) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Resignation of Deputy Chairperson
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to resign
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

10(5) Deputy Chairpersons
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Limit on Deputy Chairpersons
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-10-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 10 Deputy Chairpersons

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Deputy Chairpersons do not overlap in office
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship of Deputy Chairpersons
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps
premise text: (5) Not more than 2 persons may hold office as Deputy Chairperson at any one time.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Artificial Agent recognizes the Deputy Chairpersons
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Artificial Agent recognition of Deputy Chairpersons
modality: CogAI
operator: recognizes
premise text: (5) Not more than 2 persons may hold office as Deputy Chairperson at any one time.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Not more than 2 persons may hold office as Deputy Chairperson at any one time.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Maximum number of Deputy Chairpersons
modality: Deontic
operator: max
premise text: (5) Not more than 2 persons may hold office as Deputy Chairperson at any one time.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Deputy Chairpersons diffuse their authority to subordinates
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Propagation of Deputy Chairpersons
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (5) Not more than 2 persons may hold office as Deputy Chairperson at any one time.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Deputy Chairpersons are valid until the end of their term
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal scope of Deputy Chairpersons
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: (5) Not more than 2 persons may hold office as Deputy Chairperson at any one time.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-10-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 10(5) Deputy Chairpersons

11 Acting Chairperson
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
curation status: Proposed
has part: 11(1) Acting Chairperson
has part: 11(2) Acting Chairperson
has part: 11(3) Acting Chairperson
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-11
schema version: 2

11(1) Acting Chairperson
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Governor-General may appoint person to act as Chairperson until vacancy is filled.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-11-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 11 Acting Chairperson

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General has the power to appoint.
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 11(1) Acting Chairperson

11(2) Acting Chairperson
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Minister must appoint a Deputy Chairperson to act as Chairperson in absence of Chairperson.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-11-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 11 Acting Chairperson

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister must appoint a Deputy Chairperson.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

11(3) Acting Chairperson
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.80
note: Governor-General determines terms and conditions for Chairperson's powers and duties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-11-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-11-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 11 Acting Chairperson

12 Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.81
curation status: Proposed
has part: 12(1) Leave of absence
has part: 12(2) Leave of absence
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-12
schema version: 2

12(1) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.81
note: Member of Commission has recreation leave entitlements determined by Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-12-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 12 Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member has obligation to receive recreation leave entitlements.
modality: Deontic
operator: has

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 12(1) Leave of absence

12(2) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.81
note: Grant of leave of absence on terms and conditions determined by the Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-12-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 12 Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-12-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Granting permission
modality: Deontic
operator: grant
premise text: (2) The Minister may grant a member of the Commission leave of absence...

13 Termination of appointment of members of the Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.81
note: The Governor-General may terminate a member's appointment for misbehaviour or incapacity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-13-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-13-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-13
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-13-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses permission or obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

14 Termination of appointment of associate members of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.82
curation status: Proposed
has part: 14(1) Termination of appointment of associate members of the
has part: 14(2) Termination of appointment of associate members of the
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-14
schema version: 2

14(1) Termination of appointment of associate members of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.82
note: Minister may terminate appointment of associate member
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-14-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 14 Termination of appointment of associate members of the

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to terminate appointment
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 14(1) Termination of appointment of associate members of the

14(2) Termination of appointment of associate members of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.82
note: Termination of appointment if associate member fails to comply with obligations
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-14-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 14 Termination of appointment of associate members of the

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Minister shall terminate the appointment.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of appointment termination
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) If an associate member...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-14-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 14(2) Termination of appointment of associate members of the

15 Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
curation status: Proposed
has part: 15(1) Resignation
has part: 15(2) Resignation
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-15
schema version: 2

15(1) Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
note: Member of Commission must resign by writing signed and delivered to Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-15-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 15 Resignation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member of Commission must resign.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 15(1) Resignation

15(2) Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
note: Associate member must resign office by writing signed and delivered to Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-15-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 15 Resignation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Associate member must resign office.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-15-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 15(2) Resignation

16 Arrangement of business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
note: The Chairperson may give directions as to the arrangement of the business of the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-16-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-16
schema version: 2

17 Disclosure of interests by Chairperson
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
curation status: Proposed
has part: 17(1) Disclosure of interests by Chairperson
has part: 17(2) Disclosure of interests by Chairperson
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-17
schema version: 2

17(1) Disclosure of interests by Chairperson
type: Concept
description: written notice to the Minister
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
note: Chairperson must disclose pecuniary interests
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-17-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 17 Disclosure of interests by Chairperson

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must disclose pecuniary interests
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

17(2) Disclosure of interests by Chairperson
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
note: Disclosure of interests by Chairperson is required in addition to section 29.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-17-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 17 Disclosure of interests by Chairperson

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires disclosure of interests by Chairperson.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

17A Disclosure of certain interests by members of the Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.83
note: Member of Commission must disclose pecuniary interests when taking part in determinations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-17a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member must disclose pecuniary interests.
modality: Deontic
operator: Must

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-17a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 17A Disclosure of certain interests by members of the Commission

18 Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
curation status: Proposed
has part: 18(1) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(2) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(3) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(4) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(5) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(6) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(7) Meetings of Commission
has part: 18(8) Meetings of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18
schema version: 2

18(1) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Chairperson must convene meetings as necessary for efficient performance of Commission functions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Chairperson has a duty to convene meetings.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

18(2) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Commission determines meeting places
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

18(3) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Chairperson must preside at meetings of Commission when present.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 18(3) Meetings of Commission

18(4) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Duty to nominate Deputy Chairperson in absence of Chairperson
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Nominate Deputy Chairperson
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to nominate Deputy Chairperson
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Chairperson absent

18(5) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Member presiding at Commission meeting may give directions on procedure.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide directions
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 18(5) Meetings of Commission

18(6) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Quorum requirements for Commission meetings
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (c) the member presiding has a deliberative vote and, in the event of an equality of votes, also has a casting vote.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member presiding has a deliberative vote and casting vote
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (a) three members (including the Chairperson or a Deputy Chairperson) form a quorum;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: All questions shall be decided by a majority of votes of the members present and voting
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (b) all questions shall be decided by a majority of votes of the members present and voting;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Three members form a quorum
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (a) three members (including the Chairperson or a Deputy Chairperson) form a quorum;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 18(6) Meetings of Commission

18(7) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Methods of communication for Commission meetings
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-7-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission permits participation in meetings via specified methods
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-7-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Excerpt describes a method of communication for Commission meetings
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify

18(8) Meetings of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.84
note: Determination made by Commission may be made in respect of meetings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-18-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 18 Meetings of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-18-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to make determination
modality: Deontic
operator: may

19 Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.85
curation status: Proposed
has part: 19(1) Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
has part: 19(2) Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
has part: 19(2A) Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-19
schema version: 2

19(1) Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.85
note: Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-19-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 19 Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions

19(2) Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.85
note: Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-19-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 19 Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Directs the Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classify matters for Commission powers
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: classify
premise text: (a) specify a particular matter in relation to which the Division is to exercise the powers of the Commission;

19(2A) Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.85
note: Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-19-ss-2a
schema version: 2
part of: 19 Chairperson may direct Commission to sit in Divisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-19-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May direct
modality: Deontic
operator: may

2 Object of this Act
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.29
note: To enhance the welfare of Australians through promotion of competition and fair trading and provision for consumer protection.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2 Object of this Act

25 Delegation by Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
curation status: Proposed
has part: 25(1) Delegation by Commission
has part: 25(2) Delegation by Commission
has part: 25(3) Delegation by Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-25
schema version: 2

25(1) Delegation by Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
note: Commission may delegate certain powers to a member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-25-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 25 Delegation by Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

25(2) Delegation by Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
note: Delegate may exercise power in accordance with instrument of delegation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-25-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 25 Delegation by Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exercise power
modality: Deontic
operator: may

25(3) Delegation by Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
note: Delegation under this section is revocable at will.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-25-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-25-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 25 Delegation by Commission

26 Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
curation status: Proposed
has part: 26(1) Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers
has part: 26(2) Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-26
schema version: 2

26(1) Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
note: The Commission may delegate certain functions and powers to a staff member of ASIC.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-26-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-26-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-26-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 26 Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-26-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission may delegate certain functions and powers.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

26(2) Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.87
note: Chairperson of ASIC must agree to delegation in writing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-26-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-26-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-26-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 26 Delegation by Commission of certain functions and powers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-26-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must agree
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

27 May 2026
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.1
note: Compilation information and notes on amendments, applications, and modifications.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27
schema version: 2

27 Staff of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.88
curation status: Proposed
has part: 27(1) Staff of Commission
has part: 27(2) Staff of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27-2
schema version: 2

27(1) Staff of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.88
note: Staff must be persons engaged under the Public Service Act 1999.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27-2-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 27 Staff of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Staff must be persons engaged under the Public Service Act 1999.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 27(1) Staff of Commission

27(2) Staff of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.88
note: Establishes a Statutory Agency with the Chairperson as its Head.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27-2-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 27 Staff of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishs a Statutory Agency
modality: Deontic
operator: establishes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-2-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 27(2) Staff of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Describes the compilation's purpose and scope.
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies the text as a compilation of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Applicable

27A Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.89
curation status: Proposed
has part: 27A(1) Consultants
has part: 27A(2) Consultants
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27a
schema version: 2

27A(1) Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.89
note: The Commission may engage persons to give advice and perform services.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 27A Consultants

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by the Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 27A(1) Consultants

27A(2) Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.89
note: Terms and conditions of engagement are determined by the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-27a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 27A Consultants

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission's determination of terms and conditions is a single event.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship of determination
modality: AllenInterval
operator: determined
premise text: The Commission's determination of terms and conditions occurs at a specific point in time.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Artificial intelligence systems must comply with the determined terms and conditions.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Artificial intelligence application
modality: CogAI
operator: determined
premise text: The Commission's determination of terms and conditions can be applied by artificial intelligence systems.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Terms and conditions of engagement must be as determined by the Commission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to provide terms and conditions
modality: Deontic
operator: determined
premise text: The Commission has the authority to determine terms and conditions.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: All parties must comply with the determined terms and conditions.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Spread of determination
modality: Diffusion
operator: determined
premise text: The Commission's determination of terms and conditions spreads to all parties involved.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If the Commission determines terms and conditions, then they are binding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implication of determination
modality: LinearLogic
operator: determined
premise text: If the Commission determines terms and conditions, then those terms and conditions apply.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-27a-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 27A(2) Consultants

28 Functions of Commission in relation to dissemination of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.89
note: Commission must provide general information and report on laws related to consumer protection.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-28-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-28-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-28
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-28-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-28-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 28 Functions of Commission in relation to dissemination of

29 Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.91
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29(1) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
has part: 29(1A) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
has part: 29(1B) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
has part: 29(2) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
has part: 29(3) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29
schema version: 2

29(1) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.91
note: Minister may give Commission directions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29 Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to comply with Minister's directions.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29(1) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

29(1A) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.91
note: Minister cannot give directions under subsection (1) relating to certain parts or divisions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 29 Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...relating to Part IIIA, IV, IVA, IVBA, IVBB, IVE, VII, VIIA, X, XIB, XIC or XICA; or Division 3 of Part XI in relation to individual cases.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Directions under subsection (1) are excluded from certain parts or divisions
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Excludes
premise text: (1A) The Minister must not give directions under subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...directions under subsection (1)
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister cannot give directions under subsection (1)
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: (1A) The Minister must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...directions under subsection (1)
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister cannot give directions under subsection (1) relating to certain parts or divisions
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibits
premise text: (1A) The Minister must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...relating to Part IIIA, IV, IVA, IVBA, IVBB, IVE, VII, VIIA, X, XIB, XIC or XICA; or Division 3 of Part XI in relation to individual cases.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Directions under subsection (1) are excluded from certain parts or divisions
modality: Diffusion
operator: Excludes
premise text: (1A) The Minister must not give directions under subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...relating to Part IIIA, IV, IVA, IVBA, IVBB, IVE, VII, VIIA, X, XIB, XIC or XICA; or Division 3 of Part XI in relation to individual cases.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Directions under subsection (1) are excluded from certain parts or divisions
modality: LTL
operator: Excludes
premise text: (1A) The Minister must not give directions under subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1a-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29(1A) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

29(1B) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.91
note: The Commission must comply with a direction.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29-ss-1b
schema version: 2
part of: 29 Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must comply
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29(2) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.91
note: Minister must publish direction in Gazette
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29 Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide written copy of direction
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29(2) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

29(3) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.91
note: Commission must comply with requirements from Parliament or its committees.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29 Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29(3) Commission to comply with directions of Minister and

29A Establishment of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29A(1) Establishment of Council
has part: 29A(2) Establishment of Council
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29a
schema version: 2

29A(1) Establishment of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: Establishment of National Competition Council
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29A Establishment of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishs the National Competition Council
modality: Deontic
operator: establishes

29A(2) Establishment of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: The Council is a listed entity and the Council President is the accountable authority.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29A Establishment of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council is a listed entity.
modality: Deontic
operator: is

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The following persons are officials of the Council.
modality: Deontic
operator: are

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The purposes of the Council include the functions of the Council referred to in section 29B.
modality: Deontic
operator: include

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29a-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29A(2) Establishment of Council

29B Functions and powers of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29B(1) Functions and powers of Council
has part: 29B(2) Functions and powers of Council
has part: 29B(2A) Functions and powers of Council
has part: 29B(2B) Functions and powers of Council
has part: 29B(3) Functions and powers of Council
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29b
schema version: 2

29B(1) Functions and powers of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: The Council must carry out research and provide advice on matters referred by the Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29b-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29B Functions and powers of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must perform certain actions.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29B(2) Functions and powers of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: The Council may perform functions and exercise powers necessary to facilitate performance.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29b-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29B Functions and powers of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses permission or obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

29B(2A) Functions and powers of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: Council cannot perform functions or exercise powers unless in accordance with the Competition Principles Agreement.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2a-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29b-ss-2a
schema version: 2
part of: 29B Functions and powers of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2a-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: in accordance with the Competition Principles Agreement
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for Council's actions
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: The Council must not perform a function or exercise a power unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: unless in accordance with the Competition Principles Agreement
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of Council's actions
modality: Deontic
operator: cannot
premise text: Council must not perform a function or exercise a power

29B(2B) Functions and powers of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: Council has obligation to comply with State/Territory energy laws
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29b-ss-2b
schema version: 2
part of: 29B Functions and powers of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-2b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council has obligation to comply with State/Territory energy laws
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation

29B(3) Functions and powers of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.92
note: Cooperation with departments, bodies or authorities
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29b-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29B Functions and powers of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29b-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to cooperate
modality: Deontic
operator: may

29BA Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.93
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29BA(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
has part: 29BA(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
has part: 29BA(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29ba
schema version: 2

29BA(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.93
note: A State/Territory energy law may confer functions or powers on the Council.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29ba-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29BA Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes obligation on the Council.
modality: Deontic
operator: confer

29BA(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.93
note: No conferral of function or power by State/Territory energy law if it contravenes constitutional doctrines.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29ba-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29BA Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the conferral or imposition, or the authorisation, would contravene any constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the Council;
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal overlap between conferral of function or power and constitutional doctrines.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not authorise the conferral of a function or power, or the imposition of a duty,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the conferral or imposition, or the authorisation, would contravene any constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the Council;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on conferral of function or power by State/Territory energy law.
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not authorise the conferral of a function or power, or the imposition of a duty,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the authorisation would otherwise exceed the legislative power of the Commonwealth;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on conferral of function or power by State/Territory energy law if it exceeds legislative power.
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not authorise the conferral of a function or power, or the imposition of a duty,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the conferral or imposition, or the authorisation, would contravene any constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the Council;
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Eventual prohibition on conferral of function or power by State/Territory energy law.
modality: LTL
operator: eventually
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not authorise the conferral of a function or power, or the imposition of a duty,

29BA(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.93
note: Council must obtain Commonwealth consent to perform a duty or function under a State/Territory energy law.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29ba-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29BA Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to obtain Commonwealth consent
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29ba-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29BA(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on

29BB How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29BB(1) How duty is imposed
has part: 29BB(2) How duty is imposed
has part: 29BB(3) How duty is imposed
has part: 29BB(4) How duty is imposed
has part: 29BB(5) How duty is imposed
has part: 29BB(6) How duty is imposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb
schema version: 2

29BB(1) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
note: Imposes duty on the Council if a State/Territory energy law purports to do so.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29BB How duty is imposed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council is subject to duty.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies duty on the Council.
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
premise text: State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council is subject to duty.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Entails duty on the Council if State/Territory energy law purports to do so.
modality: Deontic
operator: entails
premise text: State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council is subject to duty.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies if State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty on the Council.
modality: Deontic
operator: impliesIf
premise text: State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council is subject to duty.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If and only if State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty on the Council, then Council is subject to duty.
modality: Deontic
operator: ifAndOnlyIf
premise text: State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council is subject to duty.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If and only if State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty on the Council, then Council is subject to duty.
modality: Deontic
operator: iff
premise text: State/Territory energy law purports to impose a duty.

29BB(2) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
note: Duty is not imposed by this Part to the extent it exceeds State legislative powers.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29BB How duty is imposed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The duty is not imposed by this Part.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exclusion of duty
modality: Deontic
operator: excludes
premise text: State legislative powers are not sufficient to support the duty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29BB(2) How duty is imposed

29BB(3) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
note: Duty imposed by law of the Commonwealth if necessary for validity
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29BB How duty is imposed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: if

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29BB(3) How duty is imposed

29BB(4) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
note: Parliament's intention to rely on available powers under the Constitution to support duty imposition.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 29BB How duty is imposed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The intention of Parliament is to rely on all powers available under the Constitution.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Parliament's reliance on available powers.
modality: Deontic
operator: Relies
premise text: This Part is taken to impose the duty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29BB(4) How duty is imposed

29BB(5) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
note: Duty is imposed by this Part in accordance with subsection (3) only to the extent to which imposing the duty is within the legislative powers of the Commonwealth and consistent with constitutional doctrines.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 29BB How duty is imposed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...imposing the duty: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States that a duty is imposed by this Part.
modality: Deontic
operator: Imposes
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Part in accordance with subsection (3) only...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...consistent with the constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the Council.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States that the duty is restricted by constitutional doctrines.
modality: Deontic
operator: Restricts
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Part in accordance with subsection (3) only...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...to the extent to which imposing the duty: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States that the duty is limited to the legislative powers of the Commonwealth.
modality: Deontic
operator: Limits
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Part in accordance with subsection (3) only...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...consistent with the constitutional doctrines restricting the duties that may be imposed on the Council.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States that the duty must be consistent with constitutional doctrines.
modality: Deontic
operator: Consistency
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Part in accordance with subsection (3) only...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...to the extent to which imposing the duty: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States that the duty is conditional upon certain conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Conditional
premise text: (5) The duty is taken to be imposed by this Part in accordance with subsection (3) only...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29BB(5) How duty is imposed

29BB(6) How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.94
note: Duty is not limited by subsections (1) to (5)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-6-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bb-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 29BB How duty is imposed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bb-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29BB(6) How duty is imposed

29BC When a State/Territory energy law imposes a duty
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.95
note: A State/Territory energy law imposes a duty on the Council if it confers a function or power and gives rise to an obligation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29bc-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29bc
schema version: 2

29C Membership of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.95
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29C(1) Membership of Council
has part: 29C(2) Membership of Council
has part: 29C(3) Membership of Council
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29c
schema version: 2

29C(1) Membership of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.95
note: Council membership requirement
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29c-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29C Membership of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29C(1) Membership of Council

29C(2) Membership of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.95
note: Each Councillor must be appointed by the Governor-General for a term of up to 5 years.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29c-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29C Membership of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The term of office for each Councillor is up to 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Term duration
modality: AllenInterval
operator: DURATION
premise text: (2) Each Councillor is to be appointed by the Governor-General, for a term of up to 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Governor-General justifies the appointment of each Councillor.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Justification for appointment
modality: Argumentation
operator: JUSTIFICATION
premise text: (2) Each Councillor is to be appointed by the Governor-General, for a term of up to 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Governor-General's authority is recognized in the appointment of each Councillor.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognition of Governor-General's authority
modality: CogAI
operator: RECOGNITION
premise text: (2) Each Councillor is to be appointed by the Governor-General, for a term of up to 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Each Councillor must be appointed by the Governor-General for a term of up to 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) Each Councillor is to be appointed by the Governor-General, for a term of up to 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment of each Councillor has an influence on the composition of the Council.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Influence on Council membership
modality: Diffusion
operator: INFLUENCE
premise text: (2) Each Councillor is to be appointed by the Governor-General, for a term of up to 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29C(2) Membership of Council

29C(3) Membership of Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.95
note: Governor-General must not appoint a person without meeting certain qualifications.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29c-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29C Membership of Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General is satisfied that...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for appointment
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: The Governor-General must not appoint unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29c-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...unless the Governor-General is satisfied...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: (3) The Governor-General must not appoint...

29D Terms and conditions of office
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.95
note: A Councillor may be appointed on either a full-time or part-time basis.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29d-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29d
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29d-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29D Terms and conditions of office

29E Acting Council President
type: Concept
references: sec-33A
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
note: The Minister may appoint a Councillor to act as the Council President.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29e-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29e-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29e
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29e-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to act as Council President
modality: Deontic
operator: may

29F Remuneration of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29F(1) Remuneration of Councillors
has part: 29F(2) Remuneration of Councillors
has part: 29F(3) Remuneration of Councillors
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29f
schema version: 2

29F(1) Remuneration of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
note: Councillors must be paid remuneration determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29f-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29F Remuneration of Councillors

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship between payment and determination
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BEFORE

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29F(1) Remuneration of Councillors

29F(2) Remuneration of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
note: A Councillor must be paid prescribed allowances.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29f-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29F Remuneration of Councillors

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A Councillor must be paid prescribed allowances.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29F(3) Remuneration of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
note: Remuneration of Councillors subject to the Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29f-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29f-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29F Remuneration of Councillors

29G Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29G(1) Leave of absence
has part: 29G(2) Leave of absence
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29g
schema version: 2

29G(1) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
note: Recreation leave entitlements determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29g-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29G Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A full-time Councillor's leave entitlements apply during their full-time employment.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Leave entitlements apply during full-time employment.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (1) A full-time Councillor has such recreation leave entitlements as are determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A full-time Councillor has recreation leave entitlements.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Recreation leave entitlements exist.
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (1) A full-time Councillor has such recreation leave entitlements as are determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Remuneration Tribunal determines recreation leave entitlements.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Remuneration Tribunal determines recreation leave entitlements.
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (1) A full-time Councillor has such recreation leave entitlements as are determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A full-time Councillor must have recreation leave entitlements.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Councillors must have recreation leave entitlements.
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (1) A full-time Councillor has such recreation leave entitlements as are determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Remuneration Tribunal's determination of recreation leave entitlements is binding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Remuneration Tribunal's determination is binding.
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (1) A full-time Councillor has such recreation leave entitlements as are determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29G(1) Leave of absence

29G(2) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.96
note: Grant leave of absence on terms and conditions determined by the Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29g-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29G Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29g-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Granting leave of absence is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

29H Termination of appointment of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29H(1) Termination of appointment of Councillors
has part: 29H(2) Termination of appointment of Councillors
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29h
schema version: 2

29H(1) Termination of appointment of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
note: Governor-General may terminate Councillor's appointment for misbehaviour or incapacity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29h-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29H Termination of appointment of Councillors

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29H(1) Termination of appointment of Councillors

29H(2) Termination of appointment of Councillors
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
note: Termination of appointment of Councillors due to bankruptcy, non-compliance with disclosure obligations, or absence from duty.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29h-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29H Termination of appointment of Councillors

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The termination must occur within 14 consecutive days or 28 days in any 12 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Termination within 14 consecutive days or 28 days in any 12 months.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Within
premise text: (2) The Governor-General must terminate the appointment...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment of a Councillor must be terminated under these conditions.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of appointment termination for certain reasons.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) The Governor-General must terminate the appointment...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Councillor must not engage in paid employment outside their duties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of engagement in paid employment outside duties.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) The Governor-General must terminate the appointment...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Councillor must comply with their disclosure obligations.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of non-compliance with disclosure obligations.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) The Governor-General must terminate the appointment...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The absence from duty must be recurring for more than 14 consecutive days.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring absence from duty for more than 14 consecutive days.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring
premise text: (2) The Governor-General must terminate the appointment...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29h-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29H(2) Termination of appointment of Councillors

29I Resignation of Councillors
type: Concept
description: resignation notice
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
note: A Councillor must provide a signed resignation notice to the Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29i-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29i-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29i
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29i-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A Councillor must provide a signed resignation notice.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to resign
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29J Arrangement of Council business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29J(1) Arrangement of Council business
has part: 29J(2) Arrangement of Council business
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29j
schema version: 2

29J(1) Arrangement of Council business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
note: The Council President may give directions about the arrangement of the Council's business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29j-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29J Arrangement of Council business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council President has the power to give directions.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

29J(2) Arrangement of Council business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.97
note: Council must not carry out work except in accordance with a program agreed to by the parties to the Competition Principles Agreement.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29j-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29J Arrangement of Council business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The prohibition applies to all work except that which is part of a program agreed to by the parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for prohibition of work.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (2) The Council must not carry out any work (other than work relating to a function under Part IIIA or VIIA)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Council must not carry out work except in accordance with a program agreed to by the parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of work without a program agreed to by the parties.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) The Council must not carry out any work (other than work relating to a function under Part IIIA or VIIA)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29j-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The prohibition applies to all work except that which is part of a program agreed to by the parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal trace for prohibition of work.
modality: LTL
operator: Temporal Trace
premise text: (2) The Council must not carry out any work (other than work relating to a function under Part IIIA or VIIA)

29L Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29L(1) Council meetings
has part: 29L(2) Council meetings
has part: 29L(3) Council meetings
has part: 29L(4) Council meetings
has part: 29L(5) Council meetings
has part: 29L(6) Council meetings
has part: 29L(7) Council meetings
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l
schema version: 2

29L(1) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Council President must convene necessary meetings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to convene meetings
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29L(2) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Meetings must be held in places determined by the Council President.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...in places determined by the Council President.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to hold meetings in specified places
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) The meetings must be held...

29L(3) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Council President must preside at meetings attended by the Council President.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must perform duty
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29L(4) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Councillor must preside if Council President is absent
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Councillor must preside
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to preside
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Council President absent

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29L(4) Council meetings

29L(5) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: The Councillor may give directions on the procedure to be followed in relation to a meeting.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses permission or obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

29L(6) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Quorum for a meeting is 3 Councillors including the Council President
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires a quorum of 3 Councillors including the Council President
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

29L(7) Council meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Decision by majority of votes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29l-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 29L Council meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29l-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to decide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

29LA Resolutions without meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29LA(1) Resolutions without meetings
has part: 29LA(2) Resolutions without meetings
has part: 29LA(3) Resolutions without meetings
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29la
schema version: 2

29LA(1) Resolutions without meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: All Councillors must sign a document in favour of a resolution.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29la-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29LA Resolutions without meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The resolution is passed on or after the commencement date
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The last day of signing must be after the commencement date
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: The document was signed on different days

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Councillors are in favour of the resolution
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Signing the document implies that the Councillors are in favour of the resolution
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: Councillors sign the document

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The resolution is a decision made by the Councillors using AI
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The resolution is a decision made by the Councillors using AI
modality: CogAI
operator: IS-A
premise text: Councillors sign the document

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The resolution is passed
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to sign the document
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Councillors must sign the document

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The resolution is a diffusion of the Councillors' will
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The resolution is a diffusion of the Councillors' will
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS-A
premise text: Councillors have a duty to sign the document

29LA(2) Resolutions without meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Resolutions without meetings
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29la-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29LA Resolutions without meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Statement signed on specific days
modality: AllenInterval
operator: on the respective days
premise text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Statement constitutes a resolution
modality: Argumentation
operator: constitutes
premise text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Statement constitutes document
modality: Deontic
operator: constitutes
premise text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Documents are combined through diffusion
modality: Diffusion
operator: are together taken
premise text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Documents together form a single document
modality: LTL
operator: together
premise text: (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), 2 or more separate documents containing statements in identical terms each of which is signed by one or more Councillors are together taken to constitute one document containing a statement in those terms signed by those Councillors on the respective days on which they signed the separate documents.

29LA(3) Resolutions without meetings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.98
note: Signing a document in favour of a resolution with a pecuniary interest is prohibited for Councillors.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29la-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 29LA Resolutions without meetings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Signing is prohibited.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The key overlaps with other resolutions without meetings.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: Councillor signs a document in favour of a resolution.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Signing is prohibited.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of signing a document in favour of a resolution with a pecuniary interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: Councillor has a pecuniary interest.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29la-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Signing is prohibited.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of signing a document in favour of a resolution with a pecuniary interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: Councillor's functions may be affected by the interest.

29M Staff to help Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29M(1) Staff to help Council
has part: 29M(2) Staff to help Council
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29m
schema version: 2

29M(1) Staff to help Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
note: Staff must be persons engaged under the Public Service Act 1999.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29m-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29M Staff to help Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Staff must be persons engaged under the Public Service Act 1999.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29M(1) Staff to help Council

29M(2) Staff to help Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
note: Council President and APS employees constitute a Statutory Agency.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29m-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29M Staff to help Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishes a statutory agency
modality: Deontic
operator: constitute

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29m-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29M(2) Staff to help Council

29N Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
curation status: Proposed
has part: 29N(1) Consultants
has part: 29N(2) Consultants
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29n
schema version: 2

29N(1) Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
note: The Council may engage persons to give advice and perform services.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29n-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 29N Consultants

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission or obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: May

29N(2) Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
note: Terms and conditions of engagement are determined by the Council.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29n-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 29N Consultants

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Determining terms and conditions of engagement.
modality: Deontic
operator: determines

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29n-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 29N(2) Consultants

29O Annual report
type: Concept
description: Details of Chapter 1
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.99
note: Annual report requirements
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-29o-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-29o
schema version: 2

2A Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.29
curation status: Proposed
has part: 2A(1) Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth
has part: 2A(2) Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2a
schema version: 2

2A(1) Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.29
note: The Act binds the Crown in right of the Commonwealth.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 2A Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Crown in right of the Commonwealth carries on a business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The binding effect is during the time the Crown in right of the Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (1) Subject to this section and sections 44AC, 44E and 95D, this Act binds...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Crown in right of the Commonwealth.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classifies the Crown in right of the Commonwealth as a subject of the Act.
modality: CogAI
operator: classify
premise text: (1) Subject to this section and sections 44AC, 44E and 95D, this Act binds...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Crown in right of the Commonwealth.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the Crown in right of the Commonwealth.
modality: Deontic
operator: binds
premise text: (1) Subject to this section and sections 44AC, 44E and 95D, this Act binds...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Crown in right of the Commonwealth carries on a business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The binding effect is during the time the Crown in right of the Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (1) Subject to this section and sections 44AC, 44E and 95D, this Act binds...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Crown in right of the Commonwealth carries on a business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The binding effect is during the time the Crown in right of the Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (1) Subject to this section and sections 44AC, 44E and 95D, this Act binds...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2A(1) Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth

2A(2) Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.29
note: The Act applies to Commonwealth and its authorities as if they were corporations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 2A Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The Act applies during the time Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, this Act applies as if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The Act applies during the time Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: CogAI
operator: during
premise text: (2) Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, this Act applies as if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Act applies to Commonwealth and its authorities.
modality: Deontic
operator: applies
premise text: (2) Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, this Act applies as if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The Act applies during the time Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (2) Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, this Act applies as if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The Act applies during the time Commonwealth carries on a business.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (2) Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, this Act applies as if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2a-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2A(2) Application of Act to Commonwealth and Commonwealth

2B Application of Act to States and Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
curation status: Proposed
has part: 2B(1) Application of Act to States and Territories
has part: 2B(2) Application of Act to States and Territories
has part: 2B(3) Application of Act to States and Territories
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2b
schema version: 2

2B(1) Application of Act to States and Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
note: The Crown in right of each State and Territory is bound by certain provisions of the Act.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2b-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 2B Application of Act to States and Territories

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...so far as the Crown carries on a business...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The provision applies during the period when the Crown carries on a business.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (1) The following provisions of this Act bind the Crown...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...so far as the Crown carries on a business...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: The provision implies that the Crown must comply with the bound provisions.
modality: Argumentation
operator: implies
premise text: (1) The following provisions of this Act bind the Crown...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...so far as the Crown carries on a business...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The provision recognizes the binding effect of the Act on the Crown in right of each State and Territory.
modality: CogAI
operator: recognizes
premise text: (1) The following provisions of this Act bind the Crown...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...so far as the Crown carries on a business...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Crown is bound by the provisions of the Act.
modality: Deontic
operator: binds
premise text: (1) The following provisions of this Act bind the Crown...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...so far as the Crown carries on a business...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The provision diffuses the binding effect to the Crown in right of each State and Territory.
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (1) The following provisions of this Act bind the Crown...

2B(2) Application of Act to States and Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
note: No liability for pecuniary penalty or prosecution
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2b-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 2B Application of Act to States and Territories

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Crown in right of a State or Territory is not liable to a pecuniary penalty or to be prosecuted for an offence.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies no liability for pecuniary penalty or prosecution
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: (2) Nothing in this Act

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2B(2) Application of Act to States and Territories

2B(3) Application of Act to States and Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
note: Protection does not apply to State or Territory authorities.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2b-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 2B Application of Act to States and Territories

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: !

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2b-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2B(3) Application of Act to States and Territories

2BA Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
curation status: Proposed
has part: 2BA(1) Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies
has part: 2BA(2) Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2ba
schema version: 2

2BA(1) Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
note: Local government bodies must comply with Parts IV and IVA to the extent they carry on a business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2ba-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 2BA Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to comply with Parts IV and IVA.
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2BA(1) Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies

2BA(2) Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.30
note: Defines local government body for application of Parts IV and IVA.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2ba-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 2BA Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: local government body
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Defines term for application of Parts IV and IVA.
modality: Deontic
operator: is defined as

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: local government body
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Provides explicit class hierarchy for local government bodies.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: has definition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2ba-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2BA(2) Application of Parts IV and IVA to local government bodies

2C Activities that are not business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.31
note: Exemptions from business activities for certain government entities
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2c-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2c-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-2c
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2c-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: !
premise text: (1) For the purposes of sections 2A, 2B and 2BA,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-2c-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 2C Activities that are not business

3 Repeal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.33
note: Repeal of two trade practices acts
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-3
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes prohibition on the Restrictive Trade Practices Acts
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

30 Constitution of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
curation status: Proposed
has part: 30(1) Constitution of Tribunal
has part: 30(2) Constitution of Tribunal
has part: 30(3) Constitution of Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-30
schema version: 2

30(1) Constitution of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
note: Continuation of Tribunal existence
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-30-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 30 Constitution of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Australian Competition Tribunal continues to exist.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal continuation
modality: Deontic
operator: CONTINUES
premise text: (1) The Trade Practices Tribunal...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 30(1) Constitution of Tribunal

30(2) Constitution of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
note: The Tribunal shall consist of a President and such number of Deputy Presidents and other members as are appointed in accordance with this section.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-cogai-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-n3logic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-30-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 30 Constitution of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Members are appointed at some point in time
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between appointments
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Applicable
premise text: (2) The Tribunal so continued in existence shall consist of a President and such number of Deputy Presidents and other members as are appointed in accordance with this section.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-cogai-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The process of appointment is not specified
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Describes the process of appointment
modality: CogAI
operator: Applicable
premise text: (2) The Tribunal so continued in existence shall consist of a President and such number of Deputy Presidents and other members as are appointed in accordance with this section.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: There is a duty to appoint members
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Describes the duty to appoint members
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable
premise text: (2) The Tribunal so continued in existence shall consist of a President and such number of Deputy Presidents and other members as are appointed in accordance with this section.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has a specific structure
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Describes the structure of the Tribunal
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Applicable
premise text: (2) The Tribunal so continued in existence shall consist of a President and such number of Deputy Presidents and other members as are appointed in accordance with this section.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-2-logic-n3logic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has a specific relationship with its members
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::n3_compiler
logic summary: Describes the relationship between the Tribunal and its members
modality: N3Logic
operator: Applicable
premise text: (2) The Tribunal so continued in existence shall consist of a President and such number of Deputy Presidents and other members as are appointed in accordance with this section.

30(3) Constitution of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
note: Member of Tribunal must be appointed by Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-30-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 30 Constitution of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment process starts with the Governor-General appointing a member of the Tribunal.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for appointment
modality: AllenInterval
operator: STARTS
premise text: (3) A member of the Tribunal shall be appointed by the Governor-General.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment process for members of the Tribunal is a reasoning task for the Governor-General.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Reasoning about appointment process
modality: Argumentation
operator: REASONING
premise text: (3) A member of the Tribunal shall be appointed by the Governor-General.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Governor-General is recognized as the authority for appointing members of the Tribunal.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognition of appointment authority
modality: CogAI
operator: RECOGNITION
premise text: (3) A member of the Tribunal shall be appointed by the Governor-General.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A member of the Tribunal MUST be appointed by the Governor-General.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to appoint member of Tribunal
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) A member of the Tribunal shall be appointed by the Governor-General.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment process for members of the Tribunal spreads to all relevant parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Spread of appointment information
modality: Diffusion
operator: SPREADS
premise text: (3) A member of the Tribunal shall be appointed by the Governor-General.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-30-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 30(3) Constitution of Tribunal

31 Qualifications of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
curation status: Proposed
has part: 31(1) Qualifications of members of Tribunal
has part: 31(2) Qualifications of members of Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-31
schema version: 2

31(1) Qualifications of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
note: A person must be a Judge of a Federal Court to be appointed as a presidential member of the Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-31-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 31 Qualifications of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...unless he or she is a Judge of a Federal Court...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Mandatory appointment requirement
modality: Deontic
operator: Must
premise text: (1) A person shall not be appointed...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 31(1) Qualifications of members of Tribunal

31(2) Qualifications of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
note: Person must be qualified for appointment by virtue of knowledge or experience.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-31-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 31 Qualifications of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Person must be qualified by virtue of knowledge or experience
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Knowledge or experience is a temporal interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: ...by virtue of his or her knowledge...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment implies qualification
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Appointment implies qualification
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: A person shall not be appointed unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Person must be qualified
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be qualified
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Person shall not be appointed unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 31(2) Qualifications of members of Tribunal

31A Appointment of Judge as presidential member of Tribunal not
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.101
note: Appointment of Judge as presidential member of Tribunal does not affect tenure.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-31a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation negation
modality: Deontic
operator: does not affect

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-31a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 31A Appointment of Judge as presidential member of Tribunal not

32 Terms and conditions of appointment
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Member of Tribunal holds office for a specified period and on terms and conditions determined by Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-32-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-32
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-32-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 32 Terms and conditions of appointment

33 Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
curation status: Proposed
has part: 33(4) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
has part: 33(5) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
has part: 33(6) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-33
schema version: 2

33(4) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Member of Tribunal must be paid remuneration determined by Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-33-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 33 Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member of Tribunal must be paid remuneration.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 33(4) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal

33(5) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Member of Tribunal must be paid allowances
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-33-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 33 Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to pay allowances
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 33(5) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal

33(6) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal subject to the Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-33-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 33 Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the State.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-33-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 33(6) Remuneration and allowances of members of Tribunal

34 Acting appointments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
curation status: Proposed
has part: 34(1) Acting appointments
has part: 34(2) Acting appointments
has part: 34(3) Acting appointments
has part: 34(4) Acting appointments
has part: 34(5) Acting appointments
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-34
schema version: 2

34(1) Acting appointments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Minister may appoint Deputy President or acting Deputy President when President is absent or there is a vacancy in the office of President.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-34-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 34 Acting appointments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May appoint
modality: Deontic
operator: may

34(2) Acting appointments
type: Concept
references: sec-33A
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Governor-General may appoint a person to act as Deputy President during absence of member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-34-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 34 Acting appointments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General has the power to appoint.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

34(3) Acting appointments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Appoint acting member of Tribunal during absence from duty
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-34-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 34 Acting appointments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General may appoint acting member
modality: Deontic
operator: may

34(4) Acting appointments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Continue acting as a member of the Tribunal after resumption of duty by absent member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-34-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 34 Acting appointments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to continue acting
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation

34(5) Acting appointments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.102
note: Appointment continuation upon member's absence
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-34-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 34 Acting appointments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-34-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment continuation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to continue appointment
modality: Deontic
operator: Continuation
premise text: Member's absence

35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
curation status: Proposed
has part: 35(1) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
has part: 35(2) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
has part: 35(3) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
has part: 35(4) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
has part: 35(5) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
has part: 35(6) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
has part: 35(7) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35
schema version: 2

35(1) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: Governor-General may suspend a member of the Tribunal from office on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 35(1) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

35(2) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: Statement of ground for suspension must be laid before Parliament within 7 sitting days.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide statement
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

35(3) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: Governor-General must terminate suspension if both Houses pass a resolution to restore the member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General must terminate suspension.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: If both Houses pass a resolution, then Governor-General terminates suspension.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: →

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 35(3) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

35(4) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: Governor-General may remove member of Tribunal from office if House of Parliament fails to pass resolution.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General may remove the member of the Tribunal from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Removal within 15 sitting days if resolution not passed.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Within
premise text: (4) If, at the expiration of 15 sitting days...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General may remove the member of the Tribunal from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes prohibition on Governor-General's action.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (4) If, at the expiration of 15 sitting days...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General may remove the member of the Tribunal from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Enforces prohibition on Governor-General's action.
modality: Deontic
operator: Enforce
premise text: (4) If, at the expiration of 15 sitting days...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General may remove the member of the Tribunal from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Justifies removal if resolution not passed.
modality: Deontic
operator: Justify
premise text: (4) If, at the expiration of 15 sitting days...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General may remove the member of the Tribunal from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implies removal of member if resolution not passed.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Imply
premise text: (4) If, at the expiration of 15 sitting days...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-4-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 35(4) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

35(5) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: Removal from office if member of Tribunal becomes bankrupt
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General shall remove him or her from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval between bankruptcy and removal from office
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (5) If a member of the Tribunal becomes bankrupt...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General shall remove him or her from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implication of bankruptcy on removal from office
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: (5) If a member of the Tribunal becomes bankrupt...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General shall remove him or her from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Inference of removal from office based on bankruptcy
modality: CogAI
operator: Inference
premise text: (5) If a member of the Tribunal becomes bankrupt...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General shall remove him or her from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on removal from office if member of Tribunal becomes bankrupt
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (5) If a member of the Tribunal becomes bankrupt...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Governor-General shall remove him or her from office.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Propagated effect of bankruptcy on removal from office
modality: Diffusion
operator: Propagation
premise text: (5) If a member of the Tribunal becomes bankrupt...

35(6) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: A member of the Tribunal shall not be removed from office except as provided by this section.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...as provided by this section.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on removal of Tribunal members
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: (6) A member of the Tribunal shall not be removed from office except...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 35(6) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

35(7) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: Presidential member of Tribunal ceases office if no longer Judge of Federal Court.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-35-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 35 Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ceasing to hold office
modality: Deontic
operator: cease
premise text: (7) A presidential member of the Tribunal ceases...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-35-ss-7-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 35(7) Suspension and removal of members of Tribunal

36 Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.104
note: A member of the Tribunal may resign by writing signed and delivered to the Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-36-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-36-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-36
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-36-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member has obligation to resign
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-36-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 36 Resignation

37 Constitution of Tribunal for particular matters
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.105
note: Presidential member and 2 non-presidential members must constitute the Tribunal for hearing and determining proceedings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-37-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-37-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-37
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-37-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...a presidential member and 2 non-presidential members
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Presidential member must be present
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Division of the Tribunal must consist of...

38 Validity of determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.105
note: The validity of a determination is not affected by defects in the Tribunal's constitution.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-38-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-38-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-38-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-38
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-38-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The determination's validity is not affected.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to uphold validity of determinations
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: The Tribunal's constitution is valid.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-38-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The defect or irregularity in the constitution does not affect the determination's validity.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to disregard defects in the Tribunal's constitution
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
premise text: There are no explicit requirements for the Tribunal's constitution.

39 President may give directions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.105
curation status: Proposed
has part: 39(1) President may give directions
has part: 39(2) President may give directions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-39
schema version: 2

39(1) President may give directions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.105
note: The President may give directions regarding Tribunal business arrangement and Division constitution.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-39-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-39-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-39-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 39 President may give directions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-39-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The President has the power to give directions.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

39(2) President may give directions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.105
note: The President may give directions to Deputy Presidents regarding procedure in Tribunal proceedings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-39-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-39-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-39-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 39 President may give directions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-39-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The President has the power to give directions.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

4 Interpretation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.33
note: Definitions for terms used in the Act.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-6
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-7
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Definitions for terms used in the Act.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ACMA is a legal person.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Class hierarchy definition
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: ACMA means the Australian Communications and Media Authority.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A person with an accreditation is an accredited person.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Definition of Accredited Person
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: accredited person means a person who holds an accreditation under subsection 56CA(1).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An accredited action initiator is defined in section 56AMC.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Definition of Accredited Action Initiator
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: accredited action initiator has the meaning given by section 56AMC.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An accredited data recipient is defined in section 56AK.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Definition of Accredited Data Recipient
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: accredited data recipient has the meaning given by section 56AK.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-6
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An acquisition determination is defined by subsection 51ABZE(1).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Definition of Acquisition Determination
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: acquisition determination, in respect of a notification of an acquisition, means:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4-logic-descriptionlogic-7
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Acquire means to acquire goods through purchase, exchange, or lease, or to accept a service.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Definition of Acquire
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: acquire includes: (a) in relation to goods—acquire by way of purchase, exchange or taking on lease, on hire or on hire-purchase; and (b) in relation to services—accept.

40 Disclosure of interests by members of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.105
note: Member must disclose pecuniary interest to President.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-40-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-40-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-40
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-40-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member has a duty to disclose pecuniary interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-40-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 40 Disclosure of interests by members of Tribunal

41 Presidential member to preside
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.106
note: Presidential member must preside at Division proceedings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-41-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-41-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-41
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-41-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to preside
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

42 Decision of questions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.106
curation status: Proposed
has part: 42(1) Decision of questions
has part: 42(2) Decision of questions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-42
schema version: 2

42(1) Decision of questions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.106
note: Determine questions of law according to presidential member's opinion
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-42-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 42 Decision of questions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...shall be determined in accordance with...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to follow the president's opinion
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (1) A question of law...

42(2) Decision of questions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.106
note: Majority opinion determines a question in proceedings before a Division of the Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-42-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 42 Decision of questions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Questions arise during proceedings before a Division of the Tribunal
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Question arises during proceedings before a Division of the Tribunal
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: Proceedings before a Division of the Tribunal include questions arising during proceedings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision on question implies majority opinion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Majority opinion implies decision on question
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: Majority opinion determines a question

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-42-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Division of the Tribunal must follow majority opinion
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to follow majority opinion
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Majority opinion determines a question

43 Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
curation status: Proposed
has part: 43(1) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
has part: 43(2) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
has part: 43(3) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
has part: 43(4) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
has part: 43(5) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43
schema version: 2

43(1) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 43 Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 43(1) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

43(2) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: Directs specified member of Tribunal in proceedings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 43 Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Granting permission.
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission

43(3) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: Conditional commencement of proceedings
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 43 Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

43(4) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: President may add a third member to the Tribunal at any time before proceedings determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 43 Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: President has the power to add a third member.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 43(4) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

43(5) Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: The Tribunal may consider previous proceedings records.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 43 Member of Tribunal ceasing to be available

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May consider
modality: Deontic
operator: may

43A Counsel assisting Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
curation status: Proposed
has part: 43A(1) Counsel assisting Tribunal
has part: 43A(2) Counsel assisting Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43a
schema version: 2

43A(1) Counsel assisting Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: The President may appoint a legal practitioner to assist the Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 43A Counsel assisting Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by the President
modality: Deontic
operator: May

43A(2) Counsel assisting Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.107
note: Chapter 1 Preliminary
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43a-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 43A Counsel assisting Tribunal

43B Consultants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.108
note: The Registrar may engage persons as consultants.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-43b
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to engage consultants
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-43b-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 43B Consultants

44 Staff of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.108
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44(1) Staff of Tribunal
has part: 44(2) Staff of Tribunal
has part: 44(3) Staff of Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44
schema version: 2

44(1) Staff of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.108
note: Appointment of Registrar and Deputy Registrars
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44 Staff of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: There shall be a Registrar of the Tribunal
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the Tribunal
modality: Deontic
operator: shall

44(2) Staff of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.108
note: Staff of Tribunal duties and functions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44 Staff of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The staff of the tribunal are appointed between certain dates
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Staff appointment interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
premise text: (2) The Registrar and the Deputy Registrars shall be appointed by the Minister...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The staff of the tribunal have specific roles
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Staff roles
modality: Argumentation
operator: has role
premise text: (2) The Registrar and the Deputy Registrars shall be appointed by the Minister...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The staff of the tribunal have specific functions
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Staff functions
modality: CogAI
operator: has function
premise text: (2) The Registrar and the Deputy Registrars shall be appointed by the Minister...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Registrar and the Deputy Registrars have such duties and functions as are provided by this Act...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Staff have duties and functions
modality: Deontic
operator: has duty
premise text: (2) The Registrar and the Deputy Registrars shall be appointed by the Minister...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The staff of the tribunal diffuse their duties to others
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Staff duties diffusion
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (2) The Registrar and the Deputy Registrars shall be appointed by the Minister...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44(2) Staff of Tribunal

44(3) Staff of Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.108
note: Staff must be persons engaged under the Public Service Act 1999.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44 Staff of Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Staff must be persons engaged under the Public Service Act 1999.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44(3) Staff of Tribunal

44A Acting appointments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.108
note: The Minister may appoint a person to act as Registrar or Deputy Registrar.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Minister has the power to appoint.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44A Acting appointments

44AA Objects of Part
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.139
note: Promote economically efficient infrastructure operation and investment.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aa-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aa-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44aa
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aa-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulatory obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: shall

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aa-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AA Objects of Part

44AB Definitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.109
note: Definitions for Australian Energy Market Agreement and its members.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ab-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ab
schema version: 2

44AC This Part binds the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.109
note: The Crown is bound by this Part.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ac-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ac-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ac
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ac-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Crown has an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

44AD Extra-territorial operation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.109
note: Include operation in relation to things and acts outside Australia
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ad-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ad-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ad
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ad-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Include operation in relation to these
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Moral obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: should
premise text: Parliament's intention

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ad-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AD Extra-territorial operation

44AE Establishment of the AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.111
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AE(1) Establishment of the AER
has part: 44AE(2) Establishment of the AER
has part: 44AE(3) Establishment of the AER
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ae
schema version: 2

44AE(1) Establishment of the AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.111
note: Establishment of the AER
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ae-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AE Establishment of the AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishs the AER
modality: Deontic
operator: establishes

44AE(2) Establishment of the AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.111
note: The AER must have a common seal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ae-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AE Establishment of the AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) The AER: (a) is a body corporate with perpetual succession; and (b) MUST HAVE a common seal; and (c) may acquire, hold and dispose of real and personal property; and (d) may sue and be sued in its corporate name.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The AER must have a common seal.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE
premise text: (2) The AER: (a) is a body corporate with perpetual succession; and (b) must have a common seal; and (c) may acquire, hold and dispose of real and personal property; and (d) may sue and be sued in its corporate name.

44AE(3) Establishment of the AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.111
note: The AER is not to be a corporate Commonwealth entity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ae-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AE Establishment of the AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The AER is not a corporate Commonwealth entity.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ae-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AE(3) Establishment of the AER

44AF AER to hold money and property on behalf of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.111
note: The AER holds money and property on behalf of the Commonwealth.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44af-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44af
schema version: 2

44AG Constitution of the AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.111
note: Appoint Commonwealth and State/Territory AER members.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ag-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ag-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ag
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ag-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State/Territory to appoint members.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

44AH Commonwealth functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AH(1) Commonwealth functions
has part: 44AH(2) Commonwealth functions
has part: 44AH(3) Commonwealth functions
has part: 44AH(4) Commonwealth functions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ah
schema version: 2

44AH(1) Commonwealth functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: The AER has functions conferred under a law of the Commonwealth or prescribed by regulations made under this Act.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ah-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AH Commonwealth functions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The AER has functions
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: (1) The AER has any functions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The AER must have functions
modality: Deontic
operator: is required to have
premise text: (1) The AER has any functions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AH(1) Commonwealth functions

44AH(2) Commonwealth functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: Regulations may empower the AER to make legislative instruments.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ah-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AH Commonwealth functions

44AH(3) Commonwealth functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: Exempts legislative instruments from disallowance under the Legislation Act 2003.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ah-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AH Commonwealth functions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The exemption applies to legislative instruments empowered by regulations made for the purposes of paragraph (1)(b).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exempts legislative instruments from disallowance.
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
premise text: Section 42 (disallowance) of the Legislation Act 2003.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AH(3) Commonwealth functions

44AH(4) Commonwealth functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: Express provision to the contrary in regulations overrides subsection (3)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ah-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ah-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44AH Commonwealth functions

44AI Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AI(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
has part: 44AI(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
has part: 44AI(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
has part: 44AI(4) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
has part: 44AI(5) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ai
schema version: 2

44AI(1) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: A State/Territory energy law may confer functions or powers on the AER.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ai-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AI Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to confer functions
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44AI(2) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: No conferral of function or power by State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument to certain extent.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ai-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AI Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal overlap between conferral and constitutional doctrines.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps
premise text: the conferral or imposition, or the authorisation would contravene any constitutional doctrines...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of conferral by State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument.
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not authorise the conferral...

44AI(3) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: Commonwealth consent required for conferral of functions on AER
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ai-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AI Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commonwealth consent is required
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires Commonwealth consent
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: Conferral of function without consent is not allowed

44AI(4) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: A local energy instrument must be designated for the purposes of this subsection under a relevant agreement before conferring functions or powers on the AER.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ai-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44AI Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the instrument is designated for the purposes of this subsection under the Australian Energy Market Agreement, or any other relevant agreement...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The designation must occur during the effective period of the instrument.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: During
premise text: (4) A local energy instrument may confer functions or powers, or impose duties, on the AER only if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the instrument is designated for the purposes of this subsection under the Australian Energy Market Agreement, or any other relevant agreement...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The instrument must be designated for the purposes of this subsection.
modality: Deontic
operator: Must
premise text: (4) A local energy instrument may confer functions or powers, or impose duties, on the AER only if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the instrument is designated for the purposes of this subsection under the Australian Energy Market Agreement, or any other relevant agreement...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The designation must occur until the effective period of the instrument.
modality: LTL
operator: Until
premise text: (4) A local energy instrument may confer functions or powers, or impose duties, on the AER only if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AI(4) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER

44AI(5) Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.112
note: No merits review of AER decisions under State/Territory energy laws or local energy instruments.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ai-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44AI Commonwealth consent to conferral of functions etc. on AER

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Subsection (4) applies to the law.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Overlaps with subsection (4) of section 44AI(5).
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
premise text: (5) To avoid doubt, if a State/Territory energy law is also a local energy instrument, subsection (4) applies to the law.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A decision of the AER under a State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument is not to be subject to merits review...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognizes prohibition as a rule.
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognize
premise text: (5) To avoid doubt, if a State/Territory energy law is also a local energy instrument, subsection (4) applies to the law.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A decision of the AER under a State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument is not to be subject to merits review...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits merits review of AER decisions under State/Territory energy laws or local energy instruments.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (5) To avoid doubt, if a State/Territory energy law is also a local energy instrument, subsection (4) applies to the law.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A decision of the AER under a State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument is not to be subject to merits review...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses prohibition to all relevant decisions.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
premise text: (5) To avoid doubt, if a State/Territory energy law is also a local energy instrument, subsection (4) applies to the law.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ai-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A decision of the AER under a State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument is not to be subject to merits review...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace of merits review prohibition.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring
premise text: (5) To avoid doubt, if a State/Territory energy law is also a local energy instrument, subsection (4) applies to the law.

44AJ How duty is imposed
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.113
note: Duty imposed on AER by State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aj-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aj-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44aj
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aj-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Obligation on AER
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes duty on AER
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes
premise text: State/Territory energy law or local energy instrument

44AK When a State/Territory energy law etc. imposes a duty
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.115
note: Imposes a duty on AER under certain circumstances.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ak-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ak-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ak
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ak-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States the existence of an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes

44AL Powers of the AER
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.115
note: The AER has power to do all things necessary or convenient.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44al-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44al-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44al
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44al-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The AER has power.
modality: Deontic
operator: hasPower

44AM Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AM(1) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
has part: 44AM(2) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
has part: 44AM(3) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44am
schema version: 2

44AM(1) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
note: A Commonwealth AER member must be appointed by the Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44am-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AM Appointment of Commonwealth AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide appointment
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AM(1) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members

44AM(2) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
note: Must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44am-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AM Appointment of Commonwealth AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The period must not exceed 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The obligation is during a specific temporal interval.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) A Commonwealth AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: The obligation is a requirement.
modality: Argumentation
operator: must
premise text: (2) A Commonwealth AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The obligation is a requirement that can be automated.
modality: CogAI
operator: must
premise text: (2) A Commonwealth AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Holding office is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: holds
premise text: (2) A Commonwealth AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The obligation is a requirement that spreads to other obligations.
modality: Diffusion
operator: must
premise text: (2) A Commonwealth AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

44AM(3) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
note: Knowledge or experience requirement for appointment as Commonwealth AER member
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44am-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AM Appointment of Commonwealth AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires knowledge or experience
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Must have knowledge of industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration
modality: Epistemic
operator: must know

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Must have experience in industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration
modality: LTL
operator: has experience in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44am-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AM(3) Appointment of Commonwealth AER members

44AO Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AO(1) Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member
has part: 44AO(2) Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ao
schema version: 2

44AO(1) Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
note: The Minister may appoint a person to act as Commonwealth AER member under certain circumstances.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ao-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AO Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An appointment may be made during this time
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Vacancy in office triggers appointment
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during a vacancy in the office of Commonwealth AER member
premise text: There is a vacancy in the office of Commonwealth AER member

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A person may be appointed as Commonwealth AER member
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by the Minister
modality: Deontic
operator: may
premise text: The Minister has the power to appoint

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An appointment may be made during this time
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Appointment valid for all periods of absence
modality: LTL
operator: during any period, or during all periods
premise text: The AER member is absent from duty or location

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AO(1) Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member

44AO(2) Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.116
note: Knowledge or experience in specified fields required for appointment as Commonwealth AER member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ao-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AO Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment is valid during the time period when the person has knowledge or experience in specified fields.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes the time period during which the appointment is valid.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) A person is not eligible for appointment to act as a Commonwealth AER member unless the person has knowledge of, or experience in, industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The cognitive process involves considering the person's knowledge or experience in specified fields during the time period when the person is eligible for appointment.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Describes the cognitive process involved in making the appointment.
modality: CogAI
operator: during
premise text: (2) A person is not eligible for appointment to act as a Commonwealth AER member unless the person has knowledge of, or experience in, industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person must have knowledge or experience in specified fields.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires knowledge or experience in specified fields.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (2) A person is not eligible for appointment to act as a Commonwealth AER member unless the person has knowledge of, or experience in, industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The information about the appointment spreads during the time period when the person has knowledge or experience in specified fields.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Describes the spread of information about the appointment.
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (2) A person is not eligible for appointment to act as a Commonwealth AER member unless the person has knowledge of, or experience in, industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment is valid during the time period when the person has knowledge or experience in specified fields.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Describes the time period during which the appointment is valid.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (2) A person is not eligible for appointment to act as a Commonwealth AER member unless the person has knowledge of, or experience in, industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection or public administration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ao-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AO(2) Acting appointment of Commonwealth AER member

44AP Appointment of State/Territory AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.117
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AP(1) Appointment of State/Territory AER members
has part: 44AP(2) Appointment of State/Territory AER members
has part: 44AP(3) Appointment of State/Territory AER members
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ap
schema version: 2

44AP(1) Appointment of State/Territory AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.117
note: State/Territory AER member must be appointed by Governor-General
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ap-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AP Appointment of State/Territory AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide appointment
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44AP(2) Appointment of State/Territory AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.117
note: Must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ap-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AP Appointment of State/Territory AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The State/Territory AER member must hold office during a period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The obligation is during a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) A State/Territory AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The State/Territory AER member must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Holding office is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: holds
premise text: (2) A State/Territory AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The State/Territory AER member must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must hold office for a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
modality: Deontic
operator: must-hold-office-for
premise text: (2) A State/Territory AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The State/Territory AER member must not hold office for more than 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must not exceed 5 years.
modality: Deontic
operator: must-not-exceed-5-years
premise text: (2) A State/Territory AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The State/Territory AER member must hold office during a period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The obligation is during a specified period not exceeding 5 years.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (2) A State/Territory AER member holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

44AP(3) Appointment of State/Territory AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.117
note: Knowledge or experience in industry, commerce, economics, law, consumer protection, or public administration is required for appointment.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ap-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AP Appointment of State/Territory AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ap-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires knowledge or experience in a specific field.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

44AQ Acting appointment of State/Territory AER member
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.117
note: The Minister may appoint a person to act as State/Territory AER member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aq-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aq-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44aq
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aq-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted to the Minister
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44AR AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.118
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AR(1) AER Chair
has part: 44AR(2) AER Chair
has part: 44AR(3) AER Chair
has part: 44AR(4) AER Chair
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ar
schema version: 2

44AR(1) AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.118
note: Appointment of AER Deputy Chair Appointment of AER Chair by Governor-General
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ar-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AR AER Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Appointment obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AR(1) AER Chair

44AR(2) AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.118
note: Eligibility requirement for AER Deputy Chair appointment Eligibility requirement for AER Chair appointment
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ar-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AR AER Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Person is not eligible for appointment as the AER Deputy Chair
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires eligibility
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: Person must be a full-time AER member

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...person is a full-time AER member.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires full-time membership
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: Person is not eligible unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AR(2) AER Chair

44AR(3) AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.118
note: The AER Deputy Chair must hold office for a period not exceeding 5 years. The AER Chair must hold office for a period not exceeding 5 years.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-diffusion-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-deontic-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ar-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AR AER Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The AER Deputy Chair's term is within the 5-year limit.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Within a temporal interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: within
premise text: (3) The period must not exceed 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The AER Deputy Chair must hold office for a period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Must hold office
modality: Argumentation
operator: must
premise text: (3) The AER Deputy Chair holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The AER Deputy Chair must hold office for a period not exceeding 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Holding office
modality: Deontic
operator: holds
premise text: (3) The AER Deputy Chair holds office for the period specified in the instrument of appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-deontic-6
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Holding office is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: holds

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The AER Deputy Chair's term is limited to 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses information about the term limit
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (3) The period must not exceed 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The AER Deputy Chair's term is limited to 5 years.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implies a limit on the term
modality: LinearLogic
operator: implies
premise text: (3) The period must not exceed 5 years.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AR(3) AER Chair

44AR(4) AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.118
note: Ceasing to be AER member also ceases being AER Chair. If a person ceases to be an AER member, they also cease to be the AER Deputy Chair.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-ltl-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ar-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44AR AER Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A ceases to be an AER member and the AER Chair.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Ceasing to be AER Chair occurs during ceasing to be AER member.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: A is an AER member.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A ceases to be an AER member and the AER Chair.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ceasing to be A
modality: Deontic
operator: cease
premise text: A is an AER member.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: B ceases to be an AER member and the AER Chair.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ceasing to be B also ceases being B.
modality: Deontic
operator: cease
premise text: B is an AER member.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: B ceases to be an AER Deputy Chair.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ceasing to be B also ceases being B.
modality: Deontic
operator: cease
premise text: B is an AER Deputy Chair.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-deontic-6
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ceasing a duty
modality: Deontic
operator: cease

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A ceases to be an AER member and the AER Chair.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Ceasing to be AER Chair occurs during ceasing to be AER member.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: A is an AER member.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ar-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AR(4) AER Chair

44AS Acting AER Deputy Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.119
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AS(1) Acting AER Deputy Chair
has part: 44AS(2) Acting AER Deputy Chair
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44as
schema version: 2

44AS(1) Acting AER Deputy Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.119
note: The Minister may appoint an AER member as Deputy Chair.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44as-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AS Acting AER Deputy Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for appointment
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (i) is absent from duty or from Australia; (ii) is, for any reason, unable to perform the duties of the office.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Ability to act as Deputy Chair
modality: Argumentation
operator: can
premise text: (a) during a vacancy in the office of the AER Deputy Chair, (b) during any period...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Ability to act as Deputy Chair
modality: CogAI
operator: can
premise text: (a) during a vacancy in the office of the AER Deputy Chair, (b) during any period...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to act
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Permission to act as Deputy Chair
modality: Diffusion
operator: may
premise text: (a) during a vacancy in the office of the AER Deputy Chair, (b) during any period...

44AS(2) Acting AER Deputy Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.119
note: Ceases appointment if AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44as-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AS Acting AER Deputy Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes temporal overlap between appointment cessation and AER Deputy Chair ceasing membership
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (2) If a person acting as the AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member, then the appointment to act as the AER Deputy Chair also ceases.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits appointment continuation if AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: (2) If a person acting as the AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member, then the appointment to act as the AER Deputy Chair also ceases.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes obligation on State to cease appointment if AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (2) If a person acting as the AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member, then the appointment to act as the AER Deputy Chair also ceases.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Describes temporal relationship between appointment cessation and AER Deputy Chair ceasing membership
modality: LTL
operator: Until
premise text: (2) If a person acting as the AER Deputy Chair ceases to be an AER member, then the appointment to act as the AER Deputy Chair also ceases.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44as-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AS(2) Acting AER Deputy Chair

44AT Remuneration of AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AT(1) Remuneration of AER members
has part: 44AT(2) Remuneration of AER members
has part: 44AT(3) Remuneration of AER members
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44at
schema version: 2

44AT(1) Remuneration of AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: AER member must be paid remuneration determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44at-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AT Remuneration of AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AT(1) Remuneration of AER members

44AT(2) Remuneration of AER members
type: Concept
description: Allowances
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: Member must be paid prescribed allowances
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44at-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AT Remuneration of AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to pay allowances
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44AT(3) Remuneration of AER members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: Remuneration of AER members subject to the Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44at-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AT Remuneration of AER members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the State.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44at-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AT(3) Remuneration of AER members

44AU Additional remuneration of AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AU(1) Additional remuneration of AER Chair
has part: 44AU(2) Additional remuneration of AER Chair
has part: 44AU(3) Additional remuneration of AER Chair
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44au
schema version: 2

44AU(1) Additional remuneration of AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: The AER Chair must be paid additional remuneration determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44au-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AU Additional remuneration of AER Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AU(1) Additional remuneration of AER Chair

44AU(2) Additional remuneration of AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: The AER Chair must be paid additional allowances.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44au-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AU Additional remuneration of AER Chair

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide additional allowances.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AU(2) Additional remuneration of AER Chair

44AU(3) Additional remuneration of AER Chair
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: Subject to the Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973, except subsection 7(11)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44au-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44au-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AU Additional remuneration of AER Chair

44AV Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AV(1) Leave of absence
has part: 44AV(2) Leave of absence
has part: 44AV(3) Leave of absence
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44av
schema version: 2

44AV(1) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: A full-time AER member has recreation leave entitlements determined by the Remuneration Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44av-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AV Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Entitlement exists
modality: Deontic
operator: has

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AV(1) Leave of absence

44AV(2) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: Grant leave of absence on terms and conditions determined by the Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44av-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AV Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to grant leave of absence
modality: Deontic
operator: grant

44AV(3) Leave of absence
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.120
note: Grant leave of absence on terms and conditions determined by the AER Chair
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44av-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AV Leave of absence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44av-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Leave of absence granted
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to grant leave of absence
modality: Deontic
operator: grant
premise text: AER Chair has authority

44AW Other terms and conditions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
note: Terms and conditions for AER members
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aw-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44aw
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44aw-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AW Other terms and conditions

44AX Outside employment
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AX(1) Outside employment
has part: 44AX(2) Outside employment
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ax
schema version: 2

44AX(1) Outside employment
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
note: No full-time AER member can engage in paid employment outside their office without Minister's consent.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-diffusion-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-cogai-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-shacl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ax-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AX Outside employment

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Employment overlaps with office duties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal overlap between employment and office duties.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (1) A full-time AER member must not engage in paid employment outside the duties of the member’s office without the Minister’s consent.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-cogai-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Minister recognizes authority to grant consent.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognition of Minister's authority to grant consent.
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognizes
premise text: (1) A full-time AER member must not engage in paid employment outside the duties of the member’s office without the Minister’s consent.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No paid employment outside office duties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of paid employment outside office duties.
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: (1) A full-time AER member must not engage in paid employment outside the duties of the member’s office without the Minister’s consent.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-diffusion-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Minister's consent implies permission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Minister's consent implies permission for employment outside office duties.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Implicates
premise text: (1) A full-time AER member must not engage in paid employment outside the duties of the member’s office without the Minister’s consent.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-logic-shacl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Employment classification is valid.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::shacl
logic summary: Validation of employment classification as outside office duties.
modality: SHACL
operator: Validates
premise text: (1) A full-time AER member must not engage in paid employment outside the duties of the member’s office without the Minister’s consent.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AX(1) Outside employment

44AX(2) Outside employment
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
note: No part-time AER member can engage in paid employment that conflicts with their duties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ax-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AX Outside employment

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ax-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No conflicting employment allowed
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of conflicting employment
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: Member's duties must be performed properly

44AY Disclosure of interests
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AY(1) Disclosure of interests
has part: 44AY(2) Disclosure of interests
has part: 44AY(3) Disclosure of interests
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ay
schema version: 2

44AY(1) Disclosure of interests
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
note: Disclosure of interests by AER members
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ay-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AY Disclosure of interests

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member must disclose interest
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AY(1) Disclosure of interests

44AY(2) Disclosure of interests
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
note: Record disclosure in meeting minutes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ay-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AY Disclosure of interests

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to record disclosure
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AY(2) Disclosure of interests

44AY(3) Disclosure of interests
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.121
note: Exemption from duty to disclose interests for AER members acting in their capacity as AER members.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ay-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AY Disclosure of interests

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Section 29 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 has a temporal exemption for AER members acting in their capacity as AER members.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal exemption

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exempts AER members from duty to disclose interests when acting in their capacity as AER members.
modality: Deontic
operator: Exemption
premise text: Section 29 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 does not apply.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exempts AER members from duty to disclose interests when acting in their capacity as associate members of the Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: Exemption
premise text: Section 29 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 will apply in relation to a person who is an AER member when he or she is acting in his or her capacity as an associate member of the Commission.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Section 29 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 has an exemption for AER members acting in their capacity as associate members of the Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: Exemption

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Section 29 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 prohibits disclosure of interests for AER members acting in their capacity as AER members.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ay-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AY(3) Disclosure of interests

44AZ Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.122
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44AZ(1) Resignation
has part: 44AZ(2) Resignation
has part: 44AZ(3) Resignation
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44az
schema version: 2

44AZ(1) Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.122
note: The AER Chair must convene meetings as necessary. Resignation obligation Governor-General may terminate appointment of AER member under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44az-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44AZ Resignation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to convene meetings
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member has an obligation to resign
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General may terminate appointment
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AZ(1) Resignation

44AZ(2) Resignation
type: Concept
description: written resignation
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.122
note: The AER Chair must provide a written resignation to the Governor-General. Determination of meeting places by the AER Chair Governor-General may terminate appointment of AER member under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44az-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44AZ Resignation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Absence must be for a specified duration.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: for
premise text: (2) The Governor-General may terminate the appointment of a full-time AER member if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The AER Chair must provide a written resignation.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General may terminate appointment.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Termination can occur under multiple conditions.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: or
premise text: (2) The Governor-General may terminate the appointment of a full-time AER member if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44AZ(2) Resignation

44AZ(3) Resignation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.122
note: Quorum requirement for AER meetings Termination of appointment for absence or conflict of interest Resignation obligation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-6
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-7
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44az-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44AZ Resignation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-6
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Overlap between absence and duty period
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
premise text: (a) the member is absent, except on leave of absence, from 3 consecutive meetings of the AER;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The meeting is invalid if less than 3 members are present
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires a quorum of 3 members
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: At least 3 AER members must be present

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The meeting is invalid if less than one member is present
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires the AER Chair to be present
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: At least one member must be present

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The meeting is invalid if less than 2 members are present
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires a quorum of at least 3 members
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: At least 2 members must be present

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on termination without cause
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) The Governor-General may terminate the appointment of a part-time AER member if:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on paid employment that conflicts with duties
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (b) the member engages in paid employment that conflicts or could conflict with the proper performance of the duties of his or her office.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44az-ss-3-logic-deontic-7
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Resignation received
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Governor-General is obligated to receive resignation
modality: Deontic
operator: OBLIGES
premise text: AER Deputy Chair appointment

44B Definitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.139
note: Definitions for access code and related terms.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44b-logic-descriptionlogic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44b
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44b-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Defines key terms.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: has definition

44C How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.143
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44C(1) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
has part: 44C(2) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
has part: 44C(3) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44c
schema version: 2

44C(1) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.143
note: This section applies if the provider of a service is a partnership or joint venture that consists of 2 or more corporations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44c-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44C How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44C(1) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures

44C(2) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.143
note: Permits participants to act on behalf of the provider.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44c-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44C How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Allows action on behalf of the provider.
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit

44C(3) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.143
note: Partnerships and joint ventures are subject to the provision's costs.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44c-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44C How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The provision applies to partnerships and joint ventures.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expansion of scope
modality: Deontic
operator: extension
premise text: The provision applies to participants bearing costs.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44c-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44C(3) How this Part applies to partnerships and joint ventures

44CA Meaning of declaration criteria
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.144
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44CA(1) Meaning of declaration criteria
has part: 44CA(2) Meaning of declaration criteria
has part: 44CA(3) Meaning of declaration criteria
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ca
schema version: 2

44CA(1) Meaning of declaration criteria
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.144
note: Declaration criteria for a service must promote material increase in competition and public interest.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ca-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44CA Meaning of declaration criteria

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (1) The declaration criteria for a service are: (a) that access (or increased access) to the service, on reasonable terms and conditions, as a result of a declaration of the service would promote a material increase in competition in at least one market (whether or not in Australia), other than the market for the service; and
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service declaration must promote material increase in competition and public interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) The declaration criteria for a service are: (a) that access (or increased access) to the service, on reasonable terms and conditions, as a result of a declaration of the service would promote a material increase in competition in at least one market (whether or not in Australia), other than the market for the service; and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (c) that the facility is of national significance, having regard to: (i) the size of the facility; or (ii) the importance of the facility to constitutional trade or commerce; or (iii) the importance of the facility to the national economy;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service declaration must meet facility size and importance criteria.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (c) that the facility is of national significance, having regard to: (i) the size of the facility; or (ii) the importance of the facility to constitutional trade or commerce; or (iii) the importance of the facility to the national economy;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (d) that access (or increased access) to the service, on reasonable terms and conditions, as a result of a declaration of the service would promote the public interest.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service declaration must promote public interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (d) that access (or increased access) to the service, on reasonable terms and conditions, as a result of a declaration of the service would promote the public interest.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (b) that the facility that is used (or will be used) to provide the service could meet the total foreseeable demand in the market: (i) over the period for which the service would be declared; and (ii) at the least cost compared to any 2 or more facilities (which could include the first-mentioned facility);
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service declaration must meet market demand criteria.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (b) that the facility that is used (or will be used) to provide the service could meet the total foreseeable demand in the market: (i) over the period for which the service would be declared; and (ii) at the least cost compared to any 2 or more facilities (which could include the first-mentioned facility);

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (a) that access (or increased access) to the service, on reasonable terms and conditions, as a result of a declaration of the service would promote a material increase in competition in at least one market (whether or not in Australia), other than the market for the service;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service declaration must promote material increase in competition.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (a) that access (or increased access) to the service, on reasonable terms and conditions, as a result of a declaration of the service would promote a material increase in competition in at least one market (whether or not in Australia), other than the market for the service;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44CA(1) Meaning of declaration criteria

44CA(2) Meaning of declaration criteria
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.144
note: Consider facility expansion when determining capacity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ca-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44CA Meaning of declaration criteria

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Facility expansion obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Facility capacity definition
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: ClassInclusion
premise text: (2) For the purposes of paragraph (1)(b):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44CA(2) Meaning of declaration criteria

44CA(3) Meaning of declaration criteria
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.144
note: Council must have regard to certain factors when considering whether a service should be declared.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ca-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44CA Meaning of declaration criteria

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The declaration criteria are within a timeframe
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Council's consideration is within a timeframe
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (3) Without limiting the matters to which the Council may have regard...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The declaration criteria are an argument for declaring a service
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Council's consideration is an argument for declaring a service
modality: Argumentation
operator: IS A
premise text: (3) Without limiting the matters to which the Council may have regard...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The declaration criteria are a cognitive process
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Council's consideration is a cognitive process
modality: CogAI
operator: IS A
premise text: (3) Without limiting the matters to which the Council may have regard...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Council must have regard to...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must consider certain factors
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE REGARD TO
premise text: (3) Without limiting the matters to which the Council may have regard...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The declaration criteria are spread to other entities
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Council's consideration is spread to other entities
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS SPREAD BY
premise text: (3) Without limiting the matters to which the Council may have regard...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ca-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44CA(3) Meaning of declaration criteria

44D Meaning of designated Minister
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.145
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44D(1) Meaning of designated Minister
has part: 44D(2) Meaning of designated Minister
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44d
schema version: 2

44D(1) Meaning of designated Minister
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.145
note: Designated Minister is specified as the Commonwealth Minister unless certain subsections apply.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44d-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44d-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44d-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44D Meaning of designated Minister

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44d-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commonwealth Minister is the designated Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: unless
premise text: (2), (3), (4) or (5)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44d-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44D(1) Meaning of designated Minister

44D(2) Meaning of designated Minister
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.145
note: Definition of designated Minister
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44d-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44d-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44D Meaning of designated Minister

44DA The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.146
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44DA(1) The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have
has part: 44DA(2) The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44da
schema version: 2

44DA(1) The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.146
note: Treat each individual principle as a guideline rather than a binding rule.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44da-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44da-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44da-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44DA The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44da-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council and Ministers have an obligation to treat principles as guidelines.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

44DA(2) The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.146
note: An effective access regime may contain additional matters that are not inconsistent with Competition Principles Agreement principles.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44da-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44da-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44DA The principles in the Competition Principles Agreement have

44E This Part binds the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.147
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44E(1) This Part binds the Crown
has part: 44E(2) This Part binds the Crown
has part: 44E(3) This Part binds the Crown
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44e
schema version: 2

44E(1) This Part binds the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.147
note: This Part binds the Crown
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44e-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44E This Part binds the Crown

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the Crown
modality: Deontic
operator: binds

44E(2) This Part binds the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.147
note: Crown not liable for prosecution
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44e-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44E This Part binds the Crown

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Crown not liable for prosecution
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: No liability
modality: Deontic
operator: not makes
premise text: (2) Nothing in this Part

44E(3) This Part binds the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.147
note: Protection does not apply to certain authorities.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44e-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44E This Part binds the Crown

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Indicates the scope of protection overlaps with certain authorities.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (3) The protection in subsection (2) does not apply to an authority of the Commonwealth or an authority of a State or Territory.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Indicates the scope of protection is recognized by AI.
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognizes
premise text: (3) The protection in subsection (2) does not apply to an authority of the Commonwealth or an authority of a State or Territory.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits protection from applying to certain authorities.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Indicates the scope of protection diffuses with certain authorities.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuses
premise text: (3) The protection in subsection (2) does not apply to an authority of the Commonwealth or an authority of a State or Territory.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44e-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Indicates the scope of protection repeats with certain authorities.
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
premise text: (3) The protection in subsection (2) does not apply to an authority of the Commonwealth or an authority of a State or Territory.

44F Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44F(1) Person may request recommendation
has part: 44F(1A) Person may request recommendation
has part: 44F(2) Person may request recommendation
has part: 44F(3) Person may request recommendation
has part: 44F(5) Person may request recommendation
has part: 44F(6) Person may request recommendation
has part: 44F(7) Person may request recommendation
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f
schema version: 2

44F(1) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: Request for recommendation of a service to be declared
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-ltl-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service is not eligible to be declared if there is a 15-year no-coverage determination in force
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: 15-year no-coverage determination within the National Gas Law
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Within
premise text: (i) a 15-year no-coverage determination is in force under the National Gas Law in respect of the pipeline

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The designated Minister may apply in writing to the Council asking the Council to recommend that a particular service be declared
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by the State
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit
premise text: None

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service is not eligible to be declared if there is a decision under section 44LG
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service ineligible due to decision under section 44LG
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: there is a decision of the designated Minister in force under section 44LG that the service is ineligible to be declared

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service is not eligible to be declared if it is part of a regime with an effective access regime in force
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Service classification based on regime or access undertaking
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classifies
premise text: (a) the service is the subject of a regime for which a decision under section 44N that the regime is an effective access regime is in force (including as a result of an extension under section 44NB); or

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-6
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service is not eligible to be declared if it is part of an access undertaking in operation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Service classification based on access undertaking
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classifies
premise text: (b) the service is the subject of an access undertaking in operation under Division 6

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service is not eligible to be declared if there is a price regulation exemption in force
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Price regulation exemption recurring trace
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring
premise text: (ii) a price regulation exemption is in force under the National Gas Law in respect of the pipeline

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44F(1) Person may request recommendation

44F(1A) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
description: written notice
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: Council must give written notice explaining why certain paragraphs apply and that an application cannot be made for a service.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must give written notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44F(1A) Person may request recommendation

44F(2) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
description: Information about the application
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: The Council must tell the provider of the service that it has received an application.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must tell the provider of the service that it has received an application.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44F(3) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: Service not declared if application made in bad faith
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Service not declared
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits service declaration if application made in bad faith
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Application made in good faith

44F(5) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: Applicant may withdraw application before recommendation is made.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May withdraw application
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44F(5) Person may request recommendation

44F(6) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: Request for Council recommendation variation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to request variation
modality: Deontic
operator: May

44F(7) Person may request recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.148
note: Council must decide on variation request
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44f-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44F Person may request recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44f-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to decide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44FA Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.150
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44FA(1) Council may request information
has part: 44FA(2) Council may request information
has part: 44FA(3) Council may request information
has part: 44FA(4) Council may request information
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44fa
schema version: 2

44FA(1) Council may request information
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.150
note: Request for information
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44fa-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44FA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44FA(2) Council may request information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.150
note: The Council must provide a copy of the notice to the applicant and provider.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44fa-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44FA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must provide a copy of the notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of the provision as an obligation.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44FA(3) Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.150
note: Council must consider information given within a specified period when making a recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-ltl-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44fa-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44FA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This information was given within the specified period.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The specified period is an interval that must be considered by the Council.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: WITHIN
premise text: A specified period has ended.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council must have regard to this information.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must consider information given within a specified period.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Information given in compliance with a notice under subsection (1) within the specified period.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council may disregard this information.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council may disregard information of the kind specified in the notice given after the specified period has ended.
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY DISREGARD
premise text: Information of the kind specified in the notice that is given after the specified period has ended.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-3-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This is part of the Council's recursive decision-making process.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The Council's decision-making process involves considering information in a recursive manner.
modality: LTL
operator: RECURSIVE
premise text: The Council considers information given in compliance with a notice under subsection (1) within the specified period.

44FA(4) Council may request information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.150
note: Council must provide information in response to a notice under this section in a corresponding way to the way those subsections apply to a submission made in response to a notice under subsection 44GB(1).
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44fa-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44FA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44fa-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must provide information.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44G Criteria for the Council recommending declaration of a service
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.151
note: The Council must satisfy all declaration criteria before recommending a service.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44g-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44g-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44g
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44g-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must satisfy all declaration criteria.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44GA Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.151
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44GA(1) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44GA(2) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44GA(3) Time limit for Council recommendations
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ga
schema version: 2

44GA(1) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.151
note: Council must make a recommendation within the consideration period.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ga-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44GA Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Recommendation implies consideration period
modality: LinearLogic
operator: IMPLIES

44GA(2) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.151
note: Defines consideration period for Council recommendations
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ga-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44GA Time limit for Council recommendations

44GA(3) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.151
note: Disregard certain days when calculating the expected period for a recommendation under section 44F.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-ltl-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ga-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44GA Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The period starting on the day referred to in column 2 and ending on the day referred to in column 3
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval during which days are disregarded
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Column 2 and Column 3 are specified

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Disregard any day in a period starting on the day referred to in column 2 and ending on the day referred to in column 3
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exclusion of days from the expected period
modality: Deontic
operator: excludedBy
premise text: Column 1, Column 2, and Column 3 are specified

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Disregard any day in a period starting on the day referred to in column 2 and ending on the day referred in column 3
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exclusion of days from the expected period
modality: Deontic
operator: excludedBy
premise text: Column 1, Column 2, and Column 3 are specified

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ga-ss-3-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The period starting on the day referred to in column 2 and ending on the day referred to in column 3
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal interval during which days are disregarded
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: Column 2 and Column 3 are specified

44GB Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.153
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44GB(1) Council may invite public submissions on the application
has part: 44GB(2) Council may invite public submissions on the application
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gb
schema version: 2

44GB(1) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.153
note: Council may invite public submissions on an application under section 44F.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44GB Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to invite public submissions.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of the application as suitable for public submission.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classifies

44GB(2) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.153
note: Public submissions must be made within a specified timeframe.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44GB Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide public submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gb-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44GB(2) Council may invite public submissions on the application

44GC Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.155
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44GC(1) Council must publish its recommendation
has part: 44GC(2) Council must publish its recommendation
has part: 44GC(3) Council must publish its recommendation
has part: 44GC(4) Council must publish its recommendation
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gc
schema version: 2

44GC(1) Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.155
note: Council must publish its recommendation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gc-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44GC Council must publish its recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of recommendation
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44GC(2) Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
description: yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.155
note: Council must give a copy of the publication to the applicant and provider.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gc-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44GC Council must publish its recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44GC(3) Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.155
note: Council must take action on a specific day
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gc-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44GC Council must publish its recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must do something
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44GC(4) Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.155
note: The Council may give notice to the applicant and provider before publishing its recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44gc-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44GC Council must publish its recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44gc-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to give notice
modality: Deontic
operator: May

44H Designated Minister may declare a service
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44H(1) Designated Minister may declare a service
has part: 44H(1A) Designated Minister may declare a service
has part: 44H(4) Designated Minister may declare a service
has part: 44H(8) Designated Minister may declare a service
has part: 44H(9) Designated Minister may declare a service
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44h
schema version: 2

44H(1) Designated Minister may declare a service
type: Concept
description: Decision
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Must declare or decide not to declare a service upon receiving a declaration recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44h-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44H Designated Minister may declare a service

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to declare or decide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44H(1A) Designated Minister may declare a service
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Must have regard to objects of Part in decision-making
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44h-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 44H Designated Minister may declare a service

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider objects of Part
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE REGARD TO

44H(4) Designated Minister may declare a service
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Must declare a service only if satisfied of declaration criteria.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44h-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44H Designated Minister may declare a service

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on declaring a service without satisfying declaration criteria.
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot

44H(8) Designated Minister may declare a service
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Designated Minister must specify expiry date in declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44h-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44H Designated Minister may declare a service

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-8-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44H(8) Designated Minister may declare a service

44H(9) Designated Minister may declare a service
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Designated Minister must publish decision within 60 days or be deemed to have made a decision in accordance with the declaration recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-9-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-9-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44h-ss-9
schema version: 2
part of: 44H Designated Minister may declare a service

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-9-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for publication is specified.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Designated Minister must publish decision within 60 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44h-ss-9-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44H(9) Designated Minister may declare a service

44HA Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44HA(1) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
has part: 44HA(2) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
has part: 44HA(3) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
has part: 44HA(4) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ha
schema version: 2

44HA(1) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Publish decision on declaration recommendation and reasons for the decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ha-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44HA Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of declaration recommendation and reasons for the decision
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44HA(1) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44HA(2) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Designated Minister must publish decision and provide to applicant and provider.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ha-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44HA Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...and provider.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Designated Minister must give a copy of the publication to...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44HA(2) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44HA(3) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Designated Minister may give notice to persons before publishing decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ha-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44HA Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to provide notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-3-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44HA(3) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44HA(4) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.156
note: Must have regard to submissions when deciding what to publish.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-ltl-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ha-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44HA Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Submission is a relevant matter when considering decisions within a specific time frame.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (4) The designated Minister must have regard to any submission so made in deciding what to publish.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider submissions when making decisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE REGARD TO
premise text: (4) The designated Minister must have regard to any submission so made in deciding what to publish.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May consider other relevant matters when making decisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY HAVE REGARD TO
premise text: (4) The designated Minister must have regard to any submission so made in deciding what to publish.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Submission is a relevant matter when considering decisions and is spread by the designated Minister.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS SPREAD BY
premise text: (4) The designated Minister must have regard to any submission so made in deciding what to publish.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Submission is a relevant matter when considering decisions within a specific time frame.
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (4) The designated Minister must have regard to any submission so made in deciding what to publish.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ha-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44HA(4) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44I Duration and effect of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.157
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44I(1) Duration and effect of declaration
has part: 44I(2) Duration and effect of declaration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44i
schema version: 2

44I(1) Duration and effect of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.157
note: Declaration begins operating at a specified time after publication, with a minimum delay of 21 days.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44i-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44I Duration and effect of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Declaration operates at specified time
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Declaration begins operating
modality: Deontic
operator: begins
premise text: Time specified in declaration

44I(2) Duration and effect of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.157
note: Declaration does not begin to operate until order is no longer in effect under subsection 44KA(6) or Tribunal makes a new decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44i-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44I Duration and effect of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration does not begin to operate until the order is no longer in effect under subsection 44KA(6) or the Tribunal makes a new decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for declaration operation
modality: AllenInterval
operator: until
premise text: (2) If an application for review of a declaration is made within 21 days after the day the declaration is published; and (b) the Tribunal makes an order under section 44KA staying the operation of the declaration;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration does not begin to operate until the order is no longer in effect under subsection 44KA(6) or the Tribunal makes a new decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Temporal condition for declaration operation
modality: Deontic
operator: until
premise text: (2) If an application for review of a declaration is made within 21 days after the day the declaration is published; and (b) the Tribunal makes an order under section 44KA staying the operation of the declaration;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration does not begin to operate until the order is no longer in effect under subsection 44KA(6) or the Tribunal makes a new decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal's decision required for declaration operation
modality: Deontic
operator: must
premise text: (2) If an application for review of a declaration is made within 21 days after the day the declaration is published; and (b) the Tribunal makes an order under section 44KA staying the operation of the declaration;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration does not begin to operate until the order is no longer in effect under subsection 44KA(6) or the Tribunal makes a new decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal condition for declaration operation
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: (2) If an application for review of a declaration is made within 21 days after the day the declaration is published; and (b) the Tribunal makes an order under section 44KA staying the operation of the declaration;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44i-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44I(2) Duration and effect of declaration

44J Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44J(1) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(2) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(3) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(3A) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(4) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(5) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(6) Revocation of declaration
has part: 44J(7) Revocation of declaration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j
schema version: 2

44J(1) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: The Council must have regard to the objects of this Part when making its decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must have regard to the objects of this Part.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44J(2) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Council must be satisfied before recommending revocation of declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-ltl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...it is satisfied that, at the time of the recommendation: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for recommendation.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (2) The Council cannot recommend revocation of a declaration unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...it is satisfied that, at the time of the recommendation: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must satisfy conditions before making recommendation.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) The Council cannot recommend revocation of a declaration unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...it is satisfied that, at the time of the recommendation: ... (a) subsection 44F(1) would prevent the making of an application for a recommendation that the service concerned be declared; or
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be satisfied before making application for declaration.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) The Council cannot recommend revocation of a declaration unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...it is satisfied that, at the time of the recommendation: ... (b) subsection 44H(4) would prevent the service concerned from being declared.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be satisfied before declaring service.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) The Council cannot recommend revocation of a declaration unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-logic-ltl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...it is satisfied that, at the time of the recommendation: ... (a) subsection 44F(1) would prevent the making of an application for a recommendation that the service concerned be declared; or
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal interval for application.
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (2) The Council cannot recommend revocation of a declaration unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44J(2) Revocation of declaration

44J(3) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Minister must decide on revocation of declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: revocation decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must decide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44J(3) Revocation of declaration

44J(3A) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Designated Minister must consider objects of Part in decision-making.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-3a
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision-making
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Objects of Part

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-3a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44J(3A) Revocation of declaration

44J(4) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Designated Minister must publish decision to revoke or not revoke declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Designated Minister must publish decision.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44J(4) Revocation of declaration

44J(5) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
description: Reasons for decision
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Designated Minister must give reasons for decision not to revoke declared service.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Reasons for decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Designated Minister must give reasons
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44J(5) Revocation of declaration

44J(6) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Designated Minister must receive revocation recommendation before revoking declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Designated Minister must receive revocation recommendation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide revocation recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44J(6) Revocation of declaration

44J(7) Revocation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.158
note: Failure to publish decision within 60 days results in automatic revocation of declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44j-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44J Revocation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the designated Minister is taken, immediately after the end of that 60-day period: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval from start of day recommendation received to end of 60 days.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: interval relation
premise text: (7) If the designated Minister does not publish under subsection (4) his or her decision on the revocation recommendation within the period starting at the start of the day...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the designated Minister is taken, immediately after the end of that 60-day period: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to publish decision within 60 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation
premise text: (7) If the designated Minister does not publish under subsection (4) his or her decision on the revocation recommendation...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the designated Minister is taken, immediately after the end of that 60-day period: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to publish decision within 60 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: permission
premise text: (7) If the designated Minister does not publish under subsection (4) his or her decision on the revocation recommendation...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44j-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the designated Minister is taken, immediately after the end of that 60-day period: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace from start of day recommendation received to end of 60 days.
modality: LTL
operator: recurring trace
premise text: (7) If the designated Minister does not publish under subsection (4) his or her decision on the revocation recommendation within the period starting at the start of the day...

44K Review of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.159
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44K(1) Review of declaration
has part: 44K(2) Review of declaration
has part: 44K(3) Review of declaration
has part: 44K(4) Review of declaration
has part: 44K(5) Review of declaration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44k
schema version: 2

44K(1) Review of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.159
note: Provider may apply for review of declaration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44k-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44K Review of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Provider has the right to request a review.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

44K(2) Review of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.159
note: Right to review of designated Minister's decision
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44k-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44K Review of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Right to apply for review
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44K(2) Review of declaration

44K(3) Review of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.159
note: Application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister's decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44k-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44K Review of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST BE MADE AT LEAST 21 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Application must be made at least 21 days after publication.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (3) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review IS A FORMAL REQUEST.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Application is a formal request.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: (3) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review IS A LEGAL ACTION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Application is a legal action.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: (3) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST BE MADE AT LEAST 21 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Application must be made at least 21 days after publication.
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: (3) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44K(3) Review of declaration

44K(4) Review of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.159
note: Reconsideration of the matter based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44k-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44K Review of declaration

44K(5) Review of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.159
note: The Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44k-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44K Review of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.
modality: Deontic
operator: hasSamePowersAs
premise text: (5) For the purposes of the review, the Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44k-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44K(5) Review of declaration

44KA Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.160
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44KA(1) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
has part: 44KA(2) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
has part: 44KA(3) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
has part: 44KA(4) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ka
schema version: 2

44KA(1) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.160
note: Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ka-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44KA Tribunal may stay operation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the taking of steps in reliance on the declaration is allowed before the tribunal's decision
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between declaration and taking steps in reliance on it
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, an application for review of a declaration under subsection 44K(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration's operation is allowed before the tribunal's decision
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Cognitive AI analysis of declaration and its operation
modality: CogAI
operator: CogAI
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, an application for review of a declaration under subsection 44K(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: does not affect the operation of the declaration; or prevent the taking of steps in reliance on the declaration.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to stay operation of declaration
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, an application for review of a declaration under subsection 44K(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration's operation is allowed before the tribunal's decision
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion of declaration and its operation
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffusion
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, an application for review of a declaration under subsection 44K(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the declaration's operation is allowed before the tribunal's decision
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace of declaration and its operation
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring trace
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, an application for review of a declaration under subsection 44K(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44KA(1) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration

44KA(2) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.160
note: Tribunal may stay operation of declaration on application by a party to proceedings for review.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ka-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44KA Tribunal may stay operation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal may make an order staying or affecting the operation of a declaration.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: The Tribunal may make an order varying or revoking a previous order.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: or

44KA(3) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.160
note: Council must be given a reasonable opportunity to make submissions before making an order under subsection (2)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ka-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44KA Tribunal may stay operation of declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal must not make an order under subsection (2).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must be given a reasonable opportunity to make submissions before making an order under subsection (2)
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The Council has not been given a reasonable opportunity to make a submission.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal must not make an order varying or revoking an existing order under paragraph (2)(a).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council and the person who requested the making of the order under paragraph (2)(a) must be given a reasonable opportunity to make submissions before making an order varying or revoking an existing order.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The Council has not been given a reasonable opportunity to make a submission.

44KA(4) Tribunal may stay operation of declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.160
note: Tribunal may make an order without informing a person
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ka-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ka-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44KA Tribunal may stay operation of declaration

44KB Tribunal may order costs be awarded
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.162
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44KB(1) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
has part: 44KB(2) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
has part: 44KB(3) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
has part: 44KB(4) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
has part: 44KB(5) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44kb
schema version: 2

44KB(1) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.162
note: Tribunal may order costs be awarded to another party.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44kb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44KB Tribunal may order costs be awarded

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44KB(1) Tribunal may order costs be awarded

44KB(2) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.162
note: The Tribunal must consider the costs incurred by another party before ordering the designated Minister to pay some or all of those costs.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44kb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44KB Tribunal may order costs be awarded

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: None
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal must consider the costs incurred by another party.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: None

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44KB(2) Tribunal may order costs be awarded

44KB(3) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.162
note: Tribunal may order costs be awarded
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44kb-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44KB Tribunal may order costs be awarded

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44KB(4) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.162
note: Regulations may make provision for fees payable for assessment or taxation of costs ordered by the Tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44kb-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44KB Tribunal may order costs be awarded

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44KB(4) Tribunal may order costs be awarded

44KB(5) Tribunal may order costs be awarded
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.162
note: Party must pay costs ordered by tribunal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44kb-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44KB Tribunal may order costs be awarded

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to pay costs
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44kb-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44KB(5) Tribunal may order costs be awarded

44L Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.163
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44L(1) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
has part: 44L(2) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
has part: 44L(3) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44l
schema version: 2

44L(1) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.163
note: Right to apply for review of decision not to revoke declaration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44l-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44L Review of decision not to revoke a declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Declaration holder has right to apply for review
modality: Deontic
operator: hasRight

44L(2) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.163
note: Application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44l-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44L Review of decision not to revoke a declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST BE MADE AT LEAST 21 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Application must be made at least 21 days after publication.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review IS A FORMAL REQUIREMENT.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Application is a formal requirement.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review IS A LEGAL REQUIREMENT.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Application is a legal requirement.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST BE MADE AT LEAST 21 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Application must be made at least 21 days after publication.
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44L(2) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration

44L(3) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.163
note: Tribunal must re-consider decision not to revoke a declaration based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44l-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44L Review of decision not to revoke a declaration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The time limits that apply to the Tribunal’s decision on the review (see section 44ZZOA).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Time limits apply to the Tribunal's decision
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: Section 44ZZOA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The review by the Tribunal is a re-consideration of the matter based on the information, reports and things referred to in section 44ZZOAA.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Tribunal's review involves artificial intelligence
modality: CogAI
operator: IS-A
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review by the Tribunal is a re-consideration of the matter
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must re-consider decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The review by the Tribunal is a re-consideration of the matter based on the information, reports and things referred to in section 44ZZOAA.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Tribunal's review is a re-consideration of a previous decision
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS-A
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal’s decision on the review (see section 44ZZOA).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Tribunal's decision is within a specified timeframe
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44l-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44L(3) Review of decision not to revoke a declaration

44LA Constitutional limits on operation of this Division
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.165
note: Service provision is subject to constitutional limits.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44la-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44la-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44la
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44la-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: None
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits service provision under certain conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: None

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44la-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LA Constitutional limits on operation of this Division

44LB Ineligibility recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.165
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LB(1) Ineligibility recommendation
has part: 44LB(2) Ineligibility recommendation
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lb
schema version: 2

44LB(1) Ineligibility recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.165
note: Application for ineligibility recommendation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LB Ineligibility recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Application must be submitted before facility construction begins
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for application submission
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Before
premise text: Note: The application must be made before construction of the facility commences

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Person with material interest may apply for ineligibility
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to recommend
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Council must make recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council has a duty to recommend ineligibility
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to make recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Council must make recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: See definition of proposed facility in section 44B
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Definition of proposed facility
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Class
premise text: Note: The application must be made before construction of the facility commences

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LB(1) Ineligibility recommendation

44LB(2) Ineligibility recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.165
note: Recommendation of ineligibility for a declared service
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LB Ineligibility recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must recommend
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LC Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.167
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LC(1) Council may request information
has part: 44LC(2) Council may request information
has part: 44LC(3) Council may request information
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lc
schema version: 2

44LC(1) Council may request information
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.167
note: Request for information
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lc-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LC Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LC(2) Council may request information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.167
note: The Council must provide a copy of the notice to the applicant and publish it.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lc-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LC Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must provide a copy of the notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: The provision is part of a class of provisions that require the Council to take action.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: SUBCLASS OF

44LC(3) Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.167
note: Must consider information given within specified period
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lc-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LC Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lc-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Consideration of information
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Given notice within specified period

44LD Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LD(1) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(2) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(3) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(4) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(5) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(6) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(7) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(8) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(9) Time limit for Council recommendations
has part: 44LD(10) Time limit for Council recommendations
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld
schema version: 2

44LD(1) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Council must make a recommendation within the consideration period.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Recommendation implies consideration period
modality: LinearLogic
operator: IMPLIES

44LD(10) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
description: Notice to the public
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Publish a notice stating the extension and new deadline for recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-10-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-10-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-10
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-10-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Publish a notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LD(2) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Defines the consideration period for Council recommendations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

44LD(3) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Disregard certain days when calculating the expected period for a recommendation under section 44LB.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

44LD(4) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Do not disregard any day more than once and limit total period to 60 days.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-ltl-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: a day is in the interval if it is disregarded under that subsection;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines a temporal interval for disregarding days
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (4) Despite subsection (3): (a) do not disregard any day more than once;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: do not disregard any day more than once;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits disregarding a day
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: (4) Despite subsection (3):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the total period that is disregarded under that subsection must not exceed 60 days;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Limits total period to 60 days
modality: Deontic
operator: Limitation
premise text: (b) the total period that is disregarded under that subsection must not exceed 60 days.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the obligation to not disregard a day is diffused to all agents;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses the obligation to not disregard days
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuses
premise text: (4) Despite subsection (3): (a) do not disregard any day more than once;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: a day is in the pattern if it is disregarded under that subsection;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Defines a recurring pattern of days to be disregarded
modality: LTL
operator: Recurrent
premise text: (4) Despite subsection (3): (a) do not disregard any day more than once;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-4-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LD(4) Time limit for Council recommendations

44LD(5) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Agreement on time limit disregard period
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-5-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

44LD(6) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
description: agreement
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Publish agreement by electronic or other means within a time limit
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for publishing agreement
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Publish agreement by electronic or other means within a time limit
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-6-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of the Council's decision-making process
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44LD(7) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Council must extend consideration period by notice if unable to make recommendation within time limit.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LD(8) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
description: Notice
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Specify when Council must make a recommendation and explain inability to do so within consideration period.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Specify when Council must make a recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LD(9) Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.168
note: Council must give a copy of the notice to applicant and provider.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-9-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ld-ss-9
schema version: 2
part of: 44LD Time limit for Council recommendations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must give a copy of the notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ld-ss-9-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LD(9) Time limit for Council recommendations

44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LE(1) Council may invite public submissions on the application
has part: 44LE(2) Council may invite public submissions on the application
has part: 44LE(3) Council may invite public submissions on the application
has part: 44LE(4) Council may invite public submissions on the application
has part: 44LE(5) Council may invite public submissions on the application
has part: 44LE(6) Council may invite public submissions on the application
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le
schema version: 2

44LE(1) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
note: Council may invite public submissions on an application under section 44LB.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to invite public submissions.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of the application as suitable for public submission.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classifies

44LE(2) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
note: Public submissions must be made within a specified timeframe.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions must be made within 14 days of the notice publication.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Submissions must be made within a specified timeframe
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: The day by which submissions may be made (which must be at least 14 days after the day the notice is published).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This is a description of the cognitive AI process for public submissions.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Describes a process for public submissions
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: The notice must specify how submissions may be made and the day by which submissions may be made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions must be made within a specified timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide public submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The notice must specify how submissions may be made and the day by which submissions may be made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This is a description of the diffusion process for public submissions.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Describes a process for public submissions
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: The notice must specify how submissions may be made and the day by which submissions may be made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions have a minimum timing requirement.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Submissions have a lower bound on their timing
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: The day by which submissions may be made (which must be at least 14 days after the day the notice is published).

44LE(3) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
note: Must consider submissions before specified day
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council must have regard to submission
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Submission made on or before specified day

44LE(4) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
note: The Council must make written submissions publicly available.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LE(5) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
note: Request for confidentiality of submission
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Grant permission to request confidentiality
modality: Deontic
operator: Allow

44LE(6) Council may invite public submissions on the application
type: Concept
description: return whole or part of submission, inform person withdrawing submission
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.170
note: Council must return written submissions if requested and withdraw oral submissions if required.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44le-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44LE Council may invite public submissions on the application

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44le-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must return written submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: Must

44LF Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.171
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LF(1) Council must publish its recommendation
has part: 44LF(2) Council must publish its recommendation
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lf
schema version: 2

44LF(1) Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
description: recommendation and reasons for the recommendation
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.171
note: Council must publish its recommendation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lf-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LF Council must publish its recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of recommendation
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44LF(2) Council must publish its recommendation
type: Concept
description: yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.171
note: Council must give a copy of the publication to specific persons.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lf-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LF Council must publish its recommendation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LG(1) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
has part: 44LG(2) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
has part: 44LG(3) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
has part: 44LG(4) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
has part: 44LG(5) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
has part: 44LG(6) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg
schema version: 2

44LG(1) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
note: Must decide on ineligibility of a service within 20 years.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must decide on ineligibility of a service within 20 years.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LG(1) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

44LG(2) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
note: Designated Minister must consider objects of Part in decision-making
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision-making
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Objects of Part

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LG(2) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

44LG(3) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
note: Service ineligible despite access undertaking
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the service is ineligible to be a declared service
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits service eligibility
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) The designated Minister may decide...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LG(3) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

44LG(4) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
note: Service ineligible if proposed facility tender process is approved
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-4-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the service is ineligible to be a declared service
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits service eligibility
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (4) The designated Minister may decide...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-4-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...even if...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies service as ineligible
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify
premise text: (4) The designated Minister may decide...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-4-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LG(4) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

44LG(5) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
note: The designated Minister must be satisfied of certain matters before declaring a service ineligible.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The designated Minister must be satisfied of certain matters.
modality: Deontic
operator: Must
premise text: (5) The designated Minister must not decide that the service is ineligible to be a declared service unless he or she is satisfied of both of the following matters:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-5-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The designated Minister must be satisfied of at least one declaration criterion.
modality: Deontic
operator: Must
premise text: (5) The designated Minister must not decide that the service is ineligible to be a declared service unless he or she is satisfied of both of the following matters: (a) that the service is to be provided by means of the proposed facility when constructed; (b) that he or she is not satisfied of at least one of the declaration criteria for the service to be provided by means of the proposed facility.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LG(5) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

44LG(6) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.172
note: Designated Minister must publish decision on ineligibility within 60 days.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lg-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44LG Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lg-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LG(6) Designated Minister’s decision on ineligibility

44LH Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LH(1) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
has part: 44LH(2) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
has part: 44LH(3) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
has part: 44LH(4) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lh
schema version: 2

44LH(1) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Publish decision on ineligibility recommendation and reasons
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lh-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LH Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of ineligibility recommendation and reasons
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LH(1) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44LH(2) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Designated Minister must publish decision and provide copy to applicant.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lh-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LH Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LH(2) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44LH(3) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Designated Minister may give notice to persons before publishing decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lh-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LH Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to provide notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-3-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LH(3) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

44LH(4) Designated Minister must publish his or her decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Must have regard to submissions when deciding what to publish.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lh-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LH Designated Minister must publish his or her decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lh-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision made with regard to submission
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider submissions when making decisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE REGARD TO
premise text: Submission made

44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LI(1) Revocation of ineligibility decision
has part: 44LI(2) Revocation of ineligibility decision
has part: 44LI(3) Revocation of ineligibility decision
has part: 44LI(4) Revocation of ineligibility decision
has part: 44LI(5) Revocation of ineligibility decision
has part: 44LI(6) Revocation of ineligibility decision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li
schema version: 2

44LI(1) Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: The Council must recommend to the designated Minister that they revoke their decision on ineligibility.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The designated Minister must revoke their decision within a certain timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The recommendation is made between the time the ineligibility decision was made and the current time.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: The Council has a duty to make recommendations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The designated Minister must revoke their decision within a certain timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The recommendation is made between the time the ineligibility decision was made and the current time.
modality: CogAI
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: The Council has a duty to make recommendations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The designated Minister must revoke their decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must recommend to the designated Minister.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The Council has a duty to make recommendations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The designated Minister must revoke their decision within a certain timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The recommendation is made between the time the ineligibility decision was made and the current time.
modality: Diffusion
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: The Council has a duty to make recommendations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The designated Minister must revoke their decision within a certain timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The recommendation is made between the time the ineligibility decision was made and the current time.
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: The Council has a duty to make recommendations.

44LI(2) Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Council must decide whether to revoke decision
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide decision revocation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Facility description must be different
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: hasPart
premise text: (2) The Council cannot recommend that a decision be revoked unless...

44LI(3) Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Must revoke ineligibility decision upon receiving recommendation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Must revoke ineligibility decision upon receiving recommendation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to revoke ineligibility decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) On receiving a recommendation that the designated Minister revoke the ineligibility decision, the designated Minister must either revoke the ineligibility decision or decide not to revoke the ineligibility decision.

44LI(4) Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Minister must have regard to objects of Part in decision-making.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister's obligation to consider Part's objects.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE REGARD TO

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LI(4) Revocation of ineligibility decision

44LI(5) Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Designated Minister must publish decision to revoke or not revoke ineligibility decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-5-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Designated Minister must publish decision.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-5-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Decision to revoke or not revoke ineligibility decision is a subclass of publication.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: SUBCLASS OF

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LI(5) Revocation of ineligibility decision

44LI(6) Revocation of ineligibility decision
type: Concept
description: Reasons for decision
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.174
note: Designated Minister must give reasons for decision to person affected.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44li-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44LI Revocation of ineligibility decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Designated Minister must give reasons
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44li-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LI(6) Revocation of ineligibility decision

44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LJ(1) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(2) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(3) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(4) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(5) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(6) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(7) Review of ineligibility decisions
has part: 44LJ(8) Review of ineligibility decisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj
schema version: 2

44LJ(1) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: A person can apply in writing to the Tribunal for a review of an ineligible decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses ability to apply for a review.
modality: Deontic
operator: can

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LJ(1) Review of ineligibility decisions

44LJ(2) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: Application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister's decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application MUST BE MADE AT LEAST 21 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Application must be made at least 21 days after publication.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application IS A REVIEW APPLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Application is a review application.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application IS A REVIEW APPLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Application is a review application.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application MUST BE MADE AT LEAST 21 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Application must be made at least 21 days after publication.
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LJ(2) Review of ineligibility decisions

44LJ(3) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: Reconsideration of ineligibility decisions based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

44LJ(4) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: The Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same temporal interval as the designated Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Same temporal interval as the designated Minister
modality: AllenInterval
operator: same temporal interval
premise text: (4) For the purposes of the review, the Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same cogAI as the designated Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Same cogAI as the designated Minister
modality: CogAI
operator: same cogAI
premise text: (4) For the purposes of the review, the Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Same powers as the designated Minister
modality: Deontic
operator: same powers
premise text: (4) For the purposes of the review, the Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same diffusion as the designated Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Same diffusion as the designated Minister
modality: Diffusion
operator: same diffusion
premise text: (4) For the purposes of the review, the Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same trace as the designated Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Same trace as the designated Minister
modality: LTL
operator: same trace
premise text: (4) For the purposes of the review, the Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister.

44LJ(5) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: Council must provide assistance for review purposes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to assist
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LJ(6) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: Member may require Council to provide information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: require

44LJ(7) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
description: Notice
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: Tribunal must give notice to applicant, provider, and other parties involved.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-7-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must give notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-7-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Notice is a subclass of obligation
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: SUBCLASS OF

44LJ(8) Review of ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.176
note: Review of ineligibility decisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lj-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44LJ Review of ineligibility decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision affirmed
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Affirm decision
modality: Deontic
operator: affirm
premise text: Tribunal may affirm decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision varied
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Vary decision
modality: Deontic
operator: vary
premise text: Tribunal may vary decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lj-ss-8-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision set aside
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Set aside decision
modality: Deontic
operator: set aside
premise text: Tribunal may set aside decision

44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LK(1) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(2) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(3) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(4) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(5) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(6) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(7) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(8) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
has part: 44LK(9) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk
schema version: 2

44LK(1) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: A person may apply in writing to the Tribunal for a review of a decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LK(1) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

44LK(2) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: Application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the designated Minister's decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: None
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: None

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LK(2) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

44LK(3) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: Reconsideration of decision to revoke or not revoke ineligibility based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Tribunal's reconsidered decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Re-evaluation of decision based on new information.
modality: Deontic
operator: Reconsideration
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

44LK(4) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: The Tribunal has the same powers as the designated Minister for review purposes.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Tribunal has same power as Minister
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal has the same power as the designated Minister.
modality: Deontic
operator: hasPower
premise text: Tribunal has powers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LK(4) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

44LK(5) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: The Council must provide assistance for the purposes of the review.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must provide assistance.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44LK(6) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: Member may require Council to provide information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: require

44LK(7) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: Tribunal must give a copy of notice to certain persons and publish it.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Tribunal must publish notice before decision is made.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (7) The Tribunal must: (b) publish, by electronic or other means, the notice.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Tribunal's decision implies publication of notice.
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: (7) The Tribunal must: (b) publish, by electronic or other means, the notice.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must give a copy of notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Notice is a document
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: IS_A
premise text: (7) The Tribunal must: (a) give a copy of the notice to:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-7-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Notice is published to certain persons.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IN
premise text: (7) The Tribunal must: (a) give a copy of the notice to:

44LK(8) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: Tribunal may affirm or set aside designated Minister's decision to revoke ineligibility
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal may affirm or set aside decision
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44LK(9) Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.178
note: Tribunal may affirm or revoke designated Minister's decision on ineligibility
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-9-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-9-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44lk-ss-9
schema version: 2
part of: 44LK Review of decision to revoke or not revoke an ineligibility

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Tribunal must affirm the designated Minister's decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Affirmation obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may
premise text: Tribunal may set aside the designated Minister's decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44lk-ss-9-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Tribunal must revoke the ineligibility decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Revocation obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may
premise text: Tribunal may set aside the designated Minister's decision

44LL Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.180
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44LL(1) Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.
has part: 44LL(2) Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ll
schema version: 2

44LL(1) Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.180
note: Decision can be revoked or cancelled under later legislation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ll-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44LL Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Decision can be made at any time before cancellation.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (c) no compensation is payable if the decision is cancelled, revoked, terminated or varied as mentioned in any of the above paragraphs;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits service from being declared.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: (a) the decision may be revoked under section 44LI;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permits revocation under section 44LI.
modality: Deontic
operator: Permission
premise text: (a) the decision may be revoked under section 44LI;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: State is obligated to provide compensation if decision is not cancelled.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (c) no compensation is payable if the decision is cancelled, revoked, terminated or varied as mentioned in any of the above paragraphs;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LL(1) Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.

44LL(2) Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.180
note: Does not affect interpretation of other provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ll-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44LL Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2)
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implication
modality: Deontic
operator: implies
premise text: (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ll-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44LL(2) Ineligibility decisions subject to alteration, cancellation etc.

44M Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.181
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44M(1) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
has part: 44M(2) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
has part: 44M(3) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
has part: 44M(4) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44m
schema version: 2

44M(1) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.181
note: Establishment of a regime for access to a service or proposed service is subject to recommendation by the Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44m-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44M Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44M(1) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

44M(2) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.181
note: Minister may make written application to Council for recommendation on access regime effectiveness
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44m-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44M Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44M(2) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

44M(3) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.181
note: Council must recommend to Commonwealth Minister on effectiveness of access regime.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44m-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44M Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44M(3) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

44M(4) Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.181
note: Must assess effectiveness of access regime and consider objects of this Part
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44m-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44M Recommendation for a Ministerial decision on effectiveness of

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44m-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: None
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: None

44MA Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44MA(1) Council may request information
has part: 44MA(2) Council may request information
has part: 44MA(3) Council may request information
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ma
schema version: 2

44MA(1) Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: Council may request information from a person.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ma-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44MA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May give notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY

44MA(2) Council may request information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: The Council must provide a copy of the notice to the applicant and provider.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ma-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44MA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Council must provide a copy of the notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: The applicant and provider are subclasses of the person who received the notice.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: SUBCLASS_OF

44MA(3) Council may request information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: Must consider information given within specified period
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ma-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44MA Council may request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ma-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Consideration of information
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Given notice within specified period

44N Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44N(1) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44N(2) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44N(2A) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44N(3) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44N(4) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44n
schema version: 2

44N(1) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: The Commonwealth Minister must decide on the effectiveness of an access regime.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44n-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44N Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commonwealth Minister must decide.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44N(2) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: Commonwealth Minister must apply principles and have regard to objects when making a decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44n-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44N Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Apply principles
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must apply principles
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Relevant principles set out in the Competition Principles Agreement

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Have regard to objects
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Have regard to objects
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE REGARD TO
premise text: Objects of this Part

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44N(2) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44N(2A) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: Disregard Chapter 5 of a National Gas Law when making a decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44n-ss-2a
schema version: 2
part of: 44N Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of Chapter 5
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-2a-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44N(2A) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44N(3) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: Specifies period for which ministerial decision is in force.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44n-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44N Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44N(4) Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.182
note: Failure to publish decision within 60 days results in automatic publication and enforcement of recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44n-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44N Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44n-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Automatic publication and enforcement.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to publish decision within 60 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation
premise text: No publication within 60 days.

44NA Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44NA(1) Recommendation by Council
has part: 44NA(2) Recommendation by Council
has part: 44NA(3) Recommendation by Council
has part: 44NA(4) Recommendation by Council
has part: 44NA(5) Recommendation by Council
has part: 44NA(6) Recommendation by Council
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na
schema version: 2

44NA(1) Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
note: Request for information from a person Application of section 44N decision to access regime
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44NA Recommendation by Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council may request information
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if a decision of the Commonwealth Minister is in force under section 44N
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Section applies if condition met
modality: Deontic
operator: applies
premise text: (1) This section applies...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Person can provide requested information
modality: Epistemic
operator: CAN

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44NA(1) Recommendation by Council

44NA(2) Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
note: Council must give a copy of notice to applicant and provider, and publish the notice. Minister may make written application to Council for recommendation on extending decision period.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44NA Recommendation by Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Council must give a copy of notice to applicant and provider.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister may make application
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Council is responsible for giving a copy of notice to applicant and provider.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: IS_A

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Application is part of decision-making process
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: HasPart

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44NA(2) Recommendation by Council

44NA(3) Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
note: Must consider information given within specified period, may disregard later information. Minister may specify variations to access regime
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44NA Recommendation by Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Council may disregard any information of the kind specified in the notice that is given after the specified period has ended.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider information given within specified period.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Given a notice under subsection (1) within the specified period, the Council must have regard to any information.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May disregard later information.
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY
premise text: Given a notice under subsection (1) within the specified period, the Council may disregard any information of the kind specified in the notice that is given after the specified period has ended.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister has the power to specify variations
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44NA(3) Recommendation by Council

44NA(4) Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
note: Council must assess effectiveness of access regime.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44NA Recommendation by Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide assessment
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44NA(5) Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
note: Council must recommend extension period to Commonwealth Minister
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44NA Recommendation by Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44NA(6) Recommendation by Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.184
note: Council must recommend not extending period for decision under section 44N if it is not an effective access regime.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44na-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44NA Recommendation by Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44na-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44NA(6) Recommendation by Council

44NB Decision by the Commonwealth Minister
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.185
note: Must assess effectiveness of access regime upon receiving recommendation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nb-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nb-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nb
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nb-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to assess effectiveness
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44NC Time limit for Council recommendations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.189
note: Council must make recommendation within consideration period
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nc-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nc-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nc
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nc-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: within the consideration period
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to make recommendation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Council must make a recommendation

44NE Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44NE(1) Council may invite public submissions
has part: 44NE(2) Council may invite public submissions
has part: 44NE(3) Council may invite public submissions
has part: 44NE(4) Council may invite public submissions
has part: 44NE(5) Council may invite public submissions
has part: 44NE(6) Council may invite public submissions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne
schema version: 2

44NE(1) Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
note: Council may invite public submissions on certain applications or initiatives.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44NE Council may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to invite public submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Descriptive clause for public submissions
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: HasPart

44NE(2) Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
note: Council must invite public submissions within specified timeframe.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44NE Council may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to invite public submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44NE(2) Council may invite public submissions

44NE(3) Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
note: Must consider submissions before specified day, may disregard late submissions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44NE Council may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Considered
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Submission made on or before specified day

44NE(4) Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
note: The Council may make any written submission publicly available.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44NE Council may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May make submissions publicly available.
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY

44NE(5) Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
note: Request for confidentiality of submission
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44NE Council may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Council may invite submission with confidentiality
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Request for permission
modality: Deontic
operator: request
premise text: Person may request

44NE(6) Council may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.192
note: Council must return written or oral submissions if requested
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ne-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44NE Council may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ne-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Mandatory action by Council
modality: Deontic
operator: Must

44NF Publication—Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.194
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44NF(1) Publication—Council
has part: 44NF(2) Publication—Council
has part: 44NF(3) Publication—Council
has part: 44NF(4) Publication—Council
has part: 44NF(5) Publication—Council
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nf
schema version: 2

44NF(1) Publication—Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.194
note: Council must publish a recommendation and its reasons.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nf-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44NF Publication—Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of recommendation and reasons
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44NF(2) Publication—Council
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.194
note: Council must provide a copy of publication to applicant and provider
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nf-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44NF Publication—Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44NF(3) Publication—Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.194
note: The Council must take action on a specific day.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nf-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44NF Publication—Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The action begins on the specified day
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes a temporal relationship
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BEGINS_ON
premise text: on the day the Commonwealth Minister publishes his or her decision or as soon as practicable after that day

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If there is consultation, then the Council must take action
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Describes a causal relationship
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: Consultation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Council must take action on the day the Commonwealth Minister publishes his or her decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must perform action
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The Council must do the things under subsections (1) and (2)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Council must take action on the specified day or shortly thereafter
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must perform action within a timeframe
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: on the day the Commonwealth Minister publishes his or her decision or as soon as practicable after that day

44NF(4) Publication—Council
type: Concept
description: Notice in writing, specifying what the Council is proposing to publish
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.194
note: Notice must be given to persons before publishing under subsection (1)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nf-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44NF Publication—Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by the Council
modality: Deontic
operator: PERMITS
premise text: The Council may give notice to persons before publishing

44NF(5) Publication—Council
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.194
note: The Council must consider submissions when deciding what to publish.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44nf-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44NF Publication—Council

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44nf-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44NG Publication—Commonwealth Minister
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.195
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44NG(1) Publication—Commonwealth Minister
has part: 44NG(2) Publication—Commonwealth Minister
has part: 44NG(3) Publication—Commonwealth Minister
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ng
schema version: 2

44NG(1) Publication—Commonwealth Minister
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.195
note: Publish decision and reasons on recommendation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ng-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44NG Publication—Commonwealth Minister

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish decision and reasons
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of publication
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44NG(2) Publication—Commonwealth Minister
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.195
note: Must provide a copy of the publication to specified parties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ng-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44NG Publication—Commonwealth Minister

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a copy of the publication.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST PROVIDE

44NG(3) Publication—Commonwealth Minister
type: Concept
description: (a) the applicant under section 44M or 44NA, or under section 44NBA; (b) the provider of the service; (c) any other person the Minister considers appropriate
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.195
note: Notice must be given to persons before publishing under subsection (1)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ng-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44NG Publication—Commonwealth Minister

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notice to persons before publishing
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) Before publishing under subsection (1), the Commonwealth Minister may give any one or more of the following persons:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ng-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May consider other person appropriate for notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY
premise text: (c) any other person the Minister considers appropriate; a notice in writing:

44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44O(1) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(1A) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(2) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(3) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(4) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(5) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(5A) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(5B) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(6) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
has part: 44O(7) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o
schema version: 2

44O(1) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Application for review of Commonwealth Minister's decision on access regime effectiveness
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44O(1) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44O(1A) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Right to review of Commonwealth Minister's decision under section 44NBC.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-diffusion-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review of Commonwealth Minister's decision under section 44NBC
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between recommendation and review
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
premise text: Recommendation under section 44NBA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review of Commonwealth Minister's decision under section 44NBC
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implication of recommendation on review
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: Recommendation under section 44NBA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review of Commonwealth Minister's decision
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Right to review
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Recommendation under section 44NBA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review of Commonwealth Minister's decision under section 44NBC
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Propagation of right to review
modality: Diffusion
operator: Propagation
premise text: Recommendation under section 44NBA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44O(1A) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44O(2) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be made before the deadline expires.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made before the deadline expires.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be made in writing.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made in writing.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST include required information.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must include required information.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An application for review MUST be submitted to the correct authority.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be submitted to the correct authority.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application for review MUST be made within 21 days after publication of the Commonwealth Minister’s decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44O(2) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44O(3) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Tribunal must reconsider ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The review by the Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter between the time limits that apply to the Tribunal’s decision on the review (see section 44ZZOA)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Time limits apply to Tribunal's decision
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: Section 44ZZOA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review by Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must reconsider decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The review by the Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter based on the information, reports and things referred to in section 44ZZOAA
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must have regard to specified information and reports
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The review by the Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter between the time limits that apply to the Tribunal’s decision on the review (see section 44ZZOA)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must make decision within time limits
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZZOA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44O(3) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44O(4) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: The Tribunal has the same powers as the Commonwealth Minister for review purposes.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same powers.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Same powers
modality: Deontic
operator: same
premise text: The Commonwealth Minister has powers.

44O(5) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Council must provide assistance for review purposes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to assist
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44O(5A) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Member may require Council to provide information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-5a
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: require

44O(5B) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: Tribunal must give a copy of notice to applicant and other parties, and publish the notice.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5b-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-5b
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must give a copy of notice to applicant and other parties.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-5b-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Notice is an instance of a document that can be published by the Tribunal.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: IS_A

44O(6) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: The Tribunal may affirm, vary or reverse the Commonwealth Minister's decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal may affirm the decision.
modality: Deontic
operator: MayAffirm

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal may vary the decision.
modality: Deontic
operator: MayVary

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-6-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal may reverse the decision.
modality: Deontic
operator: MayReverse

44O(7) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.196
note: A decision made by the Tribunal is to be taken as a Commonwealth Minister's decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44o-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44O Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The decision applies during that time.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Decision takes effect during specified period
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (7) A decision made by the Tribunal is to be taken to be a decision of the Commonwealth Minister for all purposes of this Part (except this section).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The decision supports the Minister's judgment.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Decision aids in making decisions
modality: CogAI
operator: for
premise text: (7) A decision made by the Tribunal is to be taken to be a decision of the Commonwealth Minister for all purposes of this Part (except this section).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The decision is binding on the Commonwealth Minister.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Decision takes effect for Commonwealth Minister
modality: Deontic
operator: takes
premise text: (7) A decision made by the Tribunal is to be taken to be a decision of the Commonwealth Minister for all purposes of this Part (except this section).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The decision influences the Minister's behavior.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Decision affects Commonwealth Minister's actions
modality: Diffusion
operator: for
premise text: (7) A decision made by the Tribunal is to be taken to be a decision of the Commonwealth Minister for all purposes of this Part (except this section).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The decision applies until that time.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Decision takes effect during specified period
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (7) A decision made by the Tribunal is to be taken to be a decision of the Commonwealth Minister for all purposes of this Part (except this section).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44o-ss-7-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44O(7) Review of Ministerial decision on effectiveness of access regime

44P State or Territory ceasing to be a party to Competition
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.197
note: Ceasing to be a party to Competition Principles Agreement
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44p-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44p-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44p
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44p-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prevents State or Territory from participating in Competition Principles Agreement
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

44PA Approval of competitive tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.199
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PA(1) Approval of competitive tender process
has part: 44PA(2) Approval of competitive tender process
has part: 44PA(3) Approval of competitive tender process
has part: 44PA(4) Approval of competitive tender process
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pa
schema version: 2

44PA(1) Approval of competitive tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.199
note: Approval of competitive tender process for facility ownership
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pa-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PA Approval of competitive tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to approve tender process
modality: Deontic
operator: May

44PA(2) Approval of competitive tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.199
note: Application must specify service and be in accordance with regulations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-diffusion-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-cogai-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pa-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PA Approval of competitive tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for application submission
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (2) The application must: (a) specify the service or services proposed to be provided by means of the facility; and (b) be in accordance with the regulations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-cogai-6
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Application is a key aspect of the process
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: (2) The application must: (a) specify the service or services proposed to be provided by means of the facility; and (b) be in accordance with the regulations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission's decision is binding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must comply with regulations
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The application must be in accordance with the regulations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Service specification is a key aspect of the application
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: IS_A
premise text: The application must specify the service or services proposed to be provided by means of the facility.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Application is a key aspect of the process
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: (2) The application must: (a) specify the service or services proposed to be provided by means of the facility; and (b) be in accordance with the regulations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal interval for Commission's decision
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (2) The application must: (a) specify the service or services proposed to be provided by means of the facility; and (b) be in accordance with the regulations.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PA(2) Approval of competitive tender process

44PA(3) Approval of competitive tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.199
note: The Commission must approve or refuse to approve a tender process as a competitive tender process.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pa-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44PA Approval of competitive tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission must approve or refuse to approve a tender process.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: The key is part of the section 44PA(3) provision.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: IS_A

44PA(4) Approval of competitive tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.199
note: Commission must not approve a tender process as competitive unless certain conditions are met.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pa-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44PA Approval of competitive tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must not approve a tender process as competitive unless it meets the requirements in Chapter 2 during its duration.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship between Commission's approval and tender process
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Chapter 2 Access to services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must not approve a tender process as competitive unless it meets the requirements in Chapter 2.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Relationship between Commission's approval and tender process
modality: CogAI
operator: if-and-only-if
premise text: Chapter 2 Access to services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must not approve a tender process as competitive unless certain conditions are met.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: Chapter 2 Access to services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must not approve a tender process as competitive unless it meets the requirements in Chapter 2.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Relationship between Commission's approval and tender process
modality: Diffusion
operator: if-and-only-if
premise text: Chapter 2 Access to services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pa-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must not approve a tender process as competitive unless it meets the requirements in Chapter 2 during its duration.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal relationship between Commission's approval and tender process
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: Chapter 2 Access to services

44PB Report on conduct of tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.201
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PB(1) Report on conduct of tender process
has part: 44PB(2) Report on conduct of tender process
has part: 44PB(3) Report on conduct of tender process
has part: 44PB(4) Report on conduct of tender process
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pb
schema version: 2

44PB(1) Report on conduct of tender process
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.201
note: Commission must ask tenderer to provide report on conduct of tender process after selection.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PB Report on conduct of tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide report
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PB(1) Report on conduct of tender process

44PB(2) Report on conduct of tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.201
note: Report must be in accordance with regulations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PB Report on conduct of tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must comply with regulations.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44PB(3) Report on conduct of tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.201
note: Commission may ask for further information from applicant
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pb-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44PB Report on conduct of tender process

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to request additional information
modality: Deontic
operator: May

44PB(4) Report on conduct of tender process
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.201
note: Report under subsection (1) is not a legislative instrument.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pb-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pb-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44PB Report on conduct of tender process

44PC Revocation of approval decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.201
note: Revocation of approval decision
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pc-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pc-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pc
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pc-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation of approval decision
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

44PD Time limit for Commission decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.203
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PD(1) Time limit for Commission decisions
has part: 44PD(2) Time limit for Commission decisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pd
schema version: 2

44PD(1) Time limit for Commission decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.203
note: Commission must make a decision within 90 days
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pd-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pd-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pd-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PD Time limit for Commission decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pd-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pd-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PD(1) Time limit for Commission decisions

44PD(2) Time limit for Commission decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.203
note: Disregard certain days when calculating the expected period for Commission decisions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pd-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pd-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PD Time limit for Commission decisions

44PE Commission may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.205
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PE(1) Commission may invite public submissions
has part: 44PE(2) Commission may invite public submissions
has part: 44PE(3) Commission may invite public submissions
has part: 44PE(4) Commission may invite public submissions
has part: 44PE(5) Commission may invite public submissions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pe
schema version: 2

44PE(1) Commission may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.205
note: Commission may invite public submissions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pe-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PE Commission may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May invite public submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Has part: Commission may publish a notice inviting public submissions
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: hasPart

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PE(1) Commission may invite public submissions

44PE(2) Commission may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.205
note: Public submissions must be made within a specified timeframe.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pe-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PE Commission may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions must be made within 14 days of publication.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Submissions must be made within a specified timeframe
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: The day by which submissions may be made (which must be at least 14 days after the day the notice is published).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submission process is described as a cognitive action.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Describes submission process as a cognitive action
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: The notice must specify how submissions may be made and the day by which submissions may be made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions must be made within a specified timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide public submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The notice must specify how submissions may be made and the day by which submissions may be made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submission process is described as a diffusion.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Describes submission process as a diffusion
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: The notice must specify how submissions may be made and the day by which submissions may be made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions are recurring and traceable within a specified timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Submissions are recurring and traceable
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: The day by which submissions may be made (which must be at least 14 days after the day the notice is published).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PE(2) Commission may invite public submissions

44PE(3) Commission may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.205
note: Must consider submissions made on or before specified day
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pe-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44PE Commission may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must have regard to submission
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Submission made on or before specified day

44PE(4) Commission may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.205
note: The Commission must make written submissions publicly available.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pe-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44PE Commission may invite public submissions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44PE(5) Commission may invite public submissions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.205
note: Request for public submissions at Commission invitation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pe-ss-5-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pe-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44PE Commission may invite public submissions

44PF Commission must publish its decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.206
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PF(1) Commission must publish its decisions
has part: 44PF(2) Commission must publish its decisions
has part: 44PF(3) Commission must publish its decisions
has part: 44PF(4) Commission must publish its decisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pf
schema version: 2

44PF(1) Commission must publish its decisions
type: Concept
description: Decision and reasons for the decision
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.206
note: Commission must publish its decisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pf-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PF Commission must publish its decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of decisions
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44PF(2) Commission must publish its decisions
type: Concept
description: yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.206
note: Commission must provide a copy of the publication to certain persons.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pf-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PF Commission must publish its decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Conditional provision based on specific decisions.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTINGENT ON
premise text: (2) The Commission must give a copy of the publication to: (a) for any decision—the applicant under subsection 44PA(1); and (b) for a decision under subsection 44PC(2)—the provider of the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a copy of the publication.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST PROVIDE

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May also provide a copy to other persons.
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY ALSO PROVIDE
premise text: It may also give a copy to any other person the Commission considers appropriate.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a copy of the publication.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST PROVIDE
premise text: (2) The Commission must give a copy of the publication to: (a) for any decision—the applicant under subsection 44PA(1); and (b) for a decision under subsection 44PC(2)—the provider of the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Conditional provision based on specific decisions.
modality: LTL
operator: CONTINGENT ON
premise text: (2) The Commission must give a copy of the publication to: (a) for any decision—the applicant under subsection 44PA(1); and (b) for a decision under subsection 44PC(2)—the provider of the service.

44PF(3) Commission must publish its decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.206
note: Commission must give notice to certain persons before publishing decisions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pf-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44PF Commission must publish its decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines time frame for submission
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (d) inviting the person to make a written submission to the Commission within 14 days after the notice is given

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide written submission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (d) inviting the person to make a written submission to the Commission within 14 days after the notice is given

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Combines multiple obligations
modality: LinearLogic
operator: AND
premise text: (a) for any decision—the applicant under subsection 44PA(1) or any other person the Commission considers appropriate; (c) specifying what the Commission is proposing to publish; and (d) inviting the person to make a written submission to the Commission within 14 days after the notice is given

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PF(3) Commission must publish its decisions

44PF(4) Commission must publish its decisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.206
note: Commission must consider submissions when deciding what to publish.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pf-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44PF Commission must publish its decisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pf-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider submissions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44PG Review of Commission’s initial decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.207
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PG(1) Review of Commission’s initial decision
has part: 44PG(2) Review of Commission’s initial decision
has part: 44PG(3) Review of Commission’s initial decision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pg
schema version: 2

44PG(1) Review of Commission’s initial decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.207
note: A person may apply in writing to the Tribunal for review of a Commission's decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pg-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PG Review of Commission’s initial decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Expresses a temporal relationship between events.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Between

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: States a claim that must be supported.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Claim

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses permission or obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: States a person's knowledge of the situation.
modality: Epistemic
operator: Knowledge

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Expresses a condition that must be met for an action to be valid.
modality: LTL
operator: Until

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PG(1) Review of Commission’s initial decision

44PG(2) Review of Commission’s initial decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.207
note: Must apply for review within 21 days after Commission publishes decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pg-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PG Review of Commission’s initial decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: within 21 days after the Commission publishes its decision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must apply for review within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The person must apply for review.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PG(2) Review of Commission’s initial decision

44PG(3) Review of Commission’s initial decision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.207
note: Tribunal must reconsider initial decision based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44pg-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44PG Review of Commission’s initial decision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Tribunal’s decision on the review is subject to time limits.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Tribunal's decision has time limits.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: Section 44ZZOA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review by Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter based on specified information and reports, which relates to access to services and involves artificial intelligence.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Review involves artificial intelligence.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review by Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must reconsider initial decision.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review by Tribunal is a reconsideration of the matter based on specified information and reports, which relates to access to services.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Review is related to access to services.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: Chapter 2 Access to services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Tribunal’s decision on the review is subject to time limits.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Tribunal's decision has a temporal interval.
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: Section 44ZZOA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44pg-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PG(3) Review of Commission’s initial decision

44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44PH(1) Review of decision to revoke an approval
has part: 44PH(2) Review of decision to revoke an approval
has part: 44PH(3) Review of decision to revoke an approval
has part: 44PH(4) Review of decision to revoke an approval
has part: 44PH(5) Review of decision to revoke an approval
has part: 44PH(5A) Review of decision to revoke an approval
has part: 44PH(5B) Review of decision to revoke an approval
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph
schema version: 2

44PH(1) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: Application for review of decision to revoke an approval
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PH(1) Review of decision to revoke an approval

44PH(2) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: Must apply for review within 21 days after Commission publishes decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must apply for review within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PH(2) Review of decision to revoke an approval

44PH(3) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: Reconsideration of decision to revoke an approval based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

44PH(4) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: Tribunal has same powers as Commission for review purposes.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal has the same powers as Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: has

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44PH(4) Review of decision to revoke an approval

44PH(5) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: The Commission must provide assistance for the purposes of the review.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide assistance
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44PH(5A) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: Member may require Commission to provide information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-5a
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: require

44PH(5B) Review of decision to revoke an approval
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.209
note: The Tribunal must review a decision to revoke an approval.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ph-ss-5b
schema version: 2
part of: 44PH Review of decision to revoke an approval

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ph-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses a duty
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44Q Register of decisions, declarations and ineligibility decisions
type: Concept
description: Register of decisions, declarations and ineligibility decisions
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.211
note: Maintain a public register of decisions, declarations and ineligibility decisions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44q-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44q-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44q-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44q
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44q-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must maintain a public register
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44q-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classify decisions, declarations and ineligibility decisions
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

44R Constitutional limits on operation of this Division
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.212
note: Restricts access to services by third parties under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44r-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44r-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44r
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44r-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: None
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits access to services by third parties under certain conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: None

44S Notification of access disputes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.212
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44S(1) Notification of access disputes
has part: 44S(2) Notification of access disputes
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44s
schema version: 2

44S(1) Notification of access disputes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.212
note: Notification of access disputes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44s-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44S Notification of access disputes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to notify Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44S(1) Notification of access disputes

44S(2) Notification of access disputes
type: Concept
description: Notice in writing
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.212
note: Must notify access dispute parties
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44s-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44S Notification of access disputes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44s-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to notify
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44T Withdrawal of notifications
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.213
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44T(1) Withdrawal of notifications
has part: 44T(2) Withdrawal of notifications
has part: 44T(3) Withdrawal of notifications
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44t
schema version: 2

44T(1) Withdrawal of notifications
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.213
note: Withdrawal of notifications
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44t-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44T Withdrawal of notifications

44T(2) Withdrawal of notifications
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.213
note: Third party cannot withdraw provider's notification despite dispute over variation of final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44t-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44T Withdrawal of notifications

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Withdrawal prohibited during dispute period.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: During
premise text: (2) Despite subparagraph (1)(a)(ii), if the provider notified a dispute over variation of a final determination, the third party may not withdraw the provider’s notification.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Prohibits withdrawal of notification despite dispute.
modality: CogAI
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) Despite subparagraph (1)(a)(ii), if the provider notified a dispute over variation of a final determination, the third party may not withdraw the provider’s notification.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits withdrawal of notification despite dispute.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) Despite subparagraph (1)(a)(ii), if the provider notified a dispute over variation of a final determination, the third party may not withdraw the provider’s notification.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Prohibits withdrawal of notification despite dispute.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) Despite subparagraph (1)(a)(ii), if the provider notified a dispute over variation of a final determination, the third party may not withdraw the provider’s notification.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Prohibits withdrawal of notification despite dispute.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) Despite subparagraph (1)(a)(ii), if the provider notified a dispute over variation of a final determination, the third party may not withdraw the provider’s notification.

44T(3) Withdrawal of notifications
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.213
note: Notification withdrawal obligation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44t-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44T Withdrawal of notifications

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44t-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to treat notification as never given
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (3) If the notification is withdrawn, it is taken for the purposes of this Part never to have been given.

44U Parties to the arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.213
note: List of parties to arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44u-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44u
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44u-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44U Parties to the arbitration

44V Determination by Commission
type: Concept
description: Written final determination
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.213
note: Must make written final determination unless terminating arbitration under specified sections.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44v-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44v-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44v
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44v-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must make written final determination
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44W Restrictions on access determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.215
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44W(1) Restrictions on access determinations
has part: 44W(2) Restrictions on access determinations
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44w
schema version: 2

44W(1) Restrictions on access determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.215
note: The Commission must not make a determination that would have certain effects.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44w-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44W Restrictions on access determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Prohibition with temporal scope.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Prohibition
premise text: (f) requiring the provider to bear some or all of the costs of interconnections to the facility or maintaining interconnections to the facility.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implications of prohibited actions.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: (d) resulting in the third party becoming the owner (or one of the owners) of any part of the facility, or of extensions of the facility,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Causal links between prohibited actions.
modality: CogAI
operator: Causal Link
premise text: (c) depriving any person of a protected contractual right;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of certain actions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) The Commission must not make a determination that would have any of the following effects:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion of prohibited actions.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
premise text: (e) requiring the provider to bear some or all of the costs of extending the facility (including expanding the capacity of the facility and expanding the geographical reach of the facility);

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44W(1) Restrictions on access determinations

44W(2) Restrictions on access determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.215
note: Exempts arbitration from applying certain paragraphs in access disputes.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44w-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44W Restrictions on access determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exempts arbitration from applying certain paragraphs.
modality: Deontic
operator: Exemption
premise text: (2) Paragraphs (1)(a) and (b) do not apply in relation to the requirements and rights of the third party and the provider when the Commission is making a determination in arbitration of an access dispute relating to an earlier determination of an access dispute between the third party and the provider.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44w-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44W(2) Restrictions on access determinations

44X Matters that the Commission must take into account
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.217
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44X(1) Matters that the Commission must take into account
has part: 44X(2) Matters that the Commission must take into account
has part: 44X(3) Matters that the Commission must take into account
has part: 44X(4) Matters that the Commission must take into account
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44x
schema version: 2

44X(1) Matters that the Commission must take into account
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.217
note: The Commission must take certain matters into account when making a final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44x-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44X Matters that the Commission must take into account

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission must take certain matters into account.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44X(1) Matters that the Commission must take into account

44X(2) Matters that the Commission must take into account
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.217
note: Commission may consider additional relevant matters.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44x-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44X Matters that the Commission must take into account

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...take into account...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Authority to consider additional matters
modality: Deontic
operator: can
premise text: The Commission may...

44X(3) Matters that the Commission must take into account
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.217
note: Matters that the Commission must take into account
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44x-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44X Matters that the Commission must take into account

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission's obligation to consider matters
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) The Commission may take the following matters into account...

44X(4) Matters that the Commission must take into account
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.217
note: Duty to consider matter in making interim determination
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44x-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44X Matters that the Commission must take into account

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission MUST consider the matter.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider matter
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (4) In making an interim determination, the Commission does not have a duty to consider whether to take into account a matter referred to in subsection (1).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission MUST NOT consider the matter.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must not consider matter in making interim determination
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST NOT
premise text: (4) In making an interim determination, the Commission does not have a duty to consider whether to take into account a matter referred to in subsection (1).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If the Commission has a duty to consider the matter, then the Commission MUST consider the matter.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Duty to consider matter implies consideration of matter
modality: LinearLogic
operator: ⇒
premise text: (4) In making an interim determination, the Commission does not have a duty to consider whether to take into account a matter referred to in subsection (1).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44x-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If the Commission does NOT consider the matter, then the Commission MUST NOT consider the matter.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Not considering matter implies duty not to consider matter
modality: LinearLogic
operator: ⇒
premise text: (4) In making an interim determination, the Commission does not have a duty to consider whether to take into account a matter referred to in subsection (1).

44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44XA(1) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
has part: 44XA(2) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
has part: 44XA(3) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
has part: 44XA(4) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
has part: 44XA(5) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
has part: 44XA(6) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa
schema version: 2

44XA(1) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
note: Commission must make a final determination within 180 days
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a final determination
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44XA(1) Time limit for Commission’s final determination

44XA(2) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
note: Disregard certain days when working out the expected period for a final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval relation
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Disregard certain days when working out the expected period for a final determination.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44XA(2) Time limit for Commission’s final determination

44XA(3) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
note: Do not disregard any day more than once.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on disregarding days
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44XA(3) Time limit for Commission’s final determination

44XA(4) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
note: Agreement on time limit for Commission's final determination
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination

44XA(5) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
note: Commission must publish agreement by a certain time.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-5-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish agreement
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-5-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of Commission's final determination
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: CLASSIFICATION

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44XA(5) Time limit for Commission’s final determination

44XA(6) Time limit for Commission’s final determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.218
note: Commission's final determination if report not published on time
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44xa-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44XA Time limit for Commission’s final determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44xa-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission makes final determination
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: if-then
premise text: Commission publishes report on time

44Y Commission may terminate arbitration in certain cases
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.219
note: Commission may terminate arbitration under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44y-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44y
schema version: 2

44YA Commission must terminate arbitration if declaration varied
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.220
note: Must terminate arbitration if declaration varied
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ya-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ya-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ya
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ya-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Commission must terminate arbitration
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to terminate arbitration
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44K declaration varied

44Z Constitution of Commission for conduct of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.220
note: Commission constitution for arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44z-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44z-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44z
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44z-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Chairperson nomination
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishes Commission composition
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable
premise text: 2 or more members

44ZA Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.220
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZA(1) Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration
has part: 44ZA(2) Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44za
schema version: 2

44ZA(1) Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.220
note: Chairperson must preside at an arbitration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44za-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZA Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZA(1) Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration

44ZA(2) Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.220
note: Chairperson must nominate a member of the Commission to preside at an arbitration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44za-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZA Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Chairperson must nominate a member of the Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44za-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZA(2) Member of the Commission presiding at an arbitration

44ZB Reconstitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.221
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZB(1) Reconstitution of Commission
has part: 44ZB(2) Reconstitution of Commission
has part: 44ZB(3) Reconstitution of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zb
schema version: 2

44ZB(1) Reconstitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.221
note: Member must be available for arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZB Reconstitution of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member's unavailability affects their ability to participate in the arbitration.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Member must be available for arbitration within a certain time frame
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (b) for any reason, is not available for the purpose of the arbitration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member must be available for the purpose of the arbitration.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be a member of the Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) This section applies if a member of the Commission...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member's unavailability affects their ability to participate in the arbitration.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member must be one of the members who constitute the Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (b) for any reason, is not available for the purpose of the arbitration.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The member's absence affects their ability to participate in the arbitration.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member must be a member of the Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (a) stops being a member of the Commission;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZB(1) Reconstitution of Commission

44ZB(2) Reconstitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.221
note: Chairperson must direct Commission reconstitution.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZB Reconstitution of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Directing is a duty.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44ZB(3) Reconstitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.221
note: Commission must continue and finish arbitration upon direction.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zb-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZB Reconstitution of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zb-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must continue and finish arbitration.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) If a direction under subsection (2) is given...

44ZC Determination of questions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.221
note: The Commission must decide questions according to the opinion of the majority of its members.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zc-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zc-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zc
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zc-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission must decide questions.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44ZD Hearing to be in private
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.221
note: Arbitration hearing must be in private
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zd-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zd-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zd
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zd-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide private arbitration hearing
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) Subject to subsection (2), an arbitration hearing for an access dispute is to be in private.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zd-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZD Hearing to be in private

44ZE Right to representation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.222
note: Party may appear in person or be represented by someone else.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ze-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ze-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44ze
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ze-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Right to representation
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44ze-norm
type: Right
scope note: held by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
held by: NaturalPerson
part of: 44ZE Right to representation

44ZF Procedure of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.222
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZF(1) Procedure of Commission
has part: 44ZF(2) Procedure of Commission
has part: 44ZF(3) Procedure of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zf
schema version: 2

44ZF(1) Procedure of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.222
note: Commission must act speedily in arbitration hearing about access dispute.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zf-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZF Procedure of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission MUST act speedily within a reasonable timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Commission must act speedily within a reasonable timeframe.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: There is no specific time limit for the Commission's action.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If the Commission acts speedily, then it implies a fair settlement of the dispute.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Commission's speediness implies fairness in settlement of dispute.
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: The Commission's action is related to the settlement of the dispute.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission's speediness IS A part of its ability to inform itself.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Commission's speediness relates to its ability to inform itself.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS A
premise text: The Commission has the ability to inform itself.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission MUST act speedily.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission must act speedily.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The Commission has a duty to act speedily.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commission's speediness IS A part of the investigation and inquiry process.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Commission's speediness affects the investigation and inquiry process.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS A
premise text: The Commission's action is related to the investigation and inquiry process.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZF(1) Procedure of Commission

44ZF(2) Procedure of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.222
note: Determine periods for fair presentation of cases in access disputes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zf-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZF Procedure of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission may determine periods
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44ZF(3) Procedure of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.222
note: The Commission may require evidence or argument to be presented in writing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zf-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZF Procedure of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zf-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission may require evidence or argument.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44ZG Particular powers of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZG(1) Particular powers of Commission
has part: 44ZG(2) Particular powers of Commission
has part: 44ZG(3) Particular powers of Commission
has part: 44ZG(4) Particular powers of Commission
has part: 44ZG(5) Particular powers of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zg
schema version: 2

44ZG(1) Particular powers of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
note: The Commission may perform certain actions during an arbitration hearing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zg-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZG Particular powers of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The actions occur during an arbitration hearing.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission can give directions.
modality: Deontic
operator: can

44ZG(2) Particular powers of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
note: Prohibition on contempt of court in arbitration of access disputes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zg-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZG Particular powers of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No contempt of court in arbitration
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on contempt of court
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: Commission is a court of record

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZG(2) Particular powers of Commission

44ZG(3) Particular powers of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
note: Provision subject to other regulations and regulations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zg-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZG Particular powers of Commission

44ZG(4) Particular powers of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
note: Commission may give permission to a person to divulge information.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zg-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZG Particular powers of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission
modality: Deontic
operator: PERM

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-4-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZG(4) Particular powers of Commission

44ZG(5) Particular powers of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
note: Offence for contravening an order under subsection (4)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zg-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZG Particular powers of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...for a term not exceeding 6 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines the temporal interval for the offence
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (5) A person who contravenes an order under subsection (4) is guilty of an offence, punishable on conviction by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...guilty of an offence, punishable on conviction by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classifies the contravening of an order under subsection (4) as an offence using CogAI
modality: CogAI
operator: Classification
premise text: (5) A person who contravenes an order under subsection (4) is guilty of an offence, punishable on conviction by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...punishable on conviction by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits contravening an order under subsection (4)
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: (5) A person who contravenes an order under subsection (4) is guilty of an offence...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...for a term not exceeding 6 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses the prohibition to all agents
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffusion
premise text: (5) A person who contravenes an order under subsection (4) is guilty of an offence, punishable on conviction by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...for a term not exceeding 6 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Defines the recurring trace for the offence
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
premise text: (5) A person who contravenes an order under subsection (4) is guilty of an offence, punishable on conviction by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zg-ss-5-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZG(5) Particular powers of Commission

44ZH Power to take evidence on oath or affirmation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.223
note: Commission may take evidence on oath or affirmation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zh-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zh-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zh
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zh-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission has obligation to take evidence on oath or affirmation.
modality: Deontic
operator: hasObligation

44ZI Failing to attend as a witness
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.224
note: Failing to attend as a witness without reasonable excuse is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-alleninterval-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zi
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A temporal interval is specified for attending.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for attending as a witness
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: The provision specifies a temporal interval for attending.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Failing to attend without excuse is prohibited.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of failing to attend as a witness
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: A person who is served with a summons must attend.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Imprisonment is prescribed for failing to attend.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imprisonment for failure to attend as a witness
modality: Deontic
operator: Imprisonment
premise text: The provision prescribes imprisonment for failing to attend.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Attending implies compliance.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implication of attending as a witness
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Implication
premise text: Attending as a witness implies compliance with the provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zi-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZI Failing to attend as a witness

44ZJ Failing to answer questions etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.224
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZJ(1) Failing to answer questions etc.
has part: 44ZJ(2) Failing to answer questions etc.
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zj
schema version: 2

44ZJ(1) Failing to answer questions etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.224
note: Refusal to answer questions or produce documents without reasonable excuse is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zj-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZJ Failing to answer questions etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...Penalty: Imprisonment for 6 months.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of refusing to answer questions or produce documents.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A person appearing as a witness before the Commission must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZJ(1) Failing to answer questions etc.

44ZJ(2) Failing to answer questions etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.224
note: Refusal or failure to answer questions under certain circumstances is a reasonable excuse.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zj-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZJ Failing to answer questions etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Refusal or failure to answer questions under certain circumstances is a reasonable excuse.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to answer questions under certain circumstances.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Subsection (1) does not limit what is a reasonable excuse for the purposes of subsection (1).

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zj-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZJ(2) Failing to answer questions etc.

44ZK Intimidation etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.225
note: Threatening or coercing someone due to producing documents before the Commission is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zk
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision applies to actions of producing documents before the Commission
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Prohibition applies when producing documents before the Commission
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: Producing documents before the Commission is a relevant action

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision is violated when threatening or coercing
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Threatening or coercing implies a violation of this provision
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: Threatening or coercing is generally considered wrong

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: There is no cognitive AI logic for this provision
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: No cognitive AI logic applies to this provision
modality: CogAI
operator: None
premise text: This provision does not require human-like reasoning

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision prohibits threatening or coercing
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits threatening or coercing someone
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: Threatening or coercing is generally considered wrong

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: There is no diffusion logic for this provision
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: No diffusion logic applies to this provision
modality: Diffusion
operator: None
premise text: This provision does not affect the behavior of others

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zk-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZK Intimidation etc.

44ZL Party may request Commission to treat material as
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.225
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZL(1) Party may request Commission to treat material as
has part: 44ZL(2) Party may request Commission to treat material as
has part: 44ZL(3) Party may request Commission to treat material as
has part: 44ZL(4) Party may request Commission to treat material as
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zl
schema version: 2

44ZL(1) Party may request Commission to treat material as
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.225
note: Request for Commission not to disclose confidential information
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zl-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZL Party may request Commission to treat material as

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Granting permission
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit
premise text: (1) A party to an arbitration hearing may:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Request to prevent disclosure
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (b) request the Commission not to give a copy of that part to another party.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-1-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZL(1) Party may request Commission to treat material as

44ZL(2) Party may request Commission to treat material as
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.225
note: Commission must inform and ask for objection on request
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zl-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZL Party may request Commission to treat material as

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must inform and ask for objection
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZL(2) Party may request Commission to treat material as

44ZL(3) Party may request Commission to treat material as
type: Concept
description: objection and reasons
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.225
note: Party must inform Commission of objection and reasons.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zl-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZL Party may request Commission to treat material as

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must inform Commission of objection and reasons.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZL(3) Party may request Commission to treat material as

44ZL(4) Party may request Commission to treat material as
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.225
note: Commission must consider a request and any objection before treating material as such.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zl-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZL Party may request Commission to treat material as

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: REQUEST MUST BE CONSIDERED BEFORE TREATING MATERIAL AS SUCH.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Request must be considered before treating material as such.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (4) After considering: (a) a request; and (b) any objection;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: REQUEST IS AN OBJECT THAT MUST BE CONSIDERED.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Request is an object that must be considered.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS-A
premise text: (4) After considering: (a) a request; and (b) any objection;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: TREAT MATERIAL AS SUCH.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider a request and any objection.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (4) After considering: (a) a request; and (b) any objection;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: REQUEST IS AN OBJECT THAT MUST BE CONSIDERED.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Request is an object that must be considered.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS-A
premise text: (4) After considering: (a) a request; and (b) any objection;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: REQUEST MUST BE CONSIDERED BEFORE TREATING MATERIAL AS SUCH.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Request must be considered before treating material as such.
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: (4) After considering: (a) a request; and (b) any objection;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zl-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZL(4) Party may request Commission to treat material as

44ZM Sections 18 and 19 do not apply to the Commission in an
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Sections 18 and 19 do not apply to the Commission in an arbitration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zm-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zm-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zm
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zm-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Sections 18 and 19 do not apply to the Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: does not apply

44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZN(1) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(2) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(3) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(4) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(5) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(6) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(7) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
has part: 44ZN(8) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn
schema version: 2

44ZN(1) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Commission may hold joint arbitration hearing for common disputes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZN(2) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Chairperson may do so only if he or she considers this would likely result in the nominated disputes being resolved in a more efficient and timely manner.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Chairperson has the power to decide
modality: Deontic
operator: MAY

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZN(2) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZN(3) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
description: written submission within 14 days
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Chairperson must give notice to parties before doing something
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to provide notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZN(3) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZN(4) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Must consider submissions when deciding whether to do so.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions considered during decision-making.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between submissions and decisions
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Chairperson must have regard to submissions so made in deciding whether to do so.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions considered relevant to decision-making.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Reasoning for consideration of submissions
modality: Argumentation
operator: consider
premise text: Chairperson must have regard to any submission so made in deciding whether to do so.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Submissions inferred relevant to decision-making.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Inference of relevance from submissions
modality: CogAI
operator: infer
premise text: Chairperson must have regard to any submission so made in deciding whether to do so.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Must consider submissions when deciding whether to do so.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Chairperson must have regard to submissions.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Other matters considered relevant to decision-making.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Spread of consideration to other matters
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuse
premise text: Chairperson may have regard to any other matter he or she considers relevant.

44ZN(5) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Chairperson may give written directions to Commission member
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZN(5) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZN(6) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Joint arbitration hearing occurs after nomination
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval between nomination and joint arbitration hearing
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
premise text: Nomination must occur before joint arbitration hearing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Members nominated
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires the Chairperson to nominate members
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: Chairperson must nominate members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZN(6) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZN(7) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Commission may consider records of arbitration proceedings
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-7-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-7-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZN(7) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZN(8) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.226
note: Commission must have regard to joint arbitration hearing records
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zn-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZN Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission's duty
modality: Deontic
operator: mustHaveRegardTo

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zn-ss-8-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZN(8) Parties to pay costs of an arbitration

44ZO Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZO(1) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(2) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(3) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(4) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(5) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(6) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(7) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(8) Operation of final determinations
has part: 44ZO(9) Operation of final determinations
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo
schema version: 2

44ZO(1) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Interim determination takes effect on specified day. Determination has effect after 21 days if no review is applied.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

44ZO(2) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Determination is of no effect until review by Tribunal. Continuation of interim determination until earliest of two events
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Determination is of no effect.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The review process overlaps with the original determination.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: Party applies for review.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Determination is of no effect.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If a party applies for review, the determination is of no effect.
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: Party applies for review.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZO(2) Operation of final determinations

44ZO(3) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Provisions of a final determination may be expressed to apply from an earlier date.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

44ZO(4) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Cannot be earlier than specified day
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: cannot
premise text: (4) The specified day must not be earlier than the following day:

44ZO(5) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Final determination prevails over interim determination to the extent set out in the final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The provision applies during the time period specified by the final determination.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Provision applies during the time period specified by the final determination.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (5) If a provision of a final determination is expressed to apply from a day when an interim determination was in effect, the provision of the final determination prevails over the interim determination to the extent set out in the final determination.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The provision is executed during the time period specified by the final determination.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Provision is executed during the time period specified by the final determination.
modality: CogAI
operator: during
premise text: (5) If a provision of a final determination is expressed to apply from a day when an interim determination was in effect, the provision of the final determination prevails over the interim determination to the extent set out in the final determination.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The final determination prevails over the interim determination.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to prioritize final determination over interim determination.
modality: Deontic
operator: prevails
premise text: (5) If a provision of a final determination is expressed to apply from a day when an interim determination was in effect, the provision of the final determination prevails over the interim determination to the extent set out in the final determination.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The provision spreads or propagates during the time period specified by the final determination.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Provision spreads or propagates during the time period specified by the final determination.
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (5) If a provision of a final determination is expressed to apply from a day when an interim determination was in effect, the provision of the final determination prevails over the interim determination to the extent set out in the final determination.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The provision is true during the time period specified by the final determination.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Provision is true during the time period specified by the final determination.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (5) If a provision of a final determination is expressed to apply from a day when an interim determination was in effect, the provision of the final determination prevails over the interim determination to the extent set out in the final determination.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZO(5) Operation of final determinations

44ZO(6) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: First party must pay interest to other party.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to pay interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZO(6) Operation of final determinations

44ZO(7) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Commission must consider guidelines and other relevant matters when exercising power.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-7-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

44ZO(8) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Commission must determine guidelines by legislative instrument.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-8-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

44ZO(9) Operation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.230
note: Commission must make guidelines within 6 months after subsection commencement.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-9-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zo-ss-9
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZO Operation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zo-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must take reasonable steps
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44ZP Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZP(1) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(2) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(3) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(4) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(5) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(5A) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(5B) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(6) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(7) Review by Tribunal
has part: 44ZP(8) Review by Tribunal
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp
schema version: 2

44ZP(1) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: Party may apply for review of final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses a permission or obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

44ZP(2) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: Application must be made within 21 days after Commission's final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within a specified timeframe.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) The application must be made within 21 days after the Commission made the final determination.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZP(2) Review by Tribunal

44ZP(3) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: A review by the Tribunal is a re-arbitration of the access dispute.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Review by Tribunal
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a re-arbitration of the access dispute.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZZOAA

44ZP(4) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: The Tribunal has the same powers as the Commission for review purposes.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same powers.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Same powers
modality: Deontic
operator: same
premise text: The Commission has powers.

44ZP(5) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: The Commission must provide assistance for the purposes of the review.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission must provide assistance.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST PROVIDE

44ZP(5A) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: Commission must provide information and reports upon request from Member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-5a
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member requires Commission to provide information and reports.
modality: Deontic
operator: Require

44ZP(5B) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: The Tribunal must give a copy of the notice to certain parties and publish it.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5b-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-5b
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Tribunal must give a copy of the notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-5b-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: The notice is a subclass of documents that must be given to certain parties.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: SUBCLASSOF

44ZP(6) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: The Tribunal may affirm or vary the Commission's determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Affirmation is permitted.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44ZP(7) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: Tribunal's determination is binding on the Commission for all purposes of this Part (except this section).
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The determination is binding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-7-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZP(7) Review by Tribunal

44ZP(8) Review by Tribunal
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.232
note: Decision takes effect immediately upon making.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zp-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZP Review by Tribunal

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zp-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The decision takes effect immediately upon making.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Immediate effect
modality: Deontic
operator: takes effect
premise text: (8) The decision of the Tribunal takes effect from when it is made.

44ZQ Provisions that do not apply in relation to a Tribunal review
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.233
note: Sections 37-43 and 103-110 do not apply to Tribunal reviews.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zq-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zq-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zq
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zq-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Excluded from review
modality: Deontic
operator: Exclusion

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zq-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZQ Provisions that do not apply in relation to a Tribunal review

44ZR Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.233
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZR(1) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
has part: 44ZR(2) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
has part: 44ZR(3) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
has part: 44ZR(4) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zr
schema version: 2

44ZR(1) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.233
note: Party may appeal to Federal Court on a question of law from Tribunal decision under section 44ZP.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zr-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZR Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Party has the right to appeal
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZR(1) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the

44ZR(2) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.233
note: Appeal must be instituted within a specified time frame.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zr-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZR Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide appeal within the specified time frame.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZR(2) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the

44ZR(3) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.233
note: Must hear and determine appeal
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zr-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZR Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for hearing and determining appeal
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Must hear and determine appeal
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to act
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44ZR(4) Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.233
note: Orders that may be made by the Federal Court on appeal
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zr-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZR Appeals to Federal Court from determinations of the

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Appeal occurs during Chapter 2 Access to services
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (4) The orders that may be made by the Federal Court on appeal...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zr-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: List of possible orders
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: (4) The orders that may be made by the Federal Court on appeal...

44ZS Operation and implementation of a determination that is
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.234
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZS(1) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
has part: 44ZS(2) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
has part: 44ZS(3) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
has part: 44ZS(4) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zs
schema version: 2

44ZS(1) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.234
note: Continues operation despite appeal
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zs-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZS Operation and implementation of a determination that is

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Continues the effect of a decision
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTINUES
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, the fact that an appeal is instituted in the Federal Court from a decision of the Tribunal does not affect the operation of the decision or prevent action being taken to implement the decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Continues the effect of a decision
modality: Deontic
operator: CONTINUES
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, the fact that an appeal is instituted in the Federal Court from a decision of the Tribunal does not affect the operation of the decision or prevent action being taken to implement the decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Contains an exception for appeals
modality: Deontic
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, the fact that an appeal is instituted in the Federal Court from a decision of the Tribunal does not affect the operation of the decision or prevent action being taken to implement the decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Continues the effect of a decision
modality: LTL
operator: CONTINUES
premise text: (1) Subject to this section, the fact that an appeal is instituted in the Federal Court from a decision of the Tribunal does not affect the operation of the decision or prevent action being taken to implement the decision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZS(1) Operation and implementation of a determination that is

44ZS(2) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.234
note: Orders may be made to stay or affect the operation of a Tribunal's decision during an appeal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zs-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZS Operation and implementation of a determination that is

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies permission or obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44ZS(3) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.234
note: May vary or revoke an existing order
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zs-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZS Operation and implementation of a determination that is

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permissive obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

44ZS(4) Operation and implementation of a determination that is
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.234
note: Order subject to conditions and has effect until appeal decision or specified period end.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zs-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZS Operation and implementation of a determination that is

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zs-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits actions subject to conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

44ZT Transmission of documents
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.234
note: Transmission of documents in Federal Court proceedings
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zt-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zt
schema version: 2

44ZU Variation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.235
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZU(1) Variation of final determinations
has part: 44ZU(2) Variation of final determinations
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zu
schema version: 2

44ZU(1) Variation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.235
note: Commission may vary or revoke interim determinations by writing. Commission may vary final determination on application of any party.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zu-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZU Variation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Commission has the power to vary or revoke interim determinations.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZU(1) Variation of final determinations

44ZU(2) Variation of final determinations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.235
note: Commission must revoke interim determination upon request from parties. Notify access dispute when applying for variation of final determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zu-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZU Variation of final determinations

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Access dispute notified within temporal interval of application.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval of notification
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: Notification made when application was made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide revocation upon request.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Variation under section applies as if access dispute notified.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Notification obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: NOTIFY
premise text: Access dispute notified when application made.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zu-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZU(2) Variation of final determinations

44ZV Constitutional limits on operation of this Division
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
note: Contract exemption based on declaration of service and conditions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zv-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zv-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zv
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zv-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Multiple conditions for exemption
modality: Deontic
operator: and

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zv-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZV Constitutional limits on operation of this Division

44ZW Registration of contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZW(1) Registration of contract
has part: 44ZW(2) Registration of contract
has part: 44ZW(2A) Registration of contract
has part: 44ZW(3) Registration of contract
has part: 44ZW(4) Registration of contract
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zw
schema version: 2

44ZW(1) Registration of contract
type: Concept
description: (i) the names of the parties to the contract; (ii) the service to which the contract relates; (iii) the date on which the contract was made;
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
note: Registration of contract obligation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zw-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZW Registration of contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for contract registration.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (i) the names of the parties to the contract; (ii) the service to which the contract relates; (iii) the date on which the contract was made;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Artificial intelligence in contract registration.
modality: CogAI
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (i) the names of the parties to the contract; (ii) the service to which the contract relates; (iii) the date on which the contract was made;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Contract registration is mandatory.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) On application by all the parties to a contract, the Commission MUST:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion of information for contract registration.
modality: Diffusion
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (i) the names of the parties to the contract; (ii) the service to which the contract relates; (iii) the date on which the contract was made;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal interval for contract registration.
modality: LTL
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (i) the names of the parties to the contract; (ii) the service to which the contract relates; (iii) the date on which the contract was made;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZW(1) Registration of contract

44ZW(2) Registration of contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
note: Consider public interest and rights of persons using the service when deciding to register a contract.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zw-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZW Registration of contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...take into account the public interest, including the public interest in having competition in markets...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship between decision-making and consideration of public interest.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: In deciding whether to register a contract, the Commission must...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the public interest, including the public interest in having competition in markets...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Mandatory consideration of public interest and rights.
modality: Argumentation
operator: must
premise text: The Commission must take into account...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the public interest, including the public interest in having competition in markets...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Mandatory consideration of public interest and rights.
modality: CogAI
operator: must
premise text: The Commission must take into account...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the public interest, including the public interest in having competition in markets...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Mandatory consideration of public interest and rights.
modality: Deontic
operator: shall
premise text: The Commission must take into account...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the public interest, including the public interest in having competition in markets...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Mandatory consideration of public interest and rights.
modality: Diffusion
operator: must
premise text: The Commission must take into account...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZW(2) Registration of contract

44ZW(2A) Registration of contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
note: Cannot register contracts related to access matters dealt with in an existing access undertaking.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zw-ss-2a
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZW Registration of contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-2a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Registration of contracts is not allowed.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: Registration of contracts is allowed.

44ZW(3) Registration of contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
note: The Commission must publish a decision not to register a contract.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zw-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZW Registration of contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must publish a decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZW(3) Registration of contract

44ZW(4) Registration of contract
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.236
note: Commission must provide reasons for decision not to register a contract.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zw-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZW Registration of contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide reasons
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zw-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZW(4) Registration of contract

44ZX Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZX(1) Review of decision not to register contract
has part: 44ZX(2) Review of decision not to register contract
has part: 44ZX(3) Review of decision not to register contract
has part: 44ZX(4) Review of decision not to register contract
has part: 44ZX(5) Review of decision not to register contract
has part: 44ZX(5A) Review of decision not to register contract
has part: 44ZX(5B) Review of decision not to register contract
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx
schema version: 2

44ZX(1) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: Party may apply for review of decision not to register contract
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZX(1) Review of decision not to register contract

44ZX(2) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: Application for review must be made within 21 days after publication of the Commission’s decision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 21 days.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZX(2) Review of decision not to register contract

44ZX(3) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: Tribunal must re-consider decision not to register contract based on specified information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Decision not to register contract
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Tribunal must re-consider decision
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Section 44ZX(3)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZX(3) Review of decision not to register contract

44ZX(4) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: The Tribunal has the same powers as the Commission for review purposes.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Tribunal has the same powers.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Same powers
modality: Deontic
operator: same
premise text: The Commission has powers.

44ZX(5) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: The Commission must provide assistance for the purposes of review.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide assistance
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

44ZX(5A) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: Member can request Commission to provide information and reports.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-logic-ltl-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-5a
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses ability or permission.
modality: Deontic
operator: can

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Expresses necessity or obligation to provide information.
modality: Epistemic
operator: must

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5a-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Specifies time frame for Commission's action.
modality: LTL
operator: within

44ZX(5B) Review of decision not to register contract
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.237
note: Must provide a copy of notice to the applicant
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zx-ss-5b
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZX Review of decision not to register contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zx-ss-5b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a copy of notice to the applicant
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST PROVIDE

44ZY Effect of registration of contract
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.238
note: Parties to a registered contract can enforce it under Division 7 as if it were a determination of the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zy-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zy-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zy-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zy
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zy-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Under Division 7 as if it were a determination of the Commission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Enforcement obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: can
premise text: Parties to a registered contract can enforce it.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zy-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on other means of enforcement
modality: Deontic
operator: cannot
premise text: Parties to a registered contract cannot enforce it by any other means.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zy-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZY Effect of registration of contract

44ZZ Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.239
curation status: Proposed
has part: 44ZZ(1) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
has part: 44ZZ(2) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
has part: 44ZZ(3) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zz
schema version: 2

44ZZ(1) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.239
note: Preventing or hindering access to declared services is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zz-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZZ Prohibition on hindering access to declared services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

44ZZ(2) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.239
note: Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zz-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZZ Prohibition on hindering access to declared services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits conduct
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

44ZZ(3) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.239
note: Prohibition on hindering access to declared services
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-shacl-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-44zz-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 44ZZ Prohibition on hindering access to declared services

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Requires overlap between access to services and hindering action
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
premise text: (3) In this section, a user of a service includes a person who has a right to use the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classifies users of services using AI
modality: CogAI
operator: Classify
premise text: (3) In this section, a user of a service includes a person who has a right to use the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits action
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies users of services
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify
premise text: (3) In this section, a user of a service includes a person who has a right to use the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Prevents diffusion of hindering action
modality: Diffusion
operator: Prevent
premise text: (3) In this section, a user of a service includes a person who has a right to use the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-logic-shacl-6
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::shacl
logic summary: Validates classification of users of services
modality: SHACL
operator: Validate
premise text: (3) In this section, a user of a service includes a person who has a right to use the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-44zz-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 44ZZ(3) Prohibition on hindering access to declared services

45 Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.307
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45(1) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
has part: 45(2) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
has part: 45(3) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45
schema version: 2

45(1) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.307
note: Restrict dealings that would substantially lessen competition.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45 Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits actions that would substantially lessen competition.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45(1) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings

45(2) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.307
note: Paragraph (1)(b) applies to contracts or arrangements made before or after the commencement of this section.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45 Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Paragraph (1)(b) applies in relation to...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Applicable to contracts or arrangements made before or after the commencement of this section.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Applicability
premise text: (2)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Paragraph (1)(b) applies in relation to...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Applicable to contracts or arrangements made before or after the commencement of this section.
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicability
premise text: (2) Paragraph (1)(b)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Paragraph (1)(b) applies in relation to...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Applicable to contracts or arrangements made before or after the commencement of this section.
modality: Deontic
operator: Scope
premise text: (2)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Paragraph (1)(b) applies in relation to...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Applicable to contracts or arrangements made before or after the commencement of this section.
modality: LTL
operator: Temporal Applicability
premise text: (2)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45(2) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings

45(3) Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.307
note: Restrictive trade practices
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45 Contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits restrictive trade practices
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies as restrictive trade practice
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify

45AA Simplified outline
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.283
note: Corporation cannot make or give effect to a contract with cartel provision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aa-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aa-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45aa
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aa-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of making or giving effect to a contract with cartel provision.
modality: Deontic
operator: cannot

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aa-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AA Simplified outline

45AB Definitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.283
note: Definition of benefit and bid
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ab-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ab-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ab-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ab
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ab-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: benefit is a subclass of advantage
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Class hierarchy
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: type
premise text: benefit includes any advantage and is not limited to property.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ab-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: benefit is a subclass of advantage
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Subclass relationship
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subclassOf
premise text: benefit includes any advantage and is not limited to property.

45AC Extended meaning of party
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.284
note: Each related body corporate is taken to be a party to the contract, arrangement or understanding.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ac-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ac
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ac-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AC Extended meaning of party

45AD Cartel provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.284
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AD(1) Cartel provisions
has part: 45AD(2) Cartel provisions
has part: 45AD(3) Cartel provisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ad
schema version: 2

45AD(1) Cartel provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.284
note: A provision of a contract, arrangement or understanding is a cartel provision if certain conditions are met.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ad-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AD Cartel provisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies that a provision is a cartel provision if certain conditions are met
modality: Deontic
operator: implies

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AD(1) Cartel provisions

45AD(2) Cartel provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.284
note: Provision has purpose/effect of fixing, controlling or maintaining prices or discounts.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ad-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AD Cartel provisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...of directly or indirectly: (f) goods or services likely to be re-supplied by persons or classes of persons to whom those goods or services are likely to be supplied by any or all of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Provision affects prices during the contract term.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) The purpose/effect condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose, or has or is likely to have the effect, of directly or indirectly: (a) fixing, controlling or maintaining...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...of directly or indirectly: (f) goods or services likely to be re-supplied by persons or classes of persons to whom those goods or services are likely to be supplied by any or all of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Provision implies fixing, controlling or maintaining prices.
modality: Argumentation
operator: implies
premise text: (2) The purpose/effect condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose, or has or is likely to have the effect, of directly or indirectly: (a) fixing, controlling or maintaining...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...of directly or indirectly: (a) fixing, controlling or maintaining...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Provision has purpose of fixing, controlling or maintaining prices.
modality: Deontic
operator: hasPurpose
premise text: (2) The provision has the purpose/effect condition...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...of directly or indirectly: (f) goods or services likely to be re-supplied by persons or classes of persons to whom those goods or services are likely to be supplied by any or all of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Provision affects prices during the contract term.
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (2) The purpose/effect condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose, or has or is likely to have the effect, of directly or indirectly: (a) fixing, controlling or maintaining...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...of directly or indirectly: (f) goods or services likely to be re-supplied by persons or classes of persons to whom those goods or services are likely to be supplied by any or all of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Provision affects prices during the contract term.
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (2) The purpose/effect condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose, or has or is likely to have the effect, of directly or indirectly: (a) fixing, controlling or maintaining...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AD(2) Cartel provisions

45AD(3) Cartel provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.284
note: Preventing, restricting or limiting restrictive trade practices
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ad-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45AD Cartel provisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Overlapping intervals of trade practices and restrictive practices
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
premise text: (3) The purpose condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose of directly or indirectly: preventing, restricting or limiting:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Analyzing trade practices for restrictive characteristics
modality: CogAI
operator: Analyze
premise text: (3) The purpose condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose of directly or indirectly: preventing, restricting or limiting:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of restrictive trade practices
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) The purpose condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose of directly or indirectly: preventing, restricting or limiting:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Influence of trade practices on restrictive practices
modality: Diffusion
operator: Influence
premise text: (3) The purpose condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose of directly or indirectly: preventing, restricting or limiting:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Containment of trade practices within restrictive practices
modality: LTL
operator: Containment
premise text: (3) The purpose condition is satisfied if the provision has the purpose of directly or indirectly: preventing, restricting or limiting:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ad-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AD(3) Cartel provisions

45AE Meaning of expressions in other provisions of this Act
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.291
note: Disregard this Division in determining expression meanings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ae-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ae-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ae
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ae-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to disregard this Division.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

45AF Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.291
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AF(1) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
has part: 45AF(2) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
has part: 45AF(3) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45af
schema version: 2

45AF(1) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.291
note: Making a contract or arrangement with a cartel provision is an offence.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45af-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AF Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the contract, arrangement or understanding contains a cartel provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits making contracts or arrangements with cartel provisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A corporation commits an offence if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the contract, arrangement or understanding contains a cartel provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implies that making contracts or arrangements with cartel provisions is an offence.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Imply
premise text: (1) A corporation commits an offence if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AF(1) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

45AF(2) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.291
note: Knowledge or belief is required for the fault element.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45af-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AF Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires knowledge or belief.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Knowledge or belief is required.
modality: Epistemic
operator: knowledge or belief

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AF(2) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

45AF(3) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.291
note: Offence punishable by fine not exceeding $100,000,000 or 3 times the total value of benefits obtained
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45af-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45AF Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a prohibition on committing the offence
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45af-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AF(3) Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

45AG Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.292
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AG(1) Giving effect to a cartel provision
has part: 45AG(2) Giving effect to a cartel provision
has part: 45AG(3) Giving effect to a cartel provision
has part: 45AG(4) Giving effect to a cartel provision
has part: 45AG(5) Giving effect to a cartel provision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ag
schema version: 2

45AG(1) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.292
note: Giving effect to a cartel provision is an offence.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ag-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AG Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation gives effect to the cartel provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits giving effect to a cartel provision.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: (1) A corporation commits an offence if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation gives effect to the cartel provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on corporations to not give effect to cartel provisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (1) A corporation commits an offence if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation gives effect to the cartel provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implicates that giving effect to a cartel provision leads to an offence.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Implication
premise text: (1) A corporation commits an offence if...

45AG(2) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.292
note: Knowledge or belief is required for a penalty to be imposed.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ag-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AG Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires knowledge or belief.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Knowledge or belief is required.
modality: Epistemic
operator: knowledge or belief

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AG(2) Giving effect to a cartel provision

45AG(3) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.292
note: Offence against subsection (1) is punishable by a fine not exceeding the greater of the following.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ag-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45AG Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a prohibition on committing an offence.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

45AG(4) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.292
note: Indictable offence for contracts or arrangements made before, at or after commencement
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ag-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 45AG Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Indictable offence
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits contracts or arrangements
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (4) Paragraph (1)(a)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-4-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AG(4) Giving effect to a cartel provision

45AG(5) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.292
note: An offence against subsection (1) is an indictable offence.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-5-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ag-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 45AG Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ag-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AG(5) Giving effect to a cartel provision

45AH Determining guilt
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.293
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AH(1) Determining guilt
has part: 45AH(2) Determining guilt
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ah
schema version: 2

45AH(1) Determining guilt
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.293
note: A corporation can be held guilty of an offence against section 45AF or 45AG even if other parties are not criminally responsible.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ah-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AH Determining guilt

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A corporation can be held guilty...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Possibility of obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: can
premise text: None

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AH(1) Determining guilt

45AH(2) Determining guilt
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.293
note: Corporation cannot be found guilty of an offence against section 45AF or 45AG if all other parties have been acquitted.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ah-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AH Determining guilt

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The finding of guilt overlaps with the acquittal of other parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The finding of guilt overlaps with the acquittal of other parties.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: A finding of guilt would be inconsistent with their acquittal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The corporation cannot be found guilty of an offence against section 45AF or 45AG.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If all other parties are acquitted, then the corporation cannot be found guilty.
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: All other parties to the contract have been acquitted.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The corporation is not found guilty of an offence against section 45AF or 45AG.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If all other parties are acquitted, then the corporation is not found guilty.
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: All other parties to the contract have been acquitted.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The corporation cannot be found guilty of an offence against section 45AF or 45AG.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: If a finding of guilt would be inconsistent with the acquittal, then the corporation cannot be found guilty.
modality: Deontic
operator: Implies
premise text: A finding of guilt would be inconsistent with their acquittal.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The finding of guilt repeats in time with the acquittal of other parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The finding of guilt repeats in time with the acquittal of other parties.
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
premise text: All other parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding have been acquitted of such an offence.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ah-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AH(2) Determining guilt

45AI Court may make related civil orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.293
note: Court may grant injunctions against a person in relation to the conduct that constitutes or is alleged to constitute an offence.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ai-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ai-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ai
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ai-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Granting injunctions is a permissible action.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ai-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AI Court may make related civil orders

45AJ Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.294
note: Making a contract or arrangement with a cartel provision is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aj-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aj-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45aj
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aj-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits making a contract or arrangement with a cartel provision.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aj-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AJ Making a contract etc. containing a cartel provision

45AK Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.294
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AK(1) Giving effect to a cartel provision
has part: 45AK(2) Giving effect to a cartel provision
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ak
schema version: 2

45AK(1) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.294
note: Giving effect to a cartel provision is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ak-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ak-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ak-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AK Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ak-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits giving effect to a cartel provision.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ak-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AK(1) Giving effect to a cartel provision

45AK(2) Giving effect to a cartel provision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.294
note: Paragraph (1)(a) applies to contracts or arrangements made, or understandings arrived at, before, at or after the commencement of this section.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ak-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ak-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AK Giving effect to a cartel provision

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ak-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AK(2) Giving effect to a cartel provision

45AL Conduct notified
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.295
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AL(1) Conduct notified
has part: 45AL(2) Conduct notified
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45al
schema version: 2

45AL(1) Conduct notified
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.295
note: Exempts corporations from cartel provisions under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45al-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AL Conduct notified

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits the application of cartel provisions to corporations under specified conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AL(1) Conduct notified

45AL(2) Conduct notified
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.295
note: Evidential burden for relying on subsection (1) in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45al-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AL Conduct notified

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on a person to bear the evidential burden
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Requires a person to provide evidence in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
modality: Epistemic
operator: Evidential Burden

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45al-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AL(2) Conduct notified

45AM Cartel provision subject to grant of authorisation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.295
note: Grant of authorisation required for cartel provision
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45am-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45am-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45am
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45am-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional permission
modality: Deontic
operator: if-then

45AN Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.296
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AN(1) Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related
has part: 45AN(2) Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45an
schema version: 2

45AN(1) Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.296
note: Defendant bears evidential burden in relation to matter in subsection (1)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45an-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AN Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Defendant bears evidential burden
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Defendant must provide evidence
modality: Epistemic
operator: Evidential Burden

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AN(1) Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related

45AN(2) Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.296
note: Evidential burden for relying on subsection (1) in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45an-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AN Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45an-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: NaturalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: NaturalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AN(2) Contracts, arrangements or understandings between related

45AO Joint ventures—prosecution
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.296
note: Defendant bears legal burden in relation to matter in section.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ao-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ao-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ao-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ao
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ao-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Defendant bears legal burden.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ao-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classification of joint ventures.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ao-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AO Joint ventures—prosecution

45AP Joint ventures—civil penalty proceedings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.297
note: No application of sections 45AJ and 45AK in relation to a cartel provision for joint ventures.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ap-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ap
schema version: 2

45AQ Resale price maintenance
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.298
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AQ(1) Resale price maintenance
has part: 45AQ(2) Resale price maintenance
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45aq
schema version: 2

45AQ(1) Resale price maintenance
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.298
note: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ, and 45AK.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45aq-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AQ Resale price maintenance

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits cartel provisions from sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ, and 45AK.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AQ(1) Resale price maintenance

45AQ(2) Resale price maintenance
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.298
note: Evidential burden for relying on subsection (1) in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45aq-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AQ Resale price maintenance

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on a person to bear the evidential burden
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Requires a person to provide evidence in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
modality: Epistemic
operator: Evidential Burden

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aq-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AQ(2) Resale price maintenance

45AR Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.299
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AR(1) Exclusive dealing
has part: 45AR(2) Exclusive dealing
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ar
schema version: 2

45AR(1) Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.299
note: Defendant bears evidential burden in relation to cartel provision
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ar-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AR Exclusive dealing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Defendant bears evidential burden
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-1-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Defendant must provide evidence
modality: Epistemic
operator: Evidential Burden

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AR(1) Exclusive dealing

45AR(2) Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.299
note: Exemptions from cartel provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ar-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AR Exclusive dealing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes temporal relationship
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) Sections 45AG and 45AK do not apply in relation to the giving effect to a cartel provision by way of:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Describes implication between premises and conclusion
modality: Argumentation
operator: implies
premise text: (2) Sections 45AG and 45AK do not apply in relation to the giving effect to a cartel provision by way of:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Describes recognition or acknowledgment
modality: CogAI
operator: recognizes
premise text: (2) Sections 45AG and 45AK do not apply in relation to the giving effect to a cartel provision by way of:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits certain conduct
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: (2) Sections 45AG and 45AK do not apply in relation to the giving effect to a cartel provision by way of:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ar-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Describes spreading or dissemination
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (2) Sections 45AG and 45AK do not apply in relation to the giving effect to a cartel provision by way of:

45AS Dual listed company arrangement
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.300
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AS(1) Dual listed company arrangement
has part: 45AS(2) Dual listed company arrangement
has part: 45AS(3) Dual listed company arrangement
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45as
schema version: 2

45AS(1) Dual listed company arrangement
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.300
note: Exempts dual listed company arrangements from cartel provisions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45as-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AS Dual listed company arrangement

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...in so far as: (a) the contract, arrangement or understanding is a dual listed company arrangement; and (b) the making of the contract, arrangement or understanding would, or would apart from section 88, contravene section 49.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits making a contract with a cartel provision.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) Sections 45AF and 45AJ do not apply in relation to the making of a contract, arrangement or understanding that contains a cartel provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AS(1) Dual listed company arrangement

45AS(2) Dual listed company arrangement
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.300
note: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AG and 45AK under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-cogai-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-shacl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45as-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AS Dual listed company arrangement

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 49 and 88 are not contravened.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AG and 45AK under certain conditions.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
premise text: Cartel provision is a provision of a dual listed company arrangement.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-cogai-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 49 and 88 are not contravened.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AG and 45AK under certain conditions.
modality: CogAI
operator: classification
premise text: Cartel provision is a provision of a dual listed company arrangement.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AG and 45AK do not apply.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AG and 45AK under certain conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption
premise text: Cartel provision is a provision of a dual listed company arrangement.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 49 and 88 are not contravened.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AG and 45AK under certain conditions.
modality: LTL
operator: recurring
premise text: Cartel provision is a provision of a dual listed company arrangement.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-logic-shacl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 49 and 88 are not contravened.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::shacl
logic summary: Exempts cartel provisions from sections 45AG and 45AK under certain conditions.
modality: SHACL
operator: validation
premise text: Cartel provision is a provision of a dual listed company arrangement.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AS(2) Dual listed company arrangement

45AS(3) Dual listed company arrangement
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.300
note: Evidential burden for relying on subsections in relation to contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45as-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45AS Dual listed company arrangement

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide evidence
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45as-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AS(3) Dual listed company arrangement

45AT Acquisition of shares or assets
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.301
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AT(1) Acquisition of shares or assets
has part: 45AT(2) Acquisition of shares or assets
has part: 45AT(3) Acquisition of shares or assets
has part: 45AT(4) Acquisition of shares or assets
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45at
schema version: 2

45AT(1) Acquisition of shares or assets
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.301
note: Prohibits application of certain sections in relation to cartel provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45at-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AT Acquisition of shares or assets

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: There is an overlap between the two sections
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Relates to temporal overlap
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps
premise text: Section 45AF applies before section 45AG

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ and 45AK do not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits the application of certain sections
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: Cartel provision provides directly or indirectly for the acquisition of shares or assets

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AT(1) Acquisition of shares or assets

45AT(2) Acquisition of shares or assets
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.301
note: Evidential burden for relying on subsection (1) in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45at-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AT Acquisition of shares or assets

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on a person to provide evidence
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-2-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Requires a person to bear the evidential burden of relying on subsection (1)
modality: Epistemic
operator: Evidential burden

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AT(2) Acquisition of shares or assets

45AT(3) Acquisition of shares or assets
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.301
note: Prohibits application of certain sections in relation to cartel provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45at-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45AT Acquisition of shares or assets

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ and 45AK do not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Relates to a specific time period
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Cartel provision provides for an acquisition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ and 45AK do not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Relates to a specific consequence
modality: CogAI
operator: then
premise text: Acquisition is a notified acquisition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ and 45AK do not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits application of sections in relation to cartel provisions
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: Cartel provision provides for an acquisition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ and 45AK do not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Relates to a specific condition
modality: Diffusion
operator: if
premise text: Cartel provision provides for an acquisition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Sections 45AF, 45AG, 45AJ and 45AK do not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Relates to a specific time period
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: Acquisition is a notified acquisition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AT(3) Acquisition of shares or assets

45AT(4) Acquisition of shares or assets
type: Concept
description: Evidence
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.301
note: Evidential burden for relying on subsection (3) in relation to a contravention of section 45AJ or 45AK
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-4-logic-epistemic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45at-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 45AT Acquisition of shares or assets

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on a person to provide evidence
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-4-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: Shifts the burden of proof from the state to the individual
modality: Epistemic
operator: Burden of proof

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45at-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AT(4) Acquisition of shares or assets

45AU Collective acquisition of goods or services by the parties to a
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.301
note: Exempts sections from cartel provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45au-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45au-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45au
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45au-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exempts sections from cartel provisions
modality: Deontic
operator: exemption

45AV Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.303
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AV(1) Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect
has part: 45AV(2) Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45av
schema version: 2

45AV(1) Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.303
note: Clarifies the meaning of 'putting an acquisition into effect'
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45av-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45av-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AV Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect

45AV(2) Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.303
note: Engaging in conduct that would constitute putting an acquisition into effect if not for this Division constitutes a purported putting into effect.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45av-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45av-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45av-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AV Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45av-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Engaging in conduct constitutes an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: constitutes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45av-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AV(2) Purportedly putting acquisitions into effect

45AW Commission must be notified of acquisitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.303
note: Failure to notify acquisitions is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aw-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aw-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45aw
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aw-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Failure to notify is prohibited.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of failure to notify acquisitions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Acquisitions must be notified.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45aw-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AW Commission must be notified of acquisitions

45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AX(1) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
has part: 45AX(2) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
has part: 45AX(3) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
has part: 45AX(4) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
has part: 45AX(5) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
has part: 45AX(6) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax
schema version: 2

45AX(1) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
note: Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in respect of a notification.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Applicable
premise text: (i) occurring on or after the effective notification date of the notification; and (ii) at which the Commission has not decided to cease considering the notification under section 51ABZD;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person must notify the Commission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must notify the Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (a) a person is the notifying party of a notification of an acquisition; and (b) a change of fact occurs; and (c) the change of fact is material to the Commission making a determination under subsection 51ABZE(1) in respect of the notification;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person must notify the Commission within a timeframe.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must notify the Commission within a timeframe
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (iii) at which the Commission has not made a determination in respect of the notification under subsection 51ABZE(1); and (iv) if the notification is subject to phase 2 review—occurring at least 15 business days (within the meaning of section 51ABK) before the end of the phase 2 determination period for the notification.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable
premise text: (i) occurring on or after the effective notification date of the notification; and (ii) at which the Commission has not decided to cease considering the notification under section 51ABZD;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable
premise text: (iii) at which the Commission has not made a determination in respect of the notification under subsection 51ABZE(1); and (iv) if the notification is subject to phase 2 review—occurring at least 15 business days (within the meaning of section 51ABK) before the end of the phase 2 determination period for the notification.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AX(1) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

45AX(2) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
note: Notify Commission of material changes of fact
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Notification obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AX(2) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

45AX(3) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
note: Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in relation to a public benefit application.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must notify the Commission of material changes of fact.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AX(3) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

45AX(4) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
note: Notify Commission of material changes of fact
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Notification obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AX(4) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

45AX(5) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
description: Notification to Commission
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
note: Notify Commission of material changes of fact
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must notify Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AX(5) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

45AX(6) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.304
note: A person who ought reasonably be aware of something is taken to be aware of it.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-epistemic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ax-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 45AX Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between awareness and knowledge.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Relationship

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Establishes an inference from the definition of awareness.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Inference

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the State.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-epistemic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::epistemic
logic summary: States that a person is taken to be aware of something.
modality: Epistemic
operator: Knowledge

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between awareness and knowledge.
modality: LTL
operator: Temporal Knowledge

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ax-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AX(6) Commission must be notified of material changes of fact in

45AY Stayed acquisitions must not be put into effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.305
note: Acquisitions stayed must not be put into effect
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ay-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ay-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ay
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ay-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Cannot put acquisition into effect
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits putting acquisitions into effect when stayed
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Acquisition is stayed

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ay-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AY Stayed acquisitions must not be put into effect

45AZ Conditions must be complied with
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.306
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45AZ(1) Conditions must be complied with
has part: 45AZ(2) Conditions must be complied with
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45az
schema version: 2

45AZ(1) Conditions must be complied with
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.306
note: Compliance with section 45AY is required. Must comply with conditions when putting an acquisition into effect.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45az-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45AZ Conditions must be complied with

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must comply with section 45AY.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AZ(1) Conditions must be complied with

45AZ(2) Conditions must be complied with
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.306
note: Providing false or misleading information is prohibited. Failure to comply with conditions is a contravention.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45az-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45AZ Conditions must be complied with

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of providing false or misleading information.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to comply with conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45az-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45AZ(2) Conditions must be complied with

45D Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.311
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45D(1) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss
has part: 45D(2) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45d
schema version: 2

45D(1) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.311
note: Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45d-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45D Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) In the circumstances specified in subsection (3) or (4), a person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45D(1) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss

45D(2) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.311
note: A person is taken to engage in conduct for a purpose mentioned in subsection (1) if the person engages in the conduct for purposes that include that purpose.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45d-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45D Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The conduct occurs after the time of the purpose mentioned in subsection (1).
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: The person engages in conduct.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is taken to engage in conduct for a purpose mentioned in subsection (1).
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Inference to obligation
modality: Argumentation
operator: if-then
premise text: The person engages in conduct.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is taken to engage in conduct for purposes that include the purpose mentioned in subsection (1).
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Knowledge representation
modality: CogAI
operator: =
premise text: The person engages in conduct.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is taken to engage in conduct for a purpose mentioned in subsection (1).
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: if-then
premise text: The person engages in conduct.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is taken to engage in conduct for purposes that include the purpose mentioned in subsection (1).
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Inference to obligation through diffusion
modality: Diffusion
operator: if-then
premise text: The person engages in conduct.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45d-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45D(2) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss

45DA Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.312
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45DA(1) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
has part: 45DA(2) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
has part: 45DA(3) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45da
schema version: 2

45DA(1) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.312
note: Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial lessening of competition in any market in which a fourth person supplies or acquires goods or services.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-argumentation-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45da-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45DA Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...engage in conduct that hinders or prevents...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines a temporal interval during which conduct must not hinder or prevent a third person supplying goods or services.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (1) In the circumstances specified in subsection (3), a person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-argumentation-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...engage in conduct that hinders or prevents...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implies that engaging in conduct that hinders or prevents a third person supplying goods or services is wrong.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: (1) In the circumstances specified in subsection (3), a person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...engage in conduct that hinders or prevents...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits conduct that hinders or prevents a third person supplying goods or services to a fourth person.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) In the circumstances specified in subsection (3), a person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...engage in conduct that hinders or prevents...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on a person not to engage in conduct that hinders or prevents a third person supplying goods or services.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (1) In the circumstances specified in subsection (3), a person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...conduct that is engaged in for the purpose, and would have or be likely to have the effect...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Requires a recurring trace of conduct that hinders or prevents a third person supplying goods or services.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
premise text: (b) that is engaged in for the purpose, and would have or be likely to have the effect...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45DA(1) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial

45DA(2) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.312
note: A person is taken to engage in conduct for a purpose mentioned in subsection (1) if the person engages in the conduct for purposes that include that purpose.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45da-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45DA Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes relation
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45DA(2) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial

45DA(3) Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.312
note: Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial loss or damage to a corporation's business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-cogai-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-shacl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45da-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 45DA Secondary boycotts for the purpose of causing substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...causing substantial loss or damage to the business of one of those persons who is a corporation.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for secondary boycotts.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (3) Subsection (1) applies if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-cogai-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...causing substantial loss or damage to the business of one of those persons who is a corporation.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Represents knowledge about secondary boycotts in a formal way.
modality: CogAI
operator: Knowledge Representation
premise text: (3) Subsection (1) applies if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...causing substantial loss or damage to the business of one of those persons who is a corporation.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits secondary boycotts for causing substantial loss or damage.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) Subsection (1) applies if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...causing substantial loss or damage to the business of one of those persons who is a corporation.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Defines recurring trace for secondary boycotts.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
premise text: (3) Subsection (1) applies if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45da-ss-3-logic-shacl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...causing substantial loss or damage to the business of one of those persons who is a corporation.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::shacl
logic summary: Validates secondary boycotts against a set of rules.
modality: SHACL
operator: Validation
premise text: (3) Subsection (1) applies if...

45DB Boycotts affecting trade or commerce
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.313
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45DB(1) Boycotts affecting trade or commerce
has part: 45DB(2) Boycotts affecting trade or commerce
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45db
schema version: 2

45DB(1) Boycotts affecting trade or commerce
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.313
note: Prohibits engaging in conduct to prevent or hinder another person from engaging in trade or commerce.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45db-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45DB Boycotts affecting trade or commerce

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...having or likely to have...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Prohibits conduct within a specific time frame
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Prohibition
premise text: (1) A person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...must not, in concert...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits conduct
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45DB(1) Boycotts affecting trade or commerce

45DB(2) Boycotts affecting trade or commerce
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.313
note: Engaging in conduct for purposes that include a specified purpose is considered engaging in conduct for that purpose.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45db-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45DB Boycotts affecting trade or commerce

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Inclusion relation between purposes.
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45db-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45DB(2) Boycotts affecting trade or commerce

45DC Involvement and liability of employee organisations
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.313
note: Organisation is taken for purposes of sections 45D, 45DA and 45DB if participants engage in conduct in concert.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-argumentation-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45dc
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Organisation is taken for purposes of sections 45D, 45DA and 45DB.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Conduct in concert with participants overlaps with conduct of the organisation.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: Participants engage in conduct in concert.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Organisation is taken for purposes of sections 45D, 45DA and 45DB.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Engagement in conduct in concert implies organisation's involvement.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: Participants engage in conduct in concert.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Organisation is taken for purposes of sections 45D, 45DA and 45DB.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Organisation is obligated to engage in conduct in concert with participants.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Participants engage in conduct in concert.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dc-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Organisation is taken for purposes of sections 45D, 45DA and 45DB.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Conduct in concert with participants repeats over time.
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
premise text: Participants engage in conduct in concert.

45DD Situations in which boycotts permitted
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.315
note: Boycotts permitted if dominant purpose is related to employment matters
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dd-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dd-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45dd
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45dd-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishes a condition for permissible boycotts
modality: Deontic
operator: ⊃

45E Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.319
curation status: Proposed
has part: 45E(1) Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings
has part: 45E(2) Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45e
schema version: 2

45E(1) Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.319
note: Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings in supply situations
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45e-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 45E Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits actions
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45E(1) Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings

45E(2) Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.319
note: Prohibition on making contracts or arrangements with employees' organisations
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45e-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 45E Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...Chapter 3 Restrictive trade practices
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of actions
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: (2) In a supply situation, the first person must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45e-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45E(2) Prohibition of contracts, arrangements or understandings

45EA Provisions contravening section 45E not to be given effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.322
note: Prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45ea
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid
premise text: Section 45EA prohibits giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes duty
premise text: Section 45EA imposes a duty on individuals and entities not to give effect to provisions contravening section 45E

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E
modality: Deontic
operator: forbids
premise text: Section 45EA forbids individuals and entities from giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E
modality: Deontic
operator: requires prohibition
premise text: Section 45EA requires a prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E
modality: Deontic
operator: enforces prohibition
premise text: Section 45EA enforces a prohibition on giving effect to provisions contravening section 45E

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45ea-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 45EA Provisions contravening section 45E not to be given effect

45EB Sections 45D to 45EA do not affect operation of other
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.323
note: No effect on other provisions of Part
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-45eb-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-45eb
schema version: 2

46 Misuse of market power
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.323
note: Must not engage in conduct that has the purpose or effect of substantially lessening competition.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-46
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...must not engage in conduct for the duration of the prohibition.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Relates to temporal interval of prohibition.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal relation
premise text: (1) A corporation that has a substantial degree of power in a market must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...must not engage in conduct that is represented as prohibited.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Relates to knowledge representation of prohibited conduct.
modality: CogAI
operator: Knowledge representation
premise text: (1) A corporation that has a substantial degree of power in a market must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...must not engage in conduct that has the purpose or effect of substantially lessening competition.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must not engage in conduct.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A corporation that has a substantial degree of power in a market must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...must not engage in conduct that diffuses prohibited information.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Relates to diffusion of prohibited information.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffusion
premise text: (1) A corporation that has a substantial degree of power in a market must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...must not engage in conduct with a recurring pattern.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Relates to recurring traces of prohibited conduct.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring trace
premise text: (1) A corporation that has a substantial degree of power in a market must not...

46A Misuse of market power—corporation with substantial degree
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.325
note: Prohibition on misuse of market power by corporations with substantial degree
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-diffusion-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-cogai-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-46a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The duration of market power must be clearly defined
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines temporal scope for market power
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal
premise text: Market power is only applicable within the trans-Tasman market

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The use of market power must be carefully considered
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implies a causal relationship between market power and conduct
modality: Argumentation
operator: Imply
premise text: Market power can lead to conduct that harms others

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-cogai-6
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The use of AI must be considered when evaluating market power
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognizes the importance of artificial intelligence in understanding market power
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognize
premise text: Artificial intelligence can help analyze market power data

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Corporations with substantial degree must not engage in such conduct
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits misuse of market power
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Market power must not be used for personal gain

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The definition of market power must be clearly understood
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies market power as a key concept
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify
premise text: Market power is a critical aspect of the trans-Tasman market

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The definition of market power must be widely understood
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Spreads the concept of market power throughout the trans-Tasman market
modality: Diffusion
operator: Spread
premise text: Market power is a key concept that affects multiple stakeholders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46a-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 46A Misuse of market power—corporation with substantial degree

46B No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
curation status: Proposed
has part: 46B(1) No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New
has part: 46B(2) No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-46b
schema version: 2

46B(1) No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
note: No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New Zealand matters
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-46b-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 46B No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: No immunity from jurisdiction
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

46B(2) No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
note: No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New Zealand activities.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-46b-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 46B No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision applies within the defined temporal interval.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines a temporal interval for the application of this provision.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (2) This section applies in and outside Australia.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Jurisdiction is established if this provision is complied with.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Establishes a causal relationship between this provision and jurisdiction.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: (2) This section applies in and outside Australia.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision implies a duty on the State to comply with jurisdictional requirements.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Extracts relevant information from this provision.
modality: CogAI
operator: Inference
premise text: (2) This section applies in and outside Australia.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The State must comply with this provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the State.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (2) This section applies in and outside Australia.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision applies to all jurisdictions within the defined scope.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Defines the scope of applicability for this provision.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Propagation
premise text: (2) This section applies in and outside Australia.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-46b-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 46B(2) No immunity from jurisdiction in relation to certain New

47 Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
curation status: Proposed
has part: 47(1) Exclusive dealing
has part: 47(2) Exclusive dealing
has part: 47(3) Exclusive dealing
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-47
schema version: 2

47(1) Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
note: Corporation cannot engage in exclusive dealing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-47-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 47 Exclusive dealing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits exclusive dealing
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 47(1) Exclusive dealing

47(2) Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
note: Restrictive trade practices: Exclusive dealing
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-47-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 47 Exclusive dealing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits exclusive dealing
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

47(3) Exclusive dealing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.328
note: Refusal to supply goods or services under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-47-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 47 Exclusive dealing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the person or, if the person is a body corporate, a body corporate related to that body corporate:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for refusal to supply goods or services.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (3) A corporation also engages in the practice of exclusive dealing if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the person or, if the person is a body corporate, a body corporate related to that body corporate:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implication of refusal to supply goods or services.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: (3) A corporation also engages in the practice of exclusive dealing if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the person or, if the person is a body corporate, a body corporate related to that body corporate:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognition of refusal to supply goods or services.
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognize
premise text: (3) A corporation also engages in the practice of exclusive dealing if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the person or, if the person is a body corporate, a body corporate related to that body corporate:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of exclusive dealing.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) A corporation also engages in the practice of exclusive dealing if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the person or, if the person is a body corporate, a body corporate related to that body corporate:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion of refusal to supply goods or services.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
premise text: (3) A corporation also engages in the practice of exclusive dealing if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-47-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 47(3) Exclusive dealing

48 Resale price maintenance
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.334
curation status: Proposed
has part: 48(1) Resale price maintenance
has part: 48(2) Resale price maintenance
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-48
schema version: 2

48(1) Resale price maintenance
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.334
note: Prohibition on resale price maintenance
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-48-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 48 Resale price maintenance

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Forbids resale price maintenance
modality: Deontic
operator: forbid

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 48(1) Resale price maintenance

48(2) Resale price maintenance
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.334
note: Exempts corporations from resale price maintenance if they notify the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-48-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 48 Resale price maintenance

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Allows corporations to engage in resale price maintenance without restriction.
modality: Deontic
operator: Permits

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-48-ss-2-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 48(2) Resale price maintenance

49 Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.335
curation status: Proposed
has part: 49(1) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
has part: 49(2) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
has part: 49(3) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-49
schema version: 2

49(1) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.335
note: No dual listed company arrangement that would substantially lessen competition.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-49-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 49 Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...make a dual listed company arrangement if...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Restriction of temporal scope for dual listed company arrangements.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Restriction
premise text: (1) A corporation must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...make a dual listed company arrangement if...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of dual listed company arrangements that affect competition.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A corporation must not...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 49(1) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition

49(2) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.335
note: Corporation may give effect to provision under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-49-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 49 Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The corporation may give effect to the provision.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to give effect to provision under certain conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit
premise text: The arrangement is subject to a condition...

49(3) Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.335
note: Restrictive trade practices prohibited in certain markets
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-49-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 49 Dual listed company arrangements that affect competition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits restrictive trade practices
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-49-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies as a restriction on competition
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Classify

4A Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.57
curation status: Proposed
has part: 4A(1) Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate
has part: 4A(2) Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4a
schema version: 2

4A(1) Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.57
note: A body corporate is deemed to be a subsidiary of another if it meets certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 4A Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: A body corporate is deemed to be a subsidiary of another if it meets certain conditions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4a-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4A(1) Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate

4A(2) Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.57
note: Control of a corporate board of directors' composition
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4a-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 4A Subsidiary, holding and related bodies corporate

4B Consumers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.60
curation status: Proposed
has part: 4B(1) Consumers
has part: 4B(2) Consumers
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4b
schema version: 2

4B(1) Consumers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.60
note: A person is taken to have acquired goods or services as a consumer if the contrary intention appears.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4b-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 4B Consumers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Acquiring goods or services as a consumer is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: takes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4B(1) Consumers

4B(2) Consumers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.60
note: Presumption of consumer status in proceedings under the Act.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4b-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 4B Consumers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Unless the contrary is established, that the person was a consumer in relation to those goods or services.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal scope of presumption
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: Alleged in any proceeding under this Act or other proceeding in respect of a matter arising under this Act.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: That the person was a consumer in relation to particular goods or services.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Semantic representation of consumer status
modality: CogAI
operator: Knowledge Representation
premise text: If it is alleged in any proceeding under this Act or other proceeding in respect of a matter arising under this Act.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: That the person was a consumer in relation to those goods or services.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Presumption of consumer status
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: Alleged in any proceeding under this Act or other proceeding in respect of a matter arising under this Act.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: That the person was a consumer in relation to those goods or services.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Spread of presumption through proceedings
modality: Diffusion
operator: Information Spread
premise text: Alleged in any proceeding under this Act or other proceeding in respect of a matter arising under this Act.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: That the person was a consumer in relation to particular goods or services.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring application of presumption
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
premise text: Alleged in any proceeding under this Act or other proceeding in respect of a matter arising under this Act.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4b-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4B(2) Consumers

4C Acquisition, supply and re-supply
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.60
note: Definitions for acquisition, supply and re-supply of goods and services.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4c-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4c-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4c-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4c
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4c-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Reference to acquisition includes reference to property or rights in relation to goods
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4c-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Class hierarchy definition
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =

4E Market
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.61
note: Defines market for purposes of the Act.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4e-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4e-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4e-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4e
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4e-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes other goods or services competitive with the first-mentioned
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4e-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies goods or services as substitutable
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4e-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4E Market

4F References to purpose or reason
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.61
note: Deems a provision of a contract or arrangement to have had a particular purpose if included for that purpose.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4f-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4f
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4f-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4F References to purpose or reason

4G Lessening of competition to include preventing or hindering
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.62
note: Preventing or hindering competition is included in the lessening of competition.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4g
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The prohibition on preventing or hindering competition applies at all times.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Includes a temporal interval for the application of the prohibition.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: includes
premise text: For the purposes of this Act, references to the lessening of competition shall be read as including references to preventing or hindering competition.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Preventing or hindering competition is included in the lessening of competition.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes a prohibition on preventing or hindering competition.
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: For the purposes of this Act, references to the lessening of competition shall be read as including references to preventing or hindering competition.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The description of 'preventing or hindering' includes actions that prevent or hinder competition.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes a descriptive clause defining 'preventing or hindering'.
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: For the purposes of this Act, references to the lessening of competition shall be read as including references to preventing or hindering competition.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The prohibition on preventing or hindering competition is part of the diffusion.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Includes a diffusion for the application of the prohibition.
modality: Diffusion
operator: includes
premise text: For the purposes of this Act, references to the lessening of competition shall be read as including references to preventing or hindering competition.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The prohibition on preventing or hindering competition applies at all times and is part of the trace.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Includes a trace for the application of the prohibition.
modality: LTL
operator: includes
premise text: For the purposes of this Act, references to the lessening of competition shall be read as including references to preventing or hindering competition.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4g-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4G Lessening of competition to include preventing or hindering

4H Application of Act in relation to leases and licences of land and
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.62
note: References contracts, leases, and licences of land and buildings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-logic-alleninterval-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-logic-ltl-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4h
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the act of making or entering into a contract occurs after the lease or licence is granted
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: In this Act: ... (b) a reference to making or entering into a contract, in relation to such a lease or licence...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: there is an obligation to grant or take the lease or licence
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty
modality: Deontic
operator: =
premise text: a reference to making or entering into a contract, in relation to such a lease or licence, shall be read as a reference to granting or taking the lease or licence

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the act of referencing a contract occurs before the lease or licence is granted
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace
modality: LTL
operator: <=
premise text: In this Act: ... (a) a reference to a contract shall be construed as including a reference to a lease of, or a licence in respect of, land or a building...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4h-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4H Application of Act in relation to leases and licences of land and

4J Joint ventures
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.62
note: Definition of joint venture
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4j-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4j-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4j-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4j
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4j-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Reference to contract or arrangement
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4j-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Explicit class hierarchy
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =

4K Loss or damage to include injury
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.63
note: Reference to loss or damage includes injury.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4k-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4k
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4k-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4K Loss or damage to include injury

4KA Definitions etc. that do not apply in Part XI or Schedule 2
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.63
note: Exemptions for certain expressions in Part XI or Schedule 2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4ka-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4ka
schema version: 2

4L Severability
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.63
note: Nothing in this Act affects the validity or enforceability of a contract otherwise than in relation to a severable provision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4l-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4l
schema version: 2

4M Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.64
curation status: Proposed
has part: 4M(1) Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of
has part: 4M(2) Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4m
schema version: 2

4M(1) Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.64
note: The law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of confidence continue to apply.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4m-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 4M Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the interpretation of this Act.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The two laws overlap in time.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: but nothing in the law referred to in paragraph (a) or (b) affects...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the interpretation of this Act.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: The continued application of the law implies that it is still relevant.
modality: Argumentation
operator: Implication
premise text: Nothing in the law referred to in paragraph (a) or (b) affects...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the operation of...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The AI system can infer that the law continues to apply.
modality: CogAI
operator: Inference
premise text: This Act does not affect...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the operation of...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The law continues to apply despite the new Act.
modality: Deontic
operator: Continuation
premise text: This Act does not affect...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the interpretation of this Act.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The information about the continued application of the law is diffused through the legal system.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Propagation
premise text: but nothing in the law referred to in paragraph (a) or (b) affects...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 4M(1) Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of

4M(2) Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.64
note: Exemption from section 57CD
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4m-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 4M Saving of law relating to restraint of trade and breaches of

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4m-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: does not apply
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Section 57CD exemption
modality: Deontic
operator: Exempts
premise text: (2) Paragraph (1)(b)

4N Extended application of Part IIIA
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.64
curation status: Proposed
has part: 4N(1) Extended application of Part IIIA
has part: 4N(3) Extended application of Part IIIA
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4n
schema version: 2

4N(1) Extended application of Part IIIA
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.64
note: Part IIIA extends to services provided by facilities within certain areas.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4n-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4n-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4n-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 4N Extended application of Part IIIA

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Part IIIA extends to services provided by facilities within certain areas.
modality: Deontic
operator: extends

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4n-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Part IIIA applies to services provided by facilities within certain areas.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: appliesTo

4N(3) Extended application of Part IIIA
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.64
note: Nothing in subsection (1) affects the operation of section 15B of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 in respect of the application of
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-4n-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-4n-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 4N Extended application of Part IIIA

5 Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.65
curation status: Proposed
has part: 5(1) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
has part: 5(1A) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
has part: 5(2) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5
schema version: 2

5(1) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.65
note: Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-5-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-5-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(1) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia

5(1A) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.65
note: Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-5-ss-1a-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-5-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(1A) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia

5(2) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.65
note: Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-5-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-5-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 5 Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-5-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 5(2) Extended application of this Act to conduct outside Australia

50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
curation status: Proposed
has part: 50(1) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
has part: 50(2) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
has part: 50(3) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
has part: 50(3A) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
has part: 50(3B) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
has part: 50(4) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50
schema version: 2

50(1) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
note: Acquisition of shares or assets that would lessen competition is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...acquire shares or assets...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Direct prohibition of acquisition.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A corporation must not...

50(2) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
note: Acquire shares or assets that would substantially lessen competition in a market.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-ltl-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The acquisition is prohibited.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Directly prohibits acquiring shares or assets that would substantially lessen competition in a market.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) A person must not directly or indirectly acquire shares in the capital of a corporation; or acquire any assets of a corporation;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The acquisition is authorised.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Authorises acquisitions that would not substantially lessen competition in a market.
modality: Deontic
operator: Authorise
premise text: (Note: The person will not be prevented from making the acquisition if the person is granted an authorisation for the acquisition under section 88.)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The acquisition has a traceable effect on competition in a market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Traces the effect of acquiring shares or assets on competition in a market.
modality: LTL
operator: Trace
premise text: (2) A person must not directly or indirectly acquire shares in the capital of a corporation; or acquire any assets of a corporation;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The acquisition has a traceable effect on competition in a market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Traces the effect of acquiring shares or assets on competition in a market.
modality: LTL
operator: Trace
premise text: (Note: The person will not be prevented from making the acquisition if the person is granted an authorisation for the acquisition under section 88.)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50(2) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

50(3) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
note: Acquisitions that would result in a substantial lessening of competition are prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may not have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Acquisitions with overlapping effects on competition are prohibited.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
premise text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classifies acquisitions based on their potential impact on competition using CogAI.
modality: CogAI
operator: Classify
premise text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may not have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits acquisitions that would result in a substantial lessening of competition.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may not have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Acquisitions diffuse effects on competition.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
premise text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may not have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Acquisitions with recurring effects on competition are prohibited.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring
premise text: (3) For the purposes of this section, an acquisition may have the effect or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market if the acquisition would, in all the circumstances, have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of creating, strengthening or entrenching a substantial degree of power in the market.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50(3) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

50(3A) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
note: Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial degree of power in a market.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50-ss-3a
schema version: 2
part of: 50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The prohibition applies to acquisitions that overlap with the market.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (3A) Subsections 46(3) to (8) have effect for the purposes of this section as if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits acquisitions that would result in a substantial degree of power in a market.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3A) Subsections 46(3) to (8) have effect for the purposes of this section as if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The prohibition includes acquisitions that would result in a substantial degree of power in any market.
modality: Deontic
operator: Includes
premise text: (3A) Subsections 46(3) to (8) have effect for the purposes of this section as if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The prohibition excludes acquisitions that do not result in a substantial degree of power in any market.
modality: Deontic
operator: Excludes
premise text: (3A) Subsections 46(3) to (8) have effect for the purposes of this section as if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3a-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The prohibition is repeated in each market.
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
premise text: (b) a reference in those subsections to a market were a reference to a market (within the meaning of this section).

50(3B) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
note: Acquisitions that would result in a substantial lessening of competition are prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50-ss-3b
schema version: 2
part of: 50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-3b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits acquisitions that would result in a substantial lessening of competition.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

50(4) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.336
note: Acquisitions subject to a condition that requires authorisation before coming into force.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the provisions of the contract relating to the acquisition will not come into force unless and until the person has been granted an authorisation...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Overlaps with acquisitions subject to a condition.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlap
premise text: (4) Where:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the provisions of the contract relating to the acquisition will not come into force unless and until the person has been granted an authorisation...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognises acquisitions subject to a condition.
modality: CogAI
operator: Recognise
premise text: (4) Where:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the provisions of the contract relating to the acquisition will not come into force unless and until the person has been granted an authorisation...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits acquisitions subject to a condition.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (4) Where:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the provisions of the contract relating to the acquisition will not come into force unless and until the person has been granted an authorisation...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses acquisitions subject to a condition.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
premise text: (4) Where:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the provisions of the contract relating to the acquisition will not come into force unless and until the person has been granted an authorisation...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace with acquisitions subject to a condition.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring
premise text: (4) Where:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50-ss-4-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50(4) Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial

50A Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.338
curation status: Proposed
has part: 50A(1) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
has part: 50A(1A) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
has part: 50A(1B) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
has part: 50A(2) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50a
schema version: 2

50A(1) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.338
note: Restrictive trade practices
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 50A Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits acquiring a controlling interest in a corporation outside Australia
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50A(1) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

50A(1A) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.338
note: Matters from subsection 50(3) must be taken into account when determining the effect of obtaining a second controlling interest on competition.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50a-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 50A Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider subsection 50(3) matters
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50A(1A) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

50A(1B) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.338
note: Tribunal must consider benefits to the public when determining whether obtaining a controlling interest should be disregarded.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50a-ss-1b
schema version: 2
part of: 50A Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider benefits to the public
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-1b-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50A(1B) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

50A(2) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.338
note: Tribunal must give information to corporations
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-50a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 50A Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-50a-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 50A(2) Acquisitions that occur outside Australia before 1 January 2026

51 Exceptions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.341
note: Exceptions from contravention of Part 51
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51
schema version: 2

51AE Regulations relating to industry codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.440
curation status: Proposed
has part: 51AE(1) Regulations relating to industry codes
has part: 51AE(1A) Regulations relating to industry codes
has part: 51AE(1B) Regulations relating to industry codes
has part: 51AE(1C) Regulations relating to industry codes
has part: 51AE(1D) Regulations relating to industry codes
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51ae
schema version: 2

51AE(1) Regulations relating to industry codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.440
note: Regulations relating to industry codes may prescribe an industry code or specified provisions of an industry code.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51ae-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 51AE Regulations relating to industry codes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulations may prescribe an industry code.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 51AE(1) Regulations relating to industry codes

51AE(1A) Regulations relating to industry codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.440
note: Regulations prescribe industry codes, which confer functions and powers on persons or bodies.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51ae-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 51AE Regulations relating to industry codes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulations prescribe industry codes with functions and powers.
modality: Deontic
operator: hasFunction

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 51AE(1A) Regulations relating to industry codes

51AE(1B) Regulations relating to industry codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.440
note: List of persons or bodies that may confer functions and powers under the industry code
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1b-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51ae-ss-1b
schema version: 2
part of: 51AE Regulations relating to industry codes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1b-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes temporal relationship between events
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1b-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: List of persons or bodies that may confer functions and powers under the industry code
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1b-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 51AE(1B) Regulations relating to industry codes

51AE(1C) Regulations relating to industry codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.440
note: Code may provide for exercise of function or power through written instrument
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1c-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51ae-ss-1c
schema version: 2
part of: 51AE Regulations relating to industry codes

51AE(1D) Regulations relating to industry codes
type: Concept
description: Written instrument (exemption instrument)
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.440
note: Exemptions from industry codes must be exercised through written instruments.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1d-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1d-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51ae-ss-1d
schema version: 2
part of: 51AE Regulations relating to industry codes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1d-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a written instrument for exemptions.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51ae-ss-1d-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 51AE(1D) Regulations relating to industry codes

51AF Acquisition of property
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.444
curation status: Proposed
has part: 51AF(1) Acquisition of property
has part: 51AF(2) Acquisition of property
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51af
schema version: 2

51AF(1) Acquisition of property
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.444
note: Defines scope of application for section 51AF(1)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51af-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51af-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 51AF Acquisition of property

51AF(2) Acquisition of property
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.444
note: Provisions have no effect to the extent their operation would result in acquisition of property on just terms.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51af-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-51af-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 51AF Acquisition of property

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-51af-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 51AF(2) Acquisition of property

52A Definitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.446
note: Defines terms related to news businesses and digital platforms.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52a-logic-descriptionlogic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52a-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Section 52ZG defines bargaining parties and core bargaining issues.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Classifies terms into hierarchical categories.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: Section 52ZD defines bargaining news business representative.

52B Making content available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.448
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52B(1) Making content available
has part: 52B(2) Making content available
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52b
schema version: 2

52B(1) Making content available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.448
note: Service must make content available if it is reproduced, linked to, or extracted.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52b-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52b-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52B Making content available

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52b-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Service must make content available.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52b-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52B(1) Making content available

52B(2) Making content available
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.448
note: Service can make content available in multiple ways
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52b-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52b-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52B Making content available

52C Interacting with content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.448
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52C(1) Interacting with content
has part: 52C(2) Interacting with content
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52c
schema version: 2

52C(1) Interacting with content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.448
note: User interaction with content on a service is defined.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-ltl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52c-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52C Interacting with content

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: User interaction occurs during content placement.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: User interaction occurs during content placement.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (a) the content is reproduced on the service, or is otherwise placed on the service, and the user interacts with the content;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: User interaction with content on a service.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires user interaction.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (a) the content is reproduced on the service, or is otherwise placed on the service, and the user interacts with the content;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: User interaction with link to content on a service.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires link to content.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (b) a link to the content is provided on the service and the user interacts with the link;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: User interaction with extract of content on a service.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires extract of content.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (c) an extract of the content is provided on the service and the user interacts with the extract;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-logic-ltl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: User interaction continues until content removal.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: User interaction continues until content removal.
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: (a) the content is reproduced on the service, or is otherwise placed on the service, and the user interacts with the content;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52C(1) Interacting with content

52C(2) Interacting with content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.448
note: No limitation on user interaction with content.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52c-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52C Interacting with content

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52c-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: No obligation to limit interaction.
modality: Deontic
operator: !

52D Distributing content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.449
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52D(1) Distributing content
has part: 52D(2) Distributing content
has part: 52D(3) Distributing content
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52d
schema version: 2

52D(1) Distributing content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.449
note: Examples of ways a service distributes content
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-logic-ltl-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52d-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52D Distributing content

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Section 52D(1) occurs during Part 1
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between Part and Section
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Part 1 starts at section 52D(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Content distribution methods are allowed in this section
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permits content distribution methods
modality: Deontic
operator: allows
premise text: The key is part of a Section with examples

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-1-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Section 52D(2) occurs until Part 1
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal relation between Section and Part
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: Part 1 ends at section 52D(2)

52D(2) Distributing content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.449
note: Service may distribute content in ways not limited by this Part.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-ltl-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52d-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52D Distributing content

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service may distribute content in ways not limited by this Part.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Identifies overlapping temporal intervals
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not limit, for the purposes of this Part, the ways in which a service distributes content that is made available by the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service may distribute content in ways not limited by this Part.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Identifies permissive obligations
modality: Deontic
operator: may
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not limit, for the purposes of this Part, the ways in which a service distributes content that is made available by the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service may distribute content in ways not limited by this Part.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Identifies information diffusion
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not limit, for the purposes of this Part, the ways in which a service distributes content that is made available by the service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-2-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The service may distribute content in ways not limited by this Part.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Identifies universal temporal properties
modality: LTL
operator: holdsForAll
premise text: (2) Subsection (1) does not limit, for the purposes of this Part, the ways in which a service distributes content that is made available by the service.

52D(3) Distributing content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.449
note: Treat certain alterations to content distribution as alterations to the ways in which a service distributes content.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52d-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52D Distributing content

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the state to treat certain alterations as alterations to content distribution.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Defines a class of alterations to content distribution that must be treated by the state.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: ClassInclusion

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52d-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52D(3) Distributing content

52E Minister may make designation determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.451
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52E(1) Minister may make designation determination
has part: 52E(2) Minister may make designation determination
has part: 52E(3) Minister may make designation determination
has part: 52E(4) Minister may make designation determination
has part: 52E(5) Minister may make designation determination
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52e
schema version: 2

52E(1) Minister may make designation determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.451
note: Minister may make designation determination
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52e-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52E Minister may make designation determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May make designation determination
modality: Deontic
operator: may

52E(2) Minister may make designation determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.451
note: Designation determination may be made by the Minister.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52e-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52E Minister may make designation determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52E(2) Minister may make designation determination

52E(3) Minister may make designation determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.451
note: Minister must consider significant bargaining power imbalance and contribution to news industry sustainability when making designation determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52e-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52E Minister may make designation determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the group has made a significant contribution...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Consider time period of significant bargaining power imbalance and contribution to news industry sustainability.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: (a) whether there is a significant bargaining power imbalance...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the Minister must consider...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Minister must consider...
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (3) In making the determination, the Minister...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...through agreements relating to news content...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Consider diffusion of agreements relating to news content.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: (b) whether that group has made a significant contribution...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the group has made a significant contribution...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Consider time period of significant bargaining power imbalance and contribution to news industry sustainability.
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: (a) whether there is a significant bargaining power imbalance...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52E(3) Minister may make designation determination

52E(4) Minister may make designation determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.451
note: Minister may consider reports or advice of the Commission when making a designation determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52e-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52E Minister may make designation determination

52E(5) Minister may make designation determination
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.451
note: Minister must give corporation notice before making designation determination.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52e-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52E Minister may make designation determination

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52e-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Must give corporation notice in writing
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Minister intends to make a designation determination

52F Application for registration of news business and news business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.453
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52F(1) Application for registration of news business and news business
has part: 52F(2) Application for registration of news business and news business
has part: 52F(3) Application for registration of news business and news business
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52f
schema version: 2

52F(1) Application for registration of news business and news business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.453
note: Application for registration of news business and news business corporation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52f-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52F Application for registration of news business and news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must apply for registration.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52F(1) Application for registration of news business and news business

52F(2) Application for registration of news business and news business
type: Concept
description: Details of news sources, point of contact, and meeting requirements
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.453
note: Application must be in writing and meet specified requirements.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52f-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52F Application for registration of news business and news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be in writing
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Meet specified requirements
modality: Deontic
operator: MEET

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52F(2) Application for registration of news business and news business

52F(3) Application for registration of news business and news business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.453
note: The news business may be comprised of some or all of the news sources operated or controlled by the applicant corporation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52f-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52F Application for registration of news business and news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: news business
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval relation
modality: AllenInterval
operator: ⊆
premise text: operates or controls

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The news business may be comprised of some or all of the news sources operated or controlled by the applicant corporation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52f-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52F(3) Application for registration of news business and news business

52G Registration of news business and news business corporation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.453
note: Register news business if requirement is met
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52g-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52g-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52g
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52g-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ACMA must register the news business
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to register news business
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: requirement in subsection (2) is met

52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52H(1) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
has part: 52H(2) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
has part: 52H(3) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
has part: 52H(4) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
has part: 52H(5) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
has part: 52H(6) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h
schema version: 2

52H(1) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
note: Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation of registration or endorsement
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

52H(2) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
note: Revocation of registration or endorsement if requirements not met
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if the ACMA considers that any of the following requirements are not met in relation to the news business:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for revocation
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (2) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if the ACMA considers that any of the following requirements are not met in relation to the news business:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classifies news businesses based on AI-powered analysis
modality: CogAI
operator: Classify
premise text: (2) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if the ACMA considers that any of the following requirements are not met in relation to the news business:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation of registration or endorsement if requirements not met
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (2) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if the ACMA considers that any of the following requirements are not met in relation to the news business:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses information about revocation requirements
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffuse
premise text: (2) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if the ACMA considers that any of the following requirements are not met in relation to the news business:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Defines temporal trace for revocation
modality: LTL
operator: Temporal Trace
premise text: (2) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52H(2) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

52H(3) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
note: Revocation of registration if no endorsed corporation exists
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if there is no registered news business corporation...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation without endorsement
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (3) The ACMA may revoke...

52H(4) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
note: Revocation of registration or endorsement if not meeting revenue test
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-cogai-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-shacl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation does not meet the requirement in subsection 52M(1)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for revocation
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (4) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business corporation if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-cogai-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation does not meet the requirement in subsection 52M(1)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Represents knowledge about corporations and revocation
modality: CogAI
operator: Knowledge Representation
premise text: (4) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business corporation if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...if the ACMA considers that the corporation does not meet...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation of registration if not meeting revenue test
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (4) The ACMA may revoke the registration...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation does not meet the requirement in subsection 52M(1)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Defines recurring trace for revocation
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
premise text: (4) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business corporation if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-4-logic-shacl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the corporation does not meet the requirement in subsection 52M(1)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::shacl
logic summary: Validates corporations against revenue test
modality: SHACL
operator: Validation
premise text: (4) The ACMA may revoke the registration of a registered news business corporation if...

52H(5) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
note: Revocation of registration or endorsement for not being endorsed as a registered news business corporation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation of registration for not being endorsed
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

52H(6) Revocation of registration or endorsement—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.454
note: Revocation of endorsement for non-compliance with section 52L
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52h-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 52H Revocation of registration or endorsement—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Revocation allowed within specified timeframe
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines temporal interval for revocation of endorsement
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: ACMA may revoke endorsement at any time

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52h-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Only if corporation meets requirement in section 52L
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits revocation of endorsement for non-compliance with section 52L
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: ACMA may revoke endorsement

52I Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52I(1) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
has part: 52I(2) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
has part: 52I(3) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52i
schema version: 2

52I(1) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
note: Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52i-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52I Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Registration or endorsement is prohibited
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits false or misleading registration or endorsement
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: ACMA registered a news business

52I(2) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
note: ACMA may revoke registration or endorsement if false or misleading information is provided.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52i-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52I Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits providing false or misleading information.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52I(2) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading

52I(3) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
note: Information or documents may be false or misleading in a material particular because of the omission of a matter or thing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52i-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52I Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52i-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52I(3) Revocation of registration or endorsement—false or misleading

52J Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52J(1) Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify
has part: 52J(2) Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52j
schema version: 2

52J(1) Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
note: Registered news business corporation must notify ACMA if requirements are no longer met.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52j-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52J Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notification
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52J(1) Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify

52J(2) Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify
type: Concept
description: Notification
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.456
note: Registered news business corporation must notify in writing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52j-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52J Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notification
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52j-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52J(2) Obligation on registered news business corporation to notify

52K Adding or removing news source from registered news business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.457
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52K(1) Adding or removing news source from registered news business
has part: 52K(2) Adding or removing news source from registered news business
has part: 52K(3) Adding or removing news source from registered news business
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52k
schema version: 2

52K(1) Adding or removing news source from registered news business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.457
note: Registered news business corporation may apply to ACMA for addition or removal of a news source.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52k-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52K Adding or removing news source from registered news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to apply for addition or removal of a news source.
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-1-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52K(1) Adding or removing news source from registered news business

52K(2) Adding or removing news source from registered news business
type: Concept
description: news source that comprises the news business, specifications for added or removed sources
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.457
note: Application must be in writing and meet specified requirements.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52k-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52K Adding or removing news source from registered news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be in writing
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52K(2) Adding or removing news source from registered news business

52K(3) Adding or removing news source from registered news business
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.457
note: The ACMA may add a news source to the registered news business if certain conditions are met.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52k-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52K Adding or removing news source from registered news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52k-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expresses a permission or obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

52L Requirements for connection between corporation and news
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.458
note: Corporation must operate or control news business
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52l-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52l-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52l
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52l-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must operate or control news business
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52M Revenue test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.458
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52M(1) Revenue test
has part: 52M(2) Revenue test
has part: 52M(3) Revenue test
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52m
schema version: 2

52M(1) Revenue test
type: Concept
description: annual accounts prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.458
note: Annual revenue requirement for corporations
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52m-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52M Revenue test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires annual revenue exceeding $150,000
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52M(1) Revenue test

52M(2) Revenue test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.458
note: Revenue test for subsection (3) applicability
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52m-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52M Revenue test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52M(2) Revenue test

52M(3) Revenue test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.458
note: Treats revenue for a year as including the business' annual revenue for that year.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52m-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52M Revenue test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes a duty on the state to treat revenue in a certain way.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52m-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52M(3) Revenue test

52N Content test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52N(1) Content test
has part: 52N(2) Content test
has part: 52N(3) Content test
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52n
schema version: 2

52N(1) Content test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
note: News source must create core news content as primary purpose.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52n-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52N Content test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to create core news content.
modality: Deontic
operator: Must

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52N(1) Content test

52N(2) Content test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
note: News source must comprise news business
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52n-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52N Content test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: It must be during the time of the news business
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation to news business
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) This subsection covers a news source...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: It must comprise the news business
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be a news source
modality: Deontic
operator: =
premise text: (2) This subsection covers a news source...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52N(2) Content test

52N(3) Content test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
note: Content test: primary purpose of a news source
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52n-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52N Content test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: State has obligation to test content
modality: Deontic
operator: hasObligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52n-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52N(3) Content test

52O Australian audience test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52O(1) Australian audience test
has part: 52O(2) Australian audience test
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52o
schema version: 2

52O(1) Australian audience test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
note: News source must serve predominantly Australian audiences.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52o-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52O Australian audience test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to serve Australian audiences
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) The requirement in this subsection is met...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52O(1) Australian audience test

52O(2) Australian audience test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.459
note: News source must comprise news business
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52o-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52O Australian audience test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Obligation to be a news source
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be a news source
modality: Deontic
operator: =
premise text: News source comprises news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52o-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52O(2) Australian audience test

52P Professional standards test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.460
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52P(1) Professional standards test
has part: 52P(2) Professional standards test
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52p
schema version: 2

52P(1) Professional standards test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.460
note: News sources must comply with specific standards and codes of practice.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52p-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52P Professional standards test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must comply with standards
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52P(1) Professional standards test

52P(2) Professional standards test
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.460
note: Defines a news source as part of the relevant news business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52p-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52P Professional standards test

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: temporal interval for news source
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines temporal intervals for news sources
modality: AllenInterval
operator: includes
premise text: news source is part of the relevant news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Defines a news source as part of the relevant news business.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52p-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52P(2) Professional standards test

52Q Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.461
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52Q(1) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
has part: 52Q(2) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
has part: 52Q(3) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52q
schema version: 2

52Q(1) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.461
note: Creates obligations in respect of digital platform services individually.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52q-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52Q Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Creates obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: CREATE

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52Q(1) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually

52Q(2) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.461
note: Digital platform corporation must fulfill obligations for registered news business corporation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52q-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52Q Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Mandatory obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: must

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52Q(2) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually

52Q(3) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.461
note: Separate obligations for each responsible digital platform corporation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52q-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52Q Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Obligations applied separately
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Separating obligations among corporations
modality: Deontic
operator: Separation
premise text: Multiple corporations involved

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52q-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52Q(3) Obligations in respect of digital platform services individually

52R Giving list and explanation of data provided to registered news
type: Concept
description: information covered by subsection (2)
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.461
note: Digital platform corporation must provide information to registered news business
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52r-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52r-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52r
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52r-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Digital platform corporation must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52S Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.463
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52S(1) Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to
has part: 52S(2) Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52s
schema version: 2

52S(1) Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.463
note: Change to algorithm planned if it brings about significant alteration in content distribution.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52s-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52S Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the change is planned to be made to an algorithm of the designated digital platform service;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Significant effect on referral traffic
modality: AllenInterval
operator: <=>
premise text: (c) the change is likely to have a significant effect on the referral traffic from the designated digital platform service to the covered news content of registered news businesses (considered as a whole) that the service makes available.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (b) the dominant purpose of the change is to bring about an identified alteration to the ways in which the designated digital platform service distributes content that is made available by the service;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: if
premise text: (a) a change is planned to be made to an algorithm of the designated digital platform service;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (c) the change is likely to have a significant effect on the referral traffic from the designated digital platform service to the covered news content of registered news businesses (considered as a whole) that the service makes available.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Conditional obligation on considering referral traffic impact.
modality: Deontic
operator: if
premise text: (a) a change is planned to be made to an algorithm of the designated digital platform service;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the dominant purpose of the change is to bring about an identified alteration to the ways in which the designated digital platform service distributes content that is made available by the service;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Significant effect on referral traffic
modality: LTL
operator: <=>
premise text: (c) the change is likely to have a significant effect on the referral traffic from the designated digital platform service to the covered news content of registered news businesses (considered as a whole) that the service makes available.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52S(1) Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to

52S(2) Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.463
note: Notice must be given to registered news business corporations at least 14 days before change is made.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52s-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52S Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Registered news business corporation must receive notice
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Digital platform corporation must ensure notice is given

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52s-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52S(2) Change to algorithm to bring about identified alteration to

52V Section 52S—dominant purpose
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.464
note: Exemptions from dominant purpose test
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52v-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52v
schema version: 2

52W Section 52S—significant effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.464
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52W(1) Section 52S—significant effect
has part: 52W(2) Section 52S—significant effect
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52w
schema version: 2

52W(1) Section 52S—significant effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.464
note: Determine whether a change has the significant effect mentioned in paragraph 52S(1)(c)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52w-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52W Section 52S—significant effect

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52W(1) Section 52S—significant effect

52W(2) Section 52S—significant effect
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.464
note: Disregard specific factors when determining the significant effect of a change on covered news content.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52w-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52W Section 52S—significant effect

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...disregard the following matters:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ignoring specific factors is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Ignore
premise text: (a) whether, as a result of the change, there is likely to be a significant variation...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...disregard the following matters:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ignoring specific factors is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Ignore
premise text: (b) the relative turnover of registered news businesses...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...disregard the following matters:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ignoring specific factors is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Ignore
premise text: (c) the relative volume of covered news content created by...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...disregard the following matters:
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Ignoring specific factors is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Ignore
premise text: (d) the relative financial position of registered news businesses...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52w-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52W(2) Section 52S—significant effect

52X Recognition of original covered news content
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.465
note: Digital platform corporation must develop proposal for recognizing original covered news content.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52x-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52x-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52x
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52x-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to develop proposal
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52x-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52X Recognition of original covered news content

52Y Facilitating open communication—responsible digital platform
type: Concept
description: Details of the point of contact, acknowledgement of communications
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.466
note: Responsible digital platform corporation must set up a point of contact and acknowledge communications.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52y-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52y-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52y
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52y-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to set up a point of contact and acknowledge communications.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52y-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52Y Facilitating open communication—responsible digital platform

52Z Facilitating open communication—registered news business
type: Concept
description: point of contact, acknowledgement
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.467
note: A registered news business corporation must set up a point of contact and acknowledge communications from responsible digital platform corporations.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52z-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52z-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52z
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52z-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a point of contact and acknowledge communications.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52z-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52Z Facilitating open communication—registered news business

52ZA Trade secrets
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.467
note: No requirement to disclose trade secrets.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52za-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52za-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52za
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52za-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: No obligation to disclose trade secrets
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicable

52ZB Personal information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.467
note: No information that is personal information can be given.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zb-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zb-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zb
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zb-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits giving personal information.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

52ZC Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.468
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZC(1) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
has part: 52ZC(2) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
has part: 52ZC(3) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
has part: 52ZC(4) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zc
schema version: 2

52ZC(1) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.468
note: Digital service must be supplied without differentiation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zc-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZC Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must supply digital service
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZC(1) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

52ZC(2) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.468
note: Digital platform corporation must not differentiate between registered news businesses
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zc-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZC Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of differentiation
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Section 52ZC(2)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZC(2) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

52ZC(3) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.468
note: News business must not be part of a registered news business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zc-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZC Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal overlap with registered news business.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: OverlapsWith
premise text: (a) the news business is not a registered news businesses; and (b) none of the news sources that comprise the business form part of a registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on being part of a registered news business.
modality: Deontic
operator: MustNot
premise text: (a) the news business is not a registered news businesses; and (b) none of the news sources that comprise the business form part of a registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZC(3) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

52ZC(4) Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.468
note: Exemption from differentiation for certain agreements
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zc-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zc-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZC Digital service to be supplied without differentiating in

52ZD Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZD(1) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
has part: 52ZD(2) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
has part: 52ZD(3) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
has part: 52ZD(4) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zd
schema version: 2

52ZD(1) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: The registered news business corporation is the bargaining news business representative.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zd-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZD Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The registered news business corporation must be the bargaining news business representative.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Definition of a bargaining news business representative
modality: Deontic
operator: =
premise text: Registered news business corporation is the bargaining news business representative.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZD(1) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

52ZD(2) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
type: Concept
description: Agreement with the person
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: Registered news business corporation must appoint a bargaining news business representative in writing.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zd-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZD Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The agreement must be made before the appointment of the bargaining news business representative
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between the agreement and the appointment of the bargaining news business representative
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: Subsection (3) applies if an agreement in writing is made with a person

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is cognitively integrated into the registered news business as a bargaining news business representative
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Describes the relationship between the registered news business corporation and the person in terms of cognitive AI
modality: CogAI
operator: IS-A
premise text: The agreement provides that the person should be the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person must be the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a bargaining news business representative
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Registered news business corporation makes an agreement in writing with a person

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is diffused into the registered news business as a bargaining news business representative
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Describes the relationship between the registered news business corporation and the person in terms of diffusion
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS-A
premise text: The agreement provides that the person should be the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment of the bargaining news business representative must be after the agreement
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Describes the temporal relationship between the agreement and the appointment of the bargaining news business representative
modality: LTL
operator: <=
premise text: Subsection (3) applies if an agreement in writing is made with a person

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZD(2) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

52ZD(3) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: The person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zd-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZD Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The person has a role in the registered news business during their term as bargaining news business representative.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (3) Despite subsection (1), the person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The person has a role in the registered news business using artificial intelligence.
modality: CogAI
operator: is-a
premise text: (3) Despite subsection (1), the person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The person has a role.
modality: Deontic
operator: is
premise text: (3) Despite subsection (1), the person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: The person has a role in the registered news business if and only if they are the bargaining news business representative.
modality: Diffusion
operator: if-and-only-if
premise text: (3) Despite subsection (1), the person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: The person has a role in the registered news business if they are the bargaining news business representative.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: =>
premise text: (3) Despite subsection (1), the person is the bargaining news business representative for the registered news business.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZD(3) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

52ZD(4) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: A person can be the bargaining news business representative for 2 or more registered news businesses.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zd-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZD Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zd-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZD(4) Bargaining news business representative for a registered news

52ZE Notification of bargaining
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZE(1) Notification of bargaining
has part: 52ZE(2) Notification of bargaining
has part: 52ZE(3) Notification of bargaining
has part: 52ZE(4) Notification of bargaining
has part: 52ZE(5) Notification of bargaining
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52ze
schema version: 2

52ZE(1) Notification of bargaining
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: News business representative must notify digital platform corporation
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52ze-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZE Notification of bargaining

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notification
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZE(1) Notification of bargaining

52ZE(2) Notification of bargaining
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: Notification of bargaining may relate to some or all registered news businesses.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52ze-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZE Notification of bargaining

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZE(2) Notification of bargaining

52ZE(3) Notification of bargaining
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: Notification of bargaining for multiple digital platform services
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52ze-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZE Notification of bargaining

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZE(3) Notification of bargaining

52ZE(4) Notification of bargaining
type: Concept
description: yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: Notification requirements for bargaining news business representatives
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52ze-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZE Notification of bargaining

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the specified issues mentioned in subsection (1);
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Specify temporal intervals for notification requirements
modality: AllenInterval
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (4) A notification made for the purposes of subsection (1) must set out...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...those matters.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Specify issues mentioned in subsection (1)
modality: CogAI
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (e) the specified issues mentioned in subsection (1);

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...those matters.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notification details
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (4) A notification made for the purposes of subsection (1) must set out...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (d) the responsible digital platform corporation for the designated digital platform service;
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Specify digital platforms and corporations involved
modality: Diffusion
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (c) the designated digital platform service;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the specified issues mentioned in subsection (1);
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Specify temporal intervals for notification requirements
modality: LTL
operator: CONTAINS
premise text: (4) A notification made for the purposes of subsection (1) must set out...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZE(4) Notification of bargaining

52ZE(5) Notification of bargaining
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.472
note: Cannot later vary a notification to relate to a registered news business not set out in the notification.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52ze-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZE Notification of bargaining

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52ze-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: later varied to relate to a registered news business that was not set out in the notification.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: Cannot
premise text: Notification made for the purposes of subsection (1)

52ZF Application of Subdivision
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.473
note: Notification requirement for subsection 52ZE(1) applicability
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zf-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zf
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zf-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZF Application of Subdivision

52ZG Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZG(1) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
has part: 52ZG(2) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
has part: 52ZG(3) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
has part: 52ZG(4) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zg
schema version: 2

52ZG(1) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Defines bargaining parties for a digital platform service
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zg-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZG Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZG(1) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented

52ZG(2) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Bargaining parties may agree to bargain over extra specified issues.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zg-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZG Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Permission granted to bargain
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Describes the permission to bargain
modality: Deontic
operator: may
premise text: The bargaining parties may agree...

52ZG(3) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: List of core bargaining issues
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zg-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZG Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes obligation on bargaining parties
modality: Deontic
operator: imposes

52ZG(4) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Each registered news business to which the notification relates is a represented registered news business.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zg-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZG Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Asserts existence of a represented registered news business.
modality: Deontic
operator: is

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zg-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZG(4) Bargaining parties, core bargaining issues and represented

52ZH Obligation to negotiate in good faith
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Each bargaining party must negotiate in good faith over each core bargaining issue.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zh-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zh-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zh
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zh-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to negotiate in good faith
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zh-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZH Obligation to negotiate in good faith

52ZI Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZI(1) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
has part: 52ZI(2) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
has part: 52ZI(3) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
has part: 52ZI(4) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zi
schema version: 2

52ZI(1) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Notify Commission if agreement reached within 3 months Notify Commission if agreement reached
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zi-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZI Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must notify Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) This section applies if...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Notify Commission if no agreement reached
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (a) the bargaining parties have not reached agreement over each core bargaining issue within 3 months after the notification was made for the purposes of subsection 52ZE(1); or

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Notify Commission if mediation agreed upon
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (b) the bargaining parties agree to refer the core bargaining issues to mediation under this Subdivision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to notify
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZI(1) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

52ZI(2) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Each bargaining party must participate in a mediation about the core bargaining issues. Notify Commission if agreement reached
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zi-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZI Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must participate in mediation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZI(2) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

52ZI(3) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Notify Commission of agreement reached in good faith negotiations. Regulations may incorporate existing instruments or writings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zi-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZI Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to notify Commission.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZI(3) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

52ZI(4) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.474
note: Mediator must be appointed by ACMA Notify Commission if agreement reached
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zi-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZI Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must appoint mediator
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zi-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZI(4) Obligation to notify Commission if agreement reached

52ZJ Bargaining over other issues
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.476
note: Nothing in this Division limits the bargaining parties to negotiating only over the core bargaining issues.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zj-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zj
schema version: 2

52ZK Register of bargaining code arbitrators
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZK(1) Register of bargaining code arbitrators
has part: 52ZK(2) Register of bargaining code arbitrators
has part: 52ZK(3) Register of bargaining code arbitrators
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zk
schema version: 2

52ZK(1) Register of bargaining code arbitrators
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
note: Establish and keep a register of bargaining code arbitrators
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zk-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZK Register of bargaining code arbitrators

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must establish and keep a register
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52ZK(2) Register of bargaining code arbitrators
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
note: Each person listed on the register must have appropriate experience to be a member of an arbitral panel.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zk-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZK Register of bargaining code arbitrators

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Has experience in economic matters or industry matters
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Experience must be relevant to industry matters
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: Person listed on the register

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Has appropriate experience
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must have experience
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Person listed on the register

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZK(2) Register of bargaining code arbitrators

52ZK(3) Register of bargaining code arbitrators
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
note: Consider requirements in regulations when listing a person on the register.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zk-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZK Register of bargaining code arbitrators

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Requirements are considered between listing and starting arbitration
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for considering requirements
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: ACMA must consider requirements when listing a person on the register

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Requirements are classifications of regulations
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classification of requirements in regulations
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: Requirements are classifications of listing a person on the register

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ACMA must consider requirements
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consider requirements
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: ACMA must list a person on the register

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Requirements diffuse to listing a person on the register
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion of requirements to listing a person on the register
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: Requirements are classifications of listing a person on the register

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zk-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Listing a person on the register is within the temporal interval of starting arbitration
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal interval for listing a person on the register
modality: LTL
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: ACMA must list a person on the register

52ZL Notification of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZL(1) Notification of arbitration
has part: 52ZL(2) Notification of arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zl
schema version: 2

52ZL(1) Notification of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
note: Notification of arbitration required for remuneration issue
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zl-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZL Notification of arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notification
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) This section applies if: (a) a notification has been made for the purposes of subsection 52ZE(1) to a responsible digital platform corporation for a designated digital platform service;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZL(1) Notification of arbitration

52ZL(2) Notification of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.477
note: Notification of arbitration required when conditions are met
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zl-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZL Notification of arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to notify Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zl-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZL(2) Notification of arbitration

52ZM Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZM(1) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(2) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(3) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(4) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(5) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(6) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(7) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(8) Formation of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZM(9) Formation of arbitral panel
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm
schema version: 2

52ZM(1) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Notice must be given under subsection 52ZL(5)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This section applies
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Notice has been given under subsection 52ZL(5)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZM(1) Formation of arbitral panel

52ZM(2) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: An arbitral panel must be formed to arbitrate about the remuneration issue.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide an arbitral panel
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZM(2) Formation of arbitral panel

52ZM(3) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Membership of arbitral panel must be comprised of Chair and two other members.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Membership obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZM(3) Formation of arbitral panel

52ZM(4) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Members of the panel must be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-cogai-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-shacl-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The appointment must occur within a specific time frame
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for appointment
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: The members of the panel are to be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-cogai-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision can be applied using artificial intelligence
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Artificial intelligence application
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: The members of the panel are to be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Members of the panel must be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to appoint panel members
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The members of the panel are to be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If there is an agreement, then the members of the panel must be appointed
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Conditional obligation
modality: LinearLogic
operator: ⇒
premise text: The members of the panel are to be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-4-logic-shacl-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This provision can be validated using schema-based methods
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::shacl
logic summary: Schema-based validation
modality: SHACL
operator: IS_A
premise text: The members of the panel are to be appointed by agreement between the bargaining parties.

52ZM(5) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Agreement to appoint persons not listed on register of bargaining code arbitrators.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-5-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

52ZM(6) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Notice of appointment of arbitral panel members must be provided to Commission and ACMA.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Date range for notice
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (a) specifies: (i) the name (or names) of the person (or persons) appointed; and (ii) the date of the agreement;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Notice implies appointment
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: (a) specifies: (i) the name (or names) of the person (or persons) appointed; and (ii) the date of the agreement;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Notice validates appointment
modality: CogAI
operator: VALIDATES
premise text: (a) specifies: (i) the name (or names) of the person (or persons) appointed; and (ii) the date of the agreement;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide notice
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-6-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Notice spreads to Commission and ACMA
modality: Diffusion
operator: SPREADS
premise text: (a) specifies: (i) the name (or names) of the person (or persons) appointed; and (ii) the date of the agreement;

52ZM(7) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Notice must be given within a specified time period after subsection 52ZL(5) notice.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The specified time period is greater than or equal to the notice deadline.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval relationship.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: The notice must be given by the end of the specified time period.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The notice is related to artificial intelligence.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Relates to artificial intelligence.
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: The notice must be given within a specified time period.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Notice must be given by the end of the specified time period.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be given within a specified time period.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Subsection 52ZL(5) notice was given.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The notice is related to the spread of information.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Relates to the spread of information.
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: The notice must be given within a specified time period.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The specified time period is greater than or equal to the notice deadline.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Temporal interval relationship.
modality: LTL
operator: >=
premise text: The notice must be given by the end of the specified time period.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-7-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZM(7) Formation of arbitral panel

52ZM(8) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: ACMA must make appointment(s) if bargaining parties cannot agree.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to make appointment(s)
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-8-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZM(8) Formation of arbitral panel

52ZM(9) Formation of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.478
note: Appointment of arbitrator must be from register
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-9-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zm-ss-9
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZM Formation of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zm-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: From register
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Mandatory appointment
modality: Deontic
operator: must
premise text: Appointment of arbitrator

52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZN(1) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
has part: 52ZN(2) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
has part: 52ZN(3) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
has part: 52ZN(4) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
has part: 52ZN(5) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
has part: 52ZN(6) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn
schema version: 2

52ZN(1) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
description: Reasonable opportunity to declare actual or potential conflicts of interest
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
note: ACMA must declare conflicts of interest before appointing a panel member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52ZN(2) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
note: Declaration of conflicts of interest before appointment to panel.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to declare conflicts of interest.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZN(2) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

52ZN(3) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
note: ACMA may remove a panel member with conflict of interest
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person should no longer be on the panel
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits a person from being on the panel with conflict of interest
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: ACMA has reason to consider a conflict of interest

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person should receive notice before being removed from the panel
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires ACMA to give notice to the person before removing them from the panel
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate
premise text: ACMA has reason to consider a conflict of interest

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person should not be on the panel
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prevents a person with conflict of interest from serving on the panel
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: ACMA has reason to consider a conflict of interest

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person should be removed from the panel after notice is given
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires ACMA to take action before removing a panel member with conflict of interest
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate
premise text: ACMA has reason to consider a conflict of interest

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person should not be removed from the panel without notice
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prevents ACMA from removing a panel member with conflict of interest without giving notice
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: ACMA has reason to consider a conflict of interest

52ZN(4) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
description: yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
note: ACMA must disclose conflicts of interest upon appointment
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Disclosure must occur soon after notice is given
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (4) If the ACMA gives a notice under paragraph (3)(a), the ACMA must, as soon as practicable: (a) give a copy of the notice to the bargaining parties; and (b) make an appointment of another person as a member of the panel.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to disclose conflicts of interest
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide copy of notice to bargaining parties
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (4) If the ACMA gives a notice under paragraph (3)(a), the ACMA must, as soon as practicable: (a) give a copy of the notice to the bargaining parties; and (b) make an appointment of another person as a member of the panel.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Disclosure must occur soon after notice is given
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (4) If the ACMA gives a notice under paragraph (3)(a), the ACMA must, as soon as practicable: (a) give a copy of the notice to the bargaining parties; and (b) make an appointment of another person as a member of the panel.

52ZN(5) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
note: ACMA must appoint only persons listed on the register of bargaining code arbitrators.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment made only if condition met.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The appointment is conditional on the person being listed during a specific period.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Person to be appointed must be listed before appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment made only if condition met.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: ACMA's appointment is conditional on the person being listed.
modality: Deontic
operator: onlyIf
premise text: Person to be appointed must be listed on the register.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment made only if condition met.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The appointment is conditional on the person being a registered arbitrator.
modality: Deontic
operator: mustBe
premise text: Person to be appointed must be an arbitrator.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment made only if condition met.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The appointment is conditional on the person being listed before appointment.
modality: Deontic
operator: mustBe
premise text: Person to be appointed must be listed before appointment.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-5-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Appointment made only if condition met.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The appointment is conditional on the person being listed until a certain point in time.
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: Person to be appointed must be listed before appointment.

52ZN(6) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.480
note: Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zn-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZN Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The interest conflicts with the arbitration during its duration
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship between interests and arbitration
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: The person has an interest that could conflict with the proper performance of their functions in relation to the arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person's functions cannot be properly performed in relation to the arbitration
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Implication of a conflict of interest on arbitration
modality: Argumentation
operator: implies
premise text: The person has a conflict of interest in relation to the arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ACMA recognizes the conflict of interest
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Recognition of conflicts of interest by ACMA
modality: CogAI
operator: recognizes
premise text: ACMA appoints a person with a conflict of interest

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The person has a conflict of interest
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Possession of a conflict of interest
modality: Deontic
operator: has
premise text: The person has any interest, pecuniary or otherwise

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The conflict of interest spreads to other areas of the person's functions
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Spread of conflicts of interest
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: The person has an interest that could conflict with the proper performance of their functions in relation to the arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zn-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZN(6) Disclosure of conflicts of interest where ACMA appoints

52ZO Costs of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZO(1) Costs of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZO(2) Costs of arbitral panel
has part: 52ZO(3) Costs of arbitral panel
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zo
schema version: 2

52ZO(1) Costs of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Each party must pay half of the costs of each panel member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zo-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZO Costs of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide costs
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZO(1) Costs of arbitral panel

52ZO(2) Costs of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Each member of the panel must determine their costs.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zo-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZO Costs of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Each member of the panel must determine their costs.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to provide costs
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZO(2) Costs of arbitral panel

52ZO(3) Costs of arbitral panel
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Comply with rules for costs of arbitral panel
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zo-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZO Costs of arbitral panel

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zo-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to comply
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52ZP Chair to notify start of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZP(1) Chair to notify start of arbitration
has part: 52ZP(2) Chair to notify start of arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zp
schema version: 2

52ZP(1) Chair to notify start of arbitration
type: Concept
description: Notification
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Chair must notify start of arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zp-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZP Chair to notify start of arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to notify
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZP(1) Chair to notify start of arbitration

52ZP(2) Chair to notify start of arbitration
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Chair must provide written notice with specified requirements.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zp-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZP Chair to notify start of arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Chair has a duty to provide written notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zp-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZP(2) Chair to notify start of arbitration

52ZQ Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZQ(1) Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra
has part: 52ZQ(2) Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zq
schema version: 2

52ZQ(1) Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Agreement to deal with extra services in arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zq-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zq-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zq-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZQ Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zq-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to deal with extra services
modality: Deontic
operator: May

52ZQ(2) Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.481
note: Bargaining parties' agreement about dealing with extra
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zq-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zq-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZQ Bargaining parties’ agreement about dealing with extra

52ZR Application
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Application condition
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zr-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zr
schema version: 2

52ZS Obligation to participate in arbitration in good faith
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Must participate in arbitration in good faith
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zs-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zs-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zs
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zs-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to act
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zs-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZS Obligation to participate in arbitration in good faith

52ZT Information request by bargaining party—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZT(1) Information request by bargaining party—general
has part: 52ZT(2) Information request by bargaining party—general
has part: 52ZT(3) Information request by bargaining party—general
has part: 52ZT(4) Information request by bargaining party—general
has part: 52ZT(5) Information request by bargaining party—general
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zt
schema version: 2

52ZT(1) Information request by bargaining party—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Request for specified information from other party
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zt-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZT Information request by bargaining party—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The request must be made before the end of this period
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Request must be made within 5 business days after arbitration start
modality: AllenInterval
operator: During
premise text: Arbitration starts on a specific date

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The request is justified by the purpose of the Division
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Request is reasonable for purposes of Division
modality: Argumentation
operator: For
premise text: The bargaining party has a reason to make the request

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The request is valid because it comes from the right entity
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Request is made by a bargaining party
modality: CogAI
operator: For
premise text: The request comes from a legitimate source

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The other bargaining party must provide specified information
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Request for information is permitted
modality: Deontic
operator: May
premise text: The bargaining party has the right to request information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-1-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A new request is not allowed for this arbitration
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Request must not be repeated in respect of same arbitration
modality: Diffusion
operator: If
premise text: The bargaining party has already made a previous request

52ZT(2) Information request by bargaining party—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Information request by bargaining party—general
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zt-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZT Information request by bargaining party—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) This subsection covers information that is held by any of the following:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZT(2) Information request by bargaining party—general

52ZT(3) Information request by bargaining party—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Request for information must be in writing and set out reasons.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zt-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZT Information request by bargaining party—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must be made in writing
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52ZT(4) Information request by bargaining party—general
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Bargaining party must provide a copy of the request to the panel on the same day.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zt-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZT Information request by bargaining party—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZT(4) Information request by bargaining party—general

52ZT(5) Information request by bargaining party—general
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.482
note: Ensure timely compliance with information request
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zt-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZT Information request by bargaining party—general

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zt-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to comply
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZU(1) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
has part: 52ZU(2) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
has part: 52ZU(3) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
has part: 52ZU(4) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
has part: 52ZU(5) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
has part: 52ZU(6) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu
schema version: 2

52ZU(1) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Request for ruling on reasonableness of information request
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZU(1) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

52ZU(2) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Application must be made within 10 business days after request is given.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-ltl-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The application is between 10 business days and the date the request was given.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Application must be made within a specified timeframe.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (2) An application under subsection (1) can be made no later than 10 business days after the bargaining party gives the request to the other bargaining party.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The application must be made within 10 business days after the request is given.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within the specified timeframe.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) An application under subsection (1) can be made no later than 10 business days after the bargaining party gives the request to the other bargaining party.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The application shall be made within 10 business days after the request is given.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Application must be made within 10 business days after request is given.
modality: Deontic
operator: SHALL
premise text: (2) An application under subsection (1) can be made no later than 10 business days after the bargaining party gives the request to the other bargaining party.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-2-logic-ltl-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The application must be made within 10 business days after the request is given.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Application must be made within a specified timeframe.
modality: LTL
operator: WITHIN
premise text: (2) An application under subsection (1) can be made no later than 10 business days after the bargaining party gives the request to the other bargaining party.

52ZU(3) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Panel must make a ruling within 10 business days after an application is made.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to make a ruling within a specified timeframe.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZU(3) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

52ZU(4) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: The ruling may relate to all or a specified part of the information requested.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The ruling overlaps with the requested information
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Overlaps with the requested information
modality: AllenInterval
operator: overlaps-with
premise text: (4) The ruling may relate to all or a specified part of the information requested.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The ruling involves the requested information
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Involves the requested information
modality: CogAI
operator: involves
premise text: (4) The ruling may relate to all or a specified part of the information requested.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The ruling relates to the requested information
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Relates to the requested information
modality: Deontic
operator: relates
premise text: (4) The ruling may relate to all or a specified part of the information requested.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The ruling diffuses the requested information
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffuses the requested information
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (4) The ruling may relate to all or a specified part of the information requested.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The ruling overlaps with the requested information
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Overlaps with the requested information
modality: LTL
operator: overlaps-with
premise text: (4) The ruling may relate to all or a specified part of the information requested.

52ZU(5) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Panel must consider specified matters when making a ruling.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The panel must consider the specified matters.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to consider matters
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: The panel must make a ruling.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-5-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZU(5) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

52ZU(6) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: No obligation to provide information beyond what is reasonable
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zu-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZU Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zu-ss-6-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZU(6) Information request by bargaining party—challenges by

52ZV Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZV(1) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
has part: 52ZV(2) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
has part: 52ZV(3) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
has part: 52ZV(4) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
has part: 52ZV(5) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zv
schema version: 2

52ZV(1) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: No information must be given that would reveal a trade secret.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zv-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZV Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits disclosure of trade secrets.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

52ZV(2) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: No personal information may be provided.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zv-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZV Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits providing personal information.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

52ZV(3) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Ensure information is not used for purposes other than arbitration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zv-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZV Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the other bargaining party must ensure...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to ensure information is not used for purposes other than arbitration.
modality: Deontic
operator: obligation
premise text: (3) If a bargaining party gives information...

52ZV(4) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Regulations specify a different number of business days in respect of a provision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zv-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZV Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Regulations specify a different number of business days between provisions.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: between
premise text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Regulations specify a different number of business days if certain conditions are met.
modality: CogAI
operator: if
premise text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulations specify a different number of business days.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Regulations specify a different number of business days if certain conditions are met.
modality: Diffusion
operator: if
premise text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Regulations specify a different number of business days between provisions.
modality: LTL
operator: between
premise text: (4) Subsection (5) applies if: (a) there is a reference to a number of business days in a provision in section 52ZT or 52ZU; and (b) regulations made for the purposes of this paragraph specify a different number of business days in respect of that provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZV(4) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous

52ZV(5) Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.484
note: Clarifies business days for information request
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zv-ss-5-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zv-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZV Information request by bargaining party—miscellaneous

52ZW Agreed early termination of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.485
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZW(1) Agreed early termination of arbitration
has part: 52ZW(2) Agreed early termination of arbitration
has part: 52ZW(3) Agreed early termination of arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zw
schema version: 2

52ZW(1) Agreed early termination of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.485
note: Agreement for early termination of arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zw-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZW Agreed early termination of arbitration

52ZW(2) Agreed early termination of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.485
note: Notify Chair of agreement upon making
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zw-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZW Agreed early termination of arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must notify
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZW(2) Agreed early termination of arbitration

52ZW(3) Agreed early termination of arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.485
note: Parties must notify Chair of agreement before arbitration terminates early.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zw-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZW Agreed early termination of arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide notification
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zw-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZW(3) Agreed early termination of arbitration

52ZX Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZX(1) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(2) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(3) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(4) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(5) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(6) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(7) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(8) Final offer arbitration
has part: 52ZX(9) Final offer arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx
schema version: 2

52ZX(1) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
description: Terms for resolving the remuneration issue
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: The panel must determine terms for resolving the remuneration issue in accordance with certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The panel must determine the terms.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty to determine terms
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(1) Final offer arbitration

52ZX(2) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: Submit final offer and provide copy to Commission
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must submit final offer
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(2) Final offer arbitration

52ZX(3) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: Commission must provide copy of final offer to other bargaining party upon request.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(3) Final offer arbitration

52ZX(4) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: A final offer must be submitted within a certain timeframe.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide a final offer within the specified timeframe.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(4) Final offer arbitration

52ZX(5) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: An offer that does not comply with subsection (4) is not a final offer.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: final offer
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative assertion of obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: (4)

52ZX(6) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: Cannot withdraw or amend a final offer after submission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of withdrawal/amendment
modality: Deontic
operator: cannot
premise text: (6) A final offer, once submitted, cannot be withdrawn or amended.

52ZX(7) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: Panel must not accept final offers deemed detrimental to covered news content or Australian consumers.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel considers that each final offer is not in the public interest.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for detrimental final offers.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: (7) The panel must accept one of the final offers unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel considers that each final offer is not in the public interest.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Classification of detrimental final offers by CogAI.
modality: CogAI
operator: Classification
premise text: (7) The panel must accept one of the final offers unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel considers that each final offer is not in the public interest.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of accepting detrimental final offers.
modality: Deontic
operator: Must Not
premise text: (7) The panel must accept one of the final offers unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel considers that each final offer is not in the public interest.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Diffusion of detrimental final offers.
modality: Diffusion
operator: Diffusion
premise text: (7) The panel must accept one of the final offers unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel considers that each final offer is not in the public interest.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Recurring trace for detrimental final offers.
modality: LTL
operator: Recurring Trace
premise text: (7) The panel must accept one of the final offers unless...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-7-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(7) Final offer arbitration

52ZX(8) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: Panel must adjust final offer to be in public interest if not accepted.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-8-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Duty obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-8-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(8) Final offer arbitration

52ZX(9) Final offer arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.486
note: Panel must take action if one party fails to submit final offer
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zx-ss-9
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZX Final offer arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Panel must take action
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between offer submission and panel action
modality: AllenInterval
operator: >=
premise text: If one party fails to submit final offer for what the remuneration amount should be, in accordance with subsection (4)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Panel must take action
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Failure to submit offer implies panel action
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: One party fails to submit final offer for what the remuneration amount should be, in accordance with subsection (4)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Part IVBA News media and digital platforms mandatory bargaining code
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Relates to cognitive AI applications
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: Chapter 4 Provisions relating to particular industries, payment surcharges etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Panel must take action
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must take action
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: One party fails to submit final offer

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Part IVBA News media and digital platforms mandatory bargaining code
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Relates to diffusion of information
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS_A
premise text: Chapter 4 Provisions relating to particular industries, payment surcharges etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zx-ss-9-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZX(9) Final offer arbitration

52ZY Final offer arbitration—termination of arbitration if no final
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.488
note: Arbitration terminates if no final offer is submitted
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zy-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zy-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zy
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zy-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits submission of a final offer
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

52ZZ Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.489
curation status: Proposed
has part: 52ZZ(1) Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.
has part: 52ZZ(2) Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zz
schema version: 2

52ZZ(1) Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.489
note: Determine final offer submission deadline within specified timeframe. Panel must consider certain matters when making a determination under subsection 52ZX(1)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-diffusion-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-cogai-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zz-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZZ Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Panel must consider cost and remuneration amounts within a certain range
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (c) the reasonable cost to the registered news business of producing covered news content;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Panel must consider the impact of remuneration amounts on commercial interests
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: (d) whether a particular remuneration amount would place an undue burden on the commercial interests of the designated digital platform service.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-cogai-6
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Panel must consider AI-related aspects when making a determination
modality: CogAI
operator: IS_A
premise text: (1) In making a determination under subsection 52ZX(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must determine final offer submission deadline.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) The panel must make the determination no later than 35 business days...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Panel must consider certain matters
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (1) In making a determination under subsection 52ZX(1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Panel must consider the impact of remuneration amounts on multiple parties
modality: Diffusion
operator: SPREADS_TO
premise text: (ca) the reasonable cost to the designated digital platform service of making available covered news content in Australia;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZZ(1) Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.

52ZZ(2) Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.489
note: Consider bargaining power imbalance in arbitration
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-52zz-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 52ZZ Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel must consider...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Consideration of bargaining power imbalance is within the scope of arbitration
modality: AllenInterval
operator: BETWEEN
premise text: (2) In considering the matters set out in subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel must consider...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Consideration of bargaining power imbalance implies consideration of other matters
modality: Argumentation
operator: IMPLIES
premise text: (2) In considering the matters set out in subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel must consider...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Consideration of bargaining power imbalance is a type of consideration
modality: CogAI
operator: IS-A
premise text: (2) In considering the matters set out in subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The panel must consider...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must consider
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: (2) In considering the matters set out in subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the panel must consider...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Consideration of bargaining power imbalance spreads to other matters
modality: Diffusion
operator: IS-SPREAD-TO
premise text: (2) In considering the matters set out in subsection (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-52zz-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 52ZZ(2) Matters to consider in arbitration, etc.

53 Object of this Part
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.506
note: Enhance the welfare of Australians through regulation of the Australian gas market and limitation of increases in gas prices.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulation is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53 Object of this Part

53A Simplified outline
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.506
note: No scheme for avoiding gas market code or emergency price order
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No scheme is allowed
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of scheme for avoiding gas market code or emergency price order
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: A person must not enter into a scheme...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53a-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53A Simplified outline

53B Definitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.507
note: Definitions for Part IVBB
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53b-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53b-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53b-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53b
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53b-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: agreement is a subclass of contract
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Class hierarchy
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Applicable
premise text: agreement includes a contract

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53b-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: constitutional corporation is a subclass of corporation
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Subclass relationship
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Applicable
premise text: constitutional corporation means a corporation to which paragraph 51(xx) of the Constitution applies

53C Gas market conduct
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.509
note: Defines gas market conduct
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53c-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53c-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53c
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53c-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes various actions related to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53c-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53C Gas market conduct

53D Gas market participants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.510
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53D(1) Gas market participants
has part: 53D(2) Gas market participants
has part: 53D(3) Gas market participants
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53d
schema version: 2

53D(1) Gas market participants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.510
note: Definition of a gas market participant
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53d-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53D Gas market participants

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Inclusion in a class
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: The joint venture includes gas market conduct

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Class hierarchy
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: =
premise text: A gas market participant is any of the following:

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53D(1) Gas market participants

53D(2) Gas market participants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.510
note: Person or body prescribed by regulations is not a gas market participant.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53d-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53D Gas market participants

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: is not a gas market participant.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53D(2) Gas market participants

53D(3) Gas market participants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.510
note: Geographical application of subsection (1) subject to subsection (2)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53d-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53d-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53D Gas market participants

53E Extension to external Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.511
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53E(1) Extension to external Territories
has part: 53E(2) Extension to external Territories
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53e
schema version: 2

53E(1) Extension to external Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.511
note: The gas market provisions extend to every external Territory.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53e-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53e-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53E Extension to external Territories

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53e-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53E(1) Extension to external Territories

53E(2) Extension to external Territories
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.511
note: A reference in the gas market provisions to Australia includes a reference to the external Territories.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53e-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53e-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53E Extension to external Territories

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53e-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The external Territories are included in the reference to Australia
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Inclusion relation
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: Australia is a country

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53e-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53E(2) Extension to external Territories

53F Extraterritorial operation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.511
note: Provisions extend to acts, omissions, matters and things outside Australia.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53f-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53f
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53f-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53F Extraterritorial operation

53G Geographical application of offences
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.511
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53g-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53g
schema version: 2

53H Geographical application—supplies and acquisitions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.511
note: The gas market provisions apply in relation to supplying a gas commodity if the supply occurs in Australia or is imported into Australia.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-ltl-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-deontic-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-descriptionlogic-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53h
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the supply: (b) is:...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: The gas market provisions apply to supplying a gas commodity at the time of importation.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Application
premise text: (b) is: i) to a person in Australia, including by means of importing the gas commodity into Australia;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the supply: (a) occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The gas market provisions apply to supplying a gas commodity.
modality: Deontic
operator: Applicability
premise text: (1) The gas market provisions apply in relation to supplying a gas commodity if the supply occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the supply: (a) occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The state has an obligation to apply the gas market provisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (1) The gas market provisions apply in relation to supplying a gas commodity if the supply occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the supply: (a) occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: The gas market provisions apply to supplying a gas commodity.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Applicability
premise text: (1) The gas market provisions apply in relation to supplying a gas commodity if the supply occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-descriptionlogic-6
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the supply: (a) occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: The state has an obligation to apply the gas market provisions.
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (1) The gas market provisions apply in relation to supplying a gas commodity if the supply occurs in Australia; or (b) is:...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-logic-ltl-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the supply: (b) is:...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: The gas market provisions apply to supplying a gas commodity at the time of importation.
modality: LTL
operator: Temporal Application
premise text: (b) is: i) to a person in Australia, including by means of importing the gas commodity into Australia;

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53h-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53H Geographical application—supplies and acquisitions

53J Gas market provisions bind the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53J(1) Gas market provisions bind the Crown
has part: 53J(2) Gas market provisions bind the Crown
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53j
schema version: 2

53J(1) Gas market provisions bind the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
note: The Crown is bound by the gas market provisions in all its capacities.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53j-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53J Gas market provisions bind the Crown

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Crown is obligated to comply with the gas market provisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

53J(2) Gas market provisions bind the Crown
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
note: The Crown is not liable to a pecuniary penalty or prosecution for an offence.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53j-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53J Gas market provisions bind the Crown

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Crown is prohibited from being liable to a pecuniary penalty.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: The Crown is not liable to a pecuniary penalty.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53j-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Crown is prohibited from being prosecuted for an offence.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: The Crown is not subject to prosecution for an offence.

53K Application to government entities
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53K(1) Application to government entities
has part: 53K(2) Application to government entities
has part: 53K(3) Application to government entities
has part: 53K(4) Application to government entities
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53k
schema version: 2

53K(1) Application to government entities
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
note: The gas market provisions apply to government entities.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53k-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53K Application to government entities

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The gas market provisions apply.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Applicability of the gas market provisions
modality: Deontic
operator: apply
premise text: The entity is covered by subsection (3) or (4)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53K(1) Application to government entities

53K(2) Application to government entities
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
note: Does not limit the ability of a gas market instrument to limit its application in relation to an entity covered by subsection (3) or (4).
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53k-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53K Application to government entities

53K(3) Application to government entities
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
note: Entities covered by this subsection
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53k-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53K Application to government entities

53K(4) Application to government entities
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.512
note: Entity covered by this subsection includes government entities and certain public bodies.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53k-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 53K Application to government entities

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-4-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Entity is covered by this subsection
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation to office duties
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Entity holds or performs the duties of an office

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53k-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Entity covered by this subsection includes government entities and certain public bodies.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligate

53L Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53L(1) Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
has part: 53L(2) Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53l
schema version: 2

53L(1) Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Regulations may prescribe matters required or permitted by this Act to be prescribed by a gas market code.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53l-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53l-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53L Regulations may prescribe gas market codes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53l-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53L(1) Regulations may prescribe gas market codes

53L(2) Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53l-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53l-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53l-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53L Regulations may prescribe gas market codes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53l-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulations may prescribe gas market codes
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53l-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53L(2) Regulations may prescribe gas market codes

53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53M(1) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(2) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(3) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(4) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(5) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(6) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(7) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
has part: 53M(8) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m
schema version: 2

53M(1) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to make orders
modality: Deontic
operator: May

53M(2) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Exemptions from certain actions in gas market emergency price orders
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...create an offence; ...provide powers of: ...impose a tax; ...set an amount to be appropriated from the Consolidated Revenue Fund under an appropriation in this Act;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Exemptions apply during gas market emergency price orders
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) To avoid doubt, a gas market emergency price order may not do...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...create an offence; ...provide powers of: ...impose a tax; ...set an amount to be appropriated from the Consolidated Revenue Fund under an appropriation in this Act;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Exemptions apply during gas market emergency price orders
modality: CogAI
operator: during
premise text: (2) To avoid doubt, a gas market emergency price order may not do...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...create an offence; ...provide powers of: ...impose a tax; ...set an amount to be appropriated from the Consolidated Revenue Fund under an appropriation in this Act;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exemptions from certain actions
modality: Deontic
operator: excludedBy
premise text: (2) To avoid doubt, a gas market emergency price order may not do...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...create an offence; ...provide powers of: ...impose a tax; ...set an amount to be appropriated from the Consolidated Revenue Fund under an appropriation in this Act;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Exemptions apply during gas market emergency price orders
modality: Diffusion
operator: during
premise text: (2) To avoid doubt, a gas market emergency price order may not do...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...create an offence; ...provide powers of: ...impose a tax; ...set an amount to be appropriated from the Consolidated Revenue Fund under an appropriation in this Act;
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Exemptions apply during gas market emergency price orders
modality: LTL
operator: during
premise text: (2) To avoid doubt, a gas market emergency price order may not do...

53M(3) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to make gas market emergency price orders
modality: Deontic
operator: May

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-3-norm
type: Permission
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53M(3) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

53M(4) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Consultation with Commission before making gas market emergency price order
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Consultation with Commission required
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to consult with Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Minister makes gas market emergency price order

53M(5) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-5-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

53M(6) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Minister must not make a gas market emergency price order after specified time.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-6-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-6
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-6-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits making a gas market emergency price order after specified time.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

53M(7) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Gas market emergency price order is repealed at a specified time unless earlier repealed.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-7-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-7
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

53M(8) Minister may make gas market emergency price orders
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.514
note: Defines time for gas market emergency price orders
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-8-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-8-logic-alleninterval-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53m-ss-8
schema version: 2
part of: 53M Minister may make gas market emergency price orders

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53m-ss-8-logic-alleninterval-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Defines the duration of gas market emergency price orders
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during

53N Scope of gas market instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.515
note: Limits the application of a gas market instrument or its provisions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53n-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53n-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53n
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53n-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Limits the application of a gas market instrument or its provisions.
modality: Deontic
operator: Limitation

53P General
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.517
note: Rules regulating gas market conduct may be included in a gas market code.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53p-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53p-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53p
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53p-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regulating conduct is an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: includes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53p-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53P General

53Q Dealing with other gas market participants
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.517
note: Rules for dealing with other gas market participants in good faith
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53q-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53q-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53q
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53q-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Rules for dealing with other gas market participants in good faith
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53q-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53Q Dealing with other gas market participants

53R Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.518
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53R(1) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
has part: 53R(2) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
has part: 53R(3) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53r
schema version: 2

53R(1) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.518
note: Rules about negotiations relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53r-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53R Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers

53R(2) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.518
note: Rules about expressions of interest in supplying or acquiring a gas commodity
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53r-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53R Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: An expression of interest is open for the following period: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Expressions of interest have a specific period
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) A gas market code may include rules about expressions of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A response to an expression of interest must involve the following: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Responding to an expression of interest involves providing information and making offers
modality: Argumentation
operator: entails
premise text: (2) A gas market code may include rules about expressions of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A gas market participant must issue an expression of interest
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expressing an interest is required in specified circumstances
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (2) A gas market code may include rules about expressions of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A gas market participant must not issue an expression of interest
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Expressing an interest is forbidden in certain circumstances
modality: Deontic
operator: forbidden
premise text: (2) A gas market code may include rules about expressions of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A withdrawal of an expression of interest implies the following: ...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Withdrawing an expression of interest implies certain actions
modality: Diffusion
operator: implies
premise text: (2) A gas market code may include rules about expressions of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53R(2) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers

53R(3) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.518
note: Rules about offers relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53r-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53R Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires a gas market participant to make an offer in specified circumstances
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53r-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53R(3) Negotiations, expressions of interest and offers

53S Agreements
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.519
note: Rules about agreements relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53s-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53s-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53s
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53s-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires rules about agreements
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53s-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53S Agreements

53T Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.520
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53T(1) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
has part: 53T(2) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
has part: 53T(3) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53t
schema version: 2

53T(1) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.520
note: Rules for terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53t-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53T Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53T(1) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

53T(2) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.520
note: Rules about price setting for gas market participants
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53t-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53T Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (e)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires a price to be reasonable
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (f)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (g)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May take into account matters in determining a price
modality: Deontic
operator: may take into account
premise text: (f)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (g)
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must not take into account matters in determining a price
modality: Deontic
operator: must not be taken into account
premise text: (f)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Rules about how a price is expressed or refer to prices of gas commodities
modality: LinearLogic
operator: or
premise text: (h) or (a)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53T(2) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

53T(3) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.520
note: Do not offer to supply or acquire a gas commodity if rules are not complied with.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53t-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53T Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53t-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not

53U Gas exchanges
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.521
note: Regulates gas exchange operation under a market code.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53u-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53u
schema version: 2

53V Dispute and complaint resolution
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.521
note: Rules for dispute resolution in gas market codes
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53v-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53v
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53v-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53V Dispute and complaint resolution

53W Mediation and arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.522
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53W(1) Mediation and arbitration
has part: 53W(2) Mediation and arbitration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53w
schema version: 2

53W(1) Mediation and arbitration
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.522
note: Provides for mediation of disputes between gas market participants relating to gas market conduct.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53w-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53W Mediation and arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the state to provide for mediation of disputes.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53W(1) Mediation and arbitration

53W(2) Mediation and arbitration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.522
note: Establishing or maintaining a register of arbiters.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53w-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53W Mediation and arbitration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishs an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: establishes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53w-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53W(2) Mediation and arbitration

53X Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.524
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53X(1) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
has part: 53X(2) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
has part: 53X(3) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53x
schema version: 2

53X(1) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.524
note: Rules for gas market emergency price orders regarding terms of supply or acquisition
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53x-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53X Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...including rules about any of the following matters:
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: During the term of the emergency price order
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (1) A gas market emergency price order may include rules...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...including rules about any of the following matters:
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes rules about terms on which a gas market participant offers to supply or acquire
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: (1) A gas market emergency price order may include rules...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...fees payable in relation to such an offer, agreement, supply or acquisition;
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes rules about fees payable in relation to such an offer, agreement, supply or acquisition
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: ...rules about any of the following matters: (b) fees payable in relation to such an offer...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...terms (including terms relating to price) specified in an expression of interest...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes rules about terms specified in an expression of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: ...terms (including terms relating to price) specified in an expression of interest relating to supplying or acquiring a gas commodity.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...Chapter 4 Gas market Part IVBB Gas market instruments Division 2 ...
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Includes a provision relating to particular industries, payment surcharges etc.
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: Provisions relating to particular industries, payment surcharges etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53X(1) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

53X(2) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.524
note: Rules for setting a price in a gas market emergency price order
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53x-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53X Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires a price to be reasonable
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: May refer to published information about any market
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-logic-linearlogic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Offers alternative rules for setting a price
modality: LinearLogic
operator: or

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53X(2) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

53X(3) Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.524
note: Prohibition on offering to supply or acquire gas commodity if rules are not complied with
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53x-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53X Terms on which gas commodities are supplied or acquired,

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: During
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Rules of the kind mentioned in subsection (1) or (2)
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: Gas market emergency price order includes rules requiring a gas market participant not to offer to supply or acquire

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Not offer to supply or acquire gas commodity
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on offering to supply or acquire
modality: Deontic
operator: not offer
premise text: Rules of the kind mentioned in subsection (1) or (2) are not complied with

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Not agree to supply or acquire gas commodity
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on agreeing to supply or acquire gas commodity if rules are not complied with
modality: Deontic
operator: not agree
premise text: Rules of the kind mentioned in subsection (1) or (2) are not complied with

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-deontic-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Not supply gas commodity
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on supplying gas commodity if rules are not complied with
modality: Deontic
operator: not supply
premise text: Rules of the kind mentioned in subsection (1) or (2) are not complied with

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53x-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Until
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Rules of the kind mentioned in subsection (1) or (2)
modality: LTL
operator: until
premise text: Gas market emergency price order includes rules requiring a gas market participant not to offer to supply or acquire

53Y Gas exchanges
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
note: Regulates gas exchange operation under a gas market emergency price order
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53y-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53y
schema version: 2

53Z Transparency
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53Z(1) Transparency
has part: 53Z(2) Transparency
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53z
schema version: 2

53Z(1) Transparency
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
note: Rules about publishing information by gas market participants, the Minister, or the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-diffusion-5
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-cogai-6
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53z-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53Z Transparency

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The rule requires publishing information at specified intervals.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Publishing information at specified intervals
modality: AllenInterval
operator: at
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may include rules about a gas market participant, the Minister or the Commission publishing information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: If a rule requires publishing information, then it implies that the participant must publish information.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Publishing information implies compliance with the rule
modality: Argumentation
operator: implies
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may include rules about a gas market participant, the Minister or the Commission publishing information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-cogai-6
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The system recognizes that it needs to publish information.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: The system recognizes the need to publish information
modality: CogAI
operator: recognizes
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may include rules about a gas market participant, the Minister or the Commission publishing information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A rule requiring information to be published at specified intervals.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires publishing information
modality: Deontic
operator: requires
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may include rules about a gas market participant, the Minister or the Commission publishing information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The rule includes rules about publishing information.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Includes rules about publishing information
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: includes
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may include rules about a gas market participant, the Minister or the Commission publishing information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The rule diffuses knowledge about gas market matters.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Publishing information diffuses knowledge about gas market matters
modality: Diffusion
operator: diffuses
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may include rules about a gas market participant, the Minister or the Commission publishing information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53Z(1) Transparency

53Z(2) Transparency
type: Concept
description: Information or documents relevant to a gas market matter
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
note: Requires transparency in gas market matters
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53z-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53Z Transparency

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Requires transparency during the entire duration of the instrument
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (2) A gas market instrument may include rules requiring a gas market participant to give to another gas market participant information or documents relevant to a gas market matter.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-argumentation-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Must provide transparency in all cases
modality: Argumentation
operator: must
premise text: (2) A gas market instrument may include rules requiring a gas market participant to give to another gas market participant information or documents relevant to a gas market matter.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Must provide transparency in all cases, regardless of context
modality: CogAI
operator: must
premise text: (2) A gas market instrument may include rules requiring a gas market participant to give to another gas market participant information or documents relevant to a gas market matter.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A gas market participant must give information or documents relevant to a gas market matter.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires action
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Must provide transparency in all cases, regardless of context
modality: Diffusion
operator: must
premise text: (2) A gas market instrument may include rules requiring a gas market participant to give to another gas market participant information or documents relevant to a gas market matter.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53z-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53Z(2) Transparency

53ZA Reporting, records and auditing
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZA(1) Reporting, records and auditing
has part: 53ZA(2) Reporting, records and auditing
has part: 53ZA(3) Reporting, records and auditing
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53za
schema version: 2

53ZA(1) Reporting, records and auditing
type: Concept
description: Reporting, generating or keeping records, and auditing
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
note: Reporting, records and auditing requirements for gas market instruments
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53za-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZA Reporting, records and auditing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to report
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZA(1) Reporting, records and auditing

53ZA(2) Reporting, records and auditing
type: Concept
description: Financial or other reports, records or documents; Information
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
note: Reporting requirements for gas market participants
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53za-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZA Reporting, records and auditing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Reporting requirements
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST PROVIDE

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZA(2) Reporting, records and auditing

53ZA(3) Reporting, records and auditing
type: Concept
description: specified information relating to a specified event
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.526
note: Reporting and record-keeping requirements for gas market participants.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53za-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZA Reporting, records and auditing

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Reporting obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53za-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZA(3) Reporting, records and auditing

53ZB Conferral of powers and functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.527
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZB(1) Conferral of powers and functions
has part: 53ZB(2) Conferral of powers and functions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zb
schema version: 2

53ZB(1) Conferral of powers and functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.527
note: A power or function to do, or a function of doing, any of the following
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zb-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zb-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZB Conferral of powers and functions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zb-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Confer a power or function
modality: Deontic
operator: confer
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument may confer on a person or body...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zb-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZB(1) Conferral of powers and functions

53ZB(2) Conferral of powers and functions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.527
note: Gas market code may confer powers or functions on a person or body.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zb-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zb-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZB Conferral of powers and functions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zb-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZB(2) Conferral of powers and functions

53ZC Fees
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.528
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZC(1) Fees
has part: 53ZC(2) Fees
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zc
schema version: 2

53ZC(1) Fees
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.528
note: A fee may be charged for anything done by or in relation to the Commonwealth, the Commission or any other person or body.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zc-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZC Fees

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation to charge a fee.
modality: Deontic
operator: charge

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZC(1) Fees

53ZC(2) Fees
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.528
note: Defines matters that a gas market instrument may deal with when charging a fee.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zc-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZC Fees

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Defines permissible matters for fee charging.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zc-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZC(2) Fees

53ZD Incidental or related matters
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.529
note: Exemptions from requirements in gas market instruments
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zd-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zd-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zd
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zd-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Exemptions from requirements in gas market instruments
modality: Deontic
operator: Permit

53ZE What gas market instruments may refer to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.531
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZE(1) What gas market instruments may refer to
has part: 53ZE(2) What gas market instruments may refer to
has part: 53ZE(3) What gas market instruments may refer to
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53ze
schema version: 2

53ZE(1) What gas market instruments may refer to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.531
note: A gas market instrument may adopt or incorporate matter from other instruments or writings.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53ze-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZE What gas market instruments may refer to

53ZE(2) What gas market instruments may refer to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.531
note: Subsection (1) has effect despite subsection 14(2) of the Legislation Act 2003.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53ze-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZE What gas market instruments may refer to

53ZE(3) What gas market instruments may refer to
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.531
note: Defines what a gas market instrument may refer to in relation to setting a price.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53ze-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZE What gas market instruments may refer to

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the price of any gas commodity or other goods or services anywhere inside or outside Australia; or any published information about any market (whether inside or outside Australia);
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: States what a gas market instrument may refer to in relation to setting a price.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: refers to
premise text: (3) A gas market instrument may make provision in relation to a matter (including setting a price):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the price of any gas commodity or other goods or services anywhere inside or outside Australia; or any published information about any market (whether inside or outside Australia);
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: States what a gas market instrument may refer to in relation to setting a price.
modality: CogAI
operator: refers to
premise text: (3) A gas market instrument may make provision in relation to a matter (including setting a price):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (i) the price of any gas commodity or other goods or services anywhere inside or outside Australia; or (ii) any published information about any market (whether inside or outside Australia);
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: States what a gas market instrument may refer to.
modality: Deontic
operator: refers to
premise text: (3) A gas market instrument may make provision in relation to a matter (including setting a price):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the price of any gas commodity or other goods or services anywhere inside or outside Australia; or any published information about any market (whether inside or outside Australia);
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: States what a gas market instrument may refer to in relation to setting a price.
modality: Diffusion
operator: refers to
premise text: (3) A gas market instrument may make provision in relation to a matter (including setting a price):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: the price of any gas commodity or other goods or services anywhere inside or outside Australia; or any published information about any market (whether inside or outside Australia);
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: States what a gas market instrument may refer to in relation to setting a price.
modality: LTL
operator: refers to
premise text: (3) A gas market instrument may make provision in relation to a matter (including setting a price):

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53ze-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZE(3) What gas market instruments may refer to

53ZF Provisions do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZF(1) Provisions do not limit other provisions
has part: 53ZF(2) Provisions do not limit other provisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zf
schema version: 2

53ZF(1) Provisions do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: Provisions do not limit other provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zf-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zf-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZF Provisions do not limit other provisions

53ZF(2) Provisions do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: List of provisions that this section applies to
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zf-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zf-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZF Provisions do not limit other provisions

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zf-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Applies to specific provisions
modality: Deontic
operator: applies_to

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zf-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZF(2) Provisions do not limit other provisions

53ZG Constitution—gas market instruments must not give
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZG(1) Constitution—gas market instruments must not give
has part: 53ZG(2) Constitution—gas market instruments must not give
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zg
schema version: 2

53ZG(1) Constitution—gas market instruments must not give
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: Preferential treatment of one State or part thereof is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zg-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZG Constitution—gas market instruments must not give

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits preferential treatment of one State or part thereof.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument must not give preference to one State or any part thereof within the meaning of section 99 of the Constitution.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-1-logic-linearlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::linear
logic summary: Implies that preferential treatment is prohibited.
modality: LinearLogic
operator: Imply
premise text: (1) A gas market instrument must not give preference to one State or any part thereof within the meaning of section 99 of the Constitution.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZG(1) Constitution—gas market instruments must not give

53ZG(2) Constitution—gas market instruments must not give
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: Preferential treatment of one State is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zg-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZG Constitution—gas market instruments must not give

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits preferential treatment.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zg-ss-2-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZG(2) Constitution—gas market instruments must not give

53ZH Fees must not amount to taxation
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: Fees charged under gas market instruments must not amount to taxation.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zh-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zh-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zh
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zh-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits taxation through fees.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zh-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZH Fees must not amount to taxation

53ZI Powers to make legislative instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZI(1) Powers to make legislative instruments
has part: 53ZI(2) Powers to make legislative instruments
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zi
schema version: 2

53ZI(1) Powers to make legislative instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: Cannot confer power on persons or bodies other than specified.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zi-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zi-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZI Powers to make legislative instruments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zi-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: A gas market instrument must not confer a power to make a legislative instrument on a person or body other than...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: not
premise text: (a) a Minister; or (b) the Commission; or (c) a member of the staff of the Commission; or (d) an APS employee; or (e) an entity covered by subsection 53K(3)

53ZI(2) Powers to make legislative instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.532
note: No power to delegate a power to make a legislative instrument.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zi-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zi-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zi-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZI Powers to make legislative instruments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zi-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2) A gas market instrument must not confer a power to delegate a power to make a legislative instrument.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative assertion of ability
modality: Deontic
operator: not

53ZJ Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.534
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZJ(1) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
has part: 53ZJ(2) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
has part: 53ZJ(3) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zj
schema version: 2

53ZJ(1) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.534
note: A gas market instrument may not set out a pecuniary penalty without indicating it as a civil penalty.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zj-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZJ Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of pecuniary penalties without indication as civil penalty.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

53ZJ(2) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.534
note: Continuation of obligation despite expired period or passed time
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zj-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZJ Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the obligation to do that act or thing continues until the act or thing is done (even if the period has expired or the time has passed).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between periods
modality: AllenInterval
operator: MEETS
premise text: (2) If an act or thing is required under a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-cogai-5
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the obligation to do that act or thing continues until the act or thing is done (even if the period has expired or the time has passed).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: sparql_library::parsers::chk_parser
logic summary: Applicable to cognitive agents
modality: CogAI
operator: MEETS
premise text: (2) If an act or thing is required under a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the obligation to do that act or thing continues until the act or thing is done (even if the period has expired or the time has passed).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Continuation of obligation despite expired period or passed time
modality: Deontic
operator: CONTINUES
premise text: (2) If an act or thing is required under a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-diffusion-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the obligation to do that act or thing continues until the act or thing is done (even if the period has expired or the time has passed).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Applicable to diffusion of obligations
modality: Diffusion
operator: MEETS
premise text: (2) If an act or thing is required under a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the obligation to do that act or thing continues until the act or thing is done (even if the period has expired or the time has passed).
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Ordered trace of obligations
modality: LTL
operator: MEETS
premise text: (2) If an act or thing is required under a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZJ(2) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments

53ZJ(3) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.534
note: Contravention of civil penalty provision within a particular period or before a particular time
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zj-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZJ Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...within a particular period or before a particular time
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Overlaps with provisions relating to particular industries, payment surcharges etc.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Overlaps
premise text: (3) A person who contravenes a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...commits a separate contravention...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits contravention of civil penalty provision
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: (3) A person who contravenes a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-deontic-4
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...commits a separate contravention of that provision in respect of each day...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes obligation to comply with civil penalty provision
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation
premise text: (3) A person who contravenes a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-logic-ltl-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...commits a separate contravention of that provision in respect of each day...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::temporal_ltl
logic summary: Repeats for each day during which the contravention occurs
modality: LTL
operator: Repeats
premise text: (3) A person who contravenes a civil penalty provision...

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zj-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZJ(3) Civil penalty provisions of gas market instruments

53ZK Infringement notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.535
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZK(1) Infringement notices
has part: 53ZK(2) Infringement notices
has part: 53ZK(3) Infringement notices
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zk
schema version: 2

53ZK(1) Infringement notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.535
note: Division 5 of Part XI applies to a provision in a corresponding way.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zk-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zk-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZK Infringement notices

53ZK(2) Infringement notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.535
note: Extended application of Division 5 of Part XI etc.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zk-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zk-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZK Infringement notices

53ZK(3) Infringement notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.535
note: Applying Division 5 of Part XI and other provisions to a provision under this section
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zk-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zk-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZK Infringement notices

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zk-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits infringement notices
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

53ZL Commission may give draft public warning notice
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.536
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZL(1) Commission may give draft public warning notice
has part: 53ZL(2) Commission may give draft public warning notice
has part: 53ZL(3) Commission may give draft public warning notice
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zl
schema version: 2

53ZL(1) Commission may give draft public warning notice
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.536
note: Notice may be given for prohibited conduct causing detriment to others in public interest.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zl-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZL Commission may give draft public warning notice

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Notice for prohibited conduct
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition
premise text: Commission may give notice in writing if reasonable belief of prohibited conduct exists.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZL(1) Commission may give draft public warning notice

53ZL(2) Commission may give draft public warning notice
type: Concept
description: Yes
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.536
note: The Commission must give a draft public warning notice with specific details.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zl-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZL Commission may give draft public warning notice

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: The Commission must give a draft public warning notice.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZL(2) Commission may give draft public warning notice

53ZL(3) Commission may give draft public warning notice
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.536
note: Notice given under subsection (1) must not be a legislative instrument.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zl-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZL Commission may give draft public warning notice

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zl-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition on notice being a legislative instrument.
modality: Deontic
operator: MustNot

53ZM Commission may issue public warning notice
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.537
note: Commission may issue public warning notice for prohibited conduct.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zm-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zm-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zm
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zm-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibition

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zm-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZM Commission may issue public warning notice

53ZN Proceedings for defamation not to lie
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.538
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZN(1) Proceedings for defamation not to lie
has part: 53ZN(2) Proceedings for defamation not to lie
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zn
schema version: 2

53ZN(1) Proceedings for defamation not to lie
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.538
note: No defamation action against Commonwealth, Commission, or staff in relation to notice issuance.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zn-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZN Proceedings for defamation not to lie

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes obligation on the Commonwealth, Commission, and staff.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZN(1) Proceedings for defamation not to lie

53ZN(2) Proceedings for defamation not to lie
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.538
note: Defamation proceedings not allowed
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zn-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZN Proceedings for defamation not to lie

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zn-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits defamation proceedings
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

53ZO Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.539
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZO(1) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
has part: 53ZO(2) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
has part: 53ZO(3) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zo
schema version: 2

53ZO(1) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.539
note: Court may make orders against a person referred to in subsection (2) if they engaged in contravening conduct causing loss or damage to non-parties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-diffusion-5
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zo-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZO Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-alleninterval-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation between contravening conduct and loss or damage
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (b) the contravening conduct caused, or is likely to cause

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-argumentation-4
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::argumentation
logic summary: Establishes condition for court's discretion
modality: Argumentation
operator: if-then
premise text: (c) the class includes persons (non-parties) who are not, or have not been, parties to a proceeding instituted under Part VI in relation to the contravening conduct

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: suffer loss or damage
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Identifies class of persons affected by contravening conduct
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: hasClass
premise text: (a) a person engaged in conduct (the contravening conduct)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-logic-diffusion-5
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::diffusion
logic summary: Establishes condition for court's discretion
modality: Diffusion
operator: if-then
premise text: (b) the contravening conduct caused, or is likely to cause

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZO(1) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.

53ZO(2) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.539
note: An order under subsection (1) may be made against the person mentioned in paragraph (1)(a); or a person involved in the contravening conduct.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zo-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZO Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Implies an obligation.
modality: Deontic
operator: may

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZO(2) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.

53ZO(3) Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.539
note: Court must not make an order unless it considers the order will redress or prevent loss/damage to non-parties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zo-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZO Orders to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...the order will redress or prevent loss/damage...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal interval for non-parties
modality: AllenInterval
operator: Temporal Interval
premise text: ...in relation to the contravening conduct.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zo-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...unless the court considers...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Negative obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Must Not
premise text: (3) A court must not make an order...

53ZP Kinds of orders that may be made to redress loss or damage
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.541
note: Orders that may be made to redress loss or damage suffered by non-parties.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zp-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zp
schema version: 2

53ZQ Schemes for avoidance purposes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.542
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZQ(1) Schemes for avoidance purposes
has part: 53ZQ(2) Schemes for avoidance purposes
has part: 53ZQ(3) Schemes for avoidance purposes
has part: 53ZQ(4) Schemes for avoidance purposes
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zq
schema version: 2

53ZQ(1) Schemes for avoidance purposes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.542
note: Engaging in a scheme to avoid the application of a civil penalty provision is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zq-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZQ Schemes for avoidance purposes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Engaging in a scheme to avoid the application of a civil penalty provision is prohibited.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZQ(1) Schemes for avoidance purposes

53ZQ(2) Schemes for avoidance purposes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.542
note: Engaging in a scheme to avoid civil penalty provision is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zq-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZQ Schemes for avoidance purposes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Prohibited
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of scheme engagement
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Engaging in a scheme

53ZQ(3) Schemes for avoidance purposes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.542
note: Engaging in a scheme to avoid the application of a civil penalty provision is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zq-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZQ Schemes for avoidance purposes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Engaging in a scheme to avoid the application of a civil penalty provision.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-3-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZQ(3) Schemes for avoidance purposes

53ZQ(4) Schemes for avoidance purposes
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.542
note: Clarifies independence of subsections (1), (2) and (3)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zq-ss-4-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zq-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZQ Schemes for avoidance purposes

53ZR Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.544
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZR(1) Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose
has part: 53ZR(2) Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zr
schema version: 2

53ZR(1) Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.544
note: Regard must be had to any matters prescribed by the regulations when determining whether it would be reasonable to conclude that a person's purpose was to avoid the application of a civil penalty provision.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zr-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zr-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zr-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZR Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zr-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Regard must be had to any matters prescribed by the regulations.
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zr-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZR(1) Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose

53ZR(2) Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.544
note: Matters to which regard may be had in making a determination
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zr-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zr-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZR Whether it is reasonable to draw conclusion as to purpose

53ZS This Subdivision does not limit Division 2
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.544
note: Does not limit Division 2 provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zs-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zs-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zs
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zs-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Indicates prohibition or limitation
modality: Deontic
operator: !

53ZT Commission may require person to provide information
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZT(1) Commission may require person to provide information
has part: 53ZT(2) Commission may require person to provide information
has part: 53ZT(3) Commission may require person to provide information
has part: 53ZT(4) Commission may require person to provide information
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zt
schema version: 2

53ZT(1) Commission may require person to provide information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
note: Person must provide information under gas market instrument.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zt-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZT Commission may require person to provide information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZT(1) Commission may require person to provide information

53ZT(2) Commission may require person to provide information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
note: Commission requires person to provide information within a specified period and manner.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zt-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZT Commission may require person to provide information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Imposes an obligation on the state.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZT(2) Commission may require person to provide information

53ZT(3) Commission may require person to provide information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
note: Commission requires person to provide information upon notice.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zt-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZT Commission may require person to provide information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires the person to provide information.
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZT(3) Commission may require person to provide information

53ZT(4) Commission may require person to provide information
type: Concept
description: true
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
note: Commission may require person to provide information
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zt-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZT Commission may require person to provide information

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Requires person to provide information
modality: Deontic
operator: requires

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zt-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZT(4) Commission may require person to provide information

53ZU Extending periods for complying with notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZU(1) Extending periods for complying with notices
has part: 53ZU(2) Extending periods for complying with notices
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zu
schema version: 2

53ZU(1) Extending periods for complying with notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
note: A person can apply for an extension of the period to comply with a notice.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zu-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zu-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zu-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZU Extending periods for complying with notices

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zu-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission to apply for an extension
modality: Deontic
operator: Can

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zu-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZU(1) Extending periods for complying with notices

53ZU(2) Extending periods for complying with notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.545
note: Member of Commission may extend period for complying with notice.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zu-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zu-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZU Extending periods for complying with notices

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zu-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZU(2) Extending periods for complying with notices

53ZV Compliance with notices
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.546
note: Comply with notice within specified period or extended period.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zv-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zv-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zv
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zv-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Comply within period
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must comply
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST
premise text: Given notice

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zv-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZV Compliance with notices

53ZW False or misleading information etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.546
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZW(1) False or misleading information etc.
has part: 53ZW(2) False or misleading information etc.
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zw
schema version: 2

53ZW(1) False or misleading information etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.546
note: Giving false or misleading information to the Commission is prohibited.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zw-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZW False or misleading information etc.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No false or misleading information shall be given to the Commission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of false or misleading information
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Section 53ZT

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No false or misleading documents shall be produced to the Commission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of producing false or misleading documents
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Section 53ZT

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: No false or misleading information shall be given to the Commission in compliance with a notice.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibition of giving false or misleading information in compliance with a notice
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: Section 53ZT

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-1-norm
type: Prohibition
scope note: borne by: Agent
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: Agent
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 53ZW(1) False or misleading information etc.

53ZW(2) False or misleading information etc.
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.546
note: Exemptions from section 53ZW(1)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zw-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zw-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZW False or misleading information etc.

53ZX This Division does not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.547
note: Does not limit other provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zx-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zx
schema version: 2

53ZY Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZY(1) Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
has part: 53ZY(2) Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
has part: 53ZY(3) Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zy
schema version: 2

53ZY(1) Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
note: Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zy-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zy-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZY Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions

53ZY(2) Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
note: Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zy-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zy-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZY Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions

53ZY(3) Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
note: List of parts that subsection applies to
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zy-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zy-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZY Certain provisions of this Act do not limit other provisions

53ZZ Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
curation status: Proposed
has part: 53ZZ(1) Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws
has part: 53ZZ(2) Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zz
schema version: 2

53ZZ(1) Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
note: States and Territories can operate concurrently with the gas market provisions. Prohibits conduct that affects the activities, functions, relationships or business of a constitutional corporation. Regulations may incorporate or adopt provisions from other instruments.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zz-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZZ Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permits concurrent operation
modality: Deontic
operator: can

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-1-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: ...affect the activities, functions,...
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits conduct
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit
premise text: (1) The gas market provisions...

53ZZ(2) Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.548
note: Excludes or limits the operation of a law of a State or Territory Legislation Act 2003 override Prevents acquisition of property without just terms.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-53zz-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 53ZZ Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits operation of laws
modality: Deontic
operator: excludes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: override
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Subsection (1) has effect despite subsection 14(2)
modality: Deontic
operator: override
premise text: Legislation Act 2003

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-53zz-ss-2-logic-deontic-3
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Prohibits acquisition of property.
modality: Deontic
operator: Prohibit

6 Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.66
curation status: Proposed
has part: 6(1) Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
has part: 6(2) Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6
schema version: 2

6(1) Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.66
note: This Act also has effect as provided by this section.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 6 Extended application of this Act to persons who are not

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: This Act has effect as provided by this section.
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to have effect
modality: Deontic
operator: has effect
premise text: This Act also has effect as provided by this section.

6(2) Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.66
note: Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 6 Extended application of this Act to persons who are not

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Extended application of this Act to persons who are not
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 6(2) Extended application of this Act to persons who are not

6A Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
curation status: Proposed
has part: 6A(1) Establishment of Commission
has part: 6A(1A) Establishment of Commission
has part: 6A(2) Establishment of Commission
has part: 6A(3) Establishment of Commission
has part: 6A(4) Establishment of Commission
has part: 6A(5) Establishment of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a
schema version: 2

6A(1) Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
note: Establishment of Commission
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 6A Establishment of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Establishs the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
modality: Deontic
operator: establishes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 6A(1) Establishment of Commission

6A(1A) Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
note: The Commission is a non-corporate Commonwealth entity.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a-ss-1a
schema version: 2
part of: 6A Establishment of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: It is an obligation to classify it as such.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Entity classification
modality: Deontic
operator: is
premise text: The Commission is a non-corporate Commonwealth entity.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-1a-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 6A(1A) Establishment of Commission

6A(2) Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
note: The Commission must have an official seal.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 6A Establishment of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Must have an official seal.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 6A(2) Establishment of Commission

6A(3) Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
note: The Commission holds real or personal property for and on behalf of the Commonwealth.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 6A Establishment of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-3-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The property's duration is tied to the Commission's existence.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relation
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: The Commission holds the property during its existence.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: The Commonwealth is entitled to the property.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Holding obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: holds
premise text: The Commission holds real or personal property.

6A(4) Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
note: Money received by Commission is for and on behalf of the Commonwealth.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 6A Establishment of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Receives money for and on behalf of the Commonwealth.
modality: Deontic
operator: receives

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 6A(4) Establishment of Commission

6A(5) Establishment of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.76
note: Right to sue is not personal property for the purposes of subsection (3)
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-5-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6a-ss-5
schema version: 2
part of: 6A Establishment of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6a-ss-5-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Right is an obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: Obligation

6AA Application of the Criminal Code
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.75
curation status: Proposed
has part: 6AA(1) Application of the Criminal Code
has part: 6AA(2) Application of the Criminal Code
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6aa
schema version: 2

6AA(1) Application of the Criminal Code
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.75
note: Chapter 2 of the Criminal Code applies to all offences against this Act.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6aa-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6aa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6aa-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 6AA Application of the Criminal Code

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6aa-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Chapter 2 of the Criminal Code applies to all offences against this Act.
modality: Deontic
operator: applies

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6aa-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 6AA(1) Application of the Criminal Code

6AA(2) Application of the Criminal Code
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.75
note: Despite subsection (1), Part 2.5 of the Criminal Code does not apply to an offence against Part IIIA or XIC, Division 7 of
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-6aa-ss-2-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-6aa-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 6AA Application of the Criminal Code

7 Constitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
curation status: Proposed
has part: 7(1) Constitution of Commission
has part: 7(2) Constitution of Commission
has part: 7(3) Constitution of Commission
has part: 7(4) Constitution of Commission
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7
schema version: 2

7(1) Constitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
note: Commission composition
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-1-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 7 Constitution of Commission

7(2) Constitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
note: Members of Commission must be appointed by Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 7 Constitution of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to appoint members
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 7(2) Constitution of Commission

7(3) Constitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
note: The Minister must be satisfied that the person qualifies for appointment.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 7 Constitution of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to satisfy conditions
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

7(4) Constitution of Commission
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
note: Member of Commission must have knowledge or experience in consumer protection.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-4-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-7-ss-4
schema version: 2
part of: 7 Constitution of Commission

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-4-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member of Commission must have knowledge or experience in consumer protection.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST HAVE

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-7-ss-4-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 7(4) Constitution of Commission

8 Terms and conditions of appointment
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
note: Member of Commission holds office for specified period and on terms and conditions determined by Governor-General.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: LegalPerson
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: LegalPerson
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 8 Terms and conditions of appointment

8A Associate members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.77
note: The Minister may appoint persons to be associate members of the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8a-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8a-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8a
schema version: 2

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8a-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Permission granted by the Minister
modality: Deontic
operator: may

8AB AER members taken to be associate members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
curation status: Proposed
has part: 8AB(1) AER members taken to be associate members
has part: 8AB(2) AER members taken to be associate members
has part: 8AB(3) AER members taken to be associate members
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8ab
schema version: 2

8AB(1) AER members taken to be associate members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
note: An AER member is taken to be an associate member of the Commission.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8ab-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 8AB AER members taken to be associate members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: An AER member is taken to be an associate member.
modality: Deontic
operator: takes

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 8AB(1) AER members taken to be associate members

8AB(2) AER members taken to be associate members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
note: Associate membership for AER members under certain conditions.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8ab-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 8AB AER members taken to be associate members

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-2-logic-alleninterval-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2)
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::interval_reasoning
logic summary: Temporal relationship between associate membership and certain sections.
modality: AllenInterval
operator: during
premise text: (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: (2)
confidence: 0.5000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Excludes associate membership for AER members in certain sections.
modality: Deontic
operator: exclusion
premise text: (1)

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 8AB(2) AER members taken to be associate members

8AB(3) AER members taken to be associate members
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
note: Terms and conditions of appointment specified in instrument
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-8ab-ss-3-norm
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-8ab-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 8AB AER members taken to be associate members

9 Remuneration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
curation status: Proposed
has part: 9(1) Remuneration
has part: 9(2) Remuneration
has part: 9(3) Remuneration
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9
schema version: 2

9(1) Remuneration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
note: Member of Commission must be paid remuneration.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-1-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-1
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Remuneration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-1-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Obligation to pay remuneration
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-1-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 9(1) Remuneration

9(2) Remuneration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
note: Member of Commission must be paid allowances prescribed by Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-2-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-2
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Remuneration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-2-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Member of Commission must be paid allowances prescribed by Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973.
modality: Deontic
operator: MUST

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-2-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 9(2) Remuneration

9(3) Remuneration
type: Concept
source: competition-and-consumer-act-2010.pdf, p.79
note: Member of Commission includes associate member.
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-3-norm
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
asserts: competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
realized by: sec-9-ss-3
schema version: 2
part of: 9 Remuneration

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-3-logic-deontic-1
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Member includes associate member.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::logic::deontic
logic summary: Membership obligation
modality: Deontic
operator: includes
premise text: Associate is a member of Commission.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-3-logic-descriptionlogic-2
type: LogicApplication
conclusion text: Associate is a member of Commission.
confidence: 1.0000
curation status: Proposed
execution surface: modalities::dl
logic summary: Associate membership defined
modality: DescriptionLogic
operator: subclassOf
premise text: Associate is a subclass of member.

competition-and-consumer-act-2010-sec-9-ss-3-norm
type: Obligation
scope note: borne by: State
curation status: Proposed
modality: Deontic
borne by: State
deontic status: HeuristicDerived
part of: 9(3) Remuneration

Competition and Consumer Act 2010
type: Document
date: 27 May 2026
identifier: No. 51 of 1974
curation status: Proposed
proposed by: legis2cml
category: AU